What do you think?
Rate this book
Blood of the Fae #1
Tattoo of Crimson
Society, suitors, and…serial murders?
As much as she desires to please her family, gently-bred herbalist Jessa Caldwell has no intention of making a suitable match—not when she’s seeking the truth about the taint of the fae that lies within her. If she’s to escape the madness brought on by fae-touch, she must devote her energies to seeking a cure.
But then mysterious tattoos begin to appear on the citizens of Avons. None recall receiving these harbingers of death, but all die at the hand of an untraceable killer days or weeks after being marked.
When the tattoo appears on her beloved mentor, Jessa seeks the Magistry with information on the case—yet they refuse to consider her findings, so she must risk both social censure and her own safety to hunt for the killer herself.
Her one possible ally represents her greatest fear—the encroaching Otherworld consuming her mind—and may well undo all her efforts to control her fae-touch. Yet if she forsakes the offered aid, the killer will go free.
Something sinister stalks the streets of her city, and she must decide…how far will she go to stop the killing?
Tattoo of Crimson, a gaslamp fantasy novel, is the first book in the Blood of the Fae series. If you like quick-minded heroines who solve cases with logic and intuition, beautiful yet deadly fae, and Otherworldly intrigues, then you’ll love this mystery set in a world of manners and mythical monsters.
As much as she desires to please her family, gently-bred herbalist Jessa Caldwell has no intention of making a suitable match—not when she’s seeking the truth about the taint of the fae that lies within her. If she’s to escape the madness brought on by fae-touch, she must devote her energies to seeking a cure.
But then mysterious tattoos begin to appear on the citizens of Avons. None recall receiving these harbingers of death, but all die at the hand of an untraceable killer days or weeks after being marked.
When the tattoo appears on her beloved mentor, Jessa seeks the Magistry with information on the case—yet they refuse to consider her findings, so she must risk both social censure and her own safety to hunt for the killer herself.
Her one possible ally represents her greatest fear—the encroaching Otherworld consuming her mind—and may well undo all her efforts to control her fae-touch. Yet if she forsakes the offered aid, the killer will go free.
Something sinister stalks the streets of her city, and she must decide…how far will she go to stop the killing?
Tattoo of Crimson, a gaslamp fantasy novel, is the first book in the Blood of the Fae series. If you like quick-minded heroines who solve cases with logic and intuition, beautiful yet deadly fae, and Otherworldly intrigues, then you’ll love this mystery set in a world of manners and mythical monsters.
584 pages, Kindle Edition
Published January 17, 2023
22 people are currently reading
639 people want to read
About the author
Sarah Chislon
10 books44 followersSarah Chislon lives in Virginia with her husband and three daughters. When she’s not writing, she’s homeschooling her children and running a web development business with her husband. As an avid reader and a lifelong story-weaver, she delights in creating fantastic worlds and exploring them alongside her characters.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 44 reviews
April 26, 2024
This first novel in the Blood of the Fae series introduces us to Jessa Caldwell, a gentleman’s daughter who would far prefer the company of plants to people. Except her particular affinity to plant life goes a bit deeper than mere interest—she can feel the emotions of the plants, hear their songs, and these odd abilities bring great danger. She is fae-touched, and if she is exposed to having the taint of the Otherworld within her, she will be sent to the dreaded Vigil and never heard from again.
Keeping her abilities secret proves to be far more challenging when a killer who has been running loose around the city of Avons targets Jessa’s dear friend. Unable to sit back and let this horror happen, Jessa finds herself caught up in a dark mystery, danger, and fae dealings—and her fae-touch may be the only way to get out.
The first thing that struck me in this novel is the worldbuilding. It seamlessly tied Regency England into a world full of fae and alchemy, and the combination was spectacular. As Jessa is not overly familiar with all the workings of the Otherworld (the realm the fae come from), we readers get to discover things right alongside her and experience all the dangers and mysteries with each new page. At the same time, the author had such a gift for capturing a world that truly felt like Regency England. The writing style was a great mix of historical fiction tied into a fantasy tale, and I loved how Jessa had to keep to social norms in her world of manners all while facing dangerous fae dealings.
Jessa herself was a sympathetic protagonist. She has a quiet strength that I always love to find in heroines. Though she’s bookish and struggles with social engagements, she’s still willing to put herself out there when duty calls and holds respect for her family so as not to rebel, something we don’t see a whole lot in fiction and was very refreshing! Her deep loyalty to her loved ones was also so beautiful and admirable. It was truly the driving force for all her actions, and I loved seeing familial love play such a huge role in the story. The overall cast was very dynamic and diverse, with each character portraying a different corner of the world. There were some particular characters who highly intrigued me and I very much look forward to seeing just what they’re up to.
Also Jessa had a cat companion, and I am always pleased with stories featuring cat companions. Always.
To add to the genre crossover of historical and fantasy, the overall plot was also a murder mystery, and I was there for it. All the different characters definitely kept me guessing, and the slow build-up led to a satisfying conclusion to answers.
The setting of Regency England sitting on the edges of a dangerous fae world was such a perfect backdrop for an eerie mystery. The descriptions of the world and plant life made for an immersive experience overall. It is a very atmospheric story that pulls you right into the world.
The pacing itself was rather slow, especially for the first half. There was a good bit of introspection on Jessa’s part as she took matters into her own hands and followed clues. It is not a fast-paced novel, but the pace built up to an explosive climax with a satisfying ending all while leaving enough questions to get us clamoring for the next book.
CONTENT CAUTIONS
As this is a murder mystery, there are a few sparse mentions of gruesome events but we never see it on page. The fae themselves are definitely dangerous, tricky beings and cause a lot of fear and unpleasant deals. But all descriptions are tastefully done.
Things are kept very family-friendly and there isn’t even any romance in this one. It keeps the fantastical and murder mystery elements on the light side as far as on-page content so there are definitely tense moments but nothing overtly unpleasant or gruesome.
I think teens and up would especially enjoy this one.
CONCLUSION
From the immersive, unique world to the detailed writing style to the sympathetic heroine and intriguing characters and mystery, this was a compelling read all around, and I am so curious to see what more dangers await Jessa in book #2!
NOTE: I do suggest reading the prequel novella, Whispers in the Waters, first. It’s not necessary, but some events in that one are referenced here without much context, so it will enhance your overall experience reading it before this one.
This novel portrays a lovable cast of characters, thoughtful narration, and seamlessly mixes Regency fiction, mystery, and fantasy. If you like one or all of those things, this should be right up your alley!
Keeping her abilities secret proves to be far more challenging when a killer who has been running loose around the city of Avons targets Jessa’s dear friend. Unable to sit back and let this horror happen, Jessa finds herself caught up in a dark mystery, danger, and fae dealings—and her fae-touch may be the only way to get out.
The first thing that struck me in this novel is the worldbuilding. It seamlessly tied Regency England into a world full of fae and alchemy, and the combination was spectacular. As Jessa is not overly familiar with all the workings of the Otherworld (the realm the fae come from), we readers get to discover things right alongside her and experience all the dangers and mysteries with each new page. At the same time, the author had such a gift for capturing a world that truly felt like Regency England. The writing style was a great mix of historical fiction tied into a fantasy tale, and I loved how Jessa had to keep to social norms in her world of manners all while facing dangerous fae dealings.
Jessa herself was a sympathetic protagonist. She has a quiet strength that I always love to find in heroines. Though she’s bookish and struggles with social engagements, she’s still willing to put herself out there when duty calls and holds respect for her family so as not to rebel, something we don’t see a whole lot in fiction and was very refreshing! Her deep loyalty to her loved ones was also so beautiful and admirable. It was truly the driving force for all her actions, and I loved seeing familial love play such a huge role in the story. The overall cast was very dynamic and diverse, with each character portraying a different corner of the world. There were some particular characters who highly intrigued me and I very much look forward to seeing just what they’re up to.
Also Jessa had a cat companion, and I am always pleased with stories featuring cat companions. Always.
