What do you think?
Rate this book
The Last House in Lambton
Does it ever stop raining in Lambton?
Darcy and Bingley depart Netherfield Park, leaving Elizabeth Bennet acutely aware of the monotony of her life. Seeking a reprieve, she volunteers to serve as temporary companion to Mrs. Gardiner’s elderly aunt who lives in Lambton. Nothing turns out as Elizabeth expects, and she is forced to dig deep into her reserves of common sense, humor, and stubborn persistence to prove herself equal to the dreary circumstances.
Initially unaware that Pemberley is only five miles away, Elizabeth crosses paths with Darcy annoyingly often. When the gentleman rescues her from a shocking situation, Elizabeth faces some hard choices, at the same time struggling against the smoldering attraction that can neither be repressed nor fulfilled.
Mr. Darcy, meanwhile, in whose heart a fire has also been lit, is shocked by the lady’s stubborn refusal to accept his help. Alternating between alarm and begrudging admiration, he stands helplessly on the sidelines while she struggles to retain her independence. He, too, must make some hard choices in the end. Will he let her go?
332 pages, Kindle Edition
Published November 7, 2022
156 people are currently reading
234 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 180 reviews
May 18, 2023
I adored this book!
Written in the first person, it reads like a journal. On top of that - we 2 POVs! Both Elizabeth and then Darcy, alternating.
You would think that might make the story repetitive, but it does not. The author finds a way to keep the new POV, which is covering the same part of the story, fresh.
I love that this Elizabeth is a little vulnerable and at some point allows Darcy to see her vulnerability and what she deems, her failures.
Darcy isn't left wanting, as much as he tells himself he will forget Elizabeth, he just can't and finds himself doing anything he can for her.
That scene in the gallery - broke my heart! It isn't all tears though, there are several giggle out loud scenes (caught me off-guard on a public bus, nothing says loony more than a person giggling to themselves).
Not only is this a reread, it has been added to my paperback list to boot!
18.5.23 Went with the audiobook- instead of the paperback- (and aside from a couple of glitches I am sure will get fixed,) it is well narrated. Neil Mcfarlane was an inspired choice for this Darcy. His more restrained interpretation was the perfect foil for the highly spirited Katherine Anderson
Written in the first person, it reads like a journal. On top of that - we 2 POVs! Both Elizabeth and then Darcy, alternating.
You would think that might make the story repetitive, but it does not. The author finds a way to keep the new POV, which is covering the same part of the story, fresh.
I love that this Elizabeth is a little vulnerable and at some point allows Darcy to see her vulnerability and what she deems, her failures.
Darcy isn't left wanting, as much as he tells himself he will forget Elizabeth, he just can't and finds himself doing anything he can for her.
That scene in the gallery - broke my heart! It isn't all tears though, there are several giggle out loud scenes (caught me off-guard on a public bus, nothing says loony more than a person giggling to themselves).
Not only is this a reread, it has been added to my paperback list to boot!
18.5.23 Went with the audiobook- instead of the paperback- (and aside from a couple of glitches I am sure will get fixed,) it is well narrated. Neil Mcfarlane was an inspired choice for this Darcy. His more restrained interpretation was the perfect foil for the highly spirited Katherine Anderson
December 6, 2022
“Villages are the main pillars of the Country.” –Navin Polaki, My Poetry Speaks: When I’m Silent
>>Rating: mature: trigger warning for a near assault [unsuccessful]
>>Angst Level: up and down the scale, be prepared. Take Dramamine if you experience motion sickness.
>>Tissue Alert: Yeah, there were a few times I teared up. It was tempered with times of laughter.
>>Fan points: the thoughts and feelings of ODC were fierce and raw at times
>>Cover ART: fabulous and most excellent artwork.
>>Source: I received a promotional copy from Meryton Press with no expectations of a review. The views and opinions expressed are my own.
>>Timeline: If you’re familiar with JAFF, you know the timeline and recognize this as a window of time between major events in canon.
I somehow had a suspicion this story would be dark or brooding. The cover art best described the ambiance of the small market village of Lambton in winter. There was a tone about the story and when I started it, I had the strangest feeling of stepping into a revolving door only to discover it was going in the opposite direction. Yeah, it slapped me in the face big time. It grabbed me by the throat and ICNPID. When my eyes crossed at 2 a.m., I reluctantly went to bed and finished it the next day. Man!
