What do you think?
Rate this book
Counterfeit Kingdom: The Dangers of New Revelation, New Prophets, and New Age Practices in the Church
Is there a new reformation happening in the church? It depends on who you ask.
The New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) is a popular and fast-growing new movement of Christians who emphasize signs and wonders, and teach that God is giving new revelation through new apostles and prophets. But is this biblical Christianity?
In Counterfeit Kingdom, apologists and NAR experts Holly Pivec and Douglas Geivett show how the NAR’s key tenets distort the gospel, twist the Scriptures, are influenced by New Age practices, and lead faithful Christians to shipwreck their faith. They also offer practical suggestions for readers who are already influenced by the NAR, curious about it, or concerned about loved ones who have been swept up in the movement.
What used to be on the fringes of the church is now mainstream, and many are being influenced by it unaware. This book is a wake-up call.
The New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) is a popular and fast-growing new movement of Christians who emphasize signs and wonders, and teach that God is giving new revelation through new apostles and prophets. But is this biblical Christianity?
In Counterfeit Kingdom, apologists and NAR experts Holly Pivec and Douglas Geivett show how the NAR’s key tenets distort the gospel, twist the Scriptures, are influenced by New Age practices, and lead faithful Christians to shipwreck their faith. They also offer practical suggestions for readers who are already influenced by the NAR, curious about it, or concerned about loved ones who have been swept up in the movement.
What used to be on the fringes of the church is now mainstream, and many are being influenced by it unaware. This book is a wake-up call.
258 pages, Kindle Edition
First published November 1, 2022
275 people are currently reading
2362 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 333 reviews
October 13, 2022
First sentence: With more than 780,000 instagram followers, Bethel Church in Redding, California, is one of the best known churches in America and around the world.
Readers may or may not have heard of the "NAR" (aka New Apostolic Reformation), but there's a definite possibility that readers have heard of Bethel Church, Bethel Music, Hillsong, Elevation Worship, etc., (Even if you can't quite put into words what teachings are unique to this church.)
This new book examines NAR beliefs, teachings, practices, etc. to see if they are actually biblical. Or if what NAR stands for (promotes, establishes, etc) is a counterfeit kingdom. It also serves as an introduction of sorts. This book isn't exclusively for those with an interest in exposing the dangers of NAR. It is truly suitable as an introduction to the subject.
The book is packed with information. And it is arranged/organized in a clear and helpful way. It balances personal stories with theology. The authors have compiled stories from people who have left the NAR, or, people who have lost family members to NAR. The book is written passionately, zealously, persuasively to warn the mainstream about the dangers of this counterfeit kingdom.
Chapter titles:
Wake Up, Olive
Who Are The New Apostles and Prophets
Hogwarts for Christians
Jesus's Overlooked Warning
The Apostolic Takeover and Spiritual Abuse
Counterfeit Revival
The Passionately Wrong "Bible"
Toxic Worship Music
Is It Always God's Will To Heal?
Deception-Proofing Your Children
Joining the Resistance
I found this a fascinating read cover to cover. What I thought I knew about Bethel church and her famous pastors, is just the tip of the iceberg. I had no clue on most of this stuff. [Chances are, you won't either.] I found much of what I learned to be alarming, shocking, disconcerting. After reading this one, I was like, yes, I see WHY the authors wrote this book. Definitely would recommend it to any Christian who reads. [Sadly, not all Christians do read.] I thought the subject was broken down in an easy-to-digest way.
Readers may or may not have heard of the "NAR" (aka New Apostolic Reformation), but there's a definite possibility that readers have heard of Bethel Church, Bethel Music, Hillsong, Elevation Worship, etc., (Even if you can't quite put into words what teachings are unique to this church.)
This new book examines NAR beliefs, teachings, practices, etc. to see if they are actually biblical. Or if what NAR stands for (promotes, establishes, etc) is a counterfeit kingdom. It also serves as an introduction of sorts. This book isn't exclusively for those with an interest in exposing the dangers of NAR. It is truly suitable as an introduction to the subject.
The book is packed with information. And it is arranged/organized in a clear and helpful way. It balances personal stories with theology. The authors have compiled stories from people who have left the NAR, or, people who have lost family members to NAR. The book is written passionately, zealously, persuasively to warn the mainstream about the dangers of this counterfeit kingdom.
Chapter titles:
Wake Up, Olive
Who Are The New Apostles and Prophets
Hogwarts for Christians
Jesus's Overlooked Warning
The Apostolic Takeover and Spiritual Abuse
Counterfeit Revival
The Passionately Wrong "Bible"
Toxic Worship Music
Is It Always God's Will To Heal?
Deception-Proofing Your Children
Joining the Resistance
I found this a fascinating read cover to cover. What I thought I knew about Bethel church and her famous pastors, is just the tip of the iceberg. I had no clue on most of this stuff. [Chances are, you won't either.] I found much of what I learned to be alarming, shocking, disconcerting. After reading this one, I was like, yes, I see WHY the authors wrote this book. Definitely would recommend it to any Christian who reads. [Sadly, not all Christians do read.] I thought the subject was broken down in an easy-to-digest way.
September 25, 2022
Counterfeit Kingdom is a needed book explaining the unbiblical teachings of the New Apostolic Reformation movement (NAR; also know as the apostolic and prophetic movement). All believers need to be aware of and equipped to recognize the harmful teachings of NAR and churches such as Bethel (of Redding, CA), Jesus Culture and others both large and small that promote them. The book explains how NAR teaching and practices are immensely unbiblical and how many of them disturbingly mirror the New Age and occult.
As someone who was rescued out of this false teaching, I am always grateful for well-thought out books like this one. I encourage every single believer to read it because even those who are unaware of it often discover they have been influenced by these false teachings, especially through music from ministries promoting them. I also appreciate how the authors share about their heart behind writing this book (found in Chapter 2).
This book calls us not to just assume that a teacher, leader, author, etc. or a teaching or practice is good or beneficial because it seems to be fine. We should never assume someone speaks for God simply because they claim to be Christian. In Chapter 4, the book explains outlines how we can discern between true and false prophets. I found this chapter extremely helpful; the tools given in this chapter can help set many free by giving them tools to see the truth if they apply them.
The one frustration I had with the book is this: Sometimes NAR beliefs and practices are presented in the book as if they actually are the truth or correct interpretation—or so it seems for a moment, and then the explanation about what is wrong with them included after. I did a double take a few times because of this. I worry this lack of clarity could confuse the reader at times, especially if they have little to no exposure to NAR beliefs thus far in their life.
The book also has a great section to help parents educate their their children on God’s Word versus false teaching to help them recognize NAR teachings if they say, infiltrate a youth group or Sunday school curriculum.
Overall, Counterfeit Kingdom is an important book, especially as NAR teachings and practices infiltrate more and more. As the book’s concluding chapter states, “We must be discerning. We must take responsibility for our beliefs.”
I received a review copy of this book for free from Netgalley, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. All opinions are my own.
As someone who was rescued out of this false teaching, I am always grateful for well-thought out books like this one. I encourage every single believer to read it because even those who are unaware of it often discover they have been influenced by these false teachings, especially through music from ministries promoting them. I also appreciate how the authors share about their heart behind writing this book (found in Chapter 2).
This book calls us not to just assume that a teacher, leader, author, etc. or a teaching or practice is good or beneficial because it seems to be fine. We should never assume someone speaks for God simply because they claim to be Christian. In Chapter 4, the book explains outlines how we can discern between true and false prophets. I found this chapter extremely helpful; the tools given in this chapter can help set many free by giving them tools to see the truth if they apply them.
The one frustration I had with the book is this: Sometimes NAR beliefs and practices are presented in the book as if they actually are the truth or correct interpretation—or so it seems for a moment, and then the explanation about what is wrong with them included after. I did a double take a few times because of this. I worry this lack of clarity could confuse the reader at times, especially if they have little to no exposure to NAR beliefs thus far in their life.
The book also has a great section to help parents educate their their children on God’s Word versus false teaching to help them recognize NAR teachings if they say, infiltrate a youth group or Sunday school curriculum.
Overall, Counterfeit Kingdom is an important book, especially as NAR teachings and practices infiltrate more and more. As the book’s concluding chapter states, “We must be discerning. We must take responsibility for our beliefs.”
I received a review copy of this book for free from Netgalley, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. All opinions are my own.
February 21, 2023
I really wish everyone would read this book.
The teachings of the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) are dangerous and destructive to your faith. They are subtle, they sound biblical and you might not even realize the teachings in your own church.
If you’ve ever heard of: prayer declarations, learning to prophesy, that healing is always Gods will, “prophets and apostles”, then the NAR influence may have already reached your church. These practices/theology are rooted in the New Age.
The authors do a fantastic job of sharing where some of the most destructive practices and doctrines come from and use scripture to show they are not biblical.
Educate yourself on the destructive theology of NAR. read your Bible, thoroughly and in context, pray for the Holy Spirit to teach you and give you discernment when it comes to false teachers.
The teachings of the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) are dangerous and destructive to your faith. They are subtle, they sound biblical and you might not even realize the teachings in your own church.
If you’ve ever heard of: prayer declarations, learning to prophesy, that healing is always Gods will, “prophets and apostles”, then the NAR influence may have already reached your church. These practices/theology are rooted in the New Age.
