What do you think?
Rate this book
Lady Librarian Mystery #1
A Novel Disguise
When Miss Tiffany Woodall assumes the identity of her half-brother after his death, she realizes she isn’t the only one with a secret to hide in this historical series debut, perfect for fans of Deanna Raybourn and Sherry Thomas.
1784 London. Miss Tiffany Woodall didn’t murder her half-brother, but she did bury him in the back garden so that she could keep her cottage. Now, the confirmed spinster has to pretend to be Uriah and fulfill his duties as the Duke of Beaufort’s librarian while searching Astwell Palace for Uriah’s missing diamond pin, the only thing of value they own. Her ruse is almost up when she is discovered by Mr. Samir Lathrop, the local bookseller, who tries to save her from drowning while she's actually just washing up in a lake after burying her brother.
Her plan is going by the book, until the rector proposes marriage and she starts to develop feelings for Mr. Lathrop. But when her childhood friend, Tess, comes to visit, Tiffany quickly realizes her secret isn’t the only one hidden within these walls. The body of a servant is found, along with a collection of stolen items, and someone else grows mysteriously ill. Can Tiffany solve these mysteries without her own disguise being discovered? If not, she’ll lose her cottage and possibly her life.
1784 London. Miss Tiffany Woodall didn’t murder her half-brother, but she did bury him in the back garden so that she could keep her cottage. Now, the confirmed spinster has to pretend to be Uriah and fulfill his duties as the Duke of Beaufort’s librarian while searching Astwell Palace for Uriah’s missing diamond pin, the only thing of value they own. Her ruse is almost up when she is discovered by Mr. Samir Lathrop, the local bookseller, who tries to save her from drowning while she's actually just washing up in a lake after burying her brother.
Her plan is going by the book, until the rector proposes marriage and she starts to develop feelings for Mr. Lathrop. But when her childhood friend, Tess, comes to visit, Tiffany quickly realizes her secret isn’t the only one hidden within these walls. The body of a servant is found, along with a collection of stolen items, and someone else grows mysteriously ill. Can Tiffany solve these mysteries without her own disguise being discovered? If not, she’ll lose her cottage and possibly her life.
320 pages, Paperback
First published May 16, 2023
102 people are currently reading
2419 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 421 reviews
August 1, 2025
I am going to be a wet blanket. I had high hopes for this book, and it failed to deliver. I was expecting a fun and witty murder mystery with a dash of romance. This is NOT it. The story started out ok but soon slowed to a crawl. I was hoping to have a character with a mixed-race background add something new to a standard plot. It was a Modern Historical that hit most of today's hot topics. The ending was packed with a lot of action and was totally unbelievable.
July 29, 2023
What a quirky, cozy mystery!
4.5 stars
This book was chock-full of charm and originality; it was both right up my alley and very different than I’m used to.
Set in the mid 18th century, we are treated to so many great historical details, slice of life for both aristocrats and servants, and lots of societal injustice. This is all integrated seamlessly into the plot and its inclusion is used to drive the story forward or create sympathy for the characters.
I quite liked the main character Tiffany, a 40 year old spinster, who’s half brother - on whom she’s dependant- dies unexpectedly. It’s not tragic, don’t worry, he’s a selfish prick and no one misses him. To remain living in their cottage, she decides to dress up as him and continue his work as a duke’s librarian.
During her time pretending to be her brother, a murder happens at the palace. As Tiffany sees a link to her own brother’s death and worries for her life, she undergoes her own investigation. Shenanigans ensue.
Though I did enjoy this, I felt that it wasn’t explored to its fullest potential. I wanted the author to lean into the comedic opportunities of the gender bending and Tiffany’s natural quirkiness. Events would happen; the love interest Samir, constantly attempting rescue when none is needed, and when she needs to play both herself and her brother at a supper party at the palace, and I found myself wishing they had been played up for better comedy. I was smirking when I should have been laughing.
Other than that this was a fun little read and an oddball take on a cozy mystery. The side romance with Samir did not wrap up so I’m hoping this is intended as a series. I’d definitely recommend this for fans of the light mystery genre and those who like stories of women taking charge of their lives and overcoming adversity.
Couple of weird editing issues that I hope will be cleared up pre-launch:
Callus s/b callous, used a few times.
Thanks to Crooked Lane Books and NetGalley for the advanced copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
4.5 stars
This book was chock-full of charm and originality; it was both right up my alley and very different than I’m used to.
Set in the mid 18th century, we are treated to so many great historical details, slice of life for both aristocrats and servants, and lots of societal injustice. This is all integrated seamlessly into the plot and its inclusion is used to drive the story forward or create sympathy for the characters.
I quite liked the main character Tiffany, a 40 year old spinster, who’s half brother - on whom she’s dependant- dies unexpectedly. It’s not tragic, don’t worry, he’s a selfish prick and no one misses him. To remain living in their cottage, she decides to dress up as him and continue his work as a duke’s librarian.
During her time pretending to be her brother, a murder happens at the palace. As Tiffany sees a link to her own brother’s death and worries for her life, she undergoes her own investigation. Shenanigans ensue.
Though I did enjoy this, I felt that it wasn’t explored to its fullest potential. I wanted the author to lean into the comedic opportunities of the gender bending and Tiffany’s natural quirkiness. Events would happen; the love interest Samir, constantly attempting rescue when none is needed, and when she needs to play both herself and her brother at a supper party at the palace, and I found myself wishing they had been played up for better comedy. I was smirking when I should have been laughing.
Other than that this was a fun little read and an oddball take on a cozy mystery. The side romance with Samir did not wrap up so I’m hoping this is intended as a series. I’d definitely recommend this for fans of the light mystery genre and those who like stories of women taking charge of their lives and overcoming adversity.
Couple of weird editing issues that I hope will be cleared up pre-launch:
Callus s/b callous, used a few times.
Thanks to Crooked Lane Books and NetGalley for the advanced copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
May 24, 2023
Update: There will be a sequel!
🥳🥳🥳
So since my only complaint about this book was the lack of closure, I’m bumping it up to five stars and hoping to get the arc of Once Upon a Murder!!
———
I absolutely did not expect to like it so much!
Tiffany is forty years old and she runs her brother’s house. When Uriah unexpectedly dies she realizes that she is about to lose her income and her home, so she decides to take her fate in her own hands. Since she and her brother looked very much alike, she dresses up as him and takes over his job as a librarian.
I enjoyed this book immensely, and I adored Tiffany. She had her hands full being a librarian and still running a household, while making sure nobody discovered her ruse. In the meantime she was struggling to escape the advances of the local rector while falling for the handsome bookseller/constable.
This book is a brilliant comedy with well written characters and a murder mystery. There is even a touch of romance, and isn’t it refreshing to see a forty year old heroine? Gimme more!!
I was pleasantly surprised by how well researched this story is. There’s an author’s note explaining parts that you might doubt are historically accurate, and there is even a bibliography. You don’t see it often in fiction!
The ending did not tie all loose ends and I was a teeny-tiny bit disappointed, but otherwise it was a very entertaining read. Highly recommended to all historical fiction lovers!
4.5 stars!
Thank you Crooked Lane Books and NetGalley for the chance to read this book in exchange for an honest review.
🥳🥳🥳
So since my only complaint about this book was the lack of closure, I’m bumping it up to five stars and hoping to get the arc of Once Upon a Murder!!
———
I absolutely did not expect to like it so much!
Tiffany is forty years old and she runs her brother’s house. When Uriah unexpectedly dies she realizes that she is about to lose her income and her home, so she decides to take her fate in her own hands. Since she and her brother looked very much alike, she dresses up as him and takes over his job as a librarian.
I enjoyed this book immensely, and I adored Tiffany. She had her hands full being a librarian and still running a household, while making sure nobody discovered her ruse. In the meantime she was struggling to escape the advances of the local rector while falling for the handsome bookseller/constable.
This book is a brilliant comedy with well written characters and a murder mystery. There is even a touch of romance, and isn’t it refreshing to see a forty year old heroine? Gimme more!!
