Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Color of Ice

Rate this book
Set among the glaciers and thermal lagoons of Iceland, and framed by the magical art of glassblowing, The Color of Ice is the breathtaking story of a woman's awakening to passion, beauty, and the redemptive power of unconditional love.


The stunning new novel by the author of award-winning novels Queen of the Owls and The Sound Between the Notes . . .


Cathryn McAllister, a freelance photographer, travels to Iceland for a photo shoot with an enigmatic artist who wants to capture the country’s iconic blue icebergs in glass. Her plan is to head out, when the job is done, on a carefully curated “best of Iceland” solo vacation. Widowed young, Cathryn has raised two children while achieving professional success. If the price of that efficiency has been the dimming of her fire—well, she hasn’t let herself think about it. Until now.


Bit by bit, Cathryn abandons her itinerary to remain with Mack, the glassblower, who awakens a hunger for all the things she’s told herself she doesn’t need anymore. Passion. Vulnerability. Risk. Cathryn finds herself torn between the life—and self—she’s come to know and the new world Mack offers. Commitments await her back in America. But if she walks away, she’ll lose this chance to feel deeply again. Just when her path seems clear, she’s faced with a shocking discovery—and a devastating choice that shows her what love really is.

307 pages, Kindle Edition

First published October 18, 2022

47 people are currently reading
6704 people want to read

About the author

Barbara Linn Probst

5 books218 followers
Barbara Linn Probst is an award-winning author of contemporary women’s fiction living on an historic dirt road in New York’s Hudson Valley. Her acclaimed novels QUEEN OF THE OWLS (2020) and TTHE SOUND BETWEEN THE NOTES (2021) were medalists for prestigious national awards, and THE SOUND BETWEEN THE NOTES was selected by Kirkus Reviews as one of the Best Indie Books of 2021. Barbara has also published over fifty essays on the craft of writing for sites such as Jane Friedman and Writer Unboxed, along with two nonfiction books. Her third novel THE COLOR OF ICE will be released in October 2022.

FUN FACT:
Barbara's first book was framed around the art and life of iconic American painter Georgia O'Keeffe, and her second book was framed around music and the piano. THE COLOR OF ICE, set among Iceland's thermal lagoons and blue icebergs, is framed around the magical art of glassblowing.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
177 (37%)
4 stars
159 (33%)
3 stars
95 (20%)
2 stars
30 (6%)
1 star
12 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 142 reviews
Profile Image for Amy.
1,293 reviews473 followers
November 29, 2022
This book got five stars from me instead of four because both the writing and the concept were brilliant! This will soon be a "hot" book club book, and I was thrilled to get to read it.

The book is about many things intertwined. Art, creator and creation, living motion of experiencing art. Its about the individuation of children, calving and emergence. Its about life and love after loss. Its about taking risks to discover who you are. Its about both the uniqueness and the commonalities that bind us. Its about love, and art, and children, but so much more than that. Beautifully, beautifully done!
153 reviews121 followers
October 29, 2022
Reading THE COLOR OF ICE felt to me like an opportunity to experience a “Disneyland E-ticket”!

The author, once again, took me on a literary journey that included a visit to Iceland, filled with information about glassblowing, the mythology of the Northern Lights, the icebergs & photography.

When I, an avid reader, can be entertained, learn something new and enjoy a family drama/love story, that’s a book that I can honestly recommend. Book clubs will find a plethora of discussable themes. Read it! 🧊🧊🧊🧊🧊
Brava to talented author Barbara Linn Probst
Profile Image for Julie.
128 reviews45 followers
November 4, 2022
“Ice and glass and light, three portals into an incandescent world. Colorless, yet reflecting every color. Invisible, yet illuminating what was there to be seen.”

Cathryn McAllister, a widow with two grown kids, is a freelance photographer looking for an adventure to spice up her life. 📷 She has decided to spread her wings and take the trip of a lifetime to Iceland, going to photograph and interview Henry Malcolm Charbonneau, aka Mack. Mack is a glassblower from the US who has come to Iceland working on a project to capture the beauty of the icebergs in his glassblowing. 🌬

Even though Cathryn had a whole itinerary planned for Iceland (two days with Mack and eight days of touring), she finds it hard to leave the city Mack is working in. She is fascinated by his work, the glass blowing and "the heating, and shaping, softening and twisting, with an occasional puff of air to give it volume." She also finds him incredibly attractive. So day after day, she stays with Mack, assisting him with his project. Will it work out? Will Cathryn be too much of a distraction? What exactly is her plan for this trip and Mack?

