I first have to say that the overt hostility I have read in a few reviews here and elsewhere are absolutely the result of a toxic cancel culture mindset that has not only ruined so many things but is being purposely spread with an agenda that amounts to nothing more than stone throwing. The sad part is that it's based on willful ignorance, and this is apparent in the terms used by the reviewers. Good thing I didn't let this mentality persuade me to ignore this one of a kind labor of love.
On the other hand, after reading this gem I can see that this is as one reviewer put it, "an intelligent book for intelligent readers." Anyone looking to have their own hardened opinions bolstered and regurgitated back to them will find an issue somewhere in this text. Open minded witches with some real experience and broad reading with "get it." If you are easily offended there might be some points she makes that make you uncomfortable and to me, that is what one should pay attention to because that is where the growth starts.
I don't make it a practice to defend the books that I have grown to love in the witchcraft genre, but today after stumbling across a few pools of bile, I wanted to put forth my two cents because the author deserves this in my opinion. The reason I say this is because she is flat out honest and brave. There is nothing "anti" anything in this book, but if your looking for something to pick on like former Harry Potter fans, then I suppose you might be able to twist the wisdom and teaching into something ugly as some seem to have a talent for (and little else).
Ok, so why do I love this book. First, because it is inspired by magic itself. The author is not giving you another list of colors and correspondences and little rituals intended to keep you in your safe space. She even states early on , "The witch exists in a twilight state of artfully synthesized universal contradictions ." I suppose I can see why this would bother certain types of people who just want to use witchy accoutrements to stimulate their otherwise routine approaches to life. Secondly, she appeals to something you can only FEEL about witchcraft. It's that electric excitement you get when a storm is just starting to brew and the dark clouds are rolling in. In other words; MAGIC. There is no "man hating"or anti anything in this book. But of course, if you want to find this you will do so anywhere. She does write abstractly about female witches naturally having access to greater primal power due to their innate creative power and direct connection to the feminine aspects of the universe. This stance is markedly based in a lot of the shamanistic and Eastern mystical teachings I have encountered where its ok to recognize these polarities. Geraldine Smythe is obviously a bit older than probably many of her readers and it occurred to me that she comes from a magical orientation founded on classic authors like Paul Huson and the Farrars, so her writing is a little more to the point and she does not seem concerned with imbuing it with feeling rather than worrying about hurt feelings.
Either way, Im glad I own this book and it's one of those I will read again and refer to. I personally think this will be regarded as a "classic" in the far future and like some of my like-minded reviewers, I hope she continues to write books like this for those on the path.