I was pleasantly surprised by how well researched this story is. There’s an author’s note explaining parts that you might doubt are historically accurate, and there is even a bibliography. You don’t see it often in fiction!
The ending did not tie all loose ends and I was a teeny-tiny bit disappointed, but otherwise it was a very entertaining read. Highly recommended to all historical fiction lovers!
4.5 stars!
Thank you Crooked Lane Books and NetGalley for the chance to read this book in exchange for an honest review.
January 5, 2024
4.25*
Such a fun read about an older FMC in the 1700s and the unfortunate circumstances she finds herself in when her brother suddenly dies without warning. So inconsiderate of him as she has no means of income nor employment option(s) open to her...what's a gal to do but bury bro in the garden of their shared cottage and literally step into his shoes + don his wig to "man" the library and keep the monies coming in while she figures it all out of course 🙃
I mean what could possibly go wrong...she certainly couldn't have foreseen meeting a handsome chap as she washes off in a lake that very night. Said bookseller couldn't have known his gallant attempt to rescue someone from the lake after midnight would lead to a murder mystery, with Mrs Doubtfire vibes dinner party shenanigans as things spiral from there. This was easily one of the most fun reads and a new take on a period setting - I binged it in a day 🤭
I did 👀 a smidge the trial towards the end as justice sure was swift! 😬
I have had a tab open on my phone since I read this with every intention of a spot of research into the outcome of such a scenario. But considering I work too many hours of the day in the legal field as it is and I spend more of my free time than is healthy binging lawtube content I've magnanimously [to myself] opted to forego that reading as in all honesty I'm too lazy after this much time has passed 😅
I am very excited to return to this series as there is thankfully a sequel coming out Feb 2024 which is great news because if this book had been a standalone it was a little too open of an ending for my greedy liking 🤗
Please do yourself a favour and don't sleep on this book if a period setting is calling to you. It takes place in a world we often visit in books but don't always see from this step of the class ladder & with the MMC being of Indian heritage and a bookseller brings further intricate + delicate layers to this tasty story that has humour, heart and a murder mystery...c'mon what more can we ask for? 😉
PS - the vicar get get in the sea 🤬🍆
Such a fun read about an older FMC in the 1700s and the unfortunate circumstances she finds herself in when her brother suddenly dies without warning. So inconsiderate of him as she has no means of income nor employment option(s) open to her...what's a gal to do but bury bro in the garden of their shared cottage and literally step into his shoes + don his wig to "man" the library and keep the monies coming in while she figures it all out of course 🙃
I mean what could possibly go wrong...she certainly couldn't have foreseen meeting a handsome chap as she washes off in a lake that very night. Said bookseller couldn't have known his gallant attempt to rescue someone from the lake after midnight would lead to a murder mystery, with Mrs Doubtfire vibes dinner party shenanigans as things spiral from there. This was easily one of the most fun reads and a new take on a period setting - I binged it in a day 🤭
I did 👀 a smidge the trial towards the end as justice sure was swift! 😬
I have had a tab open on my phone since I read this with every intention of a spot of research into the outcome of such a scenario. But considering I work too many hours of the day in the legal field as it is and I spend more of my free time than is healthy binging lawtube content I've magnanimously [to myself] opted to forego that reading as in all honesty I'm too lazy after this much time has passed 😅
I am very excited to return to this series as there is thankfully a sequel coming out Feb 2024 which is great news because if this book had been a standalone it was a little too open of an ending for my greedy liking 🤗
Please do yourself a favour and don't sleep on this book if a period setting is calling to you. It takes place in a world we often visit in books but don't always see from this step of the class ladder & with the MMC being of Indian heritage and a bookseller brings further intricate + delicate layers to this tasty story that has humour, heart and a murder mystery...c'mon what more can we ask for? 😉
PS - the vicar get get in the sea 🤬🍆
May 17, 2023
When her half-brother dies unexpectedly, Tiffany Woodall quietly buries him and then assumes his identity. There is nothing else for her to do in 1780’s England, especially if she wants to stay in the cottage the two of them lived in. But she quickly finds that being two people is much more challenging than she expected, especially when she starts falling in love with the local book seller and has to dodge the marriage proposal of the local rector. But it’s taking over her half-brother’s job of the local duke’s librarian that puts her in the most danger when one of the servants dies. Might it tie to her brother’s death?
Obviously, there is a lot going on here, and it does mean the mystery takes a little time to become an important part of the story. But I didn’t care. I was quickly caught up in Tiffany’s life and couldn’t wait to find out what would happen to her next. And make no mistake about it, the mystery here is strong. I loved how things were all pulled together for the climax. The characters are also wonderful, with plenty of them to love or love to hate. I always felt like I was transported back in time as I was reading. My only complaint was that we learned a little more than I felt necessary about the after effects of the poison, but that was a minor issue. I’m already looking forward to the sequel. If you are looking for a fun historical mystery, don’t miss this one.
NOTE: I received an ARC of this book.
Read my full review at Carstairs Considers.
Obviously, there is a lot going on here, and it does mean the mystery takes a little time to become an important part of the story. But I didn’t care. I was quickly caught up in Tiffany’s life and couldn’t wait to find out what would happen to her next. And make no mistake about it, the mystery here is strong. I loved how things were all pulled together for the climax. The characters are also wonderful, with plenty of them to love or love to hate. I always felt like I was transported back in time as I was reading. My only complaint was that we learned a little more than I felt necessary about the after effects of the poison, but that was a minor issue. I’m already looking forward to the sequel. If you are looking for a fun historical mystery, don’t miss this one.
NOTE: I received an ARC of this book.
Read my full review at Carstairs Considers.
Read
March 12, 2024DNF at 30% so I guess it's not fair to rate this. But if I were to, it would be 1.5 to 2 stars. Boring story, unappealing characters, slow-moving and silly plot. Serviceable writing but nothing about it was very pleasurable to read. I got this for $1.99 on a sale day and if I were on a desert island with only it to read maybe it would be worth that. I am, however, floored to see that the sequel to this costs $19.99 in the Kindle version. Sorry, but you would have to pay me that 20 bucks rather than me putting out that much to read it.
April 27, 2023
Oh my! Beware the mask of disguise!
When Miss Tiffany Woodall’s sanctimonious, penny pinching, selfish brother died overnight her second thought was what would happen to her. His position as librarian to the Duke of Beaumont gave them a house to live in and money. Where would she go? Then she hit on her desperate ingenious plan. Disguise herself as her brother and continue as normal. As Uriah’s sister she’d been the one to shop, and engage village folk. Uriah had been too high in the instep for that. What could go wrong?
Everything! Moving Uriah’s body was just Tiffany’s first difficulty. From then on, being caught naked bathing in the lake, to the hilarious time of both Tiffany and the dead Uriah (yes, at the same time) being asked to dinner with the Duke and Duchess, and her once upon a time friend, another Duchess. Despite these setbacks Tiffany manages to win through, only to have the sudden death of one of the staff in a suspicious manner disturbs things. As the bodies begin to pile up, it’s obvious that there’s a murderer on the loose! Tiffany is once again liable to exposure. Especially given the attention of the intelligent, dreamy Constable Lathrop.
Lots of high jinx had this novel galloping to an end that didn’t quite resolve some questions I’d had, but definitely answered others. I’m unsure if this is black comedy, or a satire of the times. Interestingly the laws and practices of the time are documented, heightening my knowledge of why Tiffany would consider the actions she took.
Well worth the read.
A Crooked Lane ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
(Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.)
When Miss Tiffany Woodall’s sanctimonious, penny pinching, selfish brother died overnight her second thought was what would happen to her. His position as librarian to the Duke of Beaumont gave them a house to live in and money. Where would she go? Then she hit on her desperate ingenious plan. Disguise herself as her brother and continue as normal. As Uriah’s sister she’d been the one to shop, and engage village folk. Uriah had been too high in the instep for that. What could go wrong?