First and foremost, let’s talk about this STUNNING cover. 😍 After seeing it, I immediately went to read the blurb for the book and was intrigued. I was not familiar with glassblowing, so I was excited to read this book to learn more about it. I am a nature freak, so I was already drawn to the fact that the setting was in Iceland. Plus, I love all forms of art. 🎨 I am the chick that goes to the art museum and sits down and stares at paintings for hours. 🖼 So, CALLING all nature and art lovers, this book will be right up your alley.

The writing was absolutely exquisite and I felt like I was right there with Cathryn in Iceland as she took in her surroundings. I liked all of the characters and have to say I started crushing on Mack myself. This book was so majestic, beautiful, and breathtaking. It is about love, redemption, self care, and forgiveness. Prior to this book, I had already added “Queen of the Owls” to my TBR list. I'm pushing it up on my TBR list after reading this. 4.5 beautiful ⭐️'s Thank you to NetGalley and the author for my copy of this book.

“If you were an artist, you saw things differently-not only for what they were, but for what else they could mean and be.”
Profile Image for Jill.
Author 2 books2,081 followers
November 14, 2022
“Like an iceberg, a person was built on the layers that accrued, each resting on the ones below.”

Cathryn McAllister, a talented photographer and a spurned wife, is known by her two young adult children and others in her life as the “Snow Queen.” Humiliated by her husband – who, we learn early on, dies in a car accident shortly after their confrontation – she has efficiently built a career and raised her daughter and son single-handedly.

Passion and vulnerability are two emotions she has never allowed herself to experience. Until, on a business trip to Iceland, she meets Mack, the subject of her photo shoot – a glassblower who shuns involvement every bit as much as she does and yet awakens the craving and desire within her.

This is a book I did not expect to like. In fact, while reading it, I kept imagining a literary friend who I discuss books with a lot whispering in my ear: “Don’t you see that this is manipulative? Would Cathryn really make this decision at this time? Can’t you see the ending coming?”

My friend would be right. But still. I was too caught up in the narrative to care. For starters, as someone who spent a couple of weeks in Iceland, I can attest that this author captures Iceland beautifully. I would urge anyone who has been or is considering going to Iceland to read this before they go. It is an absolutely wonderful evocation of a land that – for me and, I suspect, for most people – is magical.

For another, it’s been a while since I’ve been swept up in the story of a complicated but fated romance. Mack, who is tortured, enigmatic, and isolated (physically and emotionally) reminded me of Heathcliff or other Victorian men who are impossible to get close to but maybe, just maybe, worth fighting for. And Cathryn, in her willingness to toss out the latest PC rules (women don’t need a man to complete them, women need to follow their own star) is surprisingly accessible and relatable, willing to take risks to once again feel alive.

In the course of this book, the reader learns a lot about the glaciers and thermal lagoons of Iceland, the delicate art of glassblowing, and the vagaries of the human heart. Totally enjoyed – 4.5 stars.
Profile Image for MicheleReader.
1,136 reviews167 followers
October 15, 2022
Cathryn McAllister is a mother of two young adults. She's 48 years old, a widow and is a commercial photographer who has never been able to pursue her desire to create art. An exciting job opportunity provides Cathryn with the chance to travel to Iceland to photograph the work of Henry Malcolm (Mack) Charbonneau, a talented glassblower. Mack plans to capture the essence of the majestic blue icebergs in his work. Cathryn decides to take extra time after her work commitment to see the area attractions. Once in Iceland, the setting and Mack himself awaken a passion that has lay dormant in Cathryn for a long time. While her children keep contacting her from home with their troubles, Cathryn finally focuses on herself. She acknowledges that, "𝘏𝘢𝘱𝘱𝘪𝘯𝘦𝘴𝘴 𝘩𝘢𝘥𝘯'𝘵 𝘣𝘦𝘦𝘯 𝘰𝘯 𝘩𝘦𝘳 𝘭𝘪𝘴𝘵." Cathryn realizes that not only is she falling for Mack but is also loving the woman she is becoming.

