Sira is the female heir apparent to a nomadic tribe, way before the dawn of history, during the period known as prehistory. This is the age of sabre-tooth tigers, of woolly mammoths and giant eagles. Being on the move is the norm, building villages and staying in one place a seemingly alien way of life. Amidst this wild and dangerous world, Sira’s tribe is under threat. They’re being hunted by a powerful tribe known as the Eagle Feathers whose mantra is to capture every human and absorb them into their group. Dissenters are not tolerated. While attempting to throw the Eagle Feathers off the scent, Sira and a small group are attacked. She’s injured and thought dead by her tribe, but in truth she is saved by an Other – a Neanderthal known as Harq. Who is this mysterious rescuer and will she be able to return to her tribe in time and save them from the Eagle Feathers?
Paleolithic is an okay read, but it’s not something that’s going to stay in your mind once you’ve put the book on the sidetable and switched off the lamp. In fact, there are lots of moments where there was a choice between the book and something else, and I chose something else. It’s not particularly gripping, suffice it to say. But that doesn’t make it a bad book either. I still went back to it, I still read it, I was still pleasantly distracted by the story. But it has its problems.
For one thing, the narrative is oddly jarring. There are references to ‘prehistoric forest’ (presumably it’s not ‘prehistoric’ to the prehistoric people?), ‘rushes of oxygen’ and ‘the Milky Way’. I suppose the narrator could be all-knowing, but it’s just plain weird to read a book about a prehistoric tribe and hear modern terminology for elements and galaxies. Not to mention the use of the term ‘knackered’, but maybe I’m being unjust and Sira’s tribe travelled through Eurasia with a pitstop in 20th century Britain. I don’t know, maybe I’m nitpicking, but it did interfere with the whole 'suspending disbelief' thing.
That’s not the biggest problem though. I’ve already established that the book didn’t grip me and I’m trying to put a finger on why. And it’s got to be the characters. They’re just not interesting enough to warrant any kind of emotional investment. Sira is the moral centre of the book, her views seemingly alien in a world where survival-of-the-fittest seems to be the dominant ideology. She’s also pretty and powerful and next-in-line-for-leadership. Maybe I could have got behind her, but she’s simply not in the book long enough to make that happen. For much of it, she’s nursing her wounds, whether that’s directly or while other people are having their moments to shine. Harq is more or less a closed book, not helped by the language barrier that exists between him and Sira. The only character that seemingly had some sort of progression and defined goal is Kadam, a warrior of Sira’s tribe, who is captured early on by the Eagle Feathers and forced to adopt their way of life. His storyline is probably the most exciting, which doesn’t seem right given that he is – to all intents and purposes – a side character.
The storyline itself is enjoyable even if it takes a little while to get going. There are twists and turns, there are reckonings and scenes of horror – it has a lot going on. A lot of it would have been gut-punching if the characterisation was there, as such you feel sort of detached from it all, which is a crying shame.
The world is well-realised though. The wildlife, the migrations, the competing cultures – you can tell that a lot of effort has gone into painting this world and making it seem real. There’s also a good amount of action, from skirmishes with rival tribes and wildlife to ritualistic ceremonies where one mistake can get you killed. It can forget that it’s a story sometimes though, and often it feels like less of a story and more of a documentary. I can almost hear the David Attenborough narration. It’s always evocative however, even if what we see is cheapened somewhat by the lack of decent characterisation.
All in all, Paleolithic is a decent enough bit of escapism that you can read, enjoy and quickly forget. Those with an interest in the prehistoric world will certainly get something out of it. But would I stick around for the sequel (the ending begs it)? Not likely.