Everything! Moving Uriah’s body was just Tiffany’s first difficulty. From then on, being caught naked bathing in the lake, to the hilarious time of both Tiffany and the dead Uriah (yes, at the same time) being asked to dinner with the Duke and Duchess, and her once upon a time friend, another Duchess. Despite these setbacks Tiffany manages to win through, only to have the sudden death of one of the staff in a suspicious manner disturbs things. As the bodies begin to pile up, it’s obvious that there’s a murderer on the loose! Tiffany is once again liable to exposure. Especially given the attention of the intelligent, dreamy Constable Lathrop.
Lots of high jinx had this novel galloping to an end that didn’t quite resolve some questions I’d had, but definitely answered others. I’m unsure if this is black comedy, or a satire of the times. Interestingly the laws and practices of the time are documented, heightening my knowledge of why Tiffany would consider the actions she took.
Well worth the read.
A Crooked Lane ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
(Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.)
June 5, 2023
DNF at 51 %I was expecting to really like this one but it put me in the worst slump reading it. Once I got to the halfway mark I could not read anymore of it. This one has great reviews online so I must be the minority but the writing never grabbed me and wasn't to my liking. I thought the overall story sounded interesting but that was best thing going for it. It sounded interesting but did not deliver at all.
June 12, 2023
Miss Tiffany Woodall lives with her half-brother Uriah, a controlling, humourless man in a small cottage on the Duke of Beaufort's property. Uriah works as the Duke's librarian; Uriah had taken Tiffany in many years earlier when her fiancé died, though Uriah not particularly well off himself. He, however, did her no more favours. She kept house for him, but he constantly controlled her life, restricting her circle of acquaintances, her wardrobe, stifled her spirit, and ensured she had no money of her own.
When Tiffany finds her brother dead one morning, after having vomited himself to death, she's not sad. Her first impulse is to tell no one; his death would mean she would be turned out of the cottage, so she buries him. While cleaning off the copious mud, Tiffany meets the local bookseller (and constable) Samir Lathrop.
Tiffany decides that she needs everyone to believe Uriah is still alive, so she disguises herself as him, and heads to the Duke's palace and library. No one is the wiser, and she begins her new job, enthralled by all the books, and soon finds herself getting to know Samir better when she must fulfill the Duchess' requests for novels, which the Duke's library lacks.
Tiffany also soon sees that not all is well at the Duke's. There have been a series of small thefts of jewellery, candlesticks and the like, and Tiffany begins to suspect a chambermaid, who soon turns up dead. And before too long, a young, Black footman whom the Duke's wife has a fondness for is arrested for the murder.
Tiffany decides to investigate, and gradually uncovers infidelity, jealousy and other things behind the façade of wealth, while also having to find off the odious advances of a local rector, and friend of Uriah, while also dealing with her attraction for Samir.
I wasn't sure what to expect when I read the summary for this book, and did not expect to love Tiffany so much. She's very frustrated with her circumstances, and when presented with the opportunity, jumps in to save herself. Tiffany must not only pretend to be her brother for her own safety, but she even becomes a quick change artist, going from portraying herself, to her brother, to herself, all during at a dinner party.
The book is funny, but also doesn't shy away from the grim financial prospects for an unmarried gentlewoman with no way to legitimately support herself. I loved how the author also added in lots of historical details, and a bibliography for the naysayers who insist that only white people lived in England, when the truth is a quite different and interesting.
Tiffany begins to forge a new life for herself by the end of this book, and there are relationships she's just starting to build by the last page. This makes me hope dearly that we get more of Tiffany Woodhall reading novels and solving mysteries.
Than you to Netgalley and to Crooked Lane Books for this ARC in exchange for my review.
When Tiffany finds her brother dead one morning, after having vomited himself to death, she's not sad. Her first impulse is to tell no one; his death would mean she would be turned out of the cottage, so she buries him. While cleaning off the copious mud, Tiffany meets the local bookseller (and constable) Samir Lathrop.
Tiffany decides that she needs everyone to believe Uriah is still alive, so she disguises herself as him, and heads to the Duke's palace and library. No one is the wiser, and she begins her new job, enthralled by all the books, and soon finds herself getting to know Samir better when she must fulfill the Duchess' requests for novels, which the Duke's library lacks.
Tiffany also soon sees that not all is well at the Duke's. There have been a series of small thefts of jewellery, candlesticks and the like, and Tiffany begins to suspect a chambermaid, who soon turns up dead. And before too long, a young, Black footman whom the Duke's wife has a fondness for is arrested for the murder.
Tiffany decides to investigate, and gradually uncovers infidelity, jealousy and other things behind the façade of wealth, while also having to find off the odious advances of a local rector, and friend of Uriah, while also dealing with her attraction for Samir.
I wasn't sure what to expect when I read the summary for this book, and did not expect to love Tiffany so much. She's very frustrated with her circumstances, and when presented with the opportunity, jumps in to save herself. Tiffany must not only pretend to be her brother for her own safety, but she even becomes a quick change artist, going from portraying herself, to her brother, to herself, all during at a dinner party.
The book is funny, but also doesn't shy away from the grim financial prospects for an unmarried gentlewoman with no way to legitimately support herself. I loved how the author also added in lots of historical details, and a bibliography for the naysayers who insist that only white people lived in England, when the truth is a quite different and interesting.
Tiffany begins to forge a new life for herself by the end of this book, and there are relationships she's just starting to build by the last page. This makes me hope dearly that we get more of Tiffany Woodhall reading novels and solving mysteries.
Than you to Netgalley and to Crooked Lane Books for this ARC in exchange for my review.
July 16, 2023
Thank you to NetGalley for providing an Advanced Listening Copy in exchange for an honest review.
If I am being honest, I was not 100% sold on the blurb- it seemed like a lot going on for one novel. However, I could not have been more wrong about that!
Larsen skillfully weaves the many layers to this story together and tackles many issues at once. Yes, we’ve got a murder to solve. However, we’ve also got Tiffany’s burgeoning career (as her brother), her romance, and quite frankly, her standing in life as a whole. Just when I thought that I could not be more invested in the story, Larsen introduces another element that pulls me in even further.
What really set this novel apart for me was Tiffany as the protagonist. It is so rare to see a single woman older than 25 in any sort of historical fiction, and she has a rich, full life on her own at 40. I know that the Pride and Prejudice clip where Charlotte Lucas is talking about being 27 with no prospects is going around social media, but Tiffany makes it clear that her prospects are not solely related to romance. (Though the romance in this book is quite sweet!)
Marni Penning’s narration is a delight. She brings so many characters to life and makes each person we meet unique.
This is a fantastic mystery but also simply a wonderful piece of historical fiction, and it is one of my favourite new books of 2023!
If I am being honest, I was not 100% sold on the blurb- it seemed like a lot going on for one novel. However, I could not have been more wrong about that!
Larsen skillfully weaves the many layers to this story together and tackles many issues at once. Yes, we’ve got a murder to solve. However, we’ve also got Tiffany’s burgeoning career (as her brother), her romance, and quite frankly, her standing in life as a whole. Just when I thought that I could not be more invested in the story, Larsen introduces another element that pulls me in even further.
What really set this novel apart for me was Tiffany as the protagonist. It is so rare to see a single woman older than 25 in any sort of historical fiction, and she has a rich, full life on her own at 40. I know that the Pride and Prejudice clip where Charlotte Lucas is talking about being 27 with no prospects is going around social media, but Tiffany makes it clear that her prospects are not solely related to romance. (Though the romance in this book is quite sweet!)
Marni Penning’s narration is a delight. She brings so many characters to life and makes each person we meet unique.
This is a fantastic mystery but also simply a wonderful piece of historical fiction, and it is one of my favourite new books of 2023!
August 31, 2023
Prior to this, I had read one book by the author - Secret of the Sonnets, which I liked. The mystery part wasn't very intriguing, but the plot was fresh and there was amusing banter. But this book disappointed me quite a lot, and nothing seemed to fall in place.
The plots in the genre usually stretch the imagination but the premise in this one was quite far-fetched. A woman masquerading as a man may have worked if the man in question was not a familiar person. But to fool several others who he has been meeting everyday for six months? Simply doesn't work. The change in the getup during dinner is right out of Mrs Doubtfire, and impossible for to accomplish without the help of a maid, given the dresses of the era.