The Color of Ice is a beautiful work of lyrical prose. It is a quiet, emotional book that delves into one woman's journey for self-discovery and second chances. Author Barbara Linn Probst's excellent descriptions of the many attractions and settings in "The Land of Fire and Ice" will send you searching for more information on Iceland's rugged landscapes and scenery which serve as the perfect backdrop for the reawakening of a woman whose daughter referred to her as the Snow Queen. Take your time with this moving book and you will be rewarded. 

Many thanks to the author and She Writes Press for the opportunity to read The Color of Ice in advance of its publication.

Rated 4.5 stars.

Review posted on MicheleReader.com.
Profile Image for Linda.
1,102 reviews142 followers
October 31, 2022
I've read all of Barbara Linn Probst's books. Each is wonderful and very heartwarming. Emotional. So good. This one is my new favorite though. This book was just so good. It is full of emotion. Full of growing and learning. Full of the things that I love in a good book. The characters are great. Very relatable and endearing. The art of glass blowing is something that has always fascinated me. I always wondered how it was done.

The descriptions in this book make you feel like you are in the room with this artist. Mack called himself an artisan but I see him as a true artist. The things he could do with glass sound wonderful. Amazing. Beautiful. Set in Iceland among all the icebergs it's a truly wonderful story. Mack is so talented and he is hurting too. He has held on to his pain and possibly released it a bit in his work. In the pieces he makes. Possibly.

Cathryn is in Iceland to take photos of Mack's work and of Mack himself. It's a job for her and could possibly lead to a bit more. Cathryn has not had the best of luck. Her husband was killed and for many years she has held guilt because of that. Her two children are somewhat spoiled brats in ways. At least her son is. Her daughter is a little bit aloof toward her. While she is in Iceland they both have to deal with some things on their own and possibly grow up a bit.

The chemistry between Mack and Cathryn is strong. Even though he's a bit of a loner and will not stay all night with her the chemistry is there. He's holding in some pain and Cathryn knows it. Of course so is she. When they are able to open up and share things get easier.

This book is beautiful. Truly beautiful. Lesson's learned. Hurts dealt with. Emotions shared. Both of the main characters are broken. For a while they do need each other. For a lifetime of hurt a little bit of just being is great. Cathryn needs to grow in her own way just as her daughter does. Mack needs to let go of something so he can move on. This is truly a wonderful book. It will make you stop and think about life. About the beautiful things we may not normally pay attention to. A child playing with a boat. A boy on a cliff. A man and woman both enjoying the beauty in an iceberg. The beauty in the perfect piece of blown glass. This book will shatter you and pull you back together. It's just truly a good one. One of the best I have read this year.

Thank you #NetGalley, #BarbaraLinnProbst, #SheWritesPress for this ARC. This is my own true thoughts about this book and I feel I fell short.

5 huge stars and the very highest recommendation. Have lots of Kleenex. You will need them.
Profile Image for Nancy.
1,931 reviews483 followers
October 9, 2022
It was Iceland’s fault. She never would have let herself fall into this kind of spell in America.
from The Color of Ice by Barbara Linn Probst

Cathryn was in control. After the accidental death of her philandering husband, she had to be. She walked away from the art photography she was working on for a career as a photographer for hire. She raised her two children. Sometimes she had a fling, but no love affairs.

Her new assignment was to interview and photograph a glass blower who was in Iceland preparing for his new series. She decided she would stay on after the interview and take a rare holiday. See the sights.

Things change after meeting Mac. Mac is maddeningly distant, maddingly attractive to Cathryn. She finds excuses to return to his borrowed workroom, watching him create his series inspired by the blue glaciers of Iceland,, and then helping out, then shown how to work with the glass herself. Sometimes, it seems Mac likes her, but he shuts down inexplicitly. He has his secrets.

But so does Cathryn. She has tamped down all the anger and sorrow for years; it would be a luxury she can’t afford. But surrounded by Iceland’s otherworldly, stark beauty and engaging in a lustful fling with Max, Cathryn finds she likes this freer self. When the kids call with problems, she offers her support but lets them solve the problems themselves. She is evolving. And so is Max, who finally tells his story.

