What do you think?
Rate this book
Ugly: The Stepsister's Story
You probably know me as the younger ugly stepsister. The foolish stepsister. The girl who was so jealous of Cinderella's charm and beauty that I forced her to dress in rags and do all the chores while my mother and sister and I did nothing, sitting in our rooms all day while Cinderella slaved away to serve us. But that is not at all what happened.
No one ever remembers that it wasn't just Cinderella's father who died. Mine did too. No one asks why I am considered ugly or remembers that I fell in love with Prince Curtis years before that fateful night at the ball. No one wonders what my family was doing while Cinderella was cleaning. But I am here to tell you. I am the ugly stepsister, and this is my story.
No one ever remembers that it wasn't just Cinderella's father who died. Mine did too. No one asks why I am considered ugly or remembers that I fell in love with Prince Curtis years before that fateful night at the ball. No one wonders what my family was doing while Cinderella was cleaning. But I am here to tell you. I am the ugly stepsister, and this is my story.
316 pages, Kindle Edition
Published October 1, 2022
40 people are currently reading
717 people want to read
About the author
Mary Mecham
18 books824 followersMary Mecham writes high stakes, high swoon, no spice romantasy and fairy tale retellings packed full of adventure and romances. Her greatest joy is writing snarky banter and morally grey characters.
She is a born and raised Texan with a love of theater and books overshadowed only by her passion for disability advocacy. Her favorite food is chips and queso, her favorite holiday is April Fool's Day, and her favorite trope is enemies to lovers.
When she isn't writing, Mary enjoys spending time with her family and trying out new experiences, from fire breathing and axe throwing to trapeze flying and power paragliding.
She currently lives in Texas with her husband and three children.
You can get a FREE e-copy of her Rumpelstiltskin retelling, A Curse of Gold and Beauty, when you sign up for her newsletter at MaryMecham.com
She is a born and raised Texan with a love of theater and books overshadowed only by her passion for disability advocacy. Her favorite food is chips and queso, her favorite holiday is April Fool's Day, and her favorite trope is enemies to lovers.
When she isn't writing, Mary enjoys spending time with her family and trying out new experiences, from fire breathing and axe throwing to trapeze flying and power paragliding.
She currently lives in Texas with her husband and three children.
You can get a FREE e-copy of her Rumpelstiltskin retelling, A Curse of Gold and Beauty, when you sign up for her newsletter at MaryMecham.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 117 reviews
January 3, 2025
It’s been a minute so I can’t write one of my insanely long reviews like I normally do, but this is one of my favorite books of all time. I loved the romance and the depiction of Cinderella as the bad guy 💞
January 1, 2026
We all know Cinderella's story. How her father dies and her stepmother and stepsisters make her do all the cleaning, washing and cooking, while they do nothing. But what if that story isn't true?
Truly, the younger stepsister, is a sympathetic character. She lives with her family at the castle, is best friends with Curtis, the younger prince, and is learning to be an interpreter. When she and Curtis admit their feelings for each other, life couldn't be better. That's when tragedy strikes...
Mecham has kept a lot from the original fairytale, but really put her own twist on it. Therefore I don't know what to expect, and I like that. When Cinderella - Cynthia - makes her entrance, she seems like a nice person at first, but when her circumstances change, so does she (to simplify).
I don't always sympathise with Truly's actions, but they're easy enough to understand. I really like the story's underlying message, that looks is not what's important, personality is. Can't we all agree on that?
* I received an ARC from the author and I'm giving my honest review. I've read the revised edition from 2025. *
Truly, the younger stepsister, is a sympathetic character. She lives with her family at the castle, is best friends with Curtis, the younger prince, and is learning to be an interpreter. When she and Curtis admit their feelings for each other, life couldn't be better. That's when tragedy strikes...
Mecham has kept a lot from the original fairytale, but really put her own twist on it. Therefore I don't know what to expect, and I like that. When Cinderella - Cynthia - makes her entrance, she seems like a nice person at first, but when her circumstances change, so does she (to simplify).
I don't always sympathise with Truly's actions, but they're easy enough to understand. I really like the story's underlying message, that looks is not what's important, personality is. Can't we all agree on that?
* I received an ARC from the author and I'm giving my honest review. I've read the revised edition from 2025. *
June 18, 2023
While it may not be the first retelling of "Cinderella" to flip the script from the perspective of the ugly stepsister, Ugly: The Stepsister's Story by Mary Mecham is really something special. The last book I read from this author, Poisoned: Snow White's Story was somewhat misleading because the story focused more on the dwarf characters than on Snow White. This one, on the other hand, is exactly what it looks like, a fresh new take on "Cinderella" with a tragic heroine that explores trauma in a believable and sympathetic way. I also thought the love story in this book was much stronger, possibly because the main couple knew each other for most of their lives. Between this and A Curse of Gold and Beauty, I think writing romance is one of Mary Mecham's strongest suits even though she places more focus on disabled representation, which she also does well.
Truly is a refined lady of the court who lives in the castle with her parents and sister. Her master linguistic skills make her a valuable resource to the kingdom's foreign relations, and her compassion and sincerity make her a perfect match for Prince Curtis, who is second in line for the throne to his brother. She seems to have the perfect life until a horrible event takes place one day on a diplomatic mission when she is attacked by terrorists, and her face is marred beyond recognition. She is understandably traumatized by these events and becomes a recluse, refusing to see Curtis again or even respond to his letters, believing that he could never love her if he saw what she looked like after the accident. The book has some strong Phantom of the Opera romantic vibes with a sympathetic heroine who is worth rooting for.
The character dynamics are handled extremely well. It is crystal clear why Curtis has feelings for Truly and vice versa. They are both compassionate people who put others before themselves and don't believe in the false pretenses of royal life. Truly's sister, Comfort, is so understanding and supportive of her that she made me wish I had a sister just like her. The only character I didn't like was Cynthia, who represents Cinderella in this story. I understand that because this was a role reversal, in order to like one character, another would have to seem less appealing, but Cynthia had virtually no redeeming qualities. She was so cruel to Truly and kept calling her ugly over and over again even after her father explained everything she had been through. Yet, Truly continued to forgive her and was way more kind to her than she actually deserved.
I enjoyed how Mary Mecham incorporated elements of the Brothers Grimm interpretation of "Cinderella" with the magic tree that members of the family would sneak gifts inside of for the others to find. It was a fun twist that provided a more logical explanation for the supernatural elements of the fairy tale. I also liked that there were two princes, similar to Andrew Lloyd Webber's interpretation of the story, so there didn't need to be a love triangle to create additional barriers between Truly and Cynthia. This also proved that Truly cared about Curtis as a person and not because he was a prince. Truly felt more like a "Cinderella" figure than Cynthia because she recovered from a horrible situation and learned to open her heart to love and happiness again.