To add to the genre crossover of historical and fantasy, the overall plot was also a murder mystery, and I was there for it. All the different characters definitely kept me guessing, and the slow build-up led to a satisfying conclusion to answers.
The setting of Regency England sitting on the edges of a dangerous fae world was such a perfect backdrop for an eerie mystery. The descriptions of the world and plant life made for an immersive experience overall. It is a very atmospheric story that pulls you right into the world.
The pacing itself was rather slow, especially for the first half. There was a good bit of introspection on Jessa’s part as she took matters into her own hands and followed clues. It is not a fast-paced novel, but the pace built up to an explosive climax with a satisfying ending all while leaving enough questions to get us clamoring for the next book.
CONTENT CAUTIONS
As this is a murder mystery, there are a few sparse mentions of gruesome events but we never see it on page. The fae themselves are definitely dangerous, tricky beings and cause a lot of fear and unpleasant deals. But all descriptions are tastefully done.
Things are kept very family-friendly and there isn’t even any romance in this one. It keeps the fantastical and murder mystery elements on the light side as far as on-page content so there are definitely tense moments but nothing overtly unpleasant or gruesome.
I think teens and up would especially enjoy this one.
CONCLUSION
From the immersive, unique world to the detailed writing style to the sympathetic heroine and intriguing characters and mystery, this was a compelling read all around, and I am so curious to see what more dangers await Jessa in book #2!
NOTE: I do suggest reading the prequel novella, Whispers in the Waters, first. It’s not necessary, but some events in that one are referenced here without much context, so it will enhance your overall experience reading it before this one.
This novel portrays a lovable cast of characters, thoughtful narration, and seamlessly mixes Regency fiction, mystery, and fantasy. If you like one or all of those things, this should be right up your alley!
Read
December 11, 2023If you are in the mood for a slow build, immersive gaslamp fantasy with serial murders, duplicitous fae, a conscientious heroine hampered by convention, and lush herbal magic, this is the series for you.
I wish I had started with the novella WHISPERS IN THE WATER as it took me some time to find my feet in this complex world and family. Once the fae characters appeared, I was hooked, and while I was occasionally frustrated by the bureaucratic obstacles to the heroine’s investigations, the excellent climactic sequence rewarded me amply.
I feel like the series is about to take off with the heroine being set up for a bit more independence (I hope?!) in the next book, and more revelations about her relationship to the Otherworld. I’m looking forward to more development of the fae characters, especially!
I wish I had started with the novella WHISPERS IN THE WATER as it took me some time to find my feet in this complex world and family. Once the fae characters appeared, I was hooked, and while I was occasionally frustrated by the bureaucratic obstacles to the heroine’s investigations, the excellent climactic sequence rewarded me amply.
I feel like the series is about to take off with the heroine being set up for a bit more independence (I hope?!) in the next book, and more revelations about her relationship to the Otherworld. I’m looking forward to more development of the fae characters, especially!
April 3, 2023
A gaslamp fantasy/murder mystery, with perilous fae and a mystery-solving heroine with a magical cat? You guys . . . what is not to love! The setting and writing is delicious and perfect for fans of Regency-esque fantasy. The characters were so well done and I was captivated by the setting and the fact that the fae were so Other! Masterful.
(Disclaimer: I was a proofreader for this book, but I just enjoyed it so much!)
(Disclaimer: I was a proofreader for this book, but I just enjoyed it so much!)
January 17, 2023
What a brilliant book. It’s a gaslamp fantasy murder mystery with the fae, a strong female lead who uses her wits, academic knowledge, and abilities, plus a Victorian world filled with wonder and whimsical, where it all takes place.
The book takes a while to get going, and I was slightly lost in the happenings, not sure of what was going on. There is a prequel, which I did not read and it might be best to read Whispers in the Waters before starting this book, as it might provide more backdrop to this story.
But once you get into it, the writing is filled with life, wonderful and descriptive, and made me feel as if I was in the time frame that it was taking place in. The characters are well-developed, and the story is very interesting and draws you in. Despite being quite a long book, you can’t stop reading and the pages just fly by.
Looking forward to reading the next book in the series.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The book takes a while to get going, and I was slightly lost in the happenings, not sure of what was going on. There is a prequel, which I did not read and it might be best to read Whispers in the Waters before starting this book, as it might provide more backdrop to this story.
But once you get into it, the writing is filled with life, wonderful and descriptive, and made me feel as if I was in the time frame that it was taking place in. The characters are well-developed, and the story is very interesting and draws you in. Despite being quite a long book, you can’t stop reading and the pages just fly by.
Looking forward to reading the next book in the series.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
December 20, 2022
I THOROUGHLY enjoyed Tattoo of Crimson. The prequel Whispers in the Waters worked as a teaser, making me curious about Jessa and her world without giving me enough time to really attach…not so here! I was hooked almost immediately. Complex characters, each with their own motives, breathtaking plot twists and glimmers of a possible romance. Jessa is no damsel to be rescued, nor is she a superwoman…she’s a real, relatable, sometimes naive, always indefatigable young woman who counts the cost and stands up to do hard things. I love Chislon’s voice, which echoes older classic styles without being dry or overly verbose. You are swept into a whole world of fae and Other creatures with a story lengthy enough to sink your teeth into and enjoy. Despite its length, it still ended too soon for me! I was left replaying favorite parts, pondering the characters, and wondering what comes next long after I finished. I can’t wait for book two!
*I received an advance copy for free and am voluntarily leaving a review
*I received an advance copy for free and am voluntarily leaving a review
April 2, 2023
Tattoo of Crimson ♦ Sarah Chislon
Tattoo of Crimson by Sarah Chislon is a gaslamp fantasy murder mystery featuring the fae. The book will keep you on the edge of your favorite reading place as you stay excited to see what will happen next. Tattoo of Crimson is full of mystery and suspense.
Opinion
Tattoo of Crimson is a slow read. The book is full of details! Which I can't talk about here, otherwise I would spoil way too much.
A killer who can travel between universes is also a very intriguing plot point. From the opening to the last page, the enigmatic writing style will have you guessing about whom the murderer is. Jessa uncovers and investigates a number of clues, and each one is slowly exposed to the reader. The knowledge is revealed to the reader at the same time as it is to the characters. I was left turning the pages and couldn't put it down.
Because it's a slow read Tattoo of Crimson can take a while to get rolling, and I would have been confused by all the events if I hadn't read Whispers in the Waters, the prequel to the Blood of the Fae series. Therefore, I would highly recommend reading the prequel first.
But once you get into it, the writing is vivid, brilliant, and descriptive, and it transports you to the time period it is set in. The plot is captivating and has well-developed characters. Despite being a lengthy book, Tattoo of Crimson keeps you hooked, and you can't put the book down.
Conclusion
Tattoo of Crimson is a superbly written book that is chock-full of surprise, beauty, and creativity! It was enjoyable to read.
I received an advance review copy for free by BookSirens , and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This review was first published at The Art of Reading .
Tattoo of Crimson by Sarah Chislon is a gaslamp fantasy murder mystery featuring the fae. The book will keep you on the edge of your favorite reading place as you stay excited to see what will happen next. Tattoo of Crimson is full of mystery and suspense.
Opinion
Tattoo of Crimson is a slow read. The book is full of details! Which I can't talk about here, otherwise I would spoil way too much.
A killer who can travel between universes is also a very intriguing plot point. From the opening to the last page, the enigmatic writing style will have you guessing about whom the murderer is. Jessa uncovers and investigates a number of clues, and each one is slowly exposed to the reader. The knowledge is revealed to the reader at the same time as it is to the characters. I was left turning the pages and couldn't put it down.
Because it's a slow read Tattoo of Crimson can take a while to get rolling, and I would have been confused by all the events if I hadn't read Whispers in the Waters, the prequel to the Blood of the Fae series. Therefore, I would highly recommend reading the prequel first.