On the one hand, Elizabeth felt a bit off. However, on the other hand, she was more. Does that make sense? I couldn’t quite put my finger on it. She was her stubborn self and walked into a situation that was more than she could handle. We have to remember that she was way too young to face the venture she had accepted or insisted upon. Mrs. Gardiner’s Aunt Jennings needed help and Mrs. Gardiner couldn’t be away from London [her husband and children] that long. Elizabeth was feeling that she didn’t want to be at Longbourn, and was restless in London, so she suggested that she go instead. Uncle Gardiner wasn’t sure he approved.
Elizabeth had always said she would take employment, if necessary when her father passed. The estate was entailed to their cousin and they would enter genteel poverty living on her mother’s income. This would be a good experience for her to see what that would be like. Well, let’s just say, things were NOT what she expected.
The housekeeper would be gone for several months and Elizabeth would be in charge. The housekeeper had kept vital information from Mrs. Jennings’ niece. She wrote the letters and managed what was said. Now that Elizabeth was there, she saw immediately that she would have her hands full. The staff was inadequate and either too old or too young for the job. The cook was surly and commanded her kitchen with one fist on her hip and a wooden spoon in the other. When her ire was up, it was reflected in what they would eat at their next meal. Mrs. Bennet had not allowed her daughters in the kitchen so Elizabeth had no idea about such matters. She would seek unlikely help from another housekeeper at a nearby estate.
“In small towns, people are always ready to share your troubles. If you don’t have any, they are happy to create you some.” –Marcel Jouhandeau
Elizabeth would have to walk wherever she needed to go as there was no transportation. It didn’t take long for even Elizabeth to weary of walking back and forth into Lambton. The difference was that she had to carry her purchases. That was vastly different from walking around the Longbourn estate with a book or a bundle of flowers in her hand. She also had to deal with the treatment of the locals. It wasn’t outright disrespect but Elizabeth was gently-born and no one would know that unless she stomped her foot like Lydia and announced that she was a gentlewoman. To them, she was no better than a servant and was treated accordingly. In Meryton, her family was given the first choice of products as the Longbourn estate was at the top of the social strata. Her purchases would then be delivered to the estate. In Lambton, she was cheated and given the dregs or castoffs and made to feel it. Her pride took quite a hit when she had to learn how to do chores, cook, help clean, and still care for Mrs. Jennings.
The story started with Elizabeth’s POV until about 31% when we then switched to Darcy’s POV. Oh-My-Goodness! I love this guy. Whew! I was impressed with the writing style of the dual perspectives as it flipped back and forth between ODC. Yes, we might cover the same scene or timeframe but their perspectives were so different that it was interesting to read. Many of us can quote the dialogue we all know and love. Gibson tweaked those scenes and handled information with a different approach. The same information was conveyed but from someone different. That was interesting.
Mrs. Jennings, Oh-My-Goodness. I have always loved older people. She was so sweet and such a character. She was the glue that held the story together. I realize the outcome might be considered unlikely; however, she was vital to the story. Dementia is a real problem for the elderly. Elizabeth was so gentle with her. Unless you have looked into the face of a loved one and wondered if they recognized you, you cannot understand this situation that Elizabeth faced. I have seen that look and the confusion that comes with it. What day is it? Is it morning or night? The gentle care given to this precious lady made me tear up. Elizabeth was so protective of her and worked so hard to maintain and protect her dignity.
No story is easy-peasy and it all hit the fan one frightful night. As scary as it was, Gibson tempered it with humor. The descriptions were amazing and Darcy was, once again, my hero. Man, that was so cool. His servant Sam is also my hero. I love that guy.
Villains: Can you tag an entire village as a villain? Perhaps not; however, in most JAFF stories, Lambton is presented as an extension of the Pemberley estate and they act accordingly in the presence of the Darcy family or someone they know. How would they act with strangers? How would they treat servants other than those from Pemberley or other high-status estates? Well, this story ripped the band-aid off with a flourish and we had first-hand evidence of that treatment. Mrs. Jennings’ house was at the end of the street. As Lambton grew, it went in the opposite direction