If he could be her tragedy, I could be a better one. As a newcomer on Ophelia Island, Florida, Sam Carter is distraught about moving away from his life in West Virginia. But the moment he lays eyes on the mysterious diner girl, Georgia Gabehart, he can't help but surrender to her bewitching allure. Sam is mesmerized by Georgia even as she steals sailboats at night and breaks into lighthouses-the master of playing with knives and not getting cut. Until she's trapped in the tight grip of her boyfriend with a dark side. When a dangerous hurricane sweeps Sam into a police investigation and Georgia is nowhere to be found, Sam gives himself only one love, even if loving might end in tragedy. This dazzling coming of age debut novel from award-winning fiction writer M.M. Cochran will take your breath away.
M. M. Cochran crafts a beautiful and mysterious story of the ties that bind us to each other and the secrets that often hide just beneath the surface, threatening to disrupt our carefully laid plans. The protagonist, Sam, falls hard for a girl who has more secrets than Ophelia island itself, and the story follows a wonderful and intricately twisted path through storms, inner darkness, and young love trying to make sense of it all. I loved this book for its setting and slightly ephemeral feel-technology is for the most part absent (or largely secondary), so this book could easily fit in a time frame anywhere from 10 years ago to the present day, and this timeless quality makes it feel slightly removed from reality. It's easy to place yourself in Sam's shoes and feel his hurt and confusion as he tries to make sense of his last summer before college.
TITLE: Between the Ocean and the Stars AUTHOR: M M Cochran PUB DATE: 10.18.2022 Now Available
Heartbreaking Poignant Emotional
It’s the summer before college, and Sam Carter falls hard. Meeting Georgia changes his life - she lives life in reckless abandon. In the midst of hurricane Boris, Sam’s life is thrown into a whirlwind.
I enjoyed Sam’s voice and point of view as he tries to find his place and navigating his feelings. Cochran writes an emotional and gripping story of young love and how far we would go for love.
I loved this book! from beginning to end, I was hooked. I loved how the characters felt really real. they weren’t perfect and they made mistakes and that’s exactly what people do. consider me an m.m. cochran fan 🤩
Moving is never easy and it’s particularly difficult during the teens years. Sam has to leave all he knows in West Virginia and finds himself in some podunk town in Florida and thinks all is lost until he spies Georgia.
But will Georgia bring him what he is seeking or will she take him places he really does not want to go? At this point in his life Sam does not care. All he is looking for is something in his life to make some sense even if that something makes no sense at all.
Intrigued?
This is a YA book and yet I was not bored. Nor did I feel as if I was reading a teen angst type of book. It kept me intrigued and turning the pages until the end. It’s not your typical romancy type of book and sometimes that is just what you need even though you don’t realize it.
M.M. Cochran has created something beautiful with her first novel.
Between the Ocean and the Stars is a story of love and longing between two perfectly imperfect souls.
There's a storm swirling around Sam and Georgia, and it isn't just the hurricane. The story wends and weaves with highs and lows, just the way real life unfolds. Through it we see young love, loyalty in uncertainty and reckless courage. And you might recognize the familiar ache of looking hard for someone else, just to end up finding yourself.
Between the Ocean and the Stars is one of those books I can’t stop thinking about after finishing it. I’m finding more and more to unpack.
This wasn’t exactly a satisfying read, glad as I am to have read it. But that’s the point. It captures a certain angle of real life—of core memories, of exhilarating experiences, of disappointment, of taking chances, of keeping secrets, of letting go—that you can’t help but feel. Because that’s how life goes. We’re not in love with every part of it, but it’s worth going through it anyway.
The characters are such believable personalities—not outstanding, not totally good or totally bad. They have conflicting motivations. They don’t feel good about all their choices. I was proud of them at times, disappointed at others. And that made me want to understand them, not just read about them.
The plot perfectly corresponds with Sam’s perception of his life: at first slow (but not too slow to enjoy reading), then cranked into high gear, and then you pace alongside Sam as he’s faced with difficult choices that require bold and unhesitant action. The mystery element of this story had me reading the entire second half of the book in one sitting, through the night.
If you’re wanting a cute little romance with a predictable ending and all the warm and fuzzy feels, keep looking. If you’re up for a love story that has to fare through broken homes, police investigations, and hurricanes, you’ve come to the right place.
“If he could be her tragedy, I could be a better one.”
This book hit me like a hurricane. In a whirlwind of teenage love and thrilling mystery, M. M. Cochran crafted a beautiful tragedy that left me spinning. The way the plot suddenly shifted gears was truly masterful, and I was speechless. One second it was an adorable romance and the next it was a “WHAT JUST HAPPENED” kind of book. (No spoilers!) If you love roller coasters for plot lines, read Between the Ocean and the Stars!
It's the most realistic book I have read in years. I'm older but feel like I just stepped onto the island with Sam. Loved the book and highly recommend it for all ages.