But once you get into it, the writing is vivid, brilliant, and descriptive, and it transports you to the time period it is set in. The plot is captivating and has well-developed characters. Despite being a lengthy book, Tattoo of Crimson keeps you hooked, and you can't put the book down.
Conclusion
Tattoo of Crimson is a superbly written book that is chock-full of surprise, beauty, and creativity! It was enjoyable to read.
I received an advance review copy for free by BookSirens , and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This review was first published at The Art of Reading .
January 9, 2023
This was my first read by Sarah Chislon. This is book one in the Blood of Fae series. I enjoyed this book and thought it was well written. I enjoyed the historical setting that created this book. It had plenty of fantasy with a twist of mystery. I enjoyed following the FMC and her interesting storyline. She was on the hunt for the killer and I was there with her. If you love a good mystery with a twist then I recommend checking out this story. I look forward to reading the next book in the series.
"I received an advance copy for free, and I'm voluntarily leaving a review"
"I received an advance copy for free, and I'm voluntarily leaving a review"
December 15, 2023
Tattoo of Crimson was an entertaining and engaging first book in Chilson’s Blood of the Fae series and, although there were a few things that stopped me from loving it, I enjoyed it as a whole. Let’s talk about the postitive’s first… The characters. Jessa is our MC, and a character that I instantly empathised with. She is a woman ahead of her time, one that doesn’t wish for the trappings of society, but would rather spend her days finding new species of plant and writing about them in the book she could publish if she wasn’t a girl. She’s steadfast and strong, but I enjoyed how Chilson allowed her to fear without it seeming a weakness. She knows the dangers she will face, she isn’t stupid, rather she weighs the lives of those she could save over her own and so forges on headfirst into danger. Alongside Jessa we get introduced to a multitude of side characters from her family, society, law enforcement and the fae. These all play a large part in the story, adding tension and emotion when needed and allow Chilson to flesh out both her MC and her world with ease.
The atmosphere in this book was wondrously creepy and incredibly tense in parts. Chilson has taken the handsome and alluring Fae we’re used too and made them dark and scary beings. Beings that come from the ‘Otherworld,’ a place beyond Jessa’s own where Fae, as well as a multitude of other creatures, reside and a place that the people of Avon’s are incredibly fearful of. These beings are given the respect they deserve, there are no rose coloured glasses, no romance between the immortal fae and the young human. Instead Jessa is forced to work with the creatures she fears the most to save those she loves, and she does it with her eyes wide open to the dangers.
The worldbuilding of Avons & the Otherworld were incredibly well done and, although there were a few parts where the story got a bit bogged down in information, in general it was fed to us quite naturally through the story. The story itself is part fantasy and part mystery. We have a killer on the loose, one who seemingly picks victims at random, and their calling card is a tattoo placed on the victim days before he comes to claim them. I really enjoyed the murder mystery element to this, there were a lot of plot twists, a few goose chases we got sent on, and some of the scenes certainly added an almost horror element to the story, adding to the tension and drama. But alonside the mystery of the killer, we also have the mystery of Jessa herself, and how she came to be ‘fae touched,’ as she calls it.
As you can see, I did truly enjoy this book, but I do feel we could have lost about 25% of it and it would have been amazing. There was a lot of introspection, something that never really bothers me, but it was so incredibly repetitive, to the point where I would skip whole paragraphs because I knew what was being said. I also felt like there was a slight repetitive nature to some of Jessa’s scenes with her Aunt’s and the almost police force of Avon’s, warning her off investigating the murder, ensuring she acts like a proper lady, and these both slowed down my reading and did affect my enjoyment of the story a little. I also felt the pacing was a little off, it took a good while for us to get fully invested into the mystery of the killings, but I do feel that once that plot point started, the pacing of the book picked up quickly.
If you’re looking for a good fantasy mystery with fae and no romance whatsoever, I would definitely recommend this, despite the repetition and slight pacing issues. The end of this book was brilliant, though the main mystery of this book was tied up we are still left with quite a few questions, about Jessa and her abilities and about the Fae in general, and I’m incredibly eager to get my hands on the next book in the series.
The atmosphere in this book was wondrously creepy and incredibly tense in parts. Chilson has taken the handsome and alluring Fae we’re used too and made them dark and scary beings. Beings that come from the ‘Otherworld,’ a place beyond Jessa’s own where Fae, as well as a multitude of other creatures, reside and a place that the people of Avon’s are incredibly fearful of. These beings are given the respect they deserve, there are no rose coloured glasses, no romance between the immortal fae and the young human. Instead Jessa is forced to work with the creatures she fears the most to save those she loves, and she does it with her eyes wide open to the dangers.
The worldbuilding of Avons & the Otherworld were incredibly well done and, although there were a few parts where the story got a bit bogged down in information, in general it was fed to us quite naturally through the story. The story itself is part fantasy and part mystery. We have a killer on the loose, one who seemingly picks victims at random, and their calling card is a tattoo placed on the victim days before he comes to claim them. I really enjoyed the murder mystery element to this, there were a lot of plot twists, a few goose chases we got sent on, and some of the scenes certainly added an almost horror element to the story, adding to the tension and drama. But alonside the mystery of the killer, we also have the mystery of Jessa herself, and how she came to be ‘fae touched,’ as she calls it.
As you can see, I did truly enjoy this book, but I do feel we could have lost about 25% of it and it would have been amazing. There was a lot of introspection, something that never really bothers me, but it was so incredibly repetitive, to the point where I would skip whole paragraphs because I knew what was being said. I also felt like there was a slight repetitive nature to some of Jessa’s scenes with her Aunt’s and the almost police force of Avon’s, warning her off investigating the murder, ensuring she acts like a proper lady, and these both slowed down my reading and did affect my enjoyment of the story a little. I also felt the pacing was a little off, it took a good while for us to get fully invested into the mystery of the killings, but I do feel that once that plot point started, the pacing of the book picked up quickly.
If you’re looking for a good fantasy mystery with fae and no romance whatsoever, I would definitely recommend this, despite the repetition and slight pacing issues. The end of this book was brilliant, though the main mystery of this book was tied up we are still left with quite a few questions, about Jessa and her abilities and about the Fae in general, and I’m incredibly eager to get my hands on the next book in the series.
January 1, 2023
This is a tricky book for me to review; on the one hand I really liked the strange Regency fae world within it where characters went on a journey of discovery with zero romance to get in the way, yet on the other I struggled at times with the very slow pacing and info-drop method of storytelling. The first 50% of the book wasn't quite what I'd expected given how much I'd liked the world building of the prequel Whispers in the Waters (which is a required read - plus it's bonus scene - in order to understand events referenced). Later on when the story picked up I was much more engaged, and it ends on an intriguing To Be Continued note with plenty of character plot points left open to explore.
Our story picks up with one Miss Jessa Caldwell finding herself caught up in terrible events in her home city of Avons: a killed is on the loose, one who marks his victims with a tattoo in the weeks before their death. Is it magic? Alchemy? Whatever it is, the authoritarian Magistry and their magic-hunting comrades of the Vigil aren't making things public knowledge. Jessa would happily stay away from it all given how she suspects her fae-touch may be growing in strength, yet when her patron and friend Ibbie is marked for death she will stop at nothing to try and find answers, social proprieties around being a young unmarried gel be damned.
On the face of it, it's a story I can get behind. A stubborn, driven Jessa and her oddly intelligent cat Jade out on the hunt for something otherworldly... or perhaps Otherworldly, given her recent involvement with the fae who exist in her world. It's a good mystery that rumbles on, bringing in many characters from her family as well as around the city (and beyond) to bounce off. The fae lore woven in with the high society world combined with the historical tinged language made for a deep and immersive fantasy world you wanted to dig further into. Jessa is a character to root for, given she comes across as realistically curious and reasonably intelligent without being infallible or having men fall at her feet (or she at theirs).