Ugly: The Stepsister's Story by Mary Mecham is a captivating and unique retelling of "Cinderella" that delves into the perspective of the ugly stepsister. Mecham handles trauma and disabled representation with sensitivity and care, while also crafting a compelling romance. The character dynamics between Truly, Curtis, and Comfort are expertly handled, although Cynthia's lack of redeeming qualities may be off-putting to some readers. The use of the magic tree and two princes adds depth to the story, making it a must-read for anyone looking for a fresh take on a classic fairy tale. Overall, this book shows Mecham's prowess in creating innovative retellings with strong character development, making her an author to watch in the future.
Truly is a refined lady of the court who lives in the castle with her parents and sister. Her master linguistic skills make her a valuable resource to the kingdom's foreign relations, and her compassion and sincerity make her a perfect match for Prince Curtis, who is second in line for the throne to his brother. She seems to have the perfect life until a horrible event takes place one day on a diplomatic mission when she is attacked by terrorists, and her face is marred beyond recognition. She is understandably traumatized by these events and becomes a recluse, refusing to see Curtis again or even respond to his letters, believing that he could never love her if he saw what she looked like after the accident. The book has some strong Phantom of the Opera romantic vibes with a sympathetic heroine who is worth rooting for.
The character dynamics are handled extremely well. It is crystal clear why Curtis has feelings for Truly and vice versa. They are both compassionate people who put others before themselves and don't believe in the false pretenses of royal life. Truly's sister, Comfort, is so understanding and supportive of her that she made me wish I had a sister just like her. The only character I didn't like was Cynthia, who represents Cinderella in this story. I understand that because this was a role reversal, in order to like one character, another would have to seem less appealing, but Cynthia had virtually no redeeming qualities. She was so cruel to Truly and kept calling her ugly over and over again even after her father explained everything she had been through. Yet, Truly continued to forgive her and was way more kind to her than she actually deserved.
I enjoyed how Mary Mecham incorporated elements of the Brothers Grimm interpretation of "Cinderella" with the magic tree that members of the family would sneak gifts inside of for the others to find. It was a fun twist that provided a more logical explanation for the supernatural elements of the fairy tale. I also liked that there were two princes, similar to Andrew Lloyd Webber's interpretation of the story, so there didn't need to be a love triangle to create additional barriers between Truly and Cynthia. This also proved that Truly cared about Curtis as a person and not because he was a prince. Truly felt more like a "Cinderella" figure than Cynthia because she recovered from a horrible situation and learned to open her heart to love and happiness again.
Ugly: The Stepsister's Story by Mary Mecham is a captivating and unique retelling of "Cinderella" that delves into the perspective of the ugly stepsister. Mecham handles trauma and disabled representation with sensitivity and care, while also crafting a compelling romance. The character dynamics between Truly, Curtis, and Comfort are expertly handled, although Cynthia's lack of redeeming qualities may be off-putting to some readers. The use of the magic tree and two princes adds depth to the story, making it a must-read for anyone looking for a fresh take on a classic fairy tale. Overall, this book shows Mecham's prowess in creating innovative retellings with strong character development, making her an author to watch in the future.
November 9, 2025
⋆⭒˚.⋆𐙚 ˚.⋆⭒˚.⋆𐙚 ˚.⋆⭒˚.⋆𐙚 ˚.⋆⭒˚.⋆𐙚 ˚.⋆⭒˚.⋆
This is Mary's debut! I love everything she writes and I will read anything and everything she ever publishes. This book starts when Truly and Curtis are fifteen, they were so awkward in the beginning and I loved it. Oh my goodness Truly went through so much pain my eyes were watering at some parts. She just needed a hug and someone to love her.
This was so sad!! My eyes kept watering. Cynthia was really rude for no reason! And Truly kept being nice to her. I loved the fairy godmother tree thing. It was such a cute tradition!!! And the reunion when Curtis and Truly got back together ahhh I was screaming (internally because it was the middle of the night) and his letters? So sweet!! I loved the ending!
TL;DR I loved this! Curtis is so sweet! And some parts were very sad.
The characters
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Truly ~ I loved her. She was so sweet and I felt so bad for her.
Curtis ~ I really really liked him. He was so sweet and caring and funny.
Comfort ~ she was ok.
Cynthia ~ She was such a brat.
Algernon ~ He was ok.
Hubert ~ he was really boring honestly but that's how he was supposed to be.
What to expect
👠 Childhood Friends To Lovers
👠 Villain Retelling Of Cinderella
👠 Prince x commoner
👠 Cinnamon Roll MMC
👠 Healing From Trauma
Quotes
~~~~~~~
“Curtis would spin with me across the floor until we were breathless or sneak away with me to slide down the banisters in the entrance hall.”
“If only broken hearts were as easy to sweep away as broken glass.”
“Hope your recovery is going better than mine!
Yours Truly (get it?), Curtis”
Content
~~~~~~~
❤️🔥Romance| an almost kiss at fifteen years old, multiple kisses with almost no details at fifteen(her) and sixteen(him). When they grow up they also share a few more kisses with minimal details
🤬Language| none.
🗡️Violence| Shooting with arrows, slapping, burning with torch, punching,
🏳️🌈LGBTQ| Curtis jokes about kissing a boy when Hubert gets mad at him for kissing Truly,
✝️ Religion/spirituality | Curtis says hallelujah,
⚠️Other| Sever facial burns, PTSD, panic attacks, death of father, Greif, blood, death,murder, bullying, illness, murder, broken bones,
This is Mary's debut! I love everything she writes and I will read anything and everything she ever publishes. This book starts when Truly and Curtis are fifteen, they were so awkward in the beginning and I loved it. Oh my goodness Truly went through so much pain my eyes were watering at some parts. She just needed a hug and someone to love her.
This was so sad!! My eyes kept watering. Cynthia was really rude for no reason! And Truly kept being nice to her. I loved the fairy godmother tree thing. It was such a cute tradition!!! And the reunion when Curtis and Truly got back together ahhh I was screaming (internally because it was the middle of the night) and his letters? So sweet!! I loved the ending!
TL;DR I loved this! Curtis is so sweet! And some parts were very sad.
The characters
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Truly ~ I loved her. She was so sweet and I felt so bad for her.
Curtis ~ I really really liked him. He was so sweet and caring and funny.
Comfort ~ she was ok.
Cynthia ~ She was such a brat.
Algernon ~ He was ok.
Hubert ~ he was really boring honestly but that's how he was supposed to be.
What to expect
👠 Childhood Friends To Lovers
👠 Villain Retelling Of Cinderella
👠 Prince x commoner
👠 Cinnamon Roll MMC
👠 Healing From Trauma
Quotes
~~~~~~~
“Curtis would spin with me across the floor until we were breathless or sneak away with me to slide down the banisters in the entrance hall.”
“If only broken hearts were as easy to sweep away as broken glass.”
“Hope your recovery is going better than mine!