The murder mystery was also quite simplistic - I had a strong suspicion early on who the culprit is, and I was certain before the halfway mark. Then, there is the question of historic accuracy.
I know these books are mostly for entertainment, but I found such huge inconsistencies quite annoying. A rather grudging 2 stars, since I did finish the book.
The plots in the genre usually stretch the imagination but the premise in this one was quite far-fetched. A woman masquerading as a man may have worked if the man in question was not a familiar person. But to fool several others who he has been meeting everyday for six months? Simply doesn't work. The change in the getup during dinner is right out of Mrs Doubtfire, and impossible for to accomplish without the help of a maid, given the dresses of the era.
The murder mystery was also quite simplistic - I had a strong suspicion early on who the culprit is, and I was certain before the halfway mark. Then, there is the question of historic accuracy.
I know these books are mostly for entertainment, but I found such huge inconsistencies quite annoying. A rather grudging 2 stars, since I did finish the book.
November 23, 2022
This book was a very pleasant surprise!
The Georgian period, the older main character, and her personal circumstances all come together to make a different kind of story. It's mainly a murder mystery with some romance, but my favorite elements pertain to Tiffany herself and the way she navigates her new situation after her half-brother dies.
As she realizes that he didn't die of natural causes like she at first thought, she tries to discover the real culprit, even with so much at stake for her personally.
I hope there will be more to this series!
I received a copy from the publisher via NetGalley and this is my honest opinion.
The Georgian period, the older main character, and her personal circumstances all come together to make a different kind of story. It's mainly a murder mystery with some romance, but my favorite elements pertain to Tiffany herself and the way she navigates her new situation after her half-brother dies.
As she realizes that he didn't die of natural causes like she at first thought, she tries to discover the real culprit, even with so much at stake for her personally.
I hope there will be more to this series!
I received a copy from the publisher via NetGalley and this is my honest opinion.
March 18, 2024
Dollycas's Thoughts
Mr. Uriah Woodall is the Duke of Beaufort’s librarian and his half-sister Miss Tiffany Woodall keeps house for him, most days feeling like a servant more than a sister. One morning Uriah doesn't come down for breakfast. When Tiffany checks on him, she finds him dead. He had been sick in the night and between the smell and the shock she is lost about what to do. In fear of losing their home and knowing she won't inherit anything, she makes an risky decision. She buries her brother under a tree in the backyard. Then she dons her brother's clothes and wig and pretends to be him to do his job and to keep the cottage. While there she will look for their only family possession that had value, a diamond pin Uriah lost at Astwell Palace.
Amazed that her plan is working she goes into town without her disguise only to have the rector propose marriage following the death of his second wife. What he really wants is a caretaker for his 14 children. She also realizes she is developing feelings for another man, a local bookseller, and constable Mr. Samir Lathrop.
Then the Duchess has a house party and invites the Duchess of Surrey who just happens to be Tiffany's childhood friend. She is sure the woman will immediately see through her novel disguise, but Tiffany realizes her secret isn't the only one at Astwell Palace.
When a servant dies suspiciously and when another person becomes ill, Tiffany knows there is something afoot in the Duke of Beaufort's home and she is determined to solve the mystery. Can she do it without revealing her own secret? or will she die trying?
_____
I know I would never survive London in 1784. Tiffany Woodall is a strong woman hemmed in by the constraints of the time. She had been engaged to Third Lieutenant Nathaniel Occom but he died before they could marry. So she has been keeping house for her half-brother for twenty years. He was a hard man to work for, a selfish miserly man, but probably very true to the time. Following his death Tiffany had the courage to save herself. Digging the grave and burying her brother takes physical strength. Then she has to think on her feet and out of the box. She seems to be able to fool people dressed in her disguise or people at that time really don't look closely at others around them. It was her actions and human nature that would reveal the truth to some people but they held her secret.
Mr. Samir (Sam) Lathrop was an open-thinking man. A bookseller who Tiffany later found out is the town constable. They didn't get off on the right foot. There were times he thought she needed rescuing and those moments had me laughing out loud. But Tiffany had to work hard to keep up her ruse and Sam is a pretty observant man.
I enjoyed the diverse cast of characters in this book. I was engaged by Tiffany and her plight. Sam, is a kind man who just wants to help. I loved their interactions. Ms. Larsen also gives her readers characters to dislike, one who was especially intense and even creepy. All the characters developed nicely throughout the story.
I was delighted by the author's descriptive writing style. I can tell from the historical details that the author spent time thoroughly researching the era. From the palace and all its rooms to Tiffany's Bristle cottage, the bookstore to the church, I was able to envision each place clearly. I also appreciated her attention to detail about what the characters were wearing including the heavily powdered wigs. I believe this custom started as a way for a King to hide his gray hair and others soon adopted the custom. Such crazy vanity that went on for years.
Ms. Larsen has written a very strong mystery that develops slowly at first with Tiffany's masquerade falling into place. Then precise clues move the mystery forward. Tiffany was juggling a lot at the palace and away from it. Tending the library she learns there have been thefts at the palace. The rector is relentless in his quest to control her. But she takes her investigation seriously and uncovers things at the palace are not what they seem. She just needs to put the pieces all together. I must say, I was so wrapped up in Tiffany's life that I didn't really work on solving the mystery before her. I just let myself be entertained by the captivating story.
A Novel Disguise is a clever debut for the Lady Librarian Mystery Series. It's a wonderful mystery laced with humor and a bit of romance. Ms. Larsen's strong and memorable characters will grab your attention and hold on tight until the final page. The sequel is impatiently waiting on my Kindle. I hope to escape into it soon!
Mr. Uriah Woodall is the Duke of Beaufort’s librarian and his half-sister Miss Tiffany Woodall keeps house for him, most days feeling like a servant more than a sister. One morning Uriah doesn't come down for breakfast. When Tiffany checks on him, she finds him dead. He had been sick in the night and between the smell and the shock she is lost about what to do. In fear of losing their home and knowing she won't inherit anything, she makes an risky decision. She buries her brother under a tree in the backyard. Then she dons her brother's clothes and wig and pretends to be him to do his job and to keep the cottage. While there she will look for their only family possession that had value, a diamond pin Uriah lost at Astwell Palace.
Amazed that her plan is working she goes into town without her disguise only to have the rector propose marriage following the death of his second wife. What he really wants is a caretaker for his 14 children. She also realizes she is developing feelings for another man, a local bookseller, and constable Mr. Samir Lathrop.
Then the Duchess has a house party and invites the Duchess of Surrey who just happens to be Tiffany's childhood friend. She is sure the woman will immediately see through her novel disguise, but Tiffany realizes her secret isn't the only one at Astwell Palace.
When a servant dies suspiciously and when another person becomes ill, Tiffany knows there is something afoot in the Duke of Beaufort's home and she is determined to solve the mystery. Can she do it without revealing her own secret? or will she die trying?
_____
I know I would never survive London in 1784. Tiffany Woodall is a strong woman hemmed in by the constraints of the time. She had been engaged to Third Lieutenant Nathaniel Occom but he died before they could marry. So she has been keeping house for her half-brother for twenty years. He was a hard man to work for, a selfish miserly man, but probably very true to the time. Following his death Tiffany had the courage to save herself. Digging the grave and burying her brother takes physical strength. Then she has to think on her feet and out of the box. She seems to be able to fool people dressed in her disguise or people at that time really don't look closely at others around them. It was her actions and human nature that would reveal the truth to some people but they held her secret.
Mr. Samir (Sam) Lathrop was an open-thinking man. A bookseller who Tiffany later found out is the town constable. They didn't get off on the right foot. There were times he thought she needed rescuing and those moments had me laughing out loud. But Tiffany had to work hard to keep up her ruse and Sam is a pretty observant man.
I enjoyed the diverse cast of characters in this book. I was engaged by Tiffany and her plight. Sam, is a kind man who just wants to help. I loved their interactions. Ms. Larsen also gives her readers characters to dislike, one who was especially intense and even creepy. All the characters developed nicely throughout the story.