I didn't get on so well with how slow the pace of the story was. Jessa had an odd habit of dropping in information casually that pertained to the case that I couldn't help but wish had been discovered on screen rather than imparted (her father's letters with the Alchemist or instance) or not knowing something before saying later something contradictory. Description early on was pretty sparse, especially around characters . I felt the character relationships too could lack depth; early on I felt we were told about them more than we were shown, particularly when it came to Ibbie and cousin Lovell. Conversations could feel a tad blunt, more as basic information exchanges than encounters designed to show us how Jessa and the others related to each other
I did enjoy it more once the story itself picked up, Jessa finally acting on her hunches and accepting her situation as she had back in the prequel story. All the little side plot points come together to make you want to know more. The mystery surrounding her sister Ainsley, Jade's uncanny actions, a certain high fae's interest in mortals, what the authorities of Avons know, what fae-touch actually is... There are so many tantalizing threads left hanging, so while the murder mystery may be solved in a genuinely creepy fashion there is so much more left to make you want to return to Jessa's life. Side characters certainly could grow on me, not least the two male leads who are most certainly not romance material
Overall, while the pacing and early setup wasn't exactly what I'd expected or hoped for after the tight writing of the prequel, this one does have an interesting story woven throughout. A little editorial polish could make this indie gem even better for the right reader; one who wants fae who aren't sex bombs, beta heroines who have a brain and don't charge into fights without knowledge, a slow-burn magical discovery tale, and a highly original fantasy world where nothing is quite as it seems.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Our story picks up with one Miss Jessa Caldwell finding herself caught up in terrible events in her home city of Avons: a killed is on the loose, one who marks his victims with a tattoo in the weeks before their death. Is it magic? Alchemy? Whatever it is, the authoritarian Magistry and their magic-hunting comrades of the Vigil aren't making things public knowledge. Jessa would happily stay away from it all given how she suspects her fae-touch may be growing in strength, yet when her patron and friend Ibbie is marked for death she will stop at nothing to try and find answers, social proprieties around being a young unmarried gel be damned.
On the face of it, it's a story I can get behind. A stubborn, driven Jessa and her oddly intelligent cat Jade out on the hunt for something otherworldly... or perhaps Otherworldly, given her recent involvement with the fae who exist in her world. It's a good mystery that rumbles on, bringing in many characters from her family as well as around the city (and beyond) to bounce off. The fae lore woven in with the high society world combined with the historical tinged language made for a deep and immersive fantasy world you wanted to dig further into. Jessa is a character to root for, given she comes across as realistically curious and reasonably intelligent without being infallible or having men fall at her feet (or she at theirs).
I didn't get on so well with how slow the pace of the story was. Jessa had an odd habit of dropping in information casually that pertained to the case that I couldn't help but wish had been discovered on screen rather than imparted (her father's letters with the Alchemist or instance) or not knowing something before saying later something contradictory. Description early on was pretty sparse, especially around characters . I felt the character relationships too could lack depth; early on I felt we were told about them more than we were shown, particularly when it came to Ibbie and cousin Lovell. Conversations could feel a tad blunt, more as basic information exchanges than encounters designed to show us how Jessa and the others related to each other
I did enjoy it more once the story itself picked up, Jessa finally acting on her hunches and accepting her situation as she had back in the prequel story. All the little side plot points come together to make you want to know more. The mystery surrounding her sister Ainsley, Jade's uncanny actions, a certain high fae's interest in mortals, what the authorities of Avons know, what fae-touch actually is... There are so many tantalizing threads left hanging, so while the murder mystery may be solved in a genuinely creepy fashion there is so much more left to make you want to return to Jessa's life. Side characters certainly could grow on me, not least the two male leads who are most certainly not romance material
Overall, while the pacing and early setup wasn't exactly what I'd expected or hoped for after the tight writing of the prequel, this one does have an interesting story woven throughout. A little editorial polish could make this indie gem even better for the right reader; one who wants fae who aren't sex bombs, beta heroines who have a brain and don't charge into fights without knowledge, a slow-burn magical discovery tale, and a highly original fantasy world where nothing is quite as it seems.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Read
January 27, 2023Reading the blurb I found out that Tattoo of Crimson is a “gaslamp fantasy” novel. I did not know that the book “market” needed to create a new subgenre. If you, like me, don’t know it, gaslamp fantasy is “a subgenre of both fantasy and historical fiction.”[1] It being a “gaslamp fantasy” explains why the alchemical devices (the knowledge of their existence is introduced from the first pages) are used scarcely and the alchemists are “just” a political faction. Also, it explains how the kingdom of Byren – where the action starts - is a true copy of Victorian England (the historical aspects are quite present and influence the events and the characters’ behaviour). Without insisting on this aspect, I'll say only that the author plays well within the fantasy and historical fiction coordinates I identified so far to fit this gaslamp (or gaslight) fantasy subgenre.
The story starts slowly enough to give the author the opportunity to introduce all the relevant elements for what follows. From time to time, I felt that there was no need to repeat or emphasise some details because the author got too close to the edge of political correctness; better show than tell. Fortunately, since the plot has taken shape and during its development, the necessary socio-political aspects are offered only when necessary for fulfilling their purpose without spoiling the story and its flow which has now an improved pace.
The mystery is quite a cozy mystery and Jessa, the main character, plays the role of the amateur sleuth well whilst she receives “unconventional” help and follows several clues and red herrings of fae nature. The main fae character (and others) is successful mostly in protecting Jessa than solving the mystery (that he was sent to solve) whilst Jessa seems to be, repeatedly, one step ahead.
The fantastical elements the author brings into the mix are classical but well-used. Between what Jessa was taught as true about the Otherworld and its inhabitants and what she discovers herself, and her own secret of unknown reason, Jessa must cross some murky waters when deciding the best path to take in solving the mystery, especially when eliminating the killer equals with the salvation of those she loves and of herself. Bargains and sacrifices are made, no price is too high.
And because gaslamp fantasy is also known as “gaslight romance”, I have to say that there are some signs of a (future… probable… and most certainly wanted by the readers) romance, but Jessa has yet to see… or feel… them. After all, Aunt Melisina wants her wed. 😋
Entertaining, with likeable (main) characters, with mundane or otherworldly dangers at every step, a dash of gothic ambience, some magic and a promise for more to come, the Tattoo of Crimson is a pleasant historical, fantasy, cozy mystery that you could read. Enjoy!
PS: Does the cover matter? Yes, definitely! (I am not talking about the books or authors you already know in one way or another.) If I like the cover (design, colour, message etc), I stop and check the blurb and author. If my interest or mood at the moment is satisfied, I’ll read it (or put it on my TBR list). And face it: the covers of all three books so far in the “Blood of the Fae” series are nicely done.
https://mythicalbooks.blogspot.com/20...
[1](goodreads, timeofindia.com or Wikipedia – I didn’t check who was the first or their sources
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/l...
https://www.goodreads.com/genres/gasl...
The story starts slowly enough to give the author the opportunity to introduce all the relevant elements for what follows. From time to time, I felt that there was no need to repeat or emphasise some details because the author got too close to the edge of political correctness; better show than tell. Fortunately, since the plot has taken shape and during its development, the necessary socio-political aspects are offered only when necessary for fulfilling their purpose without spoiling the story and its flow which has now an improved pace.
The mystery is quite a cozy mystery and Jessa, the main character, plays the role of the amateur sleuth well whilst she receives “unconventional” help and follows several clues and red herrings of fae nature. The main fae character (and others) is successful mostly in protecting Jessa than solving the mystery (that he was sent to solve) whilst Jessa seems to be, repeatedly, one step ahead.
The fantastical elements the author brings into the mix are classical but well-used. Between what Jessa was taught as true about the Otherworld and its inhabitants and what she discovers herself, and her own secret of unknown reason, Jessa must cross some murky waters when deciding the best path to take in solving the mystery, especially when eliminating the killer equals with the salvation of those she loves and of herself. Bargains and sacrifices are made, no price is too high.