The authors do a fantastic job of sharing where some of the most destructive practices and doctrines come from and use scripture to show they are not biblical.
Educate yourself on the destructive theology of NAR. read your Bible, thoroughly and in context, pray for the Holy Spirit to teach you and give you discernment when it comes to false teachers.
February 25, 2023
4.5 stars
Tbh, it took me months to read this 272 page book because it was admittedly triggering for me considering my history with specific denominations that are very closely related to NAR. I've tried to write a coherent review consistent with what is normally on this account, but everything comes out way more intimate (angry?) than I'm comfortable sharing in this space. So no formal review, but here's what I'll say:
This book will call out a lot of organizations, churches, people, social media accounts, worship groups, etc in your life if you are in any way involved in Big Eva...but that just shows how pervasive NAR is becoming. It's everywhere. Beware.
This book isn't an emotional diatribe against NAR...it is a calm, thorough expose, using primary sources. What is there is the truth. People may not like seeing it on the page because it is inconvenient for them, but that doesn't make anything less true. I didn't even like seeing it on the page because it's so personally painful for me, but part of healing is meeting realities head on. This book helped me do that and I'm grateful.
Tbh, it took me months to read this 272 page book because it was admittedly triggering for me considering my history with specific denominations that are very closely related to NAR. I've tried to write a coherent review consistent with what is normally on this account, but everything comes out way more intimate (angry?) than I'm comfortable sharing in this space. So no formal review, but here's what I'll say:
This book will call out a lot of organizations, churches, people, social media accounts, worship groups, etc in your life if you are in any way involved in Big Eva...but that just shows how pervasive NAR is becoming. It's everywhere. Beware.
This book isn't an emotional diatribe against NAR...it is a calm, thorough expose, using primary sources. What is there is the truth. People may not like seeing it on the page because it is inconvenient for them, but that doesn't make anything less true. I didn't even like seeing it on the page because it's so personally painful for me, but part of healing is meeting realities head on. This book helped me do that and I'm grateful.
May 9, 2023
good idea, bad execution.
the premises of this book could’ve worked if the author had done more research.
this book claims to be an excellent guide to NAR teaching and it’s dangers.
however it fails to —
- provide primary sources. the majority of the “testimonies” are he said, she said. most stories don’t include real names of the victims & and are incredibly generalized. although the author is quick to call out full names of “NAR ministers”. yet we don’t know who the victims are.
further more, the author did not get a single interview/ quote from the people she is accusing. not even local ministers that follow NAR. this just tells me that her network is not big enough to connect with the people she is writing about. she has no direct contact to Bethel or it’s ministers.
it also tells us that she did not seek to understand the ministers she is writing about - not even local ones.
- provide credibility. i touched on their network in the earlier point. both authors provide a brief paragraph on their interest in this topic. however, it doesn’t show their credibility. On every social platform Holly describes herself as an advocate against NAR. if i’m looking for a credible source on this topic - i would seek council from a well rounded theologian, someone who has experience with working with mega churches . Holly is basing her entire career going against Bethel.
- provide proof of NAR in IHOP, HILLSONG, YWAM, ELEVATION , VBS etc. the author basically blacklists any big christian organization that has influence. no proof or sources provided.
i think the most controversial thing about this book is that there is no such thing is NAR - no church officially follows it. NAR is a term created by people who disagree with certain beliefs & churches, and they put this label on others. i definitely believe that many churches lack sound teachings, and take things to an extreme, and we need to be cautious of that.
What I agreed on -
- being cautious about certain beliefs- like looking for a miracle instead of looking for the gospel, or making sure that you have a clear mind and aren’t under the influence of anything else. and studying the Bible is extremely important.
- praying for discernment this day and age
- passion translation is not a legit Bible translation
overall, i would not recommend this book to anybody. there are way better books on church, theology, and end times. this is poorly written & poorly researched.
the premises of this book could’ve worked if the author had done more research.
this book claims to be an excellent guide to NAR teaching and it’s dangers.
however it fails to —
- provide primary sources. the majority of the “testimonies” are he said, she said. most stories don’t include real names of the victims & and are incredibly generalized. although the author is quick to call out full names of “NAR ministers”. yet we don’t know who the victims are.
further more, the author did not get a single interview/ quote from the people she is accusing. not even local ministers that follow NAR. this just tells me that her network is not big enough to connect with the people she is writing about. she has no direct contact to Bethel or it’s ministers.
it also tells us that she did not seek to understand the ministers she is writing about - not even local ones.
- provide credibility. i touched on their network in the earlier point. both authors provide a brief paragraph on their interest in this topic. however, it doesn’t show their credibility. On every social platform Holly describes herself as an advocate against NAR. if i’m looking for a credible source on this topic - i would seek council from a well rounded theologian, someone who has experience with working with mega churches . Holly is basing her entire career going against Bethel.
- provide proof of NAR in IHOP, HILLSONG, YWAM, ELEVATION , VBS etc. the author basically blacklists any big christian organization that has influence. no proof or sources provided.
i think the most controversial thing about this book is that there is no such thing is NAR - no church officially follows it. NAR is a term created by people who disagree with certain beliefs & churches, and they put this label on others. i definitely believe that many churches lack sound teachings, and take things to an extreme, and we need to be cautious of that.
What I agreed on -
- being cautious about certain beliefs- like looking for a miracle instead of looking for the gospel, or making sure that you have a clear mind and aren’t under the influence of anything else. and studying the Bible is extremely important.
- praying for discernment this day and age
- passion translation is not a legit Bible translation
overall, i would not recommend this book to anybody. there are way better books on church, theology, and end times. this is poorly written & poorly researched.
January 13, 2023
This book encourages the reader to really think about what they believe and how imperative it is to stay true to Gods Word.
It’s about a growing false movement called NAR (new apostolic reformation) which Bethel Redding church in California is at the forefront of.
I loved that it didn’t just talk about the dangers of this movement, but explained the biblical reasons why. It was very clear and concise.
The history before Bethel is also very important to learn about, as the roots of the NAR come from a charismatic influence. People like Smith Wigglesworth, Katherine Kulman, Kenneth Hagin, Oral Roberts and Benny Hinn. Who were all problematic teachers in their time and hero’s to charismatics.
(I recommend John MacArthur’s book ‘Strange Fire’ which shares this history.)
Having grown up in a charismatic church, I have struggled with what is true and what is not, especially with certain practises such as being slay in the spirit, open heaven and tongues as evidence, but with Gods help and deep study of His Word, He has graciously humbled me and shown me His way. I have been able to repent of the false beliefs I allowed myself to trust in and to be set free. Its been many years since then, and I continue to pray for God to lead me into His truth by His Spirit, and nothing more.
That’s why these kinds of books are so dear to me. It’s one more person speaking out, one more person warning of the dangers of false teachings, one more person leading people to the real Jesus and His Word. This warms my heart.
If you have questions or are uneasy about what the NAR and Bethel Redding church teaches, I want you to know it’s ok to question, it’s ok to think critically, it’s ok to test all things, and its ok to look to Gods Word for answers.
This book (Counterfeit Kingdom) will also be a big help in understanding this belief system and how it contradicts the Bible.
I highly recommend it.
“Trust in the LORD with all your heart, And lean not on your own understanding; In all your ways acknowledge Him, And He shall direct your paths.” Proverbs 3:5-6
It’s about a growing false movement called NAR (new apostolic reformation) which Bethel Redding church in California is at the forefront of.
I loved that it didn’t just talk about the dangers of this movement, but explained the biblical reasons why. It was very clear and concise.
The history before Bethel is also very important to learn about, as the roots of the NAR come from a charismatic influence. People like Smith Wigglesworth, Katherine Kulman, Kenneth Hagin, Oral Roberts and Benny Hinn. Who were all problematic teachers in their time and hero’s to charismatics.
(I recommend John MacArthur’s book ‘Strange Fire’ which shares this history.)
Having grown up in a charismatic church, I have struggled with what is true and what is not, especially with certain practises such as being slay in the spirit, open heaven and tongues as evidence, but with Gods help and deep study of His Word, He has graciously humbled me and shown me His way. I have been able to repent of the false beliefs I allowed myself to trust in and to be set free. Its been many years since then, and I continue to pray for God to lead me into His truth by His Spirit, and nothing more.
That’s why these kinds of books are so dear to me. It’s one more person speaking out, one more person warning of the dangers of false teachings, one more person leading people to the real Jesus and His Word. This warms my heart.
If you have questions or are uneasy about what the NAR and Bethel Redding church teaches, I want you to know it’s ok to question, it’s ok to think critically, it’s ok to test all things, and its ok to look to Gods Word for answers.
This book (Counterfeit Kingdom) will also be a big help in understanding this belief system and how it contradicts the Bible.
I highly recommend it.
“Trust in the LORD with all your heart, And lean not on your own understanding; In all your ways acknowledge Him, And He shall direct your paths.” Proverbs 3:5-6
February 20, 2023
Turn on the radio or walk into almost any evangelical church. One of the first things you will hear is songs by Bethel Worship or Jesus Culture. Young people are especially attracted to these songs. The production quality and musicianship is top-notch. The Jesus Culture website says, “Jesus Culture is not a band, but a family with a collection of songs that reflect what God is doing in their church and their lives. The heart of Jesus Culture has always been to not just sing songs, but to encounter God and see lives changed through those encounters.”