Yours Truly (get it?), Curtis”
Content
~~~~~~~
❤️🔥Romance| an almost kiss at fifteen years old, multiple kisses with almost no details at fifteen(her) and sixteen(him). When they grow up they also share a few more kisses with minimal details
🤬Language| none.
🗡️Violence| Shooting with arrows, slapping, burning with torch, punching,
🏳️🌈LGBTQ| Curtis jokes about kissing a boy when Hubert gets mad at him for kissing Truly,
✝️ Religion/spirituality | Curtis says hallelujah,
⚠️Other| Sever facial burns, PTSD, panic attacks, death of father, Greif, blood, death,murder, bullying, illness, murder, broken bones,
February 7, 2026
This book is amazing! The twist on the Cinderella story was amazing! I love how it told the story and how it had all the elements of the original story while being completely new at the same time.
The family!!!! Y’all! I wanted to cry! This family was so good! They actually loved and cared for each other! This is how a family should be written! No more of the orphans with parent issues please!
The main characters were amazing! The prince was sweet and genuine and just so good! The girl went through so much but I love how the grief was shown and how they became stronger.
I highly recommend this book! It is a new all time favorite!!!
The family!!!! Y’all! I wanted to cry! This family was so good! They actually loved and cared for each other! This is how a family should be written! No more of the orphans with parent issues please!
The main characters were amazing! The prince was sweet and genuine and just so good! The girl went through so much but I love how the grief was shown and how they became stronger.
I highly recommend this book! It is a new all time favorite!!!
March 7, 2023
Very sweet and touching Cinderella retelling. I like how the stepsister is the heroine. Curtis is so adorable and funny.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️1/2 stars!!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️1/2 stars!!
November 10, 2025
It’s not my favorite of her books, but I did like it. It was a cozy chill read, so if you’re looking for something quick and sweet, I would recommend. It’s a different take on the Cinderella tale, from the stepsister’s point of view, which I found interesting.
The characters were good, though some fell a little flat for me. The plot was interesting, though I feel like it could’ve been shown a bit more than just telling what was happening.
Content:
No spice romance, violence, grief, and recovering from a traumatic event
The characters were good, though some fell a little flat for me. The plot was interesting, though I feel like it could’ve been shown a bit more than just telling what was happening.
Content:
No spice romance, violence, grief, and recovering from a traumatic event
October 3, 2022
I was in the mood for a twisted Cinderella retelling, and this book delivered!
I didn't know quite what to expect going into this book, but it immediately captured my attention.
I enjoyed how the aspects of the Cinderella tale were incorporated: the glass slippers being made by a glass blower, Truly and her mother and sister filling the roll of the fairy godmother, the invitations to the ball being a scheme on Curtis' part, "Cinderella" being more the wicked stepsister than the stepsisters, among other things.
Truly and Curtis were an unexpected but enjoyable pairing. Their friendship turned to romance was incredibly sweet and tugged at my heartstrings. Theirs was a heartfelt relationship that was pure and young at heart. I loved seeing the stepsister get her prince.
There were also several parts that made me laugh, like when the glass slipper was tossed around like a footfall, the childhood story of when Truly was thrown from her horse, and the memory of the honey cakes in the king's seat!
As funny as many parts were, others were intense and emotional, with characters who were broken and then built back up, creating good character growth. It all ended with a happily ever after that was well-earned and fitting.
This was a fun and easy to read story that I ended up finishing in a day. I look forward to reading more from this author!
I didn't know quite what to expect going into this book, but it immediately captured my attention.
I enjoyed how the aspects of the Cinderella tale were incorporated: the glass slippers being made by a glass blower, Truly and her mother and sister filling the roll of the fairy godmother, the invitations to the ball being a scheme on Curtis' part, "Cinderella" being more the wicked stepsister than the stepsisters, among other things.
Truly and Curtis were an unexpected but enjoyable pairing. Their friendship turned to romance was incredibly sweet and tugged at my heartstrings. Theirs was a heartfelt relationship that was pure and young at heart. I loved seeing the stepsister get her prince.
There were also several parts that made me laugh, like when the glass slipper was tossed around like a footfall, the childhood story of when Truly was thrown from her horse, and the memory of the honey cakes in the king's seat!
As funny as many parts were, others were intense and emotional, with characters who were broken and then built back up, creating good character growth. It all ended with a happily ever after that was well-earned and fitting.
This was a fun and easy to read story that I ended up finishing in a day. I look forward to reading more from this author!
November 28, 2025
What an interesting perspective. Leave it to Mary Mecham to take the Cinderella story and turn it completely on a head. You’ve always known Cinderella to be the victim, but what if she was not. This is definitely a book that is about found family and how just changing your outlook on things can change everything. All the major points in the Cinderella story happen but from a different perspective, I really enjoyed this refreshing perspective, and it actually makes me kind of pity the stepsisters in the original story.
October 30, 2025
What if Cinderella was in fact vain, self-centered and
only thought of herself and didn’t appreciate her stepmother or her stepsisters and what they did for her?
In this retelling that is exactly what happens. Truly loves her family and works for the kingdom beside her father and her best friend happens to be the son of the king and queen. However, on a outing to help others, they are attacked and she is brutalized and horrible scarred. Her father is killed and she withdraws into herself because of what happened to her. Her mother meets a man with a daughter her age and they marry but the girl is anything but kind to them. When the man dies, they all have to work because they had to pay off her father’s debts. Cinderella resents this but when a royal ball is announced, Truly decides to help her stepsister attend the ball. By having her mother and sister help her they make a ball gown for her and through Truly’s efforts she gets enough to also gift her gloves and glass slippers. Her stepsister still looks down on all of them even after all they did. She gets the prince who is just as vain as she is but Truly also meets her prince again at the same ball and they have the happily ever after they wanted before she was attacked.
It was hard for me to read how cruel people can be towards others and again how ungrateful others can be as well. It is a fact of life, however, as one can read of how cruel some people can be and certainly the lack of gratitude is on full display just about everywhere one looks.
I recommend this book to all so if you happen be like the mob who attacked Truly or like the haughty prince and his Cinderella I would hope that you’ll be changed by this story and cease to be that way anymore.
It’s an interesting twisted concept to have Cinderella being the one who was ungrateful and failing to appreciate what the others did for her. You’ll cheer for Truly and Curtis, however, and their happily ever after after being so long apart though!
I do like fairy tales. It’s the perfect escape for me and hopefully for you as well from what we face daily even if some of the tales are dark in places like this one!
only thought of herself and didn’t appreciate her stepmother or her stepsisters and what they did for her?
In this retelling that is exactly what happens. Truly loves her family and works for the kingdom beside her father and her best friend happens to be the son of the king and queen. However, on a outing to help others, they are attacked and she is brutalized and horrible scarred. Her father is killed and she withdraws into herself because of what happened to her. Her mother meets a man with a daughter her age and they marry but the girl is anything but kind to them. When the man dies, they all have to work because they had to pay off her father’s debts. Cinderella resents this but when a royal ball is announced, Truly decides to help her stepsister attend the ball. By having her mother and sister help her they make a ball gown for her and through Truly’s efforts she gets enough to also gift her gloves and glass slippers. Her stepsister still looks down on all of them even after all they did. She gets the prince who is just as vain as she is but Truly also meets her prince again at the same ball and they have the happily ever after they wanted before she was attacked.