And because gaslamp fantasy is also known as “gaslight romance”, I have to say that there are some signs of a (future… probable… and most certainly wanted by the readers) romance, but Jessa has yet to see… or feel… them. After all, Aunt Melisina wants her wed. 😋
Entertaining, with likeable (main) characters, with mundane or otherworldly dangers at every step, a dash of gothic ambience, some magic and a promise for more to come, the Tattoo of Crimson is a pleasant historical, fantasy, cozy mystery that you could read. Enjoy!
PS: Does the cover matter? Yes, definitely! (I am not talking about the books or authors you already know in one way or another.) If I like the cover (design, colour, message etc), I stop and check the blurb and author. If my interest or mood at the moment is satisfied, I’ll read it (or put it on my TBR list). And face it: the covers of all three books so far in the “Blood of the Fae” series are nicely done.
https://mythicalbooks.blogspot.com/20...
[1](goodreads, timeofindia.com or Wikipedia – I didn’t check who was the first or their sources
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/l...
https://www.goodreads.com/genres/gasl...
January 26, 2023
I wasn't quite sure what I was getting into with this book, but I knew I wanted to support a local author. (Local, lol. Virginia is HUGE.) I loved the premise, and while the page count is daunting, I can honestly say that it was absolutely worth it!
Gaslamp Fantasy is an offshoot of Steampunk, or rather...it's Steampunk's prettier, otherworldly cousin. It's a mix of Historical Fiction, Fantasy and the genre of Cozy Mystery/Cozy Romance. What it becomes is an utterly delightful read!
Tattoo of Crimson follows Jessa Caldwell, a well-bred young lady of 20 who should be out trying to make a good match, and is instead studying Herbalism and attempting to ignore the pernicious awareness that a recent excursion to the Otherworld has possibly led her to being fae-touched. Desperate to help her beloved mentor, Jessa has to venture out of her comfort zone and and broach both Society and the Otherworld.
I cannot state how much I really loved this book! The descriptions are lush and evocative, with a heavy bent towards Jessa's affinity to plants. The settings are fully realized and I had no problems visualizing the places and characters. The characters are incredibly realistic, and for the most part, likeable. Everything about the mystery of the crimson tattoos and the resulting murders that Jessa investigates feels like it ought to be a film set that I've accidentally walked into. There is mystery aplenty, the barest whisper of romance, the tensions that come from a large extended family when one doesn't fit in, and a beautiful, gentle thread of strength as Jessa does her best to protect others.
I enjoyed the ending, which wrapped up the book nicely while leaving plenty of room for the second book in the series Ruins of Boon which comes out near my birthday in October of this year. Guess what got added to my wishlist! I do hope that if the author has the option to, that this book becomes an audiobook, as with the right narrator it would be an amazing treat to those of us who prefer that medium.
Gaslamp Fantasy is an offshoot of Steampunk, or rather...it's Steampunk's prettier, otherworldly cousin. It's a mix of Historical Fiction, Fantasy and the genre of Cozy Mystery/Cozy Romance. What it becomes is an utterly delightful read!
Tattoo of Crimson follows Jessa Caldwell, a well-bred young lady of 20 who should be out trying to make a good match, and is instead studying Herbalism and attempting to ignore the pernicious awareness that a recent excursion to the Otherworld has possibly led her to being fae-touched. Desperate to help her beloved mentor, Jessa has to venture out of her comfort zone and and broach both Society and the Otherworld.
I cannot state how much I really loved this book! The descriptions are lush and evocative, with a heavy bent towards Jessa's affinity to plants. The settings are fully realized and I had no problems visualizing the places and characters. The characters are incredibly realistic, and for the most part, likeable. Everything about the mystery of the crimson tattoos and the resulting murders that Jessa investigates feels like it ought to be a film set that I've accidentally walked into. There is mystery aplenty, the barest whisper of romance, the tensions that come from a large extended family when one doesn't fit in, and a beautiful, gentle thread of strength as Jessa does her best to protect others.
I enjoyed the ending, which wrapped up the book nicely while leaving plenty of room for the second book in the series Ruins of Boon which comes out near my birthday in October of this year. Guess what got added to my wishlist! I do hope that if the author has the option to, that this book becomes an audiobook, as with the right narrator it would be an amazing treat to those of us who prefer that medium.
October 24, 2023
Jessa has always toed the line of what is proper in society. She hates participating at events and would rather tend to her plants and work on her herbalist book. Also, she is processing the realization that she is fae-touched which brings on added concerns of being discovered by The Vigil. When her friend Ibbie has been found having increased melancholy, she decides to visit the park that has been rumored to have a spectre roaming near its woods for a specific plant. Her aunt finds out that she went to the park and brought her sister’s with causing increased scrutiny of her behaviors and how she reflects on the family. After agreeing to be more active in society she goes to visit Ibbie and is told a horrible truth, she has been marked by the Crimson Tattoo Killer. Distraught at the news, she is at a crossroads of how to help her friend and hopefully lift the mark from her in time. But as she uncovers more information about this serial killer she comes closer to the Otherworld and the things that she fears may push her over the edge into madness.
This picks up shortly after the novella Whispers in the Waters and is easier to follow if you have read it but it isn’t necessary. There is lots of internal dialogue at the beginning that makes it a bit slow in spots but once the Otherworld starts to rear its head it definitely picks up. That being said, I can appreciate the author laying out all the pieces slowly and as they come together the pace picks up. You can feel the frustrations and struggles that Jessa goes through as she struggles against ‘what is appropriate for a lady’. Jade is my favorite book pet by far and I am hoping we get some more information on her in the next book. Several questions are answered in this book but just as many, if not more, take their place by time we get to the end. I am hoping for some satisfaction in the next book (which happens to come out tomorrow). Overall, this was a very satisfying read and I found a new series to keep up on.
This picks up shortly after the novella Whispers in the Waters and is easier to follow if you have read it but it isn’t necessary. There is lots of internal dialogue at the beginning that makes it a bit slow in spots but once the Otherworld starts to rear its head it definitely picks up. That being said, I can appreciate the author laying out all the pieces slowly and as they come together the pace picks up. You can feel the frustrations and struggles that Jessa goes through as she struggles against ‘what is appropriate for a lady’. Jade is my favorite book pet by far and I am hoping we get some more information on her in the next book. Several questions are answered in this book but just as many, if not more, take their place by time we get to the end. I am hoping for some satisfaction in the next book (which happens to come out tomorrow). Overall, this was a very satisfying read and I found a new series to keep up on.
February 13, 2023
A huge thank you goes to Book Sirens & Sarah Chislon for letting me review a copy of Tattoo of Crimson! This gaslamp fantasy is full of twists & turns, featuring powerful fae & an overzealous guardian cat. How could I pass that up?!
Hemmed in by social & familial expectations, Jessa is a young herbalist who is scared that she’s going mad. Haunted by ‘fae-touch’, Jessa spends all of her time searching for a cure to this affliction. But when her mentor’s marked with a crimson tattoo by a serial killer, Jessa will stop at nothing to find the culprit… Even if that means she needs to harness her growing fae abilities. Will Jessa be able to save the people she loves? Is there any such thing as a ‘good’ fae? And when all is said & done, can an untraceable killer actually be brought to justice?
I’m just putting it out there… I want more!! Sarah has written a truly magical gaslamp fantasy, & this story flows *so* well! With a rich background immersing the reader in something akin to the Victorian period, the setting completely enhances the mystery & intrigue within Tattoo of Crimson. But honestly, that’s just the first ingredient of this delicious, *sumptuous* tale about fighting for love & independence.
There are multiple characters within this fantasy whom I adore. I was aching for Jessa to find her independence, to throw off the constraints her family have put on her. And when she decides she’s the one who needs to stop a killer… There is no holding her back. Our young herbalist is a feisty force to be reckoned with, along with her faithful cat, Jade. Who doesn’t love a story like that?
Tattoo of Crimson by indie author Sarah Chislon is a glorious gaslamp fantasy, full of murder, fae & restrictive social conventions...