Tragically, few people (and few churches) are examining the doctrinal foundations of these ever-popular and growing groups. Both Bethel Worship and Jesus Culture are products of Bethel Church, located in Redding, California. Two authors have researched the Bethel movement and present their findings in Counterfeit Kingdom: The Dangers of New Revelation, New Prophets, and New Age Practices in the Church.
The book narrows its focus on the practices of the so-called New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) and the various ways that it influences music and ministry in churches around the world. The authors reveal that more than 3.5 million people in America alone attend churches that embraced NAR. These churches are governed by so-called “prophets” and “apostles.”
Pivec and Geivett alert readers to the theological infrastructure and polity that governs Bethel Church. They uncover the controversial practices of “angelic slumber,” “grave sucking,” “holy laughter,” “laughter in the Spirit,” “the fire tunnel,” “destiny cards,” “communication with the dead,” and the promotion of the so-called “glory cloud.” These occult activities are not only dangerous; they are expressly forbidden in Scripture (Deut. 18:9-12).
Counterfeit Kingdom includes a series of helpful warnings that Christians must heed when evaluating assertions that come out of churches like Bethel. Also included are the various “control tactics” that are being used to deceive unsuspecting people. The authors encourage Christians to read the Bible broadly and develop basic skills in hermeneutics.
The book discusses biblical revival and helps readers discern what is authentic and what is synthetic. “In short, revival is measured in terms of obedience and holiness. Anything short of that is a counterfeit,” argue Pivec and Geivett.
The Passion Translation of the Bible is discussed. The authors reveal that it is anything but a translation. “Simmons” (the author) has crafted a Bible that would gladden the heart of a narcissist while slighting the sovereign exercises of God’s will through us.” Thus this erroneous “translation” should be marked and avoided.
One of the most helpful chapters included a discussion of the dangers of Bethel worship, which smuggles in NAR theology. Bethel worship should also be avoided.
Now is the time for followers of Christ to be discerning. We must pay close attention to our life and doctrine. We must carefully evaluate our music and the books we read. Holly Counterfeit Kingdom is a book for our times; one that should be studied and passed along to unsuspecting people.
Tragically, few people (and few churches) are examining the doctrinal foundations of these ever-popular and growing groups. Both Bethel Worship and Jesus Culture are products of Bethel Church, located in Redding, California. Two authors have researched the Bethel movement and present their findings in Counterfeit Kingdom: The Dangers of New Revelation, New Prophets, and New Age Practices in the Church.
The book narrows its focus on the practices of the so-called New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) and the various ways that it influences music and ministry in churches around the world. The authors reveal that more than 3.5 million people in America alone attend churches that embraced NAR. These churches are governed by so-called “prophets” and “apostles.”
Pivec and Geivett alert readers to the theological infrastructure and polity that governs Bethel Church. They uncover the controversial practices of “angelic slumber,” “grave sucking,” “holy laughter,” “laughter in the Spirit,” “the fire tunnel,” “destiny cards,” “communication with the dead,” and the promotion of the so-called “glory cloud.” These occult activities are not only dangerous; they are expressly forbidden in Scripture (Deut. 18:9-12).
Counterfeit Kingdom includes a series of helpful warnings that Christians must heed when evaluating assertions that come out of churches like Bethel. Also included are the various “control tactics” that are being used to deceive unsuspecting people. The authors encourage Christians to read the Bible broadly and develop basic skills in hermeneutics.
The book discusses biblical revival and helps readers discern what is authentic and what is synthetic. “In short, revival is measured in terms of obedience and holiness. Anything short of that is a counterfeit,” argue Pivec and Geivett.
The Passion Translation of the Bible is discussed. The authors reveal that it is anything but a translation. “Simmons” (the author) has crafted a Bible that would gladden the heart of a narcissist while slighting the sovereign exercises of God’s will through us.” Thus this erroneous “translation” should be marked and avoided.
One of the most helpful chapters included a discussion of the dangers of Bethel worship, which smuggles in NAR theology. Bethel worship should also be avoided.
Now is the time for followers of Christ to be discerning. We must pay close attention to our life and doctrine. We must carefully evaluate our music and the books we read. Holly Counterfeit Kingdom is a book for our times; one that should be studied and passed along to unsuspecting people.
January 14, 2023
The cover of this book depicting the Pied Piper so aptly signifies what this book is all about—the lure of the New Apostolic Reformation (known as NAR for short) and its teaching and practices. This is a really important book that places a bright spotlight on some dangerous beliefs that may seem fringe, but are quickly infiltrating orthodox churches across the nation and globe.
Holly Pivec and Doug Geivett do a really thorough job of explaining what the NAR is, what the practices are, how to identify the movement, and why it is so dangerous. While these churches may affirm the same core doctrines that most orthodox Christians would, they have radically different beliefs (and corresponding practices) that skew the meaning and importance of some of these doctrines. They also have a dramatically different eschatological (end-times) belief that is problematic and drives many of their practices.
My experience with this movement goes far beyond reading this book. I was a member of a NAR church for 3 1/2 years before the Lord helped me to see the error in its teaching at the beginning of 2021. Two years later, I’m still working through what it looks like to follow God faithfully on the other side of being deceived. I could probably write an entire blog post about how negatively NAR theology impacted my life and the freedom I’ve found on the other side of it.
That’s why this book is SO important! It’s a tool to equip people with knowledge about a movement that’s growing rapidly and leading people astray by teaching that the “true church” is the church that is governed by modern-day apostles and prophets. These apostles and prophets serve as spiritual power brokers of sorts; under their authority, followers are able to receive divine favor and power—and this divine power is necessary to do the work that Christ has ordained for His disciples to do. But Pivec and Geivett make a compelling point:
“Real spiritual power is displayed by overcoming sin and displaying the fruit of the Holy Spirit: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control (Gal. 5:16–24).”
May the Lord open the eyes of those who’ve been deceived by the teaching in this movement. There is so much freedom on the other side of needing to “bring heaven to earth” by learning to prophesy, heal the sick, and decree and declare. And it starts with an accurate understanding of Christ’s work for us and the Holy Spirit’s work in us.
I received a copy of this book for free from NetGalley and B&H Books in exchange for this honest review.
Holly Pivec and Doug Geivett do a really thorough job of explaining what the NAR is, what the practices are, how to identify the movement, and why it is so dangerous. While these churches may affirm the same core doctrines that most orthodox Christians would, they have radically different beliefs (and corresponding practices) that skew the meaning and importance of some of these doctrines. They also have a dramatically different eschatological (end-times) belief that is problematic and drives many of their practices.
My experience with this movement goes far beyond reading this book. I was a member of a NAR church for 3 1/2 years before the Lord helped me to see the error in its teaching at the beginning of 2021. Two years later, I’m still working through what it looks like to follow God faithfully on the other side of being deceived. I could probably write an entire blog post about how negatively NAR theology impacted my life and the freedom I’ve found on the other side of it.
That’s why this book is SO important! It’s a tool to equip people with knowledge about a movement that’s growing rapidly and leading people astray by teaching that the “true church” is the church that is governed by modern-day apostles and prophets. These apostles and prophets serve as spiritual power brokers of sorts; under their authority, followers are able to receive divine favor and power—and this divine power is necessary to do the work that Christ has ordained for His disciples to do. But Pivec and Geivett make a compelling point:
“Real spiritual power is displayed by overcoming sin and displaying the fruit of the Holy Spirit: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control (Gal. 5:16–24).”
May the Lord open the eyes of those who’ve been deceived by the teaching in this movement. There is so much freedom on the other side of needing to “bring heaven to earth” by learning to prophesy, heal the sick, and decree and declare. And it starts with an accurate understanding of Christ’s work for us and the Holy Spirit’s work in us.
I received a copy of this book for free from NetGalley and B&H Books in exchange for this honest review.
January 23, 2023
I first heard of the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) about 4 years ago. At the time I didn’t give it much thought, but the more I heard about this movement, the more I saw how it has influenced many churches.
This book talks most about the practices and beliefs of Bethel Church in Redding CA. This book was very eye opening. I will disclose that not all people who attend Bethel (or more charismatic churches) follow these practices and beliefs. This is a book critiquing the teachings and practices that aren’t biblical, not the person.
This book covered topics such as Waking up Olive, who are the new apostles and prophets, the Passion Bible ‘translation’, worship music, and the Bethel School of Supernatural Ministry. It was a fascinating read and I learned a lot. I was especially convicted with how Bethel uses their music to plant their teachings and practices in other churches around the world. I liked the chapter for parents to help educate their children on Gods word if they do attend a youth group or young adults that is influenced by NAR teachings.
This book may ruffle a few feathers. I pray that it will be a helpful tool on how to navigate these views and why they are dangerous. It gives good research and background information so you can have healthy and helpful discussions with your friends and family.
“We must be discerning. We must take responsibility for our beliefs”.
I definitely recommend this book!
January 10, 2023
This book is eye opening. Sobering.
