The George Orwell quote about truth and untruth at the story’s beginning gives us a brief glance at where this tale is headed. I agree wholeheartedly with it, and it engages my curiosity.
The story quickly sucks you in as you get to know Tenly. As a Cobalt, she’s basically considered a second-class citizen. She’s worked all her life toward getting out of the Tenement, the bubble society she was raised in. You’ll cheer for her to leave this world. If she does, though—there’s a cost. Doing so means she’s likely to never see anyone she loves ever again.
While it’s pretty clear immediately that Tenly’s self-proclaimed “best friend,” Kalib, is in love with her, Tenly’s emotions toward Kalib seem to sway with the wind. It’s quite confusing—for a huge chunk of the novel, it’s unclear whether she actually enjoys Kalib’s company or even thinks of him as a good person. She says they are like brother-sister at one point, but she’s perfectly willing to leave him behind in the Tenement without a second thought, and she seems to take him for granted. They are so close, yet Tenly labels him as a “scoundrel” and “criminal” at various points in the book. Even so, there are moments where it seems she may actually like him in a romantic sense. Overall, this relationship doesn’t seem super believable.
The story is, for the most part, relatively predictable, but I found in this case that this actually didn’t detract from my reading experience. I just *had* to know if I was right or wrong! And in a couple of cases, Penner does give the reader a surprise.
There is a point where Tenly is thrown into a super perilous situation and forced to make an impossible choice. I really enjoyed reading about this because I wanted to see how she handles it and how she justifies her decision when there are such dire consequences on either side.
This novel is, at its heart, about inequality. I love the way this theme was presented in a delicious dystopian atmosphere that will cause the reader to ponder the world around them.