* You can read my full review on my blog via this link: https://www.immersedinbooks.com/tatto... *
Hemmed in by social & familial expectations, Jessa is a young herbalist who is scared that she’s going mad. Haunted by ‘fae-touch’, Jessa spends all of her time searching for a cure to this affliction. But when her mentor’s marked with a crimson tattoo by a serial killer, Jessa will stop at nothing to find the culprit… Even if that means she needs to harness her growing fae abilities. Will Jessa be able to save the people she loves? Is there any such thing as a ‘good’ fae? And when all is said & done, can an untraceable killer actually be brought to justice?
I’m just putting it out there… I want more!! Sarah has written a truly magical gaslamp fantasy, & this story flows *so* well! With a rich background immersing the reader in something akin to the Victorian period, the setting completely enhances the mystery & intrigue within Tattoo of Crimson. But honestly, that’s just the first ingredient of this delicious, *sumptuous* tale about fighting for love & independence.
There are multiple characters within this fantasy whom I adore. I was aching for Jessa to find her independence, to throw off the constraints her family have put on her. And when she decides she’s the one who needs to stop a killer… There is no holding her back. Our young herbalist is a feisty force to be reckoned with, along with her faithful cat, Jade. Who doesn’t love a story like that?
Tattoo of Crimson by indie author Sarah Chislon is a glorious gaslamp fantasy, full of murder, fae & restrictive social conventions...
* You can read my full review on my blog via this link: https://www.immersedinbooks.com/tatto... *
January 24, 2023
A beautifully written book! Sarah Chislon's Victorian-ish world-building was extraordinary detailed and imaginatively woven into a vivid, whimsical and fabulously descriptive narrative. Her characters come to life as the story progresses, each one so well-developed they subtly grow into people you care about. Jessa Caldwell is a strong female character who is trying, with the help of her cherished friend Ibbie, to navigate the world of men in her publishing endeavors and avoid the matrimony-seeking traditions her aunts insist upon forcing her to perform.
Tattoo of Crimson is a gaslamp murder mystery where the ladies are genteel and the gentlemen are (mostly) gallant. Jessa Caldwell is a gentleman's daughter and an unusually talented herbalist desperately trying to be taken seriously in a man's world. She wants her book on herbology to be published, but isn't able to find a publisher willing to take a chance on publishing her book under her female name. She's also hiding a dangerous secret that, if exposed, could cost her freedom and shame her family and friends. Jessa must use all of her intellect, academic knowledge and unique abilities to discover who the Crimson Tattoo Killer is among her acquaintances and stop the creature from killing again. I must confess, I was surprised at who the killer turned out to be, so kudos to author Sarah Chislon for weaving this murder-mystery so well!
Tattoo of Crimson is a brilliantly written book, full of imagination, beauty and wonders! I enjoyed reading it, I highly recommend it and I'm giving Tattoo of Crimson a 5 Star TBR Review.
Tattoo of Crimson is a gaslamp murder mystery where the ladies are genteel and the gentlemen are (mostly) gallant. Jessa Caldwell is a gentleman's daughter and an unusually talented herbalist desperately trying to be taken seriously in a man's world. She wants her book on herbology to be published, but isn't able to find a publisher willing to take a chance on publishing her book under her female name. She's also hiding a dangerous secret that, if exposed, could cost her freedom and shame her family and friends. Jessa must use all of her intellect, academic knowledge and unique abilities to discover who the Crimson Tattoo Killer is among her acquaintances and stop the creature from killing again. I must confess, I was surprised at who the killer turned out to be, so kudos to author Sarah Chislon for weaving this murder-mystery so well!
Tattoo of Crimson is a brilliantly written book, full of imagination, beauty and wonders! I enjoyed reading it, I highly recommend it and I'm giving Tattoo of Crimson a 5 Star TBR Review.
April 29, 2025
This has been on my tbr for years. The cover has always drawn me in, but the price of the kindle book always deterred me. 🤣 So I was ecstatic when I saw this was on hoopla. And now that I’ve read it, I wouldn’t have been angry if I spent $9.99 on the ebook.
The attention to detail and consistency in Tattoo of Crimson is insane. I felt like I stepped right into a regency time period. There were zero moments where I thought well that wording or action doesn’t fit the time period.
The plot! Had me on the edge of the my seat. The last third of the book flew by for me. I could not put it down. I could see some thinking the beginning felt slow, but I loved it. You get a good understanding of Jessa and her relationships, and family, and I loved the air of mystery around her and her sisters. The murder investigation was very well thought out, and at times had my heart beating a bit faster!
Jessa is a very likable main character. She’s sensible, and level headed, but doesn’t come across as one dimensional.
I am shipping Riven! I hope we get to see more of him in the next books!
I loved the overall air of mystery in Crimson of Tattoo. Why is the government hiding history that involved Otherworld? What secrets did Jessa’s mom keep? What is going on with Jessa’s sisters. Who really is Riven? Ahh, I am so excited to read the next in the series and get some answers.
10/10 recommend
Content: no swearing, no spice, some mild violence, the murder aspect is not overly descriptive so nothing felt too gory.
The attention to detail and consistency in Tattoo of Crimson is insane. I felt like I stepped right into a regency time period. There were zero moments where I thought well that wording or action doesn’t fit the time period.
The plot! Had me on the edge of the my seat. The last third of the book flew by for me. I could not put it down. I could see some thinking the beginning felt slow, but I loved it. You get a good understanding of Jessa and her relationships, and family, and I loved the air of mystery around her and her sisters. The murder investigation was very well thought out, and at times had my heart beating a bit faster!
Jessa is a very likable main character. She’s sensible, and level headed, but doesn’t come across as one dimensional.
I am shipping Riven! I hope we get to see more of him in the next books!
I loved the overall air of mystery in Crimson of Tattoo. Why is the government hiding history that involved Otherworld? What secrets did Jessa’s mom keep? What is going on with Jessa’s sisters. Who really is Riven? Ahh, I am so excited to read the next in the series and get some answers.
10/10 recommend
Content: no swearing, no spice, some mild violence, the murder aspect is not overly descriptive so nothing felt too gory.
October 12, 2024
THIS SERIES IS SO UNFAIRLY UNDERRATED IT MAKES ME SO SAD!
Sure, everyone read ACOTAR (and most liked it). But if you want something with more substance, more plot, more lore, then read this series!
Sarah Chilson’s unique and in-depth world building pulls you in and makes you feel like you’re a part of Jessa’s world. Rather than an outsider, you are brought into the story and only leave once the book ends. The plot is captivating, Jessa (the mc) is so relatable, and the side characters are all wonderfully written, so that they add to the story rather than being haphazardly thrown in just for fluff. If you’re into mystery, historical-era fiction, TALENTED WRITING, mysterious fae, magic AND an actually likeable female main character, then this book is for you! You’ll genuinely become attached to the characters, and if you’re not used to slightly more detailed writing, it’ll take a couple of chapters to get going but it’s so worth it. I’m so sick of seeing the same books getting attention here and on booktok and social media, because honestly, most of them suck. This one’s a treasure and it’s never talked about!
TLDR:
Relatable mc that ISN’T a copy of every other female mc to exist on booktok rn, historical gas-lamp fantasy, handsome fae, funny and well-written side characters, underrated, better than ACOTAR in my not so humble opinion, actual plot, you need to read it.
Sure, everyone read ACOTAR (and most liked it). But if you want something with more substance, more plot, more lore, then read this series!
Sarah Chilson’s unique and in-depth world building pulls you in and makes you feel like you’re a part of Jessa’s world. Rather than an outsider, you are brought into the story and only leave once the book ends. The plot is captivating, Jessa (the mc) is so relatable, and the side characters are all wonderfully written, so that they add to the story rather than being haphazardly thrown in just for fluff. If you’re into mystery, historical-era fiction, TALENTED WRITING, mysterious fae, magic AND an actually likeable female main character, then this book is for you! You’ll genuinely become attached to the characters, and if you’re not used to slightly more detailed writing, it’ll take a couple of chapters to get going but it’s so worth it. I’m so sick of seeing the same books getting attention here and on booktok and social media, because honestly, most of them suck. This one’s a treasure and it’s never talked about!