Art and the creative process is central to Max and Cathryn’s lives. Max’s work to create his iceberg glass series is described in detail. Cathryn doesn’t like being a mere helper in Max’s process and wonders if she could return to creative photography again. She makes hard decisions, for the first time considering personal fulfillment over safety. The ‘Snow Queen,’ as her daughter calls her, is melting.

The novel is filled with descriptions of Iceland’s most beautiful vistas, ice tunnels, hot mud pots, and blue ice glaciers.

“If I’ve learned anything over the years,” Max says, “it’s that you need to let an experience transform inside you before you can translate it into an object.” That applies to all creative processes–including recreating oneself. Cathryn takes what she has learned in Iceland and blossoms into a healthier version of herself.

She liked who she was in Iceland. She didn’t want to stop being that person.
from The Color of Ice by Barbara Linn Probst

Cathryn’s growth makes her a better person, a better mother, and allows her to embrace her art.

Probst once again offers an inspiring novel about a woman’s personal growth and the role of art in a fulfilling life.

I received a free egalley from the publisher through NetGalley. My review is fair and unbiased.
Profile Image for Susan Peterson.
2,010 reviews384 followers
October 15, 2022
I’ve read all of Barbara Linn Probst’s books, and her voice, her point of view, is clear and strong. The Color of Ice is her best work yet, the passion that she feels for her characters and their stories is reflected in this breathtaking book. Icebergs are ever-changing, responding to the elements around them, becoming something new. The same is true for the main character, Cathryn, who has her own awakening as she responds to the beauty of Iceland, to the ever-present elements of fire and ice, and to a glassblower named Mack. Just as an iceberg is made of layers of ice, with ninety percent of it below the water line and out of sight, so does this story consist of layers of deep emotions—grief, love, forgiveness, redemption—and those layers are revealed to us bit by glorious bit. This compelling story often left me breathless, my heart stuttering between pain and hope, love and sorrow. There is beautiful imagery in this book that took me right to Iceland, to the glaciers, to the thermal lagoons, traveling with Cathryn on her journey. And the glassblowing! I felt well and truly alive when Cathryn and Mack were in the hot shop, forming objects of beauty with glass and heat and feeling…their vulnerability and fragility always just a heartbeat away. The Color of Ice is a profound, complicated, powerful novel, filled with wisdom, reflection, and the recognition that our lives are always evolving, never static and still.
Profile Image for Patricia Sands.
Author 23 books1,062 followers
May 30, 2022
Once again, Barbara Linn Probst’s lyrical writing takes readers on a splendid journey into parts unknown. In The Color of Ice, she combines the dramatic backdrop of Iceland’s rugged volcanic landscapes and majestic blue icebergs with the delicate art of glassblowing to create an intriguing exploration of the re-awakening of passion in photographer Cathryn McAllister. As she becomes drawn to the artistry and mystery of enigmatic glassblower, Mack Charbonneau, she slowly begins to question her own perceived truths. Nothing is predictable as the story unfolds through the nuanced magic of Probst’s words.
Profile Image for Mary Jackson _TheMaryReader.
1,707 reviews209 followers
October 7, 2022
I have always been fascinated by glassblowing. Porbst brought this art to light and I have to tell you her writing is outstanding. If you have never read one of her books this is the one to grab. I will be recommending this book to all my reader friends. Very well done.
The Mary Reader received this book from the publisher for review. A favorable review was not required, and all views expressed are our own.
Profile Image for Star Gater.
1,893 reviews60 followers
November 18, 2024
Thank you She Writes Press for allowing me to read and review The Color of Ice A Novel by Barbara Linn Probst on NetGalley.

Published: 10/18/22

Stars: 2.5

Most importantly, my sincerest apologies for the lateness of this review. Where do I start? Do I start with what ruined the book? Easy -- the profanity. Why didn't I like the book? I couldn't relate to it. The pitch would have had me yawn and eye roll right away.

There is the Icelandic scenery, well-described. There are the towns with names that I struggle interpreting. I find myself unable to skim over them. Glass blowing is involved; it's true. I've never read another book with this art/sport.

How's your imagination? Can you come to terms with a dead relationship, keep two children a priority, go on a solo vacation and fall in love all in a few days -- maybe a month. I can't. Unfortunately the personal sides of the story bordered on ridiculous for me, thus leaving me unable to enjoy the lovely writing.