I was delighted by the author's descriptive writing style. I can tell from the historical details that the author spent time thoroughly researching the era. From the palace and all its rooms to Tiffany's Bristle cottage, the bookstore to the church, I was able to envision each place clearly. I also appreciated her attention to detail about what the characters were wearing including the heavily powdered wigs. I believe this custom started as a way for a King to hide his gray hair and others soon adopted the custom. Such crazy vanity that went on for years.
Ms. Larsen has written a very strong mystery that develops slowly at first with Tiffany's masquerade falling into place. Then precise clues move the mystery forward. Tiffany was juggling a lot at the palace and away from it. Tending the library she learns there have been thefts at the palace. The rector is relentless in his quest to control her. But she takes her investigation seriously and uncovers things at the palace are not what they seem. She just needs to put the pieces all together. I must say, I was so wrapped up in Tiffany's life that I didn't really work on solving the mystery before her. I just let myself be entertained by the captivating story.
A Novel Disguise is a clever debut for the Lady Librarian Mystery Series. It's a wonderful mystery laced with humor and a bit of romance. Ms. Larsen's strong and memorable characters will grab your attention and hold on tight until the final page. The sequel is impatiently waiting on my Kindle. I hope to escape into it soon!
April 25, 2023
Pride & Prejudice meets Downton Abbey meets Agatha Christie in this hilariously fun mystery. I've never read anything by Samantha Larsen/Hastings but now I'm interested in more from her!
Miss Tiffany Woodall is a 40-year-old spinster keeping house for her brother. When she tries to wake up her brother one morning and he's dead, she assumes his vocation and identity in order to keep her home and her freedom. When it turns out her brother didn't die from natural causes, Tiffany makes it her mission to discreetly figure out who is administering poison and for what purpose. There are also marriage proposals, affairs, skinny dipping, jail time, and more. The writing was very engaging and I couldn't wait to see what happened next!
I'll definitely be purchasing a physical copy when this releases in a couple of weeks.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for sending me an e-arc in exchange for my honest review.
Miss Tiffany Woodall is a 40-year-old spinster keeping house for her brother. When she tries to wake up her brother one morning and he's dead, she assumes his vocation and identity in order to keep her home and her freedom. When it turns out her brother didn't die from natural causes, Tiffany makes it her mission to discreetly figure out who is administering poison and for what purpose. There are also marriage proposals, affairs, skinny dipping, jail time, and more. The writing was very engaging and I couldn't wait to see what happened next!
I'll definitely be purchasing a physical copy when this releases in a couple of weeks.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for sending me an e-arc in exchange for my honest review.
May 2, 2023
Tiffany Woodall finds herself in quite the predicament when she discovers her brother Uriah dead one morning. As a spinster who relies on her brother's income to live and his position as the librarian at Astwell Palace which provides their cottage, she'll be left with nothing once his death is discovered. Unless it's not discovered.
I couldn't imagine living in that time period and having to be completely dependent upon a male figure to provide for you. If you didn't have one, you were destitute, homeless, penniless. But Miss Tiffany Woodall has some luck on her side...she looks just like her brother. Add his wig on her head, his face powder and clothes and tah dah, she's now Uriah Woodall, librarian! Perfect!
Oh how I loved this book! I loved seeing Tiffany's spunk and determination to take care of herself and to actually have a say in her life and future. And her freedom in being able to do many things that she wanted to do but due to being a woman and the constraints of society on women, she's been unable to do so.
Now all she needs to do is keep up care of her cottage, act like Uriah at the palace and in the library, change her clothes back and forth to keep up her ruse of being both Tiffany and Uriah, order new books for the house party from Mr. Samir Lathrop the book seller, keep him from detecting that she's Tiffany, avoid the reverend who wants to propose to her, find her brother's missing diamond pin, comfort the employees at the palace who are mourning the death of a co-worker and just a few other things. Easy peasy!!! Maybe... Hopefully she can keep it all together if it starts to unravel...
Oh, you're all in for such a treat with this one. Especially if you enjoy cozy mystery stories! Lots of humor, sleuthing, a love story, mix-ups galore, avoiding unwanted suitors, a mystery, and murder!!!
Content: Clean. Fun read. Some mild suspense but nothing overly graphic. I'd let teenagers read it!
I received a copy from the author. All thoughts and opinions in the review are my own.
Happy Reading!!!
I couldn't imagine living in that time period and having to be completely dependent upon a male figure to provide for you. If you didn't have one, you were destitute, homeless, penniless. But Miss Tiffany Woodall has some luck on her side...she looks just like her brother. Add his wig on her head, his face powder and clothes and tah dah, she's now Uriah Woodall, librarian! Perfect!
Oh how I loved this book! I loved seeing Tiffany's spunk and determination to take care of herself and to actually have a say in her life and future. And her freedom in being able to do many things that she wanted to do but due to being a woman and the constraints of society on women, she's been unable to do so.
Now all she needs to do is keep up care of her cottage, act like Uriah at the palace and in the library, change her clothes back and forth to keep up her ruse of being both Tiffany and Uriah, order new books for the house party from Mr. Samir Lathrop the book seller, keep him from detecting that she's Tiffany, avoid the reverend who wants to propose to her, find her brother's missing diamond pin, comfort the employees at the palace who are mourning the death of a co-worker and just a few other things. Easy peasy!!! Maybe... Hopefully she can keep it all together if it starts to unravel...
Oh, you're all in for such a treat with this one. Especially if you enjoy cozy mystery stories! Lots of humor, sleuthing, a love story, mix-ups galore, avoiding unwanted suitors, a mystery, and murder!!!
Content: Clean. Fun read. Some mild suspense but nothing overly graphic. I'd let teenagers read it!
I received a copy from the author. All thoughts and opinions in the review are my own.
Happy Reading!!!
did-not-finish
August 12, 2023I got to 35%, couldn’t take the clumsy, unsophisticated writing, skipped ahead to the last three chapters. What started with a funny premise became a slog of obvious, childish writing.
The praise for a Methodist going off to evangelize feels like an in-artful reference to Mormonism.
Also, a titled person would not be tried in a local court in this time period. That is so basic that I’m kind of stunned that made it through Crooked Lane’s editors.
And the country home of a Duke wouldn’t be called a palace.
The praise for a Methodist going off to evangelize feels like an in-artful reference to Mormonism.
Also, a titled person would not be tried in a local court in this time period. That is so basic that I’m kind of stunned that made it through Crooked Lane’s editors.
And the country home of a Duke wouldn’t be called a palace.
May 12, 2023
I loved this! Tiffany is one of my favorite characters Samantha's written so far. She is kind and loving despite how she's been treated by her family and society.
When Tiffany wakes up one morning to find her brother dead in his room she panics. What is she going to do when they find out? Where will she go? A spinster with no money would inherit nothing. So she takes her fate into her own hand and takes on his identity instead.
The process of becoming her brother was quite extensive and I found myself anxious any time she made the switch between herself and Uriah. It's like being on the edge of your seat hoping no one discovers what she's doing. When murder takes place at the Palace where she's taken over Uriah's position as librarian, she starts to wonder if her brother's death wasn't natural.
With the help of a very handsome bookseller, Tiffany sets out to solve the mysteries happening at the Palace. I enjoyed reading about Tiffany and her life in disguise. The workings of the palace, the differences in status and station, and what is acceptable for women in society at that time made this for a balanced and exciting read. It doesn't just touch on social norms of the time period but also addresses racism and women's rights.
I 100% recommend this!
When Tiffany wakes up one morning to find her brother dead in his room she panics. What is she going to do when they find out? Where will she go? A spinster with no money would inherit nothing. So she takes her fate into her own hand and takes on his identity instead.
The process of becoming her brother was quite extensive and I found myself anxious any time she made the switch between herself and Uriah. It's like being on the edge of your seat hoping no one discovers what she's doing. When murder takes place at the Palace where she's taken over Uriah's position as librarian, she starts to wonder if her brother's death wasn't natural.
With the help of a very handsome bookseller, Tiffany sets out to solve the mysteries happening at the Palace. I enjoyed reading about Tiffany and her life in disguise. The workings of the palace, the differences in status and station, and what is acceptable for women in society at that time made this for a balanced and exciting read. It doesn't just touch on social norms of the time period but also addresses racism and women's rights.