It may also ruffle a few feathers but I think it’s a good thing. I would recommend this to all who call themselves Christians, and to go in with an open and honest mind and take a good hard look at the teachings coming from NAR influenced churches (Bethel, Hillsong, etc ...) I disregarded most warnings in the past ... simply because I didn’t really follow their teachings anyway. But I think we would do well by listening to the cautions presented in this book and critically examine the teachings, including the music, coming from this movement, and see how they hold up to what Scripture actually teaches.
It may also ruffle a few feathers but I think it’s a good thing. I would recommend this to all who call themselves Christians, and to go in with an open and honest mind and take a good hard look at the teachings coming from NAR influenced churches (Bethel, Hillsong, etc ...) I disregarded most warnings in the past ... simply because I didn’t really follow their teachings anyway. But I think we would do well by listening to the cautions presented in this book and critically examine the teachings, including the music, coming from this movement, and see how they hold up to what Scripture actually teaches.
August 21, 2023
A straight forward discussion of the NAR teachings. Well worth the read for all Christians to inform and maintain awareness of this movement and its lack of the Gospel.
March 28, 2024
Overall, very good and illuminating. I grew up in an NAR church and have experienced firsthand some of the damage that NAR theology can cause.
A couple of thoughts:
1. I don't put too much weight on firsthand anecdotes about this or that denomination's/sect's flaws. This might seem to contradict my statement a few sentences ago, and yes, I have my own stories, but honestly--what denomination of Christianity doesn't have people who have stories of that denomination's flaws? At best, these stories help make the case that bad theology and sin are damaging on a personal, human level. But at worst, they represent a small sample size and ultimately don't fairly represent a denomination as a whole.
2. Related to this point, it shouldn't come as a surprise that the church is messy since it is composed of sinners. Thus, the misconduct of church leaders doesn't automatically discount that denomination. I challenge anyone to find a denomination or even a religion outside of Christianity whose leaders have a perfect track record. Sin within a leadership structure does not automatically disprove a denomination. It merely proves that humans are sinful. Yes, sin within a leadership structure lies on a spectrum. However, condemning a denomination based on the misconduct of some of its leaders is often akin to using an ad hominem attack. A better indicator of a denomination's health is how that denomination responds to the sin of its leaders.
3. We shouldn't reject any practice because it is strange, especially because it is strange to the world. I honestly wish more Christians would pray for God to resurrect the dead. For you Christians, especially you continuationists: why wouldn't God be pleased to raise the dead even today? Of course, I dont think this will be or should be a common occurrence. But the problem with Bethel, etc. is not that they had the audacity to ask God to raise little Olive. The problem is the way in which they "asked" God (i.e. they declared rather than asked) and the way in which they responded when God chose not to resurrect the child (with a dejected lack of faith). Is God any less a resurrecting God now than he was in the Old Testament? Is God any less of a resurrecting God if he chooses not to resurrect many people? God performs the even greater miracle of resurrecting souls every day and promises one day to resurrect every body--why should we be shocked if God chooses to resurrect a body here and now? And why on earth should we reject the practice of praying for God to raise the dead because the world laughs at us? The world laughs at the indisputable reality of the gospel.
4. I have a lot of thoughts about the chapter on whether or not we should listen to Bethel music. Im not sure if this is the time/place to record those thoughts, especially since this is not the main focus of the book. But...I'll try and jot of some of my thoughts here.
Though I don't regularly listen to Bethel music, I occasionally find songs that come from their writers to be worshipful. However, I disagree with the idea that because a song comes from a person/group that has bad theology, we should not sing said song. This whole train of logic seems to be a variant of the genetic fallacy. If the song itself has bad theology, that is a different story entirely. The authors (of the book) accuse certain pastors/worship leaders of being inconsistent since those worship leaders would probably selectively avoid music from certain groups but still argue that they should be allowed to listen/worship to Bethel music. However, I would argue that the authors of the book are probably inconsistent in that they do not vet the theology of the writers of every worship song they sing. Nor do they only sing songs written by people whose theology they perfectly align with. This is one of those gray areas--no one can create a perfect filter that blocks out every song that has bad theology or that was written by someone with questionable morals/someone who may not have been a Christian. The authors would probably respond that, while we cannot filter out all bad theology, we are responsible for rejecting songs from those who we know have bad theology. But honestly, I don't think there is any single criterion that can be applied consistently when it comes to selecting worship songs. What if a person had amazing theology when they wrote a song but has since been shown to be heterodox? What if a person (like Charles Wesley) is revered for writing wonderful, theologically rich hymns, but he occasionally has lines in his songs that are confusing if not downright wrong? "Emptied himself of all but love" has led to some confusing ideas about Jesus’s incarnation, and I disagree with Charles's theology on a number of points, yet I still love the song "And Can it Be." Would I recommend the song to be sung at my church every week, or would it be my first recommendation to a new believer? Probably not. This is where discernment and Christian prudence play a large role, I believe, in how we choose what to listen to, read, watch, etc. A very mature Christian may be able to listen to all kinds of music that might be harmful to a new believer without any problem. Additionally, the authors neglect the fact that God is good and powerful enough to be glorified by things that are even pagan in origin (e.g., Christians have redeemed pagan holiday traditions and used them for Christian purposes). Is God not able to use a song whose words are good and true, even if the writer of the song turns out not to be a Christian? And who even knows at the end of the day which writers are Christian? I recognize that an argument can be made that authorial intent determines the meaning and use of a song. However, there are multiple instances in Scripture in which pagans spoke words that were true, even beyond what they themselves understood, all to the glory of God (I'm thinking of Caiphas's prophecy of Jesus’s sacrificial death). Thus, I find the idea that Christians should blacklist every song from every artist who has ever had any association with the NAR to be built on faulty logic, and thus un-nuanced and unhelpful. The reason I care so much about this kind of argument is that it pops up all the time in my circles. I have many friends who I love and respect who refuse to listen to this or that artist or read this or that book because it is associated with this or that bad thing. I have no problem if a Christian wants to follow his/her conscience and avoid a certain thing. But the problem arises when those same people then make blanket statements about what other Christians should or should not listen to using the same criteria that they apply to themselves--not realizing that other Christians may be more mature than them in certain areas. Hopefully, this review doesn't come off as 'preachy;' these are just my two cents, and I could be wrong :)
A couple of thoughts:
1. I don't put too much weight on firsthand anecdotes about this or that denomination's/sect's flaws. This might seem to contradict my statement a few sentences ago, and yes, I have my own stories, but honestly--what denomination of Christianity doesn't have people who have stories of that denomination's flaws? At best, these stories help make the case that bad theology and sin are damaging on a personal, human level. But at worst, they represent a small sample size and ultimately don't fairly represent a denomination as a whole.
2. Related to this point, it shouldn't come as a surprise that the church is messy since it is composed of sinners. Thus, the misconduct of church leaders doesn't automatically discount that denomination. I challenge anyone to find a denomination or even a religion outside of Christianity whose leaders have a perfect track record. Sin within a leadership structure does not automatically disprove a denomination. It merely proves that humans are sinful. Yes, sin within a leadership structure lies on a spectrum. However, condemning a denomination based on the misconduct of some of its leaders is often akin to using an ad hominem attack. A better indicator of a denomination's health is how that denomination responds to the sin of its leaders.
3. We shouldn't reject any practice because it is strange, especially because it is strange to the world. I honestly wish more Christians would pray for God to resurrect the dead. For you Christians, especially you continuationists: why wouldn't God be pleased to raise the dead even today? Of course, I dont think this will be or should be a common occurrence. But the problem with Bethel, etc. is not that they had the audacity to ask God to raise little Olive. The problem is the way in which they "asked" God (i.e. they declared rather than asked) and the way in which they responded when God chose not to resurrect the child (with a dejected lack of faith). Is God any less a resurrecting God now than he was in the Old Testament? Is God any less of a resurrecting God if he chooses not to resurrect many people? God performs the even greater miracle of resurrecting souls every day and promises one day to resurrect every body--why should we be shocked if God chooses to resurrect a body here and now? And why on earth should we reject the practice of praying for God to raise the dead because the world laughs at us? The world laughs at the indisputable reality of the gospel.
4. I have a lot of thoughts about the chapter on whether or not we should listen to Bethel music. Im not sure if this is the time/place to record those thoughts, especially since this is not the main focus of the book. But...I'll try and jot of some of my thoughts here.