I question the authenticity of the high praises and accolades with so much profanity. Beautiful writing does not include F---. Without all the swearing I would have recommended the book for the scenery and glass blowing.
Profile Image for Sue .
2,052 reviews124 followers
October 18, 2022
The Color of Ice is Barbara Linn Probst's third award winning novel. It hasn't won any awards yet but I am positive that there will be awards for this book in the future. From a personal view, her first two books were in my top 10 during the years they were published and this one will definitely be in my top 10 for 2022. All three of her novels are centered around the arts -- The Sound between the Notes was about music, Queen of the Owls was about painting and The Color of Ice is about glassblowing and photography. All of her books are beautiful written with sentences so well written that they touch your heart.

Cathryn is a free lance photographer who has accepted a job to take pictures of an artist who is trying to capture the blue icebergs of Iceland in glass. Her children are finally grown and she's decided to take a vacation and tour Iceland after the photo shoot is over. She is so intrigued with Mack and the freedom that she sees him working in, that she decides to cancel her tour of the country and stay with him as he creates his art. His freedom and enthusiasm awaken the artistic feelings that she's buried since the death of her husband. Her years have been spent making her career a success as she raised her two children. Even though her life is waiting for her in America, she realizes that she wants to become an artist again instead of just a photographer and it was Mack who awakened this need. Finally she has to make decisions that will be difficult no matter what she decides until a startling discovery forces her to decide what direction she needs to follow in her life to find happiness and fulfillment.

This book was emotional and beautiful and thought provoking. As someone who has always enjoyed the arts but has no artistic talent at all, I was intrigued by the journey that Cathryn had taken over the years and her total happiness when she enthusiastically decided to return to her art. Plus, I've always been interested in the art of glass blowing and this book shared many of the secrets of the craft. As always, the author has done extensive research and it is apparent throughout the story. Once again, the author brings her readers a book about a woman searching for happiness and fulfillment who is able to achieve her dreams through her art.
Profile Image for Jodie | GeauxGetLit.
760 reviews114 followers
March 2, 2023
I don’t know about you, but to get me into the holiday spirit I typically start searching for books that are centered around MCs finding themselves and rediscovering what truly makes them happy.
This book checks all those boxes for a great holiday read. You are shipped away to the gorgeous country of Iceland, following the attractive widowed Cathryn when she meets Mack who has her begin to feel alive again.
Beautiful written and vivid imagery, check this one out now!
Profile Image for Susan Ballard (subakkabookstuff).
2,606 reviews98 followers
October 28, 2022
I have always wanted to travel to Iceland. It seems like a beautiful and mysterious place with glaciers, rugged landscapes, and icy seas. The rich, detailed descriptions within this book have confirmed my longings.

The plot follows Cathryn, a freelance photographer who travels to Iceland to do a photo shoot about an artist, Mack, who specializes in glassblowing.

What follows is a story steeped in art glassblowing, but the wonders of natural beauty too.

As for Cathryn’s journey, she was widowed young and raised two kids alone. She went to Iceland on a job assignment, but meeting Mack changed her itinerary and helped reset her heart's compass.

𝘈𝘳𝘵𝘪𝘴𝘵𝘪𝘤, 𝘝𝘪𝘷𝘪𝘥, 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘙𝘦𝘥𝘦𝘮𝘱𝘵𝘪𝘷𝘦!

Thank you @suzyapprovedbooktours and @getredprbooks for a spot on tour and a gifted ebook.
Profile Image for Nita.
537 reviews58 followers
October 27, 2022
The Color of Ice by Barbara Linn Probst is such a beautiful poignant story. Her writing and words are filled with awe and grace. Five Beautiful Blue Glass Stars!
Profile Image for Emily Dunham.
37 reviews
August 20, 2023
I’m actually shocked this book is rated as highly as it is. I don’t think I’ve ever “hate read” a book before but that was the case with this one for pretty much the entire second half.

Cathryn has to be one of the most unlikeable main characters I’ve ever encountered. Her personality sucks and the way she was so desperately obsessed with Mack was so cringeworthy. He’s just not that into you!! Never mind the fact that nothing about him was particularly swoon-worthy either. The way he reacted when she broke his art felt like such an over reaction to an accident? I also could not imagine staying in another country, blowing off a HUGE career opportunity for a guy who can’t give you more than “Yes” or “It’s alright with me if you stay.” That was bad enough but the moment I completely lost respect for Cathryn was when she was critical of Deborah for never forgiving Mack when he ABANDONED his pregnant wife because he was too into immersing himself in the jungle? And then didn’t return her call until TWO DAYS after she had to deliver her stillborn baby alone?? It was impossible to enjoy this book because I could not get past her insufferableness.