I 100% recommend this!
May 19, 2023
Samantha Larsen (Hastings) is quickly becoming a favorite author of mine. I thoroughly enjoyed A Novel Disguise. I really loved how Tiffany was an older main character and how genuine and kind she was, as she navigated taking over in disguise as her late brother and solving the mysterious deaths around her.
The Georgian time period, in my opinion, is a little unpleasant with the wigs (and the wig bugs, yuck!), face paint, and the treatment of women and people of color. But the author does an excellent job portraying this time.
I loved the mystery part of the story and there was even some very funny parts. One part in particular (involving wig powder) had me laughing out loud. Samir was also a wonderful character and Thomas, Emily, Mrs. Wheatley; a superb cast of characters.
I truly am hoping for more books with these characters!
I received a copy from Netgalley. All views and opinions expressed are my own.
The Georgian time period, in my opinion, is a little unpleasant with the wigs (and the wig bugs, yuck!), face paint, and the treatment of women and people of color. But the author does an excellent job portraying this time.
I loved the mystery part of the story and there was even some very funny parts. One part in particular (involving wig powder) had me laughing out loud. Samir was also a wonderful character and Thomas, Emily, Mrs. Wheatley; a superb cast of characters.
I truly am hoping for more books with these characters!
I received a copy from Netgalley. All views and opinions expressed are my own.
April 27, 2024
It was cute and fine. A fun read. I was just a little bored. I wanted a little more from the story. While there was a bit of romance, I wanted more. Overall, not a bad way to spend a day, but I probably won’t read the others.
January 28, 2023
A surprisingly compelling & entertaining murder mystery!
Murder, mysterious secrets, blackmail, odious suitors, illicit liaisons and masquerading deception abound and entangle with an array of well fleshed out and diverse characters and a budding romance that for me made this a great start to a new series.
Instantly, I liked and cemented myself inTiffany's corner, immediately drawn in by her desperation and how downtrodden, overlooked and used she has been by her obnoxious stepbrother. Coming to enjoy her masquerade immensely... the main reason that convinced me in the first place to try Samantha Larsen, a new author for me, and a decision I'm very glad of as I rather loved this well put together cosy mystery with an injection of engaging wit, humour and hints of romance.
I was reeled into the escalating drama, the nervous energy brought on by the promise of her being found out versus the allure of seeking out hints, motives and clues to finding the culprit.
While the delightfully refreshing host of diverse, multicultural characters added another level to the suspense and intrigue and hyped up the effect of the social strictures and hardships of the time, reflected in both class and sex, and the prejudices that they endured. Making the story flow with a greater degree of interest and fun believability that made it hard to put down without being pulled back in quickly.
I particularly loved the romantic thread interwoven within the tale's core mystery plot as the interaction between Tiffany and Samir evoked a humour, warmth and deep attraction that built, thrummed and electrically sparkled throughout and pulled me in as love budded between them as misunderstandings threatened to pull them apart. Made all the more refreshing by our heroine being much older than our typical spinster, at forty years of age.
A great start that promises to continue and develop a romance emcompassed by a community of well rounded subcharacters that promises to continue and flourish in book 2 - a book I'm very much hoping for and eager to seek out in the future!
Murder, mysterious secrets, blackmail, odious suitors, illicit liaisons and masquerading deception abound and entangle with an array of well fleshed out and diverse characters and a budding romance that for me made this a great start to a new series.
Instantly, I liked and cemented myself inTiffany's corner, immediately drawn in by her desperation and how downtrodden, overlooked and used she has been by her obnoxious stepbrother. Coming to enjoy her masquerade immensely... the main reason that convinced me in the first place to try Samantha Larsen, a new author for me, and a decision I'm very glad of as I rather loved this well put together cosy mystery with an injection of engaging wit, humour and hints of romance.
I was reeled into the escalating drama, the nervous energy brought on by the promise of her being found out versus the allure of seeking out hints, motives and clues to finding the culprit.
While the delightfully refreshing host of diverse, multicultural characters added another level to the suspense and intrigue and hyped up the effect of the social strictures and hardships of the time, reflected in both class and sex, and the prejudices that they endured. Making the story flow with a greater degree of interest and fun believability that made it hard to put down without being pulled back in quickly.
I particularly loved the romantic thread interwoven within the tale's core mystery plot as the interaction between Tiffany and Samir evoked a humour, warmth and deep attraction that built, thrummed and electrically sparkled throughout and pulled me in as love budded between them as misunderstandings threatened to pull them apart. Made all the more refreshing by our heroine being much older than our typical spinster, at forty years of age.
A great start that promises to continue and develop a romance emcompassed by a community of well rounded subcharacters that promises to continue and flourish in book 2 - a book I'm very much hoping for and eager to seek out in the future!
May 16, 2023
Tiffany Woodall is enjoying being on her own ever since she found her brother dead in his bed and buried him in the back garden she has had no one to tell her what to do or when to do it and when she dresses up like her deceased brother she seems to have even more freedoms. He worked for the Duke and Duchess As the librarian, in order not to lose the little cottage she calls home she dresses up like him and shows up to work every day. When the duchess tell her she needs her to find books for her guests that are coming in for a party Tiffany knows she will have to face Mr. Lathrop again not only does she have a crush on Mr. Lathrop but the last time they met he took her bathing in the creek for her drowning and saved her despite she had no clothes on but because needs must she goes dressed as herself she goes to the little bookstore One of the perks of being the librarian is that she gets to read the books even though there’s enough happening at the house to entertain anyone. Sarah who is the ladies made his dalliances with seemingly every good looking man in the household inches also a thief but wind she turns up dead and they learn she was poisoned they also learned she wasn’t the attended victim more was she the first to be murdered. When a footman is arrested for the murder and Tiffany’s secrets also become public she knows her life is on the line. There is way too much in this book to give a detailed summary I haven’t even mentioned the detestable vicar who wanted Tiffany to marry him A mother his 14 motherless children. I loved Tiffany Mr. Lathrop and so many other great characters in this book I thought the narrator did a great job she had great comedic timing and made the book that much funnier and OMG is that funny a total five star listen. If you love Victorian era mysteries then you love A Novel Disguise by Samantha Larson, I certainly did I absolutely love this book! I received this book from NetGalley and dreamscape media but I am leaving this review voluntarily please forgive any mistakes as I am blind and dictate my review.
June 12, 2023
The premise of this book was amazing! Forty year old spinster Tiffany Woodall is wholly dependent on her half-brother Uriah. When she discovers his dead body, she immediately panics. After all, it’s his job as librarian to a prestigious duke that provides for them and allows them a cottage to live in. What’s a woman to do?
After burying him in the backyard, realizing she looks enough like Uriah to pass for him with a little powder and a wig, she decides to assume his identity, and that’s when the fun begins. There’s also a mystery to solve which suggests Uriah’s death may not have been from natural causes. As she and her new found friend Samir, the local bookseller investigate, she must assume her brother’s library position, discourage an overeager rector, keep her identity secret from Samir, avoid her visiting childhood friend, and find a murderer.
This story had everything: a cozy murder mystery, laugh out loud humor, a little romance, and enough suspense to keep me up late reading. Tiffany’s intelligence and wit made this such a fun read. I loved her budding romance with Samir and friendship with Tom, a former slave. Switching her identity back and forth between herself and her brother made for some humorous situations especially when she’s required to be two places at once! I also loved the classic gothic romances and literature references.
The mystery was well done with several suspects and motives. It kept me guessing until the end with a few red herrings thrown in. I enjoyed the way Tiffany, Samir, and Tom all worked together to discover who the murderer was. It’s a clever story cozy mystery fans will definitely enjoy.
I received an advanced complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions are completely my own and voluntarily given.
After burying him in the backyard, realizing she looks enough like Uriah to pass for him with a little powder and a wig, she decides to assume his identity, and that’s when the fun begins. There’s also a mystery to solve which suggests Uriah’s death may not have been from natural causes. As she and her new found friend Samir, the local bookseller investigate, she must assume her brother’s library position, discourage an overeager rector, keep her identity secret from Samir, avoid her visiting childhood friend, and find a murderer.