Though I don't regularly listen to Bethel music, I occasionally find songs that come from their writers to be worshipful. However, I disagree with the idea that because a song comes from a person/group that has bad theology, we should not sing said song. This whole train of logic seems to be a variant of the genetic fallacy. If the song itself has bad theology, that is a different story entirely. The authors (of the book) accuse certain pastors/worship leaders of being inconsistent since those worship leaders would probably selectively avoid music from certain groups but still argue that they should be allowed to listen/worship to Bethel music. However, I would argue that the authors of the book are probably inconsistent in that they do not vet the theology of the writers of every worship song they sing. Nor do they only sing songs written by people whose theology they perfectly align with. This is one of those gray areas--no one can create a perfect filter that blocks out every song that has bad theology or that was written by someone with questionable morals/someone who may not have been a Christian. The authors would probably respond that, while we cannot filter out all bad theology, we are responsible for rejecting songs from those who we know have bad theology. But honestly, I don't think there is any single criterion that can be applied consistently when it comes to selecting worship songs. What if a person had amazing theology when they wrote a song but has since been shown to be heterodox? What if a person (like Charles Wesley) is revered for writing wonderful, theologically rich hymns, but he occasionally has lines in his songs that are confusing if not downright wrong? "Emptied himself of all but love" has led to some confusing ideas about Jesus’s incarnation, and I disagree with Charles's theology on a number of points, yet I still love the song "And Can it Be." Would I recommend the song to be sung at my church every week, or would it be my first recommendation to a new believer? Probably not. This is where discernment and Christian prudence play a large role, I believe, in how we choose what to listen to, read, watch, etc. A very mature Christian may be able to listen to all kinds of music that might be harmful to a new believer without any problem. Additionally, the authors neglect the fact that God is good and powerful enough to be glorified by things that are even pagan in origin (e.g., Christians have redeemed pagan holiday traditions and used them for Christian purposes). Is God not able to use a song whose words are good and true, even if the writer of the song turns out not to be a Christian? And who even knows at the end of the day which writers are Christian? I recognize that an argument can be made that authorial intent determines the meaning and use of a song. However, there are multiple instances in Scripture in which pagans spoke words that were true, even beyond what they themselves understood, all to the glory of God (I'm thinking of Caiphas's prophecy of Jesus’s sacrificial death). Thus, I find the idea that Christians should blacklist every song from every artist who has ever had any association with the NAR to be built on faulty logic, and thus un-nuanced and unhelpful. The reason I care so much about this kind of argument is that it pops up all the time in my circles. I have many friends who I love and respect who refuse to listen to this or that artist or read this or that book because it is associated with this or that bad thing. I have no problem if a Christian wants to follow his/her conscience and avoid a certain thing. But the problem arises when those same people then make blanket statements about what other Christians should or should not listen to using the same criteria that they apply to themselves--not realizing that other Christians may be more mature than them in certain areas. Hopefully, this review doesn't come off as 'preachy;' these are just my two cents, and I could be wrong :)
May 22, 2025
Some fifteen years ago he sat in my church study. He was the minister of a large charismatic church in town and had come to invite me to join a new reforming “movement,” the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR). I had never heard of this movement, but he claimed it had apostles and prophets whom God had raised up to reignite the church and restore America to her Christian roots. Since those days I have heard more and more about the NAR, and began to notice how some prominent church leaders, pastors, and a few politicians, who are aligned with the NAR and are coming into influence in our civil government. I knew I needed to learn more and was glad to find a very readable 272-page softback that addressed this program. “Counterfeit Kingdom: The Dangers of New Revelation, New Prophets, and New Age Practices in the Church” was put together by Holly Pivec, blogger and author of several books on the New Apostolic Reformation, who also served as university editor at Biola University for nearly a decade, and R. Douglas Geivett, author of several works on the New Apostolic Reformation, and professor at Biola University and Talbot School of Theology.
If I understand the authors correctly, they are in agreement with the charismatic and Pentecostal tradition, and thus their work is not a cessationist manuscript. Rather, as orthodox Pentecostals they have felt – personally – the impact of the NAR and have seen its dangers. They write the book to give a voice to the countless people and churches who have been harmed by the NAR. “It’s meant to expose the movement and its practices. Along the way, we reveal the dangers of NAR teachings, the harm they’re doing, and the way they’re compromising the gospel” (15).
The authors use Bethel Church in Redding, California, as their sample case, though they do reach beyond that organization to show that Bethel is not a one-off. Pivec and Geivett address numerous oddities that seem to be mainline at Bethel, and the NAR. They show how New Age practices and teaching – given other names – are commonplace. They examine the different kinds of “prophecies” that are promoted in that association, and how their numerous inaccuracies and failures are sidestepped by leadership. There are a host of other practices and models that are studied in the book, such as prayer declarations, leaders ‘activating’ prophetic gifts in others, fresh revelations, and communicating with the dead, to name a few.
One of the beliefs of the NAR that Pivec and Geivett present is the Seven Mountain Mandate. The Seven Mountain Mandate is supposedly revealed to the NAR prophets and apostles on how to infiltrate and seize the highest positions of the major societal institutions: government, media, family, business, education, church, and the arts. The ‘prophets’ and ‘apostles’ of the NAR “claim that this mandate gives them authority to govern not only the church, but also society” (104). Let that sink in a bit.
As the authors examine various aspects and angles of the NAR, they also give good, wholesome, biblical, sober guidance so their readers can gain discernment. For example, they show how the “Bible gives three negative tests” for evaluating the legitimacy of prophecy and prophet: “the Orthodoxy Test (do their prophecies line up with Scripture?), the Lifestyle Test (are they greedy and lustful), and the Fulfillment Test (did they get it right?)…” (50). Though I’m a cessationist (let the reader understand), I still found this three-fold test useful. The writers also show how the NAR distort the gospel and minimize Jesus. Their “airtime” test is really a good, simple approach: “see how many minutes are devoted to talking about forgiveness of sin, salvation, and growth in holiness versus miracles, prophetic words, and Christians “ruling and reigning”” (105). That airtime test is a good rule-of-thumb for evaluating any ministry or church.
Pivec and Geivett give readers much more. They lay out the control tactics used by NAR groups to keep people in their circles (pg. 80-94) and what to do to recover from those tactics (pg. 95-99). They expose how the NAR has created their own “translation” of Scripture – The Passion Translation – to sneak in their peculiar dogmas, which is specious in its source and rendition (Chapter 7) – which should raise more than a bunch of eyebrows! Further, they show solid reasons to avoid NAR worship music put out by Bethel Music, Jesus Culture, Hillsong Music, Forerunner Music and Gateway Worship.
All told, this is a useful, easy-to-read book on an important topic: The New Apostolic Reformation. Copies of this work should be in the hands of pastors, elders, Bible teachers, and anyone who cares about the gospel of Jesus Christ and his church. I highly recommend the book.
If I understand the authors correctly, they are in agreement with the charismatic and Pentecostal tradition, and thus their work is not a cessationist manuscript. Rather, as orthodox Pentecostals they have felt – personally – the impact of the NAR and have seen its dangers. They write the book to give a voice to the countless people and churches who have been harmed by the NAR. “It’s meant to expose the movement and its practices. Along the way, we reveal the dangers of NAR teachings, the harm they’re doing, and the way they’re compromising the gospel” (15).
The authors use Bethel Church in Redding, California, as their sample case, though they do reach beyond that organization to show that Bethel is not a one-off. Pivec and Geivett address numerous oddities that seem to be mainline at Bethel, and the NAR. They show how New Age practices and teaching – given other names – are commonplace. They examine the different kinds of “prophecies” that are promoted in that association, and how their numerous inaccuracies and failures are sidestepped by leadership. There are a host of other practices and models that are studied in the book, such as prayer declarations, leaders ‘activating’ prophetic gifts in others, fresh revelations, and communicating with the dead, to name a few.
One of the beliefs of the NAR that Pivec and Geivett present is the Seven Mountain Mandate. The Seven Mountain Mandate is supposedly revealed to the NAR prophets and apostles on how to infiltrate and seize the highest positions of the major societal institutions: government, media, family, business, education, church, and the arts. The ‘prophets’ and ‘apostles’ of the NAR “claim that this mandate gives them authority to govern not only the church, but also society” (104). Let that sink in a bit.
As the authors examine various aspects and angles of the NAR, they also give good, wholesome, biblical, sober guidance so their readers can gain discernment. For example, they show how the “Bible gives three negative tests” for evaluating the legitimacy of prophecy and prophet: “the Orthodoxy Test (do their prophecies line up with Scripture?), the Lifestyle Test (are they greedy and lustful), and the Fulfillment Test (did they get it right?)…” (50). Though I’m a cessationist (let the reader understand), I still found this three-fold test useful. The writers also show how the NAR distort the gospel and minimize Jesus. Their “airtime” test is really a good, simple approach: “see how many minutes are devoted to talking about forgiveness of sin, salvation, and growth in holiness versus miracles, prophetic words, and Christians “ruling and reigning”” (105). That airtime test is a good rule-of-thumb for evaluating any ministry or church.
Pivec and Geivett give readers much more. They lay out the control tactics used by NAR groups to keep people in their circles (pg. 80-94) and what to do to recover from those tactics (pg. 95-99). They expose how the NAR has created their own “translation” of Scripture – The Passion Translation – to sneak in their peculiar dogmas, which is specious in its source and rendition (Chapter 7) – which should raise more than a bunch of eyebrows! Further, they show solid reasons to avoid NAR worship music put out by Bethel Music, Jesus Culture, Hillsong Music, Forerunner Music and Gateway Worship.
All told, this is a useful, easy-to-read book on an important topic: The New Apostolic Reformation. Copies of this work should be in the hands of pastors, elders, Bible teachers, and anyone who cares about the gospel of Jesus Christ and his church. I highly recommend the book.
May 25, 2024
Even as a pastor, this book really opened my eyes to the way NAR beliefs and practices have subtly infiltrated the church. In particular it has pointed out the importance of carefully evaluating the music we use in worship.
The book was also heartbreaking with the numerous accounts of real people whose lives have been forever changed by those espousing NAR theology.
This is a must read for all Christians, especially parents and teens.