Killing Mack off at the end of the book so they never had to actually go their separate ways was already painfully cliche, never mind the fact that the northern lights finally magically appeared at that exact moment. But when it was revealed that Cathryn was pregnant I audibly said “oh come on”.

I don’t think I’ve ever felt so passionately irritated by a book. Suffice to say I would not recommend
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Melissa (Nissa_the.bookworm).
1,139 reviews91 followers
September 18, 2022
Read this if you
🧊 have ever wanted to visit Iceland
😮 want a totally unexpected ending
📷 are interested in photography
🔥 would like to give glassblowing a try

•Quick take

A freelance photographer travels to Iceland and falls in love with more than just the country.

•What it’s about

The Color of Ice revolves around 48 year old Cathryn, a freelance photographer on her way to Iceland for the first time. Assigned to photograph the icebergs and the man hoping to imitate them as glass-blown figures, Cathryn ends up falling for him. As the two get to know each other better, Cathryn struggles to let go of her rigid and planned life and just let things be. As she and Henry, aka Mack, finally reveal more and more of themselves to each other, it’s anybody’s guess what will happen when they finally depart Iceland.

•My thoughts

This was an interesting story, full of new topics for me. I have always wanted to visit Iceland one day and glassblowing has always been an interest of mine. I also liked the relationship between Mack and Cathryn. They really came to care for each other. I just wished they had communicated a bit more. I also love photography, so I was encouraging Cathryn to pursue her photography passion again! The ending was a complete surprise for me. I can’t really say I loved it but I guess looking back, I wasn’t that shocked with the outcome.
Profile Image for Maria Lew.
388 reviews17 followers
April 11, 2023
What a wonderful 5 ⭐ read. My first book by Barbara Linn Probst and I loved it. All the characters feel so authentic, yet relatable; Cathryn McAllister photographer and mother of two adult kids Rachel and Judah, and Mack (Henry Malcolm Charbonneau) the glassblower. Iceland a place where everyone wants to visit, and now I can see it's not just the Northern Lights. Cathryn changes throughout the reading. You also feel a change happen within you as you experience all she goes through. It makes you contemplate birth, life, death, chance, and what is meant to be. What an ending, wow 😳. Enjoy ❤️.

I look forward to reading Queen of the Owls & The Sound Between The Notes.

#BarbaraLinnProbst
#TheColorofIce
Profile Image for sammi_reads.
789 reviews20 followers
December 24, 2022
Cathryn goes to Iceland, a bit on a whim, for a quick PR photo shoot with glassblower, Mack. While their she becomes captivated by him, Iceland and glass blowing. Really though, she is rediscovering a part of herself she lost years ago when her husband died. How long can she stay in this bubble before her real world responsibilities with her home, business and two (newly) adult children? And what will she take back with her?

I originally wanted to read this because out trip to Iceland in February '22 was canceled. You get to "see" a lot of Iceland throughout this and the setting was perfect for Cathryn's artistic journey, discovery and growth. I loved all the meaning she found while traveling, even if it was occasionally cheesy and sentimental. The part with Petur caught me.

Cathryn was a fairly generic character, and watching her learn was rewarding, however she felt like such an empty slate at times. Probably because she was being out of character and following Mack. It felt like you could experience her awkwardness and desire to do this very easily as a reader. You got a good sense of her prior and understood how unique the experience was.

However, I did not particularly buy in to the romance. I also HATED Mack. He felt like the douchey hipster at a bar who took a semester of philosophy and memorized a few lines to appear more interesting and mysterious than he actually is. I loved the glass blowing, but was rolling my eyes and annoyed by him. Cathryn's crush felt very school girl and one-sided the entire time. I was glad she stayed because she learned a lot, but wished it had been for her, not for him.