Such a great book! I loved the twists, turns, and mystery with a sweet, young love story. The detail poured into Sam’s character was outstanding. A must read! Can’t wait for the next one!
M. M. Cochran has created a wonderful debut novel about young adult love and all the ways it heals and hurts. The MC of BTOATS is Sam and due to his newness as an Ophelia resident, he provides a good lens for us to explore Ophelia and get to know its residents too. His desperation and declarations make him a relatable YA protagonist and his struggles will be empathized by many teens. When we're young, we don't always make the best choices even though our intentions are to help those we love.
The mystery aspect was well done, creating a thread to follow all the way to the end, and created much needed movement in the story. As Sam investigates and finds potential clues, he advances the story at a good pace and many readers will appreciate that this novel is far from slow. I appreciated that the story wasn't predictable and provided some fun theorizing as we learned information alongside Sam.
The mental health representation was an interesting choice to create our complicated antagonist to Sam and Georgia. Mat didn't get much sympathy due to his unpredictable and violent actions which was warranted since the main focus was on Sam's devotion to Georgia - I suppose my issue lies in the potential for misunderstandings regarding the diagnoses of Bipolar and Schizophrenia, along with the behaviors exhibited by those who are labeled with those diagnoses. However, the information of mixing alcohol and medication causing harmful side effects was accurate, and a fair warning to younger audiences. Having mental health issues doesn't make you a bad person, yet people with mental health issues can choose harmful actions.
Overall, I enjoyed this book and look forward to any other writing by this author. I'd recommend to those who enjoy the ups and downs of teen romance and the suspense/uncertainty of not knowing who to trust.
The raw power of the emotions in Between the Ocean and the Stars is something you can’t explain, you can only experience it. I was truly lost in the story, hanging onto the characters and the storylines just hoping they wouldn’t slip away.
When it was over, I just sat there feeling everything. I can’t explain it much more without spoiling things, but I felt EVERYTHING. The author made me connect with these characters so deeply, and I didn’t want to let them go.
Like picking up the pieces after a heavy storm, I find myself still thinking about the characters and trying to make sense of everything I’m feeling. Good books can’t do that. Only great ones can.
Romance and suspense aren’t genres that I read very often, and I was hesitant to even start this one. Between the Ocean and the Stars blew away my expectations. I’ve never read a more relatable character than Sam. Ever. Period. The thoughts in his head were almost word-for-word the thoughts I had when I was 18. It was so real and so raw and so emotional. Georgia was such a powerful character, and the more we got to know her, the more I felt Sam feel for her. The characters were so compelling. And honestly, I just really liked Logan. He was the perfect addition to fill out the story.
It’s possible that there were issues with things, but I didn’t notice any. I was too wrapped up in the story, reeling from what had just happened or wondering what was going to happen next (or screaming at the characters).
You either experience a hurricane, or you get out of its way. Between the Ocean and the Stars is an emotional hurricane. If you’re ready to get wrecked, you need to read this book.
𝐑𝐄𝐀𝐃 𝐓𝐇𝐈𝐒 𝐈𝐅 𝐘𝐎𝐔 💕 enjoy YA romance ⛈️ have ever experienced a hurricane 💋 remember your first love 🧇🍦 love waffles and ice cream
• 𝐐𝐔𝐈𝐂𝐊 𝐓𝐀𝐊𝐄
After Sam and his family move down to Ophelia Island off the coast of Florida, he quickly finds himself falling for a local girl named Georgia.
• 𝐖𝐇𝐀𝐓 𝐈𝐓’𝐒 𝐀𝐁𝐎𝐔𝐓
Sam just graduated from high school and his parents decided to move down to Ophelia Island. Starting over with no friends, Sam decides to go out and explore the island. That’s when he stumbles across Georgia, whom he is instantly smitten with. As Sam tries to get closer to Georgia, he’ll discover some dark secrets she’s hiding. But Sam will do anything to prove his love and affection for Georgia, even if it means getting into all kinds of mischief.
• 𝐌𝐘 𝐓𝐇𝐎𝐔𝐆𝐇𝐓𝐒
This was a super cute YA romance. I liked that it was clean as it is definitely something I probably would have enjoyed when I was around 16 or 17 years old. Even though I am not 19 anymore, I still felt like the characters were very relatable. I, like most people, have suffered from all kinds of heartbreak in my life, so I really understand how Sam felt in this story. I also liked that it was all told from his POV, as it’s rare to read romances from the male’s POV. The DV that Georgia experiences also made this story all the more raw and real.
What would you do for love? That first taste of fizzy, floating on air feeling. The absolute need to be with the person. Sam and his family have just moved to Ophelia Island, Florida. He misses home and is not loving the island. All that changes when he lays eyes on Georgia. She isn't like any girl he has ever met, and he needs her, to be near her, to drink her down with his eyes. She is his oxygen and the only need to get up in the morning.