It was hard for me to read how cruel people can be towards others and again how ungrateful others can be as well. It is a fact of life, however, as one can read of how cruel some people can be and certainly the lack of gratitude is on full display just about everywhere one looks.
I recommend this book to all so if you happen be like the mob who attacked Truly or like the haughty prince and his Cinderella I would hope that you’ll be changed by this story and cease to be that way anymore.
It’s an interesting twisted concept to have Cinderella being the one who was ungrateful and failing to appreciate what the others did for her. You’ll cheer for Truly and Curtis, however, and their happily ever after after being so long apart though!
I do like fairy tales. It’s the perfect escape for me and hopefully for you as well from what we face daily even if some of the tales are dark in places like this one!
January 26, 2026
This one was very intriguing! I really enjoyed the audiobook narrator and thought she did a great job with all the characters.
Mary Mecham always knows how to get me with the plot twists and this one delivers as well. She set up such a beautiful backstory for one of the stepsisters in the Cinderella story and I love the fresh view of the fairytale. There was great set up and I couldn't wait to see what happened next. Though the focus is one the back story and build up, it is a quick moving story and such an interesting angle for this fairytale.
The relationships between all the different characters and the MC, Truly, were really intriguing and thought-provoking. I was so curious about how the original fairytale would overlap with this one and I think it played out beautifully and was unique. And I loved how though this is single POV the author added a fun way to see what happened from the MMC's POV. Overall, I really enjoyed this story and I thought the audiobook was great as well.
Mary Mecham always knows how to get me with the plot twists and this one delivers as well. She set up such a beautiful backstory for one of the stepsisters in the Cinderella story and I love the fresh view of the fairytale. There was great set up and I couldn't wait to see what happened next. Though the focus is one the back story and build up, it is a quick moving story and such an interesting angle for this fairytale.
The relationships between all the different characters and the MC, Truly, were really intriguing and thought-provoking. I was so curious about how the original fairytale would overlap with this one and I think it played out beautifully and was unique. And I loved how though this is single POV the author added a fun way to see what happened from the MMC's POV. Overall, I really enjoyed this story and I thought the audiobook was great as well.
December 2, 2025
I am so Truly happy (get it? Truly? Never mind) that Ugly: The Stepsister’s Story has been re-released. It is such a sweet story that shows what it’s like to deal with deep trauma and healing. The trauma and misfortune was handled well and with care and I could tell that Mary Mecham put a lot of thought into it. I loved Truly and Curtis. Curtis was a favorite of mine. He was understanding and loving towards Truly, even when things seemed dark. Cynthia was a piece of work. That’s to be expected since this is a reverse Cinderella though. The sisterly bonds in Ugly were lovely and well thought out. This was a unique retelling of Cinderella and I am so glad that is is back out in the world.
Thank you to Mary Mecham for an ARC of Ugly! All opinions are my own.
Thank you to Mary Mecham for an ARC of Ugly! All opinions are my own.
February 12, 2026
So good!! Written so well!!
August 2, 2024
Wow! The freshest, and most original Cinderella retelling I’ve read this year!
Cinderella is one of my favourite stories. But if there’s a trope that trumps it, it’s the one of the injured girl whom the guy still falls for.
Truly’s story was amazing. I loved how all the elements of Cinderella were included and how it seemed like we were reading the story of Cinderella from the inside. I also loved the relationship between the sisters.
It was told in a very artful way.
Cinderella is one of my favourite stories. But if there’s a trope that trumps it, it’s the one of the injured girl whom the guy still falls for.
Truly’s story was amazing. I loved how all the elements of Cinderella were included and how it seemed like we were reading the story of Cinderella from the inside. I also loved the relationship between the sisters.
It was told in a very artful way.
November 20, 2025
I loved this book so much!
Both Truly and Curtis were so sweet and adorable. The book starts off when they are fifteen years old and I love how strong their friendship is and all the pranks that they pull. I love Truly's dedication and hard work, eventually becoming the youngest linguist they've ever had. I love how Curtis really cares about the people of his country and takes the time to get to know them, memorise their names, and help them in any way he can. I love the way their friendship eventually deepened into something more. I think that they both complement each other so perfectly!
And then a horrific and traumatic event happened. I cried when Truly shut herself off from the rest of the world. I love the way that Mary dealt with the grief and depression that Truly went through. She didn't just skim over it, but she showed how it affected her and it made me really feel for her. I also loved how her healing was slow and gradual, which made it all the more realistic.
I love how Truly was able to heal one step at a time. It was very realistic because it took time for her to regain her confidence and I love how Mary portrayed that.
When Cynthia, the Cinderella, is first introduced, I actually liked her and understood her reactions. Even later on in the book after her father died, I still continued to like her because I understood that her grief was what made her rude and not very nice to Truly and her sister Comfort. But then, at the ball, I've never hated anyone more. And then the speech that she gave to Truly, Comfort, and their mother before she left... Honestly, I felt like dumping an ice cold bucket of water over her.
Despite it all, Truly stayed kind and forgiving and generous. I enjoyed her journey as she came to finally face herself and love herself for who she is. I love her story so much.
A lot of authors have done the Cinderella retelling from the perspective from the stepsister, but I think that Mary's one is truly special and the best one I've ever read! It honestly might even be better than most of the Cinderella retellings that I've read!
Overall, I highly recommend this book. It's awesome and amazing! The plot had me at the edge of my seat and I finished it in less than two hours after I opened it.
Both Truly and Curtis were so sweet and adorable. The book starts off when they are fifteen years old and I love how strong their friendship is and all the pranks that they pull. I love Truly's dedication and hard work, eventually becoming the youngest linguist they've ever had. I love how Curtis really cares about the people of his country and takes the time to get to know them, memorise their names, and help them in any way he can. I love the way their friendship eventually deepened into something more. I think that they both complement each other so perfectly!
And then a horrific and traumatic event happened. I cried when Truly shut herself off from the rest of the world. I love the way that Mary dealt with the grief and depression that Truly went through. She didn't just skim over it, but she showed how it affected her and it made me really feel for her. I also loved how her healing was slow and gradual, which made it all the more realistic.
I love how Truly was able to heal one step at a time. It was very realistic because it took time for her to regain her confidence and I love how Mary portrayed that.
When Cynthia, the Cinderella, is first introduced, I actually liked her and understood her reactions. Even later on in the book after her father died, I still continued to like her because I understood that her grief was what made her rude and not very nice to Truly and her sister Comfort. But then, at the ball, I've never hated anyone more. And then the speech that she gave to Truly, Comfort, and their mother before she left... Honestly, I felt like dumping an ice cold bucket of water over her.