I received this book for free and am voluntarily providing a honest review.
Profile Image for Jenni Ogden.
Author 6 books321 followers
October 23, 2022
Barbara Linn Probst has created a tiny sub-genre all of her own, beautifully witten and structured novels that entwine an art form with a protagonist and her story. So far, art (painting), music, and now glass blowing. Who can guess what art form her next novel will explore? Dance? Wood carving? Pottery? Knitting? Sculpture? We will have to wait another year or two I guess to find out. But here it is, right now, the glass blowing story. Starting at the very beginning, this cover is spectacular. All her covers are beautiful but this one is the most beautiful. They are, in themselves, pieces of art. A++ to Julie Metz, the cover designer. Then the location, Iceland. The location descriptions are beautiful and I think (along with the glass blowing descriptions) make this story. They definitely make me want to go there. Then we have the fruits of the author’s hands-on research; this time glass blowing made real for we readers as we almost experience, along with Cathryn (the protagonist) some of the techniques and artistry of the craft as Mack, the immediately likeable but clearly damaged glass blower allows us to watch (and even assist a little) as he performs his magic. Most of us know at least something about painting, and music, but glass blowing? So that is a bonus. Then there is the story, which is both predictable and unpredictable. Cathryn is a mid-life widow (with a past story of course) and to me at least, not very likeable… uptight, bitter perhaps, over-organised, has discarded her own art (photography) for commerce, and if her excruciatingly unlikeable adult children are anything to go by, did not manage solo parenting very well! So she definitely has a big journey to go on to come out the other side as someone we’re rooting for.

So you will need to read this to find out if she succeeds!

Profile Image for Jessica Samuelson.
460 reviews43 followers
October 23, 2022
This was an intriguing and thought provoking read for me. At its heart, it is about two people who are attracted to each other in part because they are both haunted by the past. The two artists reacted to their own tragedies very differently. Cathryn kept her photography at a distance, using it only as a way to make money. Meanwhile, Mack buried himself in his glasswork as a way to protect himself from feeling anything else. Together, they finally begin to take steps toward healing. Even if they were never meant for anything long term.

I like the different opinions presented in this book about art: what it is (or isn’t), what it means, and how it affects both those who experience it and the artists themselves. Here are a couple of my favorite art quotes from the book:

“Looking, experiencing, getting to know the thing you want to portray. That’s half the work…The other half is transforming it into your own incarnation of what you’ve seen.”

“An artist could love anything, by really seeing it. Penetrating, and then revealing, the life within.”

NOTE: This is not a romance novel. A Happily Ever After is not guaranteed.

Thank you to NetGalley and She Writes Press for an Advanced Reader Copy ebook. ⁠
Profile Image for Cindy Roesel.
Author 1 book69 followers
October 24, 2022
Once again, Barbara Linn Probst takes us on a journey a few may have traveled, but most of us can only imagine. In The Color of Ice (SheWritesPress), Cathryn McAllister's, a photographer who has never been able to pursue her dream to make art gets her chance. She's the mother of two adult children and alone after the accidental death of her cheating husband. She realizes she has the opportunity to do what she wants. She walks away from a commercial photography career and takes up freelancing. She learns of a job interviewing a glassblower in Iceland and takes it. She'll do the job and go sight seeing after, or she thinks..

Henry Malcolm Charbonneau, known as "Mack" is Cathryn's subject. He's creating a glass series inspired by the blue glaciers of Iceland. He's emotionally unavailable and he has secrets but Cathryn finds something intriguing about him. She finds herself going into his workroom to "help out" when not needed.

Cathryn and Mack are both lost souls who have suffered and are angry. Art is their common interest and after a brief affair, each is able to let their guard down and discover the beauty of each one's love of art.

Once again, Barbara creates complex characters in an unique environment. I really liked the characters, particularly Cathryn. I enjoyed watching her grow and fulfill her dreams. Barbara explained the art of blowing glass so intricately, I could feel the heat and visualize the scene. The descriptions of Iceland were so beautiful that I wanted to hop a flight right way. But ultimately, The Color of Ice is about a woman accepting a nonlinear path to happiness and self-acceptance.
Profile Image for Cheryl.
6,635 reviews238 followers
November 29, 2022
This book is the second one I have read by this author. It is my favorite. There is a lyrical type of style that comes off reading this book. That I really enjoyed.

The emotional connection with Cathryn was strong. Although, I have to admit that in the beginning, I did struggle a bit to form this connection with her. Yet, as the story progressed as I got to know more about Cathryn, I felt for her. The struggle she was experiencing between staying or leaving was felt through the pages of the story.