The book was also heartbreaking with the numerous accounts of real people whose lives have been forever changed by those espousing NAR theology.
This is a must read for all Christians, especially parents and teens.
July 7, 2023
Before picking up this book, I was not familiar with the term, "NAR" (New Apostolic Reformation), however I was slightly familiar with the teachings and the practices, as well as the music from NAR churches such as Bethel and Hillsong. I was also familiar with self-professed "prophets," having been the unfortunate recipient of "a new word from the Lord" many times throughout my life. Reading this book was a fresh reminder of the dangers that are infiltrating the church by people who misrepresent Jesus Christ and His word, and hide behind religious lingo in order to further their own agenda. I wish I could say that I have never been duped by counterfeit gospels such as NAR, but I have, and this book gave a striking and sobering picture of just how easy it is for wolves to sneak into the sheep fold.
The Bible warns us all throughout the New Testament to be aware and watchful of false doctrines, false prophets, and "new revelations." We are cautioned to be diligent, to examine not only the teachings we hear but the lives of those who are doing the teaching. Failing to do this results in confusion, spiritual abuse, and Biblical illiteracy, and that is what the authors expound on in this book. We have to know what Scripture says (in context), studying the Bible Broadly, Often, and Deeply as the authors say, so that we may rightly apply it.
"Counterfeit Kingdom" is packed with information that is thoroughly researched. The practices and teachings of NAR are clearly explained, examined in light of Scripture, and shared alongside the personal testimonies of many Christians who have been harmed by its theology. The authors give names and affiliations that help us (especially as parents) spot what and whom we should avoid. I particularly appreciated the chapter directed to parents on how to protect your children from getting caught up in the NAR phenomena as well as what to do when your child is already submerged in its doctrines.
Below are the chapter titles and my summation of each one:
1. Wake Up, Olive (revisiting the 2019 controversy of Olive and NAR's raising the dead claims)
2. Who Are The New Apostles and Prophets (examining what Scripture says about Apostles and Prophets)
3. Hogwarts for Christians (exposing the Bethel School of Supernatural Ministry)
4. Jesus's Overlooked Warning (testing false teachers in light of Scripture's criteria)
5. The Apostolic Takeover and Spiritual Abuse (confronting the control tactics in NAR and the like)
6. Counterfeit Revival (understanding the difference between genuine revival and synthetic "revival")
7. The Passionately Wrong "Bible" (uncovering the problem with The Passion "translation")
8. Toxic Worship Music (discerning music's influence on our theology)
9. Is It Always God's Will To Heal? (confronting the dangers of the "health and wealth gospel")
10. Deception-Proofing Your Children (protecting your children and teaching them how to think critically)
11. Joining the Resistance (recapping and then encouraging further spiritual growth)
It would be tempting to glance at the title and subtitle of this book and say, "It's just a minor theological disagreement, that's all." But anything that harms God's people and masquerades as truth is a major issue, not a minor one. Furthermore, we have the responsibility to be in the know about what is deceiving thousands of people and coming after our children.
I highly recommend this book to all Christians. It is written with great love for Jesus and His church.
** If you are interested in more books along the same vein as "Counterfeit Kingdom," I suggest "God, Greed, and the Prosperity Gospel" by Costi Hinn, "Another Gospel" by Alisa Childers, and "Strange Fire" by John MacArthur.
The Bible warns us all throughout the New Testament to be aware and watchful of false doctrines, false prophets, and "new revelations." We are cautioned to be diligent, to examine not only the teachings we hear but the lives of those who are doing the teaching. Failing to do this results in confusion, spiritual abuse, and Biblical illiteracy, and that is what the authors expound on in this book. We have to know what Scripture says (in context), studying the Bible Broadly, Often, and Deeply as the authors say, so that we may rightly apply it.
"Counterfeit Kingdom" is packed with information that is thoroughly researched. The practices and teachings of NAR are clearly explained, examined in light of Scripture, and shared alongside the personal testimonies of many Christians who have been harmed by its theology. The authors give names and affiliations that help us (especially as parents) spot what and whom we should avoid. I particularly appreciated the chapter directed to parents on how to protect your children from getting caught up in the NAR phenomena as well as what to do when your child is already submerged in its doctrines.
Below are the chapter titles and my summation of each one:
1. Wake Up, Olive (revisiting the 2019 controversy of Olive and NAR's raising the dead claims)
2. Who Are The New Apostles and Prophets (examining what Scripture says about Apostles and Prophets)
3. Hogwarts for Christians (exposing the Bethel School of Supernatural Ministry)
4. Jesus's Overlooked Warning (testing false teachers in light of Scripture's criteria)
5. The Apostolic Takeover and Spiritual Abuse (confronting the control tactics in NAR and the like)
6. Counterfeit Revival (understanding the difference between genuine revival and synthetic "revival")
7. The Passionately Wrong "Bible" (uncovering the problem with The Passion "translation")
8. Toxic Worship Music (discerning music's influence on our theology)
9. Is It Always God's Will To Heal? (confronting the dangers of the "health and wealth gospel")
10. Deception-Proofing Your Children (protecting your children and teaching them how to think critically)
11. Joining the Resistance (recapping and then encouraging further spiritual growth)
It would be tempting to glance at the title and subtitle of this book and say, "It's just a minor theological disagreement, that's all." But anything that harms God's people and masquerades as truth is a major issue, not a minor one. Furthermore, we have the responsibility to be in the know about what is deceiving thousands of people and coming after our children.
I highly recommend this book to all Christians. It is written with great love for Jesus and His church.
** If you are interested in more books along the same vein as "Counterfeit Kingdom," I suggest "God, Greed, and the Prosperity Gospel" by Costi Hinn, "Another Gospel" by Alisa Childers, and "Strange Fire" by John MacArthur.
December 2, 2022
Excellent, eye-opening read! In Counterfeit Kingdom: The Dangers of New Revelation, New Prophets, and New Age Practices in the Church, Heidi Pivoc and Douglas Geivett deep dive into the beliefs and practices of NAR (New Apostolic Reformation), sharing real life examples and testimonies. The background and reach of this movement is something we all need to be aware of and recognize as harmful to the mission and health of the Church.
Reading it, I recognized things that I had red flags on with certain ministries and posts people share but could not quite put my finger on what it was. This book helped me recognize what was happening. NAR teaching and beliefs shows up in churches, ministries, and music. Especially disconcerting is that "Bethel's own leaders state openly that they view their music as a tool to 'plant' their teachings and practices in other churches throughout the world."(p148) The thought that churches are using their music not knowing this as the agenda for said music is concerning.
The authors do not just tell you the beliefs and practices, but they expound on where NAR leaders get the ideas. Often it comes from misuse or twisting of scripture. Heidi and Douglas expound on these to show what scripture really says about their practices, beliefs, and statements.
As suggested in the closing chapters of the book, we must continue to educate ourselves about NAR, educate our children about it, stay alert for signs of it in our own church and of others trying to hijack a Christian organization for its cause, and share what we learn about this movement, warning others of its dangers. We must know scripture ourselves. I highly recommend this book to anyone, but especially parents, pastors, leaders, and young adults.
Reading it, I recognized things that I had red flags on with certain ministries and posts people share but could not quite put my finger on what it was. This book helped me recognize what was happening. NAR teaching and beliefs shows up in churches, ministries, and music. Especially disconcerting is that "Bethel's own leaders state openly that they view their music as a tool to 'plant' their teachings and practices in other churches throughout the world."(p148) The thought that churches are using their music not knowing this as the agenda for said music is concerning.
The authors do not just tell you the beliefs and practices, but they expound on where NAR leaders get the ideas. Often it comes from misuse or twisting of scripture. Heidi and Douglas expound on these to show what scripture really says about their practices, beliefs, and statements.
As suggested in the closing chapters of the book, we must continue to educate ourselves about NAR, educate our children about it, stay alert for signs of it in our own church and of others trying to hijack a Christian organization for its cause, and share what we learn about this movement, warning others of its dangers. We must know scripture ourselves. I highly recommend this book to anyone, but especially parents, pastors, leaders, and young adults.
December 10, 2023
Counterfeit Kingdom by Holly Pivac and R. Douglas Geivett helps you understand the errors in the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) movement so that you are equipped to recognize the signs in your own community. It focuses particularly on the beliefs and practices of Bethel Church in Redding, CA, which have influenced many churches in the US and worldwide.
I was, quite frankly, shocked by the content and saddened that there are so many people caught up in this movement. It’s heartbreaking that the very words of God have been not only misinterpreted, but altered in a bible known as The Passion Translation to cater to this apostle/prophet model of church governance.
I have heard Bethel songs in churches I’ve attended, so I was particularly curious about the chapter that addresses NAR worship music. I have a better understanding of why the music is problematic after reading this book.
The final chapter, Conclusion: Joining the Resistance, provides a summary of the book, encourages believers to speak truth in love about the influence of NAR in their communities with tips on how to respond to pushback, and includes an excellent explanation of why speaking up about clear false teaching is not divisive. It’s life-giving.
My reading experience was mixed. While this is an informative and necessary book, it is not an enjoyable read. But then, it is not a joy to expose false teaching.