This story had everything: a cozy murder mystery, laugh out loud humor, a little romance, and enough suspense to keep me up late reading. Tiffany’s intelligence and wit made this such a fun read. I loved her budding romance with Samir and friendship with Tom, a former slave. Switching her identity back and forth between herself and her brother made for some humorous situations especially when she’s required to be two places at once! I also loved the classic gothic romances and literature references.
The mystery was well done with several suspects and motives. It kept me guessing until the end with a few red herrings thrown in. I enjoyed the way Tiffany, Samir, and Tom all worked together to discover who the murderer was. It’s a clever story cozy mystery fans will definitely enjoy.
I received an advanced complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions are completely my own and voluntarily given.
October 20, 2022
A Novel Disguise by Samantha Larsen is a great historical fiction and mystery is the first in A Lady Librarian Mystery series.
This murder/mystery takes place in 1784 in London, England. This centers around a rural village and country estate called Astwell Palace.
I loved the main character, Miss Tiffany Woodall. Misunderstood and ignored by her less than favorable sibling, Uriah, she finally experiences purpose, adventure, and love when finding her brother’s body, and dresses as said brother to keep his current position and her newfound dwelling on the estate (and a much needed source of income). She attempts to conceal these unfortunate changes, juggle being in two places at multiple duties as the Duke of Beaufort’s librarian while being ensnared into mystery, a missing family item, romance entanglements, and secrets that abound from left and right.
Can it all be solved with a positive and satisfying outcome for Tiffany and all involved? I loved finding out.
A great start! Looking forward to seeing where this goes.
5/5 stars
Thank you NG and Crooked Lane Books for this wonderful arc and in return I am submitting my unbiased and voluntary review and opinion.
I am posting this review to my GR and Bookbub accounts immediately and will post it to my Amazon, Instagram, and B&N accounts upon publication on 5/16/23.
This murder/mystery takes place in 1784 in London, England. This centers around a rural village and country estate called Astwell Palace.
I loved the main character, Miss Tiffany Woodall. Misunderstood and ignored by her less than favorable sibling, Uriah, she finally experiences purpose, adventure, and love when finding her brother’s body, and dresses as said brother to keep his current position and her newfound dwelling on the estate (and a much needed source of income). She attempts to conceal these unfortunate changes, juggle being in two places at multiple duties as the Duke of Beaufort’s librarian while being ensnared into mystery, a missing family item, romance entanglements, and secrets that abound from left and right.
Can it all be solved with a positive and satisfying outcome for Tiffany and all involved? I loved finding out.
A great start! Looking forward to seeing where this goes.
5/5 stars
Thank you NG and Crooked Lane Books for this wonderful arc and in return I am submitting my unbiased and voluntary review and opinion.
I am posting this review to my GR and Bookbub accounts immediately and will post it to my Amazon, Instagram, and B&N accounts upon publication on 5/16/23.
December 2, 2022
This was a delightfully different kind of historical novel that did a lot to point out the differences between how women and men are treated in this time period.
I loved this story. It was a comedy of errors at times which just added to it's charms and it is definitely charming. I loved the story. I loved watching Tiffany's delicate dance to keep her secret. This was not your normal Regency/Georgian/period piece and that is what makes it great.
The chemistry of the leads was natural and developed marvelously. I found the humor perfectly moderated and the subject matter was handled well.
I must say the widowed clergyman was as odious as he was intended to be. I NEEDED him to fail.
This was a fun twist to a story and I loved how perfectly it ended. I highly recommend.
I received an eArc through NetGalley and this is my honest review.
I loved this story. It was a comedy of errors at times which just added to it's charms and it is definitely charming. I loved the story. I loved watching Tiffany's delicate dance to keep her secret. This was not your normal Regency/Georgian/period piece and that is what makes it great.
The chemistry of the leads was natural and developed marvelously. I found the humor perfectly moderated and the subject matter was handled well.
I must say the widowed clergyman was as odious as he was intended to be. I NEEDED him to fail.
This was a fun twist to a story and I loved how perfectly it ended. I highly recommend.
I received an eArc through NetGalley and this is my honest review.
November 13, 2024
4.5 stars**
.
I really enjoyed this story. It was interesting to learn more of the history of how women were treated in this time period. Also, how unjust and horrible the justice system was in this period. Definitely not a time I would have wanted to live in!
.
I liked the mystery and I also enjoyed the characters. Tiffany is someone you come to care about. I am interested in reading the next book in the series to see how her position and her relationship with Samir comes along.
.
Overall a very enjoyable read!
.
I really enjoyed this story. It was interesting to learn more of the history of how women were treated in this time period. Also, how unjust and horrible the justice system was in this period. Definitely not a time I would have wanted to live in!
.
I liked the mystery and I also enjoyed the characters. Tiffany is someone you come to care about. I am interested in reading the next book in the series to see how her position and her relationship with Samir comes along.
.
Overall a very enjoyable read!
April 22, 2025
There were some promising elements in this story but they were drowned by meaningless meanderings and details. I found the pacing uneven and almost DNF'd at 75% because the draaaag. But I decided to finish and it did pick up again, if in a quite unbelievable way that teetered into farce territory. I dunno. I liked part of it but disliked most of it.
December 4, 2022
I received a copy of this from NetGalley and this is my freely given opinion.
It was initially slow going for me at the beginning of this book because I was a bit put off by the MC's treatment of her brother, but the more I read, the more I understood her and empathized with her circumstances, and grew to really enjoy the book.
Tiffany Woodall is a 40 year old spinster, who lived as a downtrodden, unpaid housekeeper and drudge to her older half brother, Uriah, who works as the librarian for the duke. Because of Uriah's high opinion of himself, general snobbishness, and his treatment of Tiffany, she is quite isolated and friendless in their community. One morning, as she is preparing the normal routine for her day and for Uriah, she goes to wake him for work to find that he has been ill and died in bed. Because she has nothing, and the roof over their head belongs to the Duke's estate and they live in it as a courtesy of Uriah's position in his household, Tiffany is frightened of being penniless and homeless, with nothing to her name and no prospects of making her way in the world, with no friends or family. As they share a strong resemblance, Tiffany makes the bold and desperate choice to bury her brother herself and take on his identity and position in the library, to keep the cottage and be able to fend for herself.
Coupled with having to play two roles, and living with the guilt and fear of discovery, Tiffany is also being pursued by the dour and unlikable rector, as a wife and mother for his humongous brood of children. She discovers a strong liking and attraction for a local bookseller, Sam Lathrop, who unfortunately is also the local constable. And, while working in the household of the duke, is caught between her past where Tiffany had a schoolgirl friendship with a member of the aristocracy, and her present as Uriah/Tiffany, and of the servant class. Finally... she finds herself caught in a murder mystery, when one of the other staff is found dead. This was determined by a local physician to have been caused by poison. Tiffany sees that her death is similar to how Uriah had died, and is wracked with guilt and fear because she had never considered that his death may be murder... and if he was murdered, does this mean she is now, as Uriah, the target for a murderer?
I loved the strong character descriptions of the various players in this novel; they really brought some of the characters, like Tiffany, Uriah, Mr. Smithley, Sam, and Thomas to life for me. The story was intriguing and I really enjoyed the contrasting elements of the story, such as the conflict and contrast of those living in different class structures, race, and gender roles, and how Tiffany felt trapped by them, but how she tried to break free of them, or how she saw others because of how she had experienced them.
This was a compelling and fascinating story and while it was initially a bit of a slow grow, I ended up thoroughly enjoying it.
I do wonder though, what did ultimately happen to Smithley and his poor brood of children. Will there be more of Tiffany, and how will she be treated, after it became knowledge to others what she did?
4.25 Stars out of 5
It was initially slow going for me at the beginning of this book because I was a bit put off by the MC's treatment of her brother, but the more I read, the more I understood her and empathized with her circumstances, and grew to really enjoy the book.