When it came to Mack, I instantly warmed up to him. Despite the fact that he had a past that was making him guarded. Thus, because of this I think is the reason that Mack was drawn to wanting to help Cathryn.
Profile Image for Jill (chill_jilland_read).
449 reviews68 followers
December 3, 2022
One thing I love most about this community is finding books I might miss out on otherwise. It makes me so happy to settle in with a good book from an author I haven’t discovered yet then loving their work. The Color of Ice takes such an unique setting and art form and creates a beautiful story about love. I was completely surprised by the passion and intensity of this story. Cathryn’s strength hooked me into the story, as did her backstory as a mother and young widow. The idea of being a photographer added such an interesting take on a story of discovery and second chances. This novel is one of the most vivid I’ve read in a while.

Thank you Get Red PR for the gifted copy.
Profile Image for Joyce.
47 reviews37 followers
August 31, 2022
The author has an amazing way of bringing Iceland and glassblowing to life with such vivid details! It truly felt like I was there with the characters. I loved how Cathryn threw all her normal tendencies to the side and followed her heart. Mack was an intriguing fella, an artist full of passion for his craft. There was a twist at the end that completely caught me off guard. I look forward to reading more of her books in the future!

Highly recommend reading!
Profile Image for Booksandcoffeemx.
2,495 reviews136 followers
October 8, 2022
𝘉𝘳𝘦𝘢𝘵𝘩𝘵𝘢𝘬𝘪𝘯𝘨𝘭𝘺 𝘣𝘦𝘢𝘶𝘵𝘪𝘧𝘶𝘭!

It’s hard to put into words what this book made me feel, I loved every page of this beautiful story about love, loss, redemption and healing. With a stunning setting, unique characters and captivating writting this story simply took my breath away. All the stars.

Thank you Suzy Approved Book Tours and Get Red PR for this tour invite.

𝗧𝗵𝗲 𝗖𝗼𝗹𝗼𝗿 𝗼𝗳 𝗜𝗰𝗲 by Barbara Linn Probst, Author releases October 18, 2022.

https://www.instagram.com/booksandcof...
Profile Image for Reeca Elliott.
2,060 reviews25 followers
October 22, 2022
Cathryn has been asked to travel to Iceland to photograph a very talented glass blower. She decides to turn this trip into a much needed vacation. But, as we all know, life throws us curve balls.

I loved Cathryn from the start. She has been just existing in her life for a while. So, she has decided to do for her and this vacation is sort of a life changing decision. Then she meets Mack, the glass blower, and sparks do not fly. Their connection smolders and slowly grows into an undeniable bond.

Now, at first, I was not a big fan of Mack. I found him borderline rude. But, his gruffness grew in me. And his talent is something else! I loved learning about the glass blowing process. I figured this would be a boring part of the book. But, this author is powerful in her descriptions.

This was very close to a 5 star read for me. The plot is just a little thin. But my word, the scenery and the prose! It just keeps you coming back for more! I fell for Iceland and much as I did this story. It is now in my bucket list!

Need a good love story about resilience and strength with a fabulous setting…THIS IS IT! Grab your copy today!

I received this novel from the author for a honest review.
Profile Image for Marilyn Rumph.
71 reviews6 followers
April 11, 2023
An exploration of art, one's own, love, and Iceland.

The Color of Ice is a great book for anyone who has considered that they aren’t living the life they were meant to live. I marked so many quotes in the book as over and over again, the author, Barbara Linn Probst, was able to move me to consider myself and my current state as an older retired woman coming out of the pandemic feeling estranged and a bit lost as to how my life was unfolding – not by design, but by happen stance. The story, though, regardless of one’s current personal state, is beautifully wrought as it captures the stark beauty of Iceland, the art of glass blowing, and the glow and heat of a love affair.
Profile Image for Beth.
4,247 reviews18 followers
August 25, 2025
I got this rather randomly; I had a vacation romance bookclub and the blurb said this was a vacation and set in Iceland. Iceland sounds cool!

It’s not a romance, but a book about a woman maturing into herself after her kids are grown, allowing herself to really feel the grief and love and anger she had bottled up while raising her kids after her cheating husband died. I enjoyed the way the landscape, art work, and emotions all pulled together.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 142 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.