I was, quite frankly, shocked by the content and saddened that there are so many people caught up in this movement. It’s heartbreaking that the very words of God have been not only misinterpreted, but altered in a bible known as The Passion Translation to cater to this apostle/prophet model of church governance.
I have heard Bethel songs in churches I’ve attended, so I was particularly curious about the chapter that addresses NAR worship music. I have a better understanding of why the music is problematic after reading this book.
The final chapter, Conclusion: Joining the Resistance, provides a summary of the book, encourages believers to speak truth in love about the influence of NAR in their communities with tips on how to respond to pushback, and includes an excellent explanation of why speaking up about clear false teaching is not divisive. It’s life-giving.
My reading experience was mixed. While this is an informative and necessary book, it is not an enjoyable read. But then, it is not a joy to expose false teaching.
January 25, 2023
This book was crazy. I had always sort of been in the sidelines when it came to Bethel church (an other churches that I know now are considered NAR), since I I didn’t want to “cast the first stone.” This book has opened my eyes to the dangers of NAR and made me confident jn wanting to distance myself from Bethel and other similar churches completely.
October 24, 2025
“Scripture is sufficient. It contains all the instruction we need to please God and fulfill His purposes. We don’t need additional revelations to please our Lord or live according to His will for our lives.”
In this short read, Pivec and Geivett write an expose of New Apostolic Reformation (NAR), which is a Charismatic Movement that is rapidly growing in the Anglo-Phone world. Examples include Bethel, Hillsong, International House of Prayer (IHOP), Gateway, Harvest, and Jesus Culture. The book especially focuses on Bethel, as the Bethel is the largest and probably most well known of the above due to their well known music.
The text focuses on the unbiblical behaviors that are common place among these churches, from awakening angels by yelling “Wakey, Wakey”, to unsuccessfully trying to raise the dead, and visiting graves of the dead to “soak out” their ability to do miracles, the book focuses largely on often absurd practices of these churches that more resemble Eastern New Age practices than something we would associate with Christianity. They fundamentally do not believe scripture is sufficient, or even that it’s that important. Spiritual power, apostles, healers, and prophets are what really matter.
It does eventually drill down into more of the assumptions that lead to these practices, namely that all have the spiritual ability do miracles, and that all true believes should expect to be able to do miracles, and that is necessary to do miracles to bring Heaven to Earth, control the culture (7 mountains mandate), and to be ready for the end times.
The book falls short in developing a good way of responding as Orthodox Christians other than saying to avoid all music from these churches (so no Bethel, no Hillsong, no Gateway even outside of services).
I personally believe that fundamentally those in historical, Protestant denominations need to respond to this massive loss of people to Charismatic movements. Many charismatic are strong believers, but fundamentally many of these fringe churches push way beyond what can be considered Protestant or Evangelical into New Age practices. The primacy and sufficiency of the Bible is the building block of the Reformation, and churches that don’t agree with the sufficiency of scripture cannot be included in the umbrellas of “Protestant” or “Evangelical”.
In this short read, Pivec and Geivett write an expose of New Apostolic Reformation (NAR), which is a Charismatic Movement that is rapidly growing in the Anglo-Phone world. Examples include Bethel, Hillsong, International House of Prayer (IHOP), Gateway, Harvest, and Jesus Culture. The book especially focuses on Bethel, as the Bethel is the largest and probably most well known of the above due to their well known music.
The text focuses on the unbiblical behaviors that are common place among these churches, from awakening angels by yelling “Wakey, Wakey”, to unsuccessfully trying to raise the dead, and visiting graves of the dead to “soak out” their ability to do miracles, the book focuses largely on often absurd practices of these churches that more resemble Eastern New Age practices than something we would associate with Christianity. They fundamentally do not believe scripture is sufficient, or even that it’s that important. Spiritual power, apostles, healers, and prophets are what really matter.
It does eventually drill down into more of the assumptions that lead to these practices, namely that all have the spiritual ability do miracles, and that all true believes should expect to be able to do miracles, and that is necessary to do miracles to bring Heaven to Earth, control the culture (7 mountains mandate), and to be ready for the end times.
The book falls short in developing a good way of responding as Orthodox Christians other than saying to avoid all music from these churches (so no Bethel, no Hillsong, no Gateway even outside of services).
I personally believe that fundamentally those in historical, Protestant denominations need to respond to this massive loss of people to Charismatic movements. Many charismatic are strong believers, but fundamentally many of these fringe churches push way beyond what can be considered Protestant or Evangelical into New Age practices. The primacy and sufficiency of the Bible is the building block of the Reformation, and churches that don’t agree with the sufficiency of scripture cannot be included in the umbrellas of “Protestant” or “Evangelical”.
April 22, 2023
Counterfeit Kingdoms: The Dangers of New Revelation, New Prophets, and New Age Practices in the Church
By: Holly Pivec and R. Douglas Geivett
257 Pages (6 hrs. 41 mins. audio)
Star Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
NAR = New Apostolic Reformation
The cover picture couldn’t be more fitting.
What is NAR?
“NAR’s core teaching is apostles and prophets must govern churches. Churches must submit to the authority of apostles and prophets, who can then bring critical new revelation that Christians need for developing miraculous powers, setting up God’s kingdom on earth, and paving the way for Christ’s return.”
The threat of false prophets isn’t a new thing, and we are living in a time where we are seeing defection from the truth of Scripture on a grand scale. Between the Word of Faith, NAR, and Progressive Christianity, it is imperative that we know our Bibles and are in prayer for discernment and for these souls being led astray because of these teachings.
Counterfeit Kingdom provides a clear and thorough presentation on NAR, opening with the Bethel Church Movement and Wake Up Olive, to breaking down NAR practices and how to discern their practices in the light of Scripture, to the Passion Translation, to NAR’s teachings finding their way into worship music, to answering the question is it always God’s will to heal?, and so much more. The authors also do a great job expounding on where NAR leaders get their ideas, which often comes from the misuse or twisting of Scripture. Christians, you will benefit greatly by reading this book and informing yourselves on this movement that has infiltrated so many churches across the globe.
By: Holly Pivec and R. Douglas Geivett
257 Pages (6 hrs. 41 mins. audio)
Star Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
NAR = New Apostolic Reformation
The cover picture couldn’t be more fitting.
What is NAR?
“NAR’s core teaching is apostles and prophets must govern churches. Churches must submit to the authority of apostles and prophets, who can then bring critical new revelation that Christians need for developing miraculous powers, setting up God’s kingdom on earth, and paving the way for Christ’s return.”
The threat of false prophets isn’t a new thing, and we are living in a time where we are seeing defection from the truth of Scripture on a grand scale. Between the Word of Faith, NAR, and Progressive Christianity, it is imperative that we know our Bibles and are in prayer for discernment and for these souls being led astray because of these teachings.
Counterfeit Kingdom provides a clear and thorough presentation on NAR, opening with the Bethel Church Movement and Wake Up Olive, to breaking down NAR practices and how to discern their practices in the light of Scripture, to the Passion Translation, to NAR’s teachings finding their way into worship music, to answering the question is it always God’s will to heal?, and so much more. The authors also do a great job expounding on where NAR leaders get their ideas, which often comes from the misuse or twisting of Scripture. Christians, you will benefit greatly by reading this book and informing yourselves on this movement that has infiltrated so many churches across the globe.
March 7, 2025
Not gonna lie, I skimmed the last few chapters. I feel like all non-fiction books could be cut down by 1/3-1/2 because there’s a lot of reiteration of the same points. 🥲
There were times I felt fired up and like the authors made valid points about NAR, and times when I felt like their writing came across a little bit bitter or overly cynical. At times it felt like they limited God to very human constraints. For example: some Bethel music is not the most theologically sound, but God can use KISS or Nickelback to move in someone’s life in a meaningful way if he wants to. Does that mean everything Nickelback or KISS sings is theologically accurate? Absolutely not. But the Lord is not tethered by human errors in judgement.
There were times I felt fired up and like the authors made valid points about NAR, and times when I felt like their writing came across a little bit bitter or overly cynical. At times it felt like they limited God to very human constraints. For example: some Bethel music is not the most theologically sound, but God can use KISS or Nickelback to move in someone’s life in a meaningful way if he wants to. Does that mean everything Nickelback or KISS sings is theologically accurate? Absolutely not. But the Lord is not tethered by human errors in judgement.
September 29, 2023
The NAR (New Apostolic Reformation) is making inroads into multiple denominations (mine notwithstanding) and the fallout is going to be drastic. This is a dangerous book especially if you are Pentecostal however it is certainly worthy of your attention because it helps you to see the trends and roads that we are being carried along. It greatly heightened my own sense of discernment (which we are all called to; 1 John 4:1-2) as to what the "prophets" are doing in our day. This book opened my eyes just as some blogs did years ago when the Emerging Church was coming down the pike.
February 5, 2025
4.5 ⭐️ I enjoyed this book! It was an easy read, and I think it’s important to know the lure of NAR churches (New Apostolic Reformation), and how to avoid that theology/culture leaking into solid churches. While I’m glad I read it, and I think the info will be valuable as I raise my kids in a culture that wants to twist the gospel to fit whatever the world has to say, I’m thankful to be part of a church that I don’t see any of these practices taking place. Being part of a solid church is invaluable, and I’m so grateful for mine! ❤️
March 14, 2024
Every ! Christian ! Must ! Read ! This ! Book !