When a hurricane is projected to hit their small island. Sam is forced to leave with his parents, while Georgia decides to ride it out with her boyfriend. Sam feels like there is something off about him, he is not a good guy. As the winds pick up, and the drenching rains begin, Sam is left to his own imagination about what is going on the island. Will everything be the same when he returns?
This is an intense first love story that will leave you yelling at the characters. The story is vibrant, the characters are well developed, and the setting is phenomenal. Thank you to MM Cochran, Ingram Elliott, and TLC Book Tours for gifting me this book.
After reading my fair share of YA novels I was, as always, excited and nervous to start this one. We all know it's very easy to find a poorly written YA novel, but not this one! Cochran does a fantastic job at pulling you in slowly, letting you soak in the environment and vibe before pushing you into a storm of mystery and excitement. I genuinely enjoyed devouring this book as I felt I could feel the sand under my toes, humidity in my hair and deep love of Cochran creation. This is a great story of the complexities and multidimensional-ism that is being human and learning what that means and a young adult; learning how to not always act out of passion but reason and logic (but a little sprinkle of it too 😉). Looking forward to more of her works!
P.s. don't skip out on the playlist that goes along with the book 🌊
What I loved: ✨Sam’s POV - rarely do I read romance books from a young man’s perspective unless it’s LGBTQ lit. Here, Sam falls hard for Georgia. The pure innocence of young love consumes Sam, his thoughts, and his actions. All of which feel real. ✨Blended Genre - you know me, I love mixed genres! This story blends romance, mystery, and coming of age. The mystery doesn’t start until mid-story, which I wanted sooner. But that's just a personal preference. The romance is both sweet and heartbreaking. Some romance tropes include First Love, Summer Love, and Save Me. Overall, the story is well-balanced and perfect for any YA fan.
I hate sad endings. But somehow this one felt right. This book was a heart wrenching read, with an unpredictable ending that had me smiling sadly until the very last page. I really enjoyed this book, well done M M Cochran! I'm super proud of you.
From a writers perspective, the dialogue and character descriptions were a little bumpy. But I absolutely loved the setting and poetic style of storytelling. Definitely some great lines and themes in this novel! Looking forward to the author's next work.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I got this book from my local Barnes and Noble when I met the Author! I wasn’t sure about it because my usual genre is fantasy. But I genuinely enjoyed this book! The storyline is amazing and the characters are well crafted. There were somethings about this book that surprised me. But overall I liked that about this book. It made it feel different than things I have read before. I would absolutely recommend this to others and I am glad I took a chance on this book. I hope to be able to read another by M.M. Cochran.
I actually read this book while I was on my plane rides for work and mannn… I was so intrigued to see how this novel finished. Between the tumultuous love story and the brain-wracking mystery, it kept the attention of the reader flawlessly! Georgia and Sam were characters that a lot of people could relate to, which serves for the BEST kind of story. Overall, I think this was an outstanding debut novel for M. M. Cochran and I’m really excited to see what she comes out with next!
2.5 stars. This turned out to be a YA romance/mystery. While it was entertaining, parts were not plausible making the story fall apart a little bit for me. But an easy summer read about a boy moving to an island in Florida the year before he starts college and falls in love with a local girl and they get embroiled in a murder mystery. A hurricane hits and all hell breaks loose. At least it did not have a sappy ending.
This book was alright and ok. When I first started reading it. It was interesting and I liked the characters, plot, dialogue, and description of scenes from the book. But the ending of it was ok. Though did not much care for it. I give this 4 stars because despite being a ok book, the ending was not good.
A fun, suspenseful debut novel! I would recommend it to anyone who likes ya suspense/romance or a different spin on a classic beach read. I probably would have given more stars if it was genre I read more often (or perhaps if I would have read it on a sandy beach myself!)
2.75 stars. Cute but a bit cringey. I’m not the target reader here; 18/19 year olds romance. Writing felt odd and of course the parents are basically cardboard cutout nothings.
This book absolutely took me by surprise in the best way. From the first few chapters, I was hooked by Sam’s story — a boy trying to start over, caught between who he was and who he’s becoming. The setting of Ophelia Island feels so vivid that you can almost smell the ocean air and hear the storm rolling in.
What makes this story so powerful is how real it feels. The emotions, the heartbreak, the tension — it all hits deep. Sam and Georgia’s relationship isn’t perfect, but that’s what makes it so honest and unforgettable. M.M. Cochran captures the ache of young love and the weight of loss in a way that feels raw and true.
The writing is beautiful and immersive. Every scene carries meaning — from the quiet moments on the beach to the chaos of the storm. The symbolism, the small-town atmosphere, and the emotional depth all blend together perfectly.
By the time I reached the ending, I just sat there in silence. It’s bittersweet, emotional, and absolutely unforgettable. This isn’t just a love story — it’s a story about healing, forgiveness, and finding peace after tragedy.
Between the Ocean and the Stars is easily one of my favorite reads. If you love stories that pull at your heart, with characters who stay with you long after you close the book, this is one you don’t want to miss!!!!