Despite it all, Truly stayed kind and forgiving and generous. I enjoyed her journey as she came to finally face herself and love herself for who she is. I love her story so much.
A lot of authors have done the Cinderella retelling from the perspective from the stepsister, but I think that Mary's one is truly special and the best one I've ever read! It honestly might even be better than most of the Cinderella retellings that I've read!
Overall, I highly recommend this book. It's awesome and amazing! The plot had me at the edge of my seat and I finished it in less than two hours after I opened it.
October 10, 2022
I quite enjoyed this retelling, skewing the whole Cinderella part of the story into a simple difference in perspective that created a catastrophic misunderstanding! And I loved the careful thought that went into incorporating each element of the Cinderella story in a realistic and natural way. It took a lot longer to get to that point than I was expecting, and I personally think that some of the first third of the book could have been cropped down to help with pacing, but I also loved seeing the beautiful friendship turned love story blossom between the “ugly” stepsister Truly and the younger prince Curtis, which made it worth it. I really enjoyed the well-developed characters and the unexpected and often hilarious twists that created, as well as how the author handled how people deal with grief and other powerful emotions. The writing style actually reminded me of Gail Carson Levine‘s Ella Enchanted, which I loved as a child, so this book was a bit of a nostalgic read for me too.
I mainly gave it four stars because of the slow pacing at the beginning that almost had me setting it aside, plus this book really would have benefited from a professional copy editor. There are a number of missing words, typos, missing commas and apostrophes, awkward phrasing, etc. that kept pulling me out of the story because it took me a second to decipher what was supposed to be there or what the author was actually trying to say. But it wasn’t often enough to ruin the read, and I’ve seen far, far worse from indie authors. I was also a bit confused why there was only one “ugly” stepsister. I kept expecting something to happen to Comfort too to disfigure her like her sister, but that never happened, which seemed a little strange since all the other Cinderella story elements were addressed so meticulously.
Overall, I’m happy I came across this and definitely recommend this book to anyone who loves clean, sweet romances and fairytale retellings!
I mainly gave it four stars because of the slow pacing at the beginning that almost had me setting it aside, plus this book really would have benefited from a professional copy editor. There are a number of missing words, typos, missing commas and apostrophes, awkward phrasing, etc. that kept pulling me out of the story because it took me a second to decipher what was supposed to be there or what the author was actually trying to say. But it wasn’t often enough to ruin the read, and I’ve seen far, far worse from indie authors. I was also a bit confused why there was only one “ugly” stepsister. I kept expecting something to happen to Comfort too to disfigure her like her sister, but that never happened, which seemed a little strange since all the other Cinderella story elements were addressed so meticulously.
Overall, I’m happy I came across this and definitely recommend this book to anyone who loves clean, sweet romances and fairytale retellings!
December 6, 2025
Before I begin, I would like to thank Mary Mecham for allowing me to read her re-release for her book, Ugly: The Stepsister’s Story which is available on Amazon starting December 1st, 2025.
Truly is the younger stepsister of the person most people consider as Cinderella. She’s viewed as the cruel and silly stepsister who forces Cinderella to wear rags, clean the house and cook all day without any time to herself. That’s not what happened. To really understand the situation, we got to go back a few years. Cinderella’s father died, but before that, so did Truly’s. No one asks about how Truly’s dad died, why she’s considered Ugly, or how their family got their work/home dynamic in the first place. If anyone is curious, here’s her side of the story.
This book was fantastic. You have Truly, a kind, intelligent, funny, and hardworking young woman that has suffered such grief and horrors when she was a teenager and is now trying to make ends meet with her family. You have Curtis, a funny, considerate, sweet, and handsome younger prince of the kingdom Truly lives in and Truly’s best friend. I loved the interactions between Truly and Curtis, not to mention Truly and her sister Comfort. I wanted to hug Truly so many times throughout the story due to the grief and trauma she suffered, and I cheered for her when she did her best to move forward. I felt bad for Cynthia, but that didn’t mean that I would view her as a friend by any means. Hubert made me want to yell at him. Algernon and Truly’s father were kind and funny, and Truly’s mother was a delight. Overall, if you like fairytale retellings from a different perspective, discussions about grief and healing, great banter, and sweet second chance best friends to lovers romance with low spice, then I would highly recommend this book. I got this copy. These opinions are my own.
Truly is the younger stepsister of the person most people consider as Cinderella. She’s viewed as the cruel and silly stepsister who forces Cinderella to wear rags, clean the house and cook all day without any time to herself. That’s not what happened. To really understand the situation, we got to go back a few years. Cinderella’s father died, but before that, so did Truly’s. No one asks about how Truly’s dad died, why she’s considered Ugly, or how their family got their work/home dynamic in the first place. If anyone is curious, here’s her side of the story.
This book was fantastic. You have Truly, a kind, intelligent, funny, and hardworking young woman that has suffered such grief and horrors when she was a teenager and is now trying to make ends meet with her family. You have Curtis, a funny, considerate, sweet, and handsome younger prince of the kingdom Truly lives in and Truly’s best friend. I loved the interactions between Truly and Curtis, not to mention Truly and her sister Comfort. I wanted to hug Truly so many times throughout the story due to the grief and trauma she suffered, and I cheered for her when she did her best to move forward. I felt bad for Cynthia, but that didn’t mean that I would view her as a friend by any means. Hubert made me want to yell at him. Algernon and Truly’s father were kind and funny, and Truly’s mother was a delight. Overall, if you like fairytale retellings from a different perspective, discussions about grief and healing, great banter, and sweet second chance best friends to lovers romance with low spice, then I would highly recommend this book. I got this copy. These opinions are my own.
February 17, 2026
This Cinderella retelling is very unique. Occasionally, you’ll see a retelling from one of the stepsister’s POV, but it’s vanishingly rare for said retelling to actually make Cinderella the antagonist; it’s usually just that one of the stepsisters is actually a decent person.
In Ugly, we are introduced to the classic stepsisters and stepmother well before. Truly, the protagonist, is the exact sort of person I’d love to be friends with in real life- she’s kind, loyal, and intelligent. Her family is loving and supportive, and her life as an apprentice translator in the kingdom’s palace is privileged, yes, but she uses that privilege to lift others and improve the world where she can. Eventually, as happens when one is the protagonist of a novel, tragedy strikes, and we arrive at the point where Truly becomes “ugly” due to scarring from an awful attack. Her father also dies in the same attack. From there, Truly and her mother and sister wade through grief as they move to the countryside, where they meet Cynthia (the Cinderella character) and her father. The Cinderella character, Cynthia, is rather a mean girl; not an evil person, necessarily, but an unkind and thoughtless one. It was so interesting to have this flip of the usual script for the story.
The inclusion of a friends-to-lovers storyline for Truly and the youngest prince, Curtis, was lovely as well. Their relationship was so loving and solid and well written!