TLDR:
Relatable mc that ISN’T a copy of every other female mc to exist on booktok rn, historical gas-lamp fantasy, handsome fae, funny and well-written side characters, underrated, better than ACOTAR in my not so humble opinion, actual plot, you need to read it.
January 27, 2023
This is my first official foray into the genre of gaslamp fantasy, which I hadn’t even heard of until this particular novel. But I love the setting, the world, and the details of the quaint but supernatural Victorian life. High fantasy has always been one of my most beloved genres, and I like how this one weaves the history into it.
Jessa is my kind of woman. She is the sort who would thrive in the independent modern age. But sadly, she lives in a time and society that places lots of restrictions upon women and what is deemed acceptable for them. She still manages to navigate the world as herself, sacrificing only what she can. Even in the face of murder, threat, high fae, and storage, powerful houses. She investigates many mysteries at once as there is more than just a secret killer. It seems everyone around her has their secrets be they family or friends.
I enjoyed the story immensely. There are a lot of twists and turns, and man does nothing happen conveniently, which gives the mystery a complexity of plot flow that I love. It’s such a dense, well-woven world, too. The effortless, beautiful detail makes it easy to sink into the world in which Jessa lives uncomfortably with her Otherworld intruders. And the writing style is appropriate historically, so you can feel the time and era in the very tone. It’s these kinds of immersive reads that carry me into new worlds.
Jessa is my kind of woman. She is the sort who would thrive in the independent modern age. But sadly, she lives in a time and society that places lots of restrictions upon women and what is deemed acceptable for them. She still manages to navigate the world as herself, sacrificing only what she can. Even in the face of murder, threat, high fae, and storage, powerful houses. She investigates many mysteries at once as there is more than just a secret killer. It seems everyone around her has their secrets be they family or friends.
I enjoyed the story immensely. There are a lot of twists and turns, and man does nothing happen conveniently, which gives the mystery a complexity of plot flow that I love. It’s such a dense, well-woven world, too. The effortless, beautiful detail makes it easy to sink into the world in which Jessa lives uncomfortably with her Otherworld intruders. And the writing style is appropriate historically, so you can feel the time and era in the very tone. It’s these kinds of immersive reads that carry me into new worlds.
February 10, 2024
REVIEW:
My first ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ for 2024!
I absolutely loved falling deep into this fantasy and found I couldn't put it down as the mystery and adventure pulled me in.
The story had strong world building and great character development with a fantastic plot.
The few breadcrumbs of electricity between Jessa and Riven, and the journey around Jessa starting to find out more about her fae-touch have me already so excited for the next book!
SETTING: Dual worlds of mortals and fae intertwine, with the Otherworldly creatures branded malevolent and warded off with iron and alchemist protections.
The mortal world is set in the 19th century, where society had strict rules around decorum and women's rights were still largely stifled.
PLOT: Avons society is paralysed with fear as a serial killer taunts their victims, marking them with a crimson tattoo as a sign of their impending fate. But this killer appears no mere mortal, able to slip into the victim's home past the protection of the Magistry and the Vigil who guard against both human and Otherworldly threats.
When Jessa's friend is marked, she's compelled to investigate even if that means she must make a bargain with the fae.
But the more contact she has with Otherworldly beings, the more Jessa struggles to control the incessant call of the Otherworld as her fae-touch threatens to take over her mind.
My first ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ for 2024!
I absolutely loved falling deep into this fantasy and found I couldn't put it down as the mystery and adventure pulled me in.
The story had strong world building and great character development with a fantastic plot.
The few breadcrumbs of electricity between Jessa and Riven, and the journey around Jessa starting to find out more about her fae-touch have me already so excited for the next book!
SETTING: Dual worlds of mortals and fae intertwine, with the Otherworldly creatures branded malevolent and warded off with iron and alchemist protections.
The mortal world is set in the 19th century, where society had strict rules around decorum and women's rights were still largely stifled.
PLOT: Avons society is paralysed with fear as a serial killer taunts their victims, marking them with a crimson tattoo as a sign of their impending fate. But this killer appears no mere mortal, able to slip into the victim's home past the protection of the Magistry and the Vigil who guard against both human and Otherworldly threats.
When Jessa's friend is marked, she's compelled to investigate even if that means she must make a bargain with the fae.
But the more contact she has with Otherworldly beings, the more Jessa struggles to control the incessant call of the Otherworld as her fae-touch threatens to take over her mind.
January 16, 2023
Who protects us from the Vigil?
I’d describe this as dark & psychological cozy fantasy.
This series has strong female lead and we tend to forget against what women struggled back in the day. The world has a long way to go in equal respect for the fairer sex (yes, even the ‘civilized’ world). Works like this are good role models for our youths, both male and female, in showing that quiet strength within society’s framework can still yield the intended results (perhaps even better). Not everyone is a public crier; sometimes subtlety and subversion get the job done much more efficiently and quickly than by causing a fuss.
Fave quote:
‘Information is power. The power to betray, the power to act, the power to destroy. It should not be given freely.’
In our world of practically no privacy, this quote may seem really off. But it was spot on in context and is a gentle reminder (whether by intent or not) that TMI can be harmful. Some information is to be shared only in trust; trust is to be earned, not liberally thrown around.
The author delivered on this being a ‘mystery set in a world of manners and mythical monsters’.
Never fear, there will be more Otherworldly intrigues in ‘Ruins of Bone’ (expected in October 2023).
I’d describe this as dark & psychological cozy fantasy.
This series has strong female lead and we tend to forget against what women struggled back in the day. The world has a long way to go in equal respect for the fairer sex (yes, even the ‘civilized’ world). Works like this are good role models for our youths, both male and female, in showing that quiet strength within society’s framework can still yield the intended results (perhaps even better). Not everyone is a public crier; sometimes subtlety and subversion get the job done much more efficiently and quickly than by causing a fuss.
Fave quote:
‘Information is power. The power to betray, the power to act, the power to destroy. It should not be given freely.’
In our world of practically no privacy, this quote may seem really off. But it was spot on in context and is a gentle reminder (whether by intent or not) that TMI can be harmful. Some information is to be shared only in trust; trust is to be earned, not liberally thrown around.
The author delivered on this being a ‘mystery set in a world of manners and mythical monsters’.
Never fear, there will be more Otherworldly intrigues in ‘Ruins of Bone’ (expected in October 2023).
November 15, 2025
This book was just my cup of tea. I loved it. Tattoo of Crimson by Sarah Chislon is an intriguing, entertaining and adventurous gaslamp fantasy. The novel follows the story of young Jessa Caldwell as she navigates a world where a separation of the mortal world and the realm of menacing Fae exists in a tenuous, even precarious state. However, a serial killer, who marks their intended victims with a crimson tattoo before murdering them 10 days later, is stalking the citizens of the town of Avon. When her dearest friend is marked and murdered, Jessa is compelled to search for the killer herself when the mystical Magistry and Vigil prove ineffective. From there the tale of mystery unfolds at an enthralling pace. Learning about the Fae threat between calls and well-meaning aunts pushing suitors at Jessa, avoiding the censure of the Magistry and the killer, all while hiding a secret of her own, Tattoo of Crimson is a story that fans of Tilly Wallace's Manners and Monsters will definitely enjoy. Sarah Chislon has created a wonderful world of magic and mystery well-worth a reader's time. Highly recommend.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
March 1, 2025
I was extremely captivated by this unique novel. Set in England when ladies were expected to be demure and excited to be married is Jessa- a woman who quietly shuns the expectations of society but plays by the rules for her family. She tries her best to live as an independent woman. She's quick-minded, inquisitive, outspoken, and thoroughly intent on solving the mysterious murders in her town.
Her hidden affliction aids her in her quest, but does she dare test the limits of her powers?