Tiffany Woodall is a 40 year old spinster, who lived as a downtrodden, unpaid housekeeper and drudge to her older half brother, Uriah, who works as the librarian for the duke. Because of Uriah's high opinion of himself, general snobbishness, and his treatment of Tiffany, she is quite isolated and friendless in their community. One morning, as she is preparing the normal routine for her day and for Uriah, she goes to wake him for work to find that he has been ill and died in bed. Because she has nothing, and the roof over their head belongs to the Duke's estate and they live in it as a courtesy of Uriah's position in his household, Tiffany is frightened of being penniless and homeless, with nothing to her name and no prospects of making her way in the world, with no friends or family. As they share a strong resemblance, Tiffany makes the bold and desperate choice to bury her brother herself and take on his identity and position in the library, to keep the cottage and be able to fend for herself.
Coupled with having to play two roles, and living with the guilt and fear of discovery, Tiffany is also being pursued by the dour and unlikable rector, as a wife and mother for his humongous brood of children. She discovers a strong liking and attraction for a local bookseller, Sam Lathrop, who unfortunately is also the local constable. And, while working in the household of the duke, is caught between her past where Tiffany had a schoolgirl friendship with a member of the aristocracy, and her present as Uriah/Tiffany, and of the servant class. Finally... she finds herself caught in a murder mystery, when one of the other staff is found dead. This was determined by a local physician to have been caused by poison. Tiffany sees that her death is similar to how Uriah had died, and is wracked with guilt and fear because she had never considered that his death may be murder... and if he was murdered, does this mean she is now, as Uriah, the target for a murderer?
I loved the strong character descriptions of the various players in this novel; they really brought some of the characters, like Tiffany, Uriah, Mr. Smithley, Sam, and Thomas to life for me. The story was intriguing and I really enjoyed the contrasting elements of the story, such as the conflict and contrast of those living in different class structures, race, and gender roles, and how Tiffany felt trapped by them, but how she tried to break free of them, or how she saw others because of how she had experienced them.
This was a compelling and fascinating story and while it was initially a bit of a slow grow, I ended up thoroughly enjoying it.
I do wonder though, what did ultimately happen to Smithley and his poor brood of children. Will there be more of Tiffany, and how will she be treated, after it became knowledge to others what she did?
4.25 Stars out of 5
December 3, 2022
3.25 Stars
ARC provided by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review
This was exactly what I was in the mood to read right now - a short, fun and relatively fast-paced book.
A Novel Disguise is set in 18th century England. Our protagonist, Tiffany Woodall, poses as her dead older brother to avoid losing her home and source of income. Her masquerade is complicated by the murder and attempted murder of servants at the palace where her brother - and now she - works. This leads Tiffany to suspect that her brother’s natural death may have been unnatural after all. Tiffany must unmask the murderer before they decide to strike again - and she find herself their next victim.
If you are able to suspend your disbelief about whether Tiffany would be able to successfully take her brother’s place, this is an enjoyable read. While it is not particularly ground-breaking or memorable - in regard to the characters, plot or writing - and I don’t think I would reread it, I still had a good time while reading it, which is what really matters. It did exactly what a decent historical murder mystery should do: the mystery was interesting enough to keep me engaged, the romance subplot was nice, and it didn’t shy away from discussing racism, classism and sexism, which is always refreshing in historical fiction. One criticism is that the ending was a little abrupt, but other than that, I was quite pleased.
Overall, I think this is a great book to read if you’re in a slump.
ARC provided by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review
This was exactly what I was in the mood to read right now - a short, fun and relatively fast-paced book.
A Novel Disguise is set in 18th century England. Our protagonist, Tiffany Woodall, poses as her dead older brother to avoid losing her home and source of income. Her masquerade is complicated by the murder and attempted murder of servants at the palace where her brother - and now she - works. This leads Tiffany to suspect that her brother’s natural death may have been unnatural after all. Tiffany must unmask the murderer before they decide to strike again - and she find herself their next victim.
If you are able to suspend your disbelief about whether Tiffany would be able to successfully take her brother’s place, this is an enjoyable read. While it is not particularly ground-breaking or memorable - in regard to the characters, plot or writing - and I don’t think I would reread it, I still had a good time while reading it, which is what really matters. It did exactly what a decent historical murder mystery should do: the mystery was interesting enough to keep me engaged, the romance subplot was nice, and it didn’t shy away from discussing racism, classism and sexism, which is always refreshing in historical fiction. One criticism is that the ending was a little abrupt, but other than that, I was quite pleased.
Overall, I think this is a great book to read if you’re in a slump.
July 7, 2023
I don’t read a ton of mysteries but fell in love with Samantha Hasting’s books early this year when I read Secret of the Sonnets so I knew I had to read this one. A Novel Disguise was completely wonderful and captivating!
This book takes place in the Georgian time period. When Tiffany Woodall finds her brother dead one morning she panics. She is a spinster who relies on his income and without it she will be forced to give up their cottage. She cannot bear the thought so she does the only thing she can think of to do, pretends to be her brother and takes over his job as a librarian. Luckily she looks enough like him and with his wig, face powder, and clothes she is determined to pull this off.
Oh I just loved Tiffany! I loved her kindness, determination, and strength. I found her so resourceful and appreciated how she was not going to give in to society and was going to make her own way. I enjoyed seeing how her world opened up to her as she pretended to be a man and got to do some of the things women were unable to do at that time, like reading novels. I can’t imagine not being able to read a book simply because you're a woman. I loved seeing her delight as she picked out books and got engrossed in them.
The mystery was so fun to read and kept me turning the pages. The book kept me guessing and I never suspected anything until the mystery was solved. Good thing Tiffany, Samir, and Tom had that covered and discovered the murderer.
A Novel Disguise is a real gem with a little of everything, mystery, humor, romance, and friendship.
If you haven’t read Samantha Hasting before you need to pick up this book. It is well written and well researched with delightful characters! Once you start reading you will not be able to put it down until you turn the very last page!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
This book takes place in the Georgian time period. When Tiffany Woodall finds her brother dead one morning she panics. She is a spinster who relies on his income and without it she will be forced to give up their cottage. She cannot bear the thought so she does the only thing she can think of to do, pretends to be her brother and takes over his job as a librarian. Luckily she looks enough like him and with his wig, face powder, and clothes she is determined to pull this off.
Oh I just loved Tiffany! I loved her kindness, determination, and strength. I found her so resourceful and appreciated how she was not going to give in to society and was going to make her own way. I enjoyed seeing how her world opened up to her as she pretended to be a man and got to do some of the things women were unable to do at that time, like reading novels. I can’t imagine not being able to read a book simply because you're a woman. I loved seeing her delight as she picked out books and got engrossed in them.
The mystery was so fun to read and kept me turning the pages. The book kept me guessing and I never suspected anything until the mystery was solved. Good thing Tiffany, Samir, and Tom had that covered and discovered the murderer.
A Novel Disguise is a real gem with a little of everything, mystery, humor, romance, and friendship.
If you haven’t read Samantha Hasting before you need to pick up this book. It is well written and well researched with delightful characters! Once you start reading you will not be able to put it down until you turn the very last page!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
June 3, 2023
Well that started very gruesomely, with a messy death and backyard burial, setting the tone for whatever mess Tiffany was going to find herself in with the rest of the book!
I have read all the author's YA historical fiction novels and adore them completely so I was very excited to read her new adult historical fiction. I will say that I was expecting more mystery and less focus on romance when I started the story, but the two blended nicely to create a well rounded story.
Overall I found this to be a solid historical mystery with the characters as the stars of the book themselves. I was a little miffed with how the book ended since I was hoping for more (cough cough, a certain romance I was rooting for!), but I learned that this was a first in a series so that gives me hope that I can see what more will play out for this cast of characters in the future.
I have read all the author's YA historical fiction novels and adore them completely so I was very excited to read her new adult historical fiction. I will say that I was expecting more mystery and less focus on romance when I started the story, but the two blended nicely to create a well rounded story.
Overall I found this to be a solid historical mystery with the characters as the stars of the book themselves. I was a little miffed with how the book ended since I was hoping for more (cough cough, a certain romance I was rooting for!), but I learned that this was a first in a series so that gives me hope that I can see what more will play out for this cast of characters in the future.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 421 reviews