Definitely an interesting Cinderella retelling! Thank you to the author for the gifted copy; all opinions are my own.
In Ugly, we are introduced to the classic stepsisters and stepmother well before. Truly, the protagonist, is the exact sort of person I’d love to be friends with in real life- she’s kind, loyal, and intelligent. Her family is loving and supportive, and her life as an apprentice translator in the kingdom’s palace is privileged, yes, but she uses that privilege to lift others and improve the world where she can. Eventually, as happens when one is the protagonist of a novel, tragedy strikes, and we arrive at the point where Truly becomes “ugly” due to scarring from an awful attack. Her father also dies in the same attack. From there, Truly and her mother and sister wade through grief as they move to the countryside, where they meet Cynthia (the Cinderella character) and her father. The Cinderella character, Cynthia, is rather a mean girl; not an evil person, necessarily, but an unkind and thoughtless one. It was so interesting to have this flip of the usual script for the story.
The inclusion of a friends-to-lovers storyline for Truly and the youngest prince, Curtis, was lovely as well. Their relationship was so loving and solid and well written!
Definitely an interesting Cinderella retelling! Thank you to the author for the gifted copy; all opinions are my own.
December 9, 2025
This Cinderella retelling was powerfully told from the perspective of the "ugly" stepsister. I was swept up in the story, and cried a lot while reading, especially witnessing everything Truly went through. The world building was charming, with details that immersed you into the story. The love that blossomed between Truly and Curtis was sweet and endearing, stemming from a childhood of mischief. I loved Comfort's resilience, and how she became the backbone of the family for Truly and their mother. Unfortunately, everyone thought they were helping their stepsister Cynthia, but she was only miserable, and suffering in silence. This was a beautiful and moving story about self acceptance.
Everything seemed perfect for Truly, until an angry mob attacked the entourage she was a part of and her world flipped. Permanently scarred, she only saw herself as ugly, and unworthy of love. She shut herself off from the world, and wallowed in self pity. When her mother remarries, she tried to befriend her new stepsister, but it goes horribly wrong. When a new disaster strikes the women must work tirelessly leaving the house chores to their stepsister, Cynthia. The family's attempts to help Cynthia ultimately lead to a disastrous realization after the royal ball.
Will Truly be able to find her worth and learn to love herself again?
Will the family be able to make amends for their mistakes?
I received a free copy with no expectation of a review.
All opinions are my own.
Everything seemed perfect for Truly, until an angry mob attacked the entourage she was a part of and her world flipped. Permanently scarred, she only saw herself as ugly, and unworthy of love. She shut herself off from the world, and wallowed in self pity. When her mother remarries, she tried to befriend her new stepsister, but it goes horribly wrong. When a new disaster strikes the women must work tirelessly leaving the house chores to their stepsister, Cynthia. The family's attempts to help Cynthia ultimately lead to a disastrous realization after the royal ball.
Will Truly be able to find her worth and learn to love herself again?
Will the family be able to make amends for their mistakes?
I received a free copy with no expectation of a review.
All opinions are my own.
November 2, 2025
This is the third Cinderella retelling that I've read by Mary Mecham, and I have to say that it's closely tied for my favorite of the three with "Escaping Pirates" (but for entirely different reasons)!
Truly (the FMC) is dynamic and interesting. She is talented, witty, mischievous, and simultaneously manages to be responsible and kind. Though you can see some things coming about her "inevitable" fate, just enough is left up in the air to keep you reading until the very end!
Curtis (the MMC) is also very interesting in his own right, and he plays off of Truly so well. You could say they "truly" belong together. (Sorry... I had to make the pun.) Very few stories make you as desperately hope that the FMC and MMC will be together despite the odds in the end.
The plot is riveting from start to finish! This novel offers a more grounded and heartfelt take on the traditional Cinderella story, bringing the "villain's" perspective to light in such a way that you may never look at Cinderella the same again. Each character is well-defined and beautifully depicted for exactly who they are beneath the surface. The pacing keeps the tension and stakes going throughout, and while there are a few kissing scenes, this book stays firmly in the no-spice range. Perfect for teens or anyone who doesn't want to read spice!
Truly (the FMC) is dynamic and interesting. She is talented, witty, mischievous, and simultaneously manages to be responsible and kind. Though you can see some things coming about her "inevitable" fate, just enough is left up in the air to keep you reading until the very end!
Curtis (the MMC) is also very interesting in his own right, and he plays off of Truly so well. You could say they "truly" belong together. (Sorry... I had to make the pun.) Very few stories make you as desperately hope that the FMC and MMC will be together despite the odds in the end.
The plot is riveting from start to finish! This novel offers a more grounded and heartfelt take on the traditional Cinderella story, bringing the "villain's" perspective to light in such a way that you may never look at Cinderella the same again. Each character is well-defined and beautifully depicted for exactly who they are beneath the surface. The pacing keeps the tension and stakes going throughout, and while there are a few kissing scenes, this book stays firmly in the no-spice range. Perfect for teens or anyone who doesn't want to read spice!
December 3, 2025
I would rate this book and 8.5/10. I absolutely loved it! It was a no-spice sweet angsty retelling that leaves you with a really different perspective on Cinderella. I wasn't sure how I would like a re-release, but at the end of the day, I cried like three times, which is really hard to get me to do. I really love Mrs. Mecham's way of writing, and this romance perfectly matches my level of swoon tolerance, seeing as the protagonist is made up of more than love for some dude.
I really loved Truly's personality. I can't stand it when a character goes through hell and is an angel about it, so I feel that her inner dramatics -if they are really dramatics- are totally justified. That being said, I absolutely love the portrayal of her older sister Comfort! Finally, good older sister representation in media! (I may or may not be biased here.)
Truly is a linguistics translator in love with the second prince, and her life is pretty much perfect. As we all know, when the protagonist is in love, has two loving parents, a good sibling relationship, a dream job, and the love of her life, she will be made thoroughly miserable before the first third of the story is ended. I sat there the whole time waiting for the other shoe (or glass slipper, hehe) to drop. I really enjoyed seeing the original tale being honored while simultaneously having Mecham's vision woven into it.
I really loved Truly's personality. I can't stand it when a character goes through hell and is an angel about it, so I feel that her inner dramatics -if they are really dramatics- are totally justified. That being said, I absolutely love the portrayal of her older sister Comfort! Finally, good older sister representation in media! (I may or may not be biased here.)
Truly is a linguistics translator in love with the second prince, and her life is pretty much perfect. As we all know, when the protagonist is in love, has two loving parents, a good sibling relationship, a dream job, and the love of her life, she will be made thoroughly miserable before the first third of the story is ended. I sat there the whole time waiting for the other shoe (or glass slipper, hehe) to drop. I really enjoyed seeing the original tale being honored while simultaneously having Mecham's vision woven into it.
December 3, 2025
I received an ARC of this book and am leaving a review voluntarily.