(especially if you are a pastor ! or work in ministry)
Or at least please just read chapters 7 & 8 !!! So pleased to see people speaking up about this. I feel like a broken record banging on about it but it's so so important. Really enjoyed all the practical examples and tips as well as how informative it was.
(especially if you are a pastor ! or work in ministry)
Or at least please just read chapters 7 & 8 !!! So pleased to see people speaking up about this. I feel like a broken record banging on about it but it's so so important. Really enjoyed all the practical examples and tips as well as how informative it was.
October 1, 2025
I’m giving this 3.5 stars. This was a great read and a thorough intro to the NAR movement. This movement is spreading fast and every believer should be aware of its teachings in order to be on guard against them. I think this would be a great starter guide for anyone who is unaware of the NAR movement. I listened to the audiobook, but I would recommend reading the physical copy. This way, you could more easily look up the Scripture that is referenced throughout the book.
April 15, 2023
Bethel has some wacky, new age-ish practices. If you want to bring yourself up to speed on some of the excesses of the NAR and Bethel, the first 3 chapters will be helpful. My problem with the rest of the book is that the authors do what so many others are guilty of: throwing the baby out with the bath water. In their attempts to warn against the excesses of the NAR, they go beyond the scriptures in their assessment of some of the practices that even solid charismatics hold to and run the risk of leading others to quench the Spirit. I find that many non charismatics are unaware of the best biblical arguments from the charismatic perspective. If they had interacted more with the arguments of those such as Sam Storms, Jack Deere, Wayne Grudem, Michael Rowntree, Craig Keener, and many more, I think this would have been more helpful book. They need to take the approach that Paul takes with the Corinthians. Paul called out improper thinking and behaviors without discouraging the pursuit of the Spirit. In fact he commands we both earnestly desire and pursue the gifts. Doug and Holly called out improper behaviors in a way that boils pursuit down to nothing. One such example is found in chapter 3 when they scrutinize the idea of “activating” the gift of prophecy. I don’t much like the term “activate” either but Paul does tell us to desire and pursue the gifts so we cannot disregard the necessity to seek after them. When we say things like “God sovereignty bestows gifts to the believer” this is true and yet he also uses the means of desire and pursuit to bestow. I think it’s indeed helpful to scrutinize some of the practices in the process of “activating” the gifts, but Holly and Doug leave the reader with the impression that you can’t pursue at all, only receive.
Additionally, their assessment of the legitimacy of prophets and prophecy disregard passages such as 1 Corinthians 14:29-31 and 1 Thessalonians 5:19-22. These verses do not require prophecy and prophets to be laser accurate like Holly and Doug say but rather the church receives, weighs, and is encouraged and built up when the prophecy hits home and when it is questionable, they abstain from accepting the prophecy. It’s curious too that Paul, in 1 Corinthians 14:30, tells the one prophesying to stop in the middle of his prophecy if another prophet receives a revelation so that the second prophet can deliver it. If 100% accuracy is required why would Paul allow a prophecy to be interrupted? We need to analyze this prophecy so that if it’s not accurate we can call this person a false prophet but if he’s being interrupted like Paul commands, how is this possible?
I 100% agree with the heart behind this book and join with Holly and Doug in saying that the NAR is dangerous. I just wish they would have taken more time to both read and understand solid Charismatics/Continuationists so that they would have potentially avoided throwing the baby out. I know others will argue that they didn’t do what I claim but I strongly believe that this is likely due to not having a more nuanced understanding of the positions of non NAR charismatics. You’ll find that they make a strong and biblical case for SOME of the practices that those in the NAR camp also hold too and this helps us avoid lumping those things in with things like the wakey wakey angel stuff and “christian” tarot cards nonsense.
Additionally, their assessment of the legitimacy of prophets and prophecy disregard passages such as 1 Corinthians 14:29-31 and 1 Thessalonians 5:19-22. These verses do not require prophecy and prophets to be laser accurate like Holly and Doug say but rather the church receives, weighs, and is encouraged and built up when the prophecy hits home and when it is questionable, they abstain from accepting the prophecy. It’s curious too that Paul, in 1 Corinthians 14:30, tells the one prophesying to stop in the middle of his prophecy if another prophet receives a revelation so that the second prophet can deliver it. If 100% accuracy is required why would Paul allow a prophecy to be interrupted? We need to analyze this prophecy so that if it’s not accurate we can call this person a false prophet but if he’s being interrupted like Paul commands, how is this possible?
I 100% agree with the heart behind this book and join with Holly and Doug in saying that the NAR is dangerous. I just wish they would have taken more time to both read and understand solid Charismatics/Continuationists so that they would have potentially avoided throwing the baby out. I know others will argue that they didn’t do what I claim but I strongly believe that this is likely due to not having a more nuanced understanding of the positions of non NAR charismatics. You’ll find that they make a strong and biblical case for SOME of the practices that those in the NAR camp also hold too and this helps us avoid lumping those things in with things like the wakey wakey angel stuff and “christian” tarot cards nonsense.
November 17, 2022
A Must Read
Happy to see NAR fully explained and how it’s connected to New Age practices. If you’re wondering if NAR influence is coming to a church near you, you might be surprised to find it’s already there.
Happy to see NAR fully explained and how it’s connected to New Age practices. If you’re wondering if NAR influence is coming to a church near you, you might be surprised to find it’s already there.
December 29, 2023
This book reminded me so much of Hank Hanegraaff's "Christianity in Crisis." It reads like an expose of the New Apostolic Reformation. The authors particularly take Bethel Church to task. They seem eager to document the extraordinary craziness and extra-biblical excess of Bethel and IHOPKC and other NAR churches.
It is a helpful book for those who have not read about the harm of this extreme fringe of the charismatic movement.
In 2005, Tim Challie's wrote a review of Hanegraaff's "Counterfeit Revival." In it, he said,
I think the same could be said of this book. While it offers helps at the end, it doesn't really offer practical helps. They're more like platitudes than helps. Their chapter on NAR music was good, but they didn't offer alternative sources of solid, biblical worship music. They were eager to name names of the offenders, but they didn't name names of those doing excellent work.
One final bummer: when they offered books for more reading about the NAR movement, the authors offered.. their own books... more books that they'd written about the movement. Granted their extensive endnotes have other sources, but it should be a concern that they recommend themselves for further reading.
I agree with their assessment that NAR teaching/churches are heretical and divisive. It would have been more helpful to offer more practical guidelines for countering false teaching.
It is a helpful book for those who have not read about the harm of this extreme fringe of the charismatic movement.
In 2005, Tim Challie's wrote a review of Hanegraaff's "Counterfeit Revival." In it, he said,
Long on symptoms, short on diagnosis and shorter still on cure, I still found this a helpful and interesting book. I trust that it will help many from being led astray into the rottenness that is found at the fringes of the charismatic movement.
I think the same could be said of this book. While it offers helps at the end, it doesn't really offer practical helps. They're more like platitudes than helps. Their chapter on NAR music was good, but they didn't offer alternative sources of solid, biblical worship music. They were eager to name names of the offenders, but they didn't name names of those doing excellent work.
One final bummer: when they offered books for more reading about the NAR movement, the authors offered.. their own books... more books that they'd written about the movement. Granted their extensive endnotes have other sources, but it should be a concern that they recommend themselves for further reading.
I agree with their assessment that NAR teaching/churches are heretical and divisive. It would have been more helpful to offer more practical guidelines for countering false teaching.
December 14, 2022
Quite possibly the most necessary book of the year. Christians far and wide need to read it.
January 31, 2023
"Some of my most beloved worship songs from youth group and summer camp were created by Bethel Music, the music label that was birthed out of the music ministry at Bethel Church in Redding, California. Songs like “You Make Me Brave,” “No Longer Slaves,” “King of My Heart,” “Raise a Hallelujah,” and “Goodness of God” became some of my favorite songs to listen and sing along to. Despite not intentionally listening to these songs in many years, much of these lyrics are committed to my memory.
However, as I’ve grown in my faith over the last several years, I’ve learned more about Bethel Church and the doctrines she teaches. The more I’ve learned, the more skeptical I’ve become of their theology and philosophy. And within the last year or two, I’ve come to realize that the kingdom they preach is a counterfeit one.
Bethel Church subscribes to a belief which has been named the New Apostolic Reformation (or NAR for short). As Holly Pivec and R. Douglas Geivett argue in their book Counterfeit Kingdom, NAR is an extremely unbiblical and dangerous movement..."
Continue reading my review at tristanycorgan.com/blog-counterfeitki... .
However, as I’ve grown in my faith over the last several years, I’ve learned more about Bethel Church and the doctrines she teaches. The more I’ve learned, the more skeptical I’ve become of their theology and philosophy. And within the last year or two, I’ve come to realize that the kingdom they preach is a counterfeit one.
Bethel Church subscribes to a belief which has been named the New Apostolic Reformation (or NAR for short). As Holly Pivec and R. Douglas Geivett argue in their book Counterfeit Kingdom, NAR is an extremely unbiblical and dangerous movement..."
Continue reading my review at tristanycorgan.com/blog-counterfeitki... .
Displaying 1 - 30 of 333 reviews