The world-building is fantastical, as are the creatures she encounters. This is a slow-building story filled with twists and turns, suspense, family love, and respect. The who-done-it and what's going to happen next kept me turning the pages. The characters are varied in personalities, and each one brings a unique aspect to the storyline.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Her hidden affliction aids her in her quest, but does she dare test the limits of her powers?
The world-building is fantastical, as are the creatures she encounters. This is a slow-building story filled with twists and turns, suspense, family love, and respect. The who-done-it and what's going to happen next kept me turning the pages. The characters are varied in personalities, and each one brings a unique aspect to the storyline.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
January 4, 2023
Tattoo of Crimson is the perfect blend of murder mystery, high fae mythology, and gas lamp fantasy. Jessa Caldwell is an amazingly conscientious character trying her hardest to balance her own personal desires, her family's expectations, and trying to solve a series of murders. She falls into her sleuthing in a natural fashion, working within the limitations set on her by her station and society. Her responses to clues and developments are reasonable and there are no sudden jumps in logic. By the time the book ends we have the satisfaction of a thoroughly explored mystery, while not every question is answered.
Chislon creates a fantastic world with compelling characters, believable risks, and intriguing possibilities. Fans of Holly Black, Molly Harper, and Olivia Atwater will love this book.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Chislon creates a fantastic world with compelling characters, believable risks, and intriguing possibilities. Fans of Holly Black, Molly Harper, and Olivia Atwater will love this book.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
January 31, 2023
Gosh, I just love that beautiful cover! I’m not a big fan of the fae in novels but I couldn’t help myself with this one. The premise itself hints at more of a mystery in a fantasy world so I thought this could be something I’d like.
Jessa Caldwell is an easily likeable character though parts of her is a mystery and still a mystery at the end of the book – I’m keen to explore this in the next book in the series. The novel is more like a murder mystery in a fantasy world though similar enough world to ours but with magic and magical creatures. There were some rather dark scenes but overall, it was a fairly easy and engaging read. The only complaint I had was the lack of romance or maybe it was just sooo slow burning that I can barely feel it. Nevertheless, looking forward to book 2 to explore more of this world!
Jessa Caldwell is an easily likeable character though parts of her is a mystery and still a mystery at the end of the book – I’m keen to explore this in the next book in the series. The novel is more like a murder mystery in a fantasy world though similar enough world to ours but with magic and magical creatures. There were some rather dark scenes but overall, it was a fairly easy and engaging read. The only complaint I had was the lack of romance or maybe it was just sooo slow burning that I can barely feel it. Nevertheless, looking forward to book 2 to explore more of this world!
December 24, 2022
I had enjoyed the prequel book Whispers In The Waters a lot and was excited for the first chapter in this series. It was a great Gaslamp Fantasy that had unique monsters and a great heroine. I enjoyed the way this was written and was hooked from the mystery going on. Sarah Chislon has a great writing style and it felt like the same style from Whispers.
"Doubtless you wonder why I’ve left so much to you. If you’ve met Jasper, you can have little question why I chose to leave my personal estates elsewhere. Of course, I considered various institutes or even the Antiquary Society—but a group cannot care as an individual does."
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
"Doubtless you wonder why I’ve left so much to you. If you’ve met Jasper, you can have little question why I chose to leave my personal estates elsewhere. Of course, I considered various institutes or even the Antiquary Society—but a group cannot care as an individual does."
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
January 4, 2023
Tattoo of Crimson is Book 1 in the Blood of the Fae by Sarah Chislon. I thought this book was fantastic! It was a fantasy with characters who are Fae, a murder mystery and a thriller. Jessa is trying to find a killer who draws a red tattoo on a person who is dead a few days or week. I thought it was interesting that the victim never remembered how they got their tattoo. Jessa's friend, Ibbie, was murdered and she left some personal homes to her and this opens up more problems for Jessa. I found so many layers to this story. I thought the ending was great and Sarah Chislon perfectly ended this book while leaving it open to book 2. This is an exceptional book. I received an arc for free and am leaving my review voluntarily.
February 1, 2023
This book was my first foray into books of this genre. Its termed gaslamp fantasy which I must admit I had never heard of as a genre until this book but its appropriate as this book is a charming blend of fantasy, murder mystery and mythos. The Victorian setting is really well imagined and vividly described.
Jessa Caldwell is a very well rounded character and felt real. She tries to maintain a balance of societal expectations in this Victorian world while exploring the mysteries in this book. The ending while tidy does leave scope for the next novel in the series which is very exciting. Looking forward to it immensely!
Many thanks for allowing me a free ARC in return for my voluntary review.
Jessa Caldwell is a very well rounded character and felt real. She tries to maintain a balance of societal expectations in this Victorian world while exploring the mysteries in this book. The ending while tidy does leave scope for the next novel in the series which is very exciting. Looking forward to it immensely!
Many thanks for allowing me a free ARC in return for my voluntary review.
May 19, 2025
Wow!! So I have read a few Gaslamp fantasies but like I didn’t fancy any of them and was wondering if this was a genre not for me when I came across this book. I thought, just this one and I was absolutely hooked from the beginning!! I loved this book.
Jessa was actually a different in a good way MC and didn’t come across as this badass in a rude and disrespectful way like so many other in fantasy—even in regency eras, but was willing to do the right and brave thing. Jade was absolutely the best animal companion even if it was clear she was aware unlike mortal animals.
If you love Gaslamp and mystery murder fantasy with fae and supernaturals with only a hint like just a pinch of romance then this just the book for you!!
Jessa was actually a different in a good way MC and didn’t come across as this badass in a rude and disrespectful way like so many other in fantasy—even in regency eras, but was willing to do the right and brave thing. Jade was absolutely the best animal companion even if it was clear she was aware unlike mortal animals.
If you love Gaslamp and mystery murder fantasy with fae and supernaturals with only a hint like just a pinch of romance then this just the book for you!!
December 28, 2022
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I was very drawn to the cover of this book - I thought the design was eye-catching and pretty, and it looked and sounded like something that I might enjoy.
This was a very pleasant mix of historical fiction, fantasy and mystery. The protagonist was someone that I liked, and the setting and the story came to life for me while I was reading.
It was a slightly longer read than I anticipated, but I enjoyed it, and would probably be interested in reading some more books featuring the same character (s).
Thank you to Booksirens and the author for a free copy to review.
I was very drawn to the cover of this book - I thought the design was eye-catching and pretty, and it looked and sounded like something that I might enjoy.
This was a very pleasant mix of historical fiction, fantasy and mystery. The protagonist was someone that I liked, and the setting and the story came to life for me while I was reading.
It was a slightly longer read than I anticipated, but I enjoyed it, and would probably be interested in reading some more books featuring the same character (s).
Thank you to Booksirens and the author for a free copy to review.
October 23, 2023
When a mysterious tattoo is appearing on individuals in the town of Avon, and they end up dead days later, everyone is stunned. Jessa seeks the Magistry with information on the case, only to be turned away. With no one listening to her and a tattoo appearing on her mentor, Jessa takes it upon herself to find the killer and solve this mystery on her own.
I loved this story, it is a dark, and mysterious read with mythical creatures and fae. The characters are intriguing and headstrong, I like the logical thinking in these books. The story line flows together nicely with the story plot and worldbuilding.
I loved this story, it is a dark, and mysterious read with mythical creatures and fae. The characters are intriguing and headstrong, I like the logical thinking in these books. The story line flows together nicely with the story plot and worldbuilding.
December 31, 2022
I don’t even know where to start—such a good book! I couldn’t put it down! The plot was gripping, the mystery was intriguing, and I am left on the edge of my seat waiting for the next book in the series. Tattoo of Crimson struck a perfect balance of providing satisfactory answers to the mysteries within this book, while leaving you waiting for future books to get answers to larger, looming questions. The characters also fully endeared themselves to me, and I can’t wait to see their continued development! An absolute must-read!!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 44 reviews