This author has definitely become one of my automatic reads. I always love the way they build characters and relationships! And this story is no exception to that rule; I am in love!
Truly and Curtis are such a lovely couple and you can absolutely see why they act the way they do. Their knowledge of one another and understanding of one another are so sweet! I love when a couple that has an established history gets to build and grow!
And I love the little details Mary adds here that let you more fully picture each character. I especially love the mention in how characters talk! There’s a few times where she describes an accent “rolling r and l” and that really made a character’s voice light up.
The Cinderella character of Cynthia is such an arrogant, prideful character and there’s nothing redeemable about her. And I love it. Sometimes, characters that are just cruel and mean are just that way. I don’t need justification if they fulfill their story role well and Cynthia absolutely does. I loathed her!
A beautiful story I will absolutely revisit.
This author has definitely become one of my automatic reads. I always love the way they build characters and relationships! And this story is no exception to that rule; I am in love!
Truly and Curtis are such a lovely couple and you can absolutely see why they act the way they do. Their knowledge of one another and understanding of one another are so sweet! I love when a couple that has an established history gets to build and grow!
And I love the little details Mary adds here that let you more fully picture each character. I especially love the mention in how characters talk! There’s a few times where she describes an accent “rolling r and l” and that really made a character’s voice light up.
The Cinderella character of Cynthia is such an arrogant, prideful character and there’s nothing redeemable about her. And I love it. Sometimes, characters that are just cruel and mean are just that way. I don’t need justification if they fulfill their story role well and Cynthia absolutely does. I loathed her!
A beautiful story I will absolutely revisit.
December 17, 2025
3.5 Stars
The story was completely clean in terms of language and romance, like the rest of Mecham's books, with a hint of violence that was handled carefully.
The story was great; it was very cool to see what the step-sisters were going through on their side of Cinderella's life.
Truly and Curtis reminded me of Ella and Char (in Gail Carson Levine's Ella Enchanted) in the best ways. Their relationship was adorable, and the way he supported her and loved her, even from afar, was great.
While I knew this was coming, I was disappointed in the lack of a redemptive/positive arc from Cynthia (Cinderella) in this story. It would have hit over 4 stars in my opinion had that been the case, but it was a good story nonetheless. My other disappointment was how poor of a king Hubert was, but no one seemed to care so long as Curtis could take care of the people, even though it wasn't HIS job to do so.
Nothing much more to say. A good read overall, with a valuable reminder that what's inside is what matters and speaks volumes more than anything else. Whether you are considered beautiful or ugly, your character outshines your appearance.
The story was completely clean in terms of language and romance, like the rest of Mecham's books, with a hint of violence that was handled carefully.
The story was great; it was very cool to see what the step-sisters were going through on their side of Cinderella's life.
Truly and Curtis reminded me of Ella and Char (in Gail Carson Levine's Ella Enchanted) in the best ways. Their relationship was adorable, and the way he supported her and loved her, even from afar, was great.
While I knew this was coming, I was disappointed in the lack of a redemptive/positive arc from Cynthia (Cinderella) in this story. It would have hit over 4 stars in my opinion had that been the case, but it was a good story nonetheless. My other disappointment was how poor of a king Hubert was, but no one seemed to care so long as Curtis could take care of the people, even though it wasn't HIS job to do so.
Nothing much more to say. A good read overall, with a valuable reminder that what's inside is what matters and speaks volumes more than anything else. Whether you are considered beautiful or ugly, your character outshines your appearance.
November 30, 2024
A sweet, refreshing Cinderella retelling! This the first retelling I've read that is from the stepsisters POV, and it was so fun! I loved how Mary Mecham perfectly set up multiple opportunities for the stepsisters to be cruel or mean, whether from grief or anger, but they choose to be better. And if they do say or do something mean, they are quick to apologize. Cynthia, the Cinderella character, has many similar opportunities, and she usually chooses poorly. The contrast between them was fantastic!
I also loved that this story explored and showed the different stages of grieving and how grief can change a person, for better or for worse.
My favorite part of all was the loving, supporting sisterly bond between the two stepsisters! Their bond was reminiscent of the sisters in Little Women and was delightful to read! Overall, I loved this book and will be recommending it to my friends and family!
I also loved that this story explored and showed the different stages of grieving and how grief can change a person, for better or for worse.
My favorite part of all was the loving, supporting sisterly bond between the two stepsisters! Their bond was reminiscent of the sisters in Little Women and was delightful to read! Overall, I loved this book and will be recommending it to my friends and family!
December 2, 2025
Reader’s Notes:
– this is told from Truly’s point of view
-there is an attack that results in burns, injuries, & deaths (during the events of the story); later there are panic attacks had due to thinking about the attack
Review:
This was SO good! I loved getting to know Truly and her family! I loved seeing Truly’s friendship with Prince Colin and that her family and his were so comfortable with each other from having known each other so long! I was so heartbroken when we discovered how Truly’s father passed (and I know he had to as this was a Cinderella retelling, but I’d forgotten and really hoped it wouldn’t happen!). I loved how Mary made this tale from the original ‘villains’ of the story’s point of view and made it a believable story that made ‘Cinderella’ the villain (of sorts) while keeping the original basics of the tale the same.
I’m sure I’m going to have to come back and reread this book from time to time with how much I loved these characters!
Summary:
Truly has grown up around the royal family due to her father’s job and loves spending time with her best friend Prince Colin. Everything seemed like a wonderful story that her father would weave for her and her sister. Until one day it no longer was.
Now considered ugly in appearance, Truly locks herself away from the world unable to face it’s harsh new realities. From life without her father, with her mother moving on with another man, and having to be willing to come out of hiding to meet her new stepfather and stepsister to be.
There is so much that we know about the story of Cinderella, but has anyone ever wondered what really happened with her stepsisters?
– this is told from Truly’s point of view
-there is an attack that results in burns, injuries, & deaths (during the events of the story); later there are panic attacks had due to thinking about the attack
Review:
This was SO good! I loved getting to know Truly and her family! I loved seeing Truly’s friendship with Prince Colin and that her family and his were so comfortable with each other from having known each other so long! I was so heartbroken when we discovered how Truly’s father passed (and I know he had to as this was a Cinderella retelling, but I’d forgotten and really hoped it wouldn’t happen!). I loved how Mary made this tale from the original ‘villains’ of the story’s point of view and made it a believable story that made ‘Cinderella’ the villain (of sorts) while keeping the original basics of the tale the same.
I’m sure I’m going to have to come back and reread this book from time to time with how much I loved these characters!
Summary:
Truly has grown up around the royal family due to her father’s job and loves spending time with her best friend Prince Colin. Everything seemed like a wonderful story that her father would weave for her and her sister. Until one day it no longer was.
Now considered ugly in appearance, Truly locks herself away from the world unable to face it’s harsh new realities. From life without her father, with her mother moving on with another man, and having to be willing to come out of hiding to meet her new stepfather and stepsister to be.
There is so much that we know about the story of Cinderella, but has anyone ever wondered what really happened with her stepsisters?
December 4, 2025
I loved this one!
I love a good villain origin story and this one did not disappoint.
This book was sadder then I expected. Although, I shouldn't have been surprised. I KNEW something bad was going to happen,because that is how origin stories work. This one was very well done. I loved the characters.
I felt so bad for Truly. She went through a lot and sometimes we accidently hurt others when we are hurting.
I loved her family and her sister, as well as the Prince and his parents. This was such a creative take on Cinderella. I really like the concept of the family knowing the royal family ahead of time.
This book is suitable for both teens and adults and makes for a great cozy read. Even though it has its sad moments, it is still sweet and cozy overall.
TW: death, mild torture, grief, bullying
I highly recommend this book to anyone who likes fractured fairytale or villain origin stories.
I received an ARC from the author. All thoughts are my own.
I love a good villain origin story and this one did not disappoint.
This book was sadder then I expected. Although, I shouldn't have been surprised. I KNEW something bad was going to happen,because that is how origin stories work. This one was very well done. I loved the characters.
I felt so bad for Truly. She went through a lot and sometimes we accidently hurt others when we are hurting.
I loved her family and her sister, as well as the Prince and his parents. This was such a creative take on Cinderella. I really like the concept of the family knowing the royal family ahead of time.
This book is suitable for both teens and adults and makes for a great cozy read. Even though it has its sad moments, it is still sweet and cozy overall.
TW: death, mild torture, grief, bullying
I highly recommend this book to anyone who likes fractured fairytale or villain origin stories.
I received an ARC from the author. All thoughts are my own.
February 8, 2026
This was a sweet retelling of Cinderella from a different viewpoint. I liked Truly’s character as much as the other main characters. This retelling did change the overall characters’ personalities, though. The only reason this was difficult for me was because it didn’t seem like a completely happy ending. I feel as if certain characters should have been dealt with more to make it a true “happy ever after”.
Now, this story is more realistic and caused me to cry several times. So, if you don’t expect everything to be “rainbows and ponies”, like if feel like I expect too much😬, this would be perfect for you. Mary definitely makes the readers feel the emotions of the characters. The main character endured a lot of trauma, and had to go through a healing period. This realistic telling also shows how a person can heal and move on to have a happy life, while remembering what brought him or her there.
Like I said, it is a sweet retelling and definitely worth the read!
Now, this story is more realistic and caused me to cry several times. So, if you don’t expect everything to be “rainbows and ponies”, like if feel like I expect too much😬, this would be perfect for you. Mary definitely makes the readers feel the emotions of the characters. The main character endured a lot of trauma, and had to go through a healing period. This realistic telling also shows how a person can heal and move on to have a happy life, while remembering what brought him or her there.
Like I said, it is a sweet retelling and definitely worth the read!
![Profile Image for Jacquelyn 💐 {This Rapunzel Reads} [Jesus Christ, my Living Hope].](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.gr-assets.com%2Fimages%2FS%2Fcompressed.photo.goodreads.com%2Fusers%2F1766269624i%2F169222098._UX200_CR0%2C0%2C200%2C200_.jpg&w=128&q=75)
December 7, 2025
💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Wow! This was so good! And I’ve never hated Cinderella so much…haha! She was an absolute brat! I loved this version of Cinderella from the stepsister’s point of view and with the kind stepmother. Truly was a sweetheart although I wanted to shake her into her senses. Curtis was so funny and playful! I loved the two of them and watching them fall in love! His love for her was beautiful and how he never gave up on her! It was so sweet and heartwarming! I loved it so much! 🥰 Comfort was a great older sister who stood up for Truly. This book pulled at my heartstrings and I enjoyed it so much! I definitely recommend this one and I’m so glad that Mary Mecham republished this one! 5 stars!
Quote that I liked:
💜 "No matter how long it takes, Truly," he whispered, "You’re worth waiting for.
💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Wow! This was so good! And I’ve never hated Cinderella so much…haha! She was an absolute brat! I loved this version of Cinderella from the stepsister’s point of view and with the kind stepmother. Truly was a sweetheart although I wanted to shake her into her senses. Curtis was so funny and playful! I loved the two of them and watching them fall in love! His love for her was beautiful and how he never gave up on her! It was so sweet and heartwarming! I loved it so much! 🥰 Comfort was a great older sister who stood up for Truly. This book pulled at my heartstrings and I enjoyed it so much! I definitely recommend this one and I’m so glad that Mary Mecham republished this one! 5 stars!
Quote that I liked:
💜 "No matter how long it takes, Truly," he whispered, "You’re worth waiting for.
💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
March 18, 2024
Mary Mecham is a magician of words and worlds.
I love how each of her stories contains worlds with little details like Curtis knowing a servant’s name even though we may or may not see him again, or the way that each character’s motivation is clearly shown (even if it is revealed piece by piece). I love how she doesn’t burden you with backstories until it is relevant to the story, such as a story the mom tells of her childhood that isn’t revealed until the mother is telling the story. Even though I knew this was a stepsister and Cinderella retelling, I was still caught up and surprised by how the story came to light. I appreciated how characters stayed true to their natures and felt like real people with small details like the students hating a new teacher.
I love how each of her stories contains worlds with little details like Curtis knowing a servant’s name even though we may or may not see him again, or the way that each character’s motivation is clearly shown (even if it is revealed piece by piece). I love how she doesn’t burden you with backstories until it is relevant to the story, such as a story the mom tells of her childhood that isn’t revealed until the mother is telling the story. Even though I knew this was a stepsister and Cinderella retelling, I was still caught up and surprised by how the story came to light. I appreciated how characters stayed true to their natures and felt like real people with small details like the students hating a new teacher.
December 12, 2025
This was such a unique and fascinating way to retell Cinderella! Mary Mecham continues to blow my mind with her writing! So good!
Have you ever wondered about Cinderella’s stepsisters? What their lives were like before? What their father was like? If so, read this story of Truly and her heartbreaking tale.
Highlights:
Truly’s dad ❤️
The letters 🥰
The fairy tree
I love Truly for her intelligence and bravery. I love her compassion and graciousness.
““I want forever with you, Truly,” he said firmly. “But more than that, I want you to feel whole again. I want you to have time to heal, to remember who you are, to step into every room with confidence, knowing your worth.”
This was an ARC, all thoughts are my own.
Have you ever wondered about Cinderella’s stepsisters? What their lives were like before? What their father was like? If so, read this story of Truly and her heartbreaking tale.
Highlights:
Truly’s dad ❤️
The letters 🥰
The fairy tree
I love Truly for her intelligence and bravery. I love her compassion and graciousness.
““I want forever with you, Truly,” he said firmly. “But more than that, I want you to feel whole again. I want you to have time to heal, to remember who you are, to step into every room with confidence, knowing your worth.”
This was an ARC, all thoughts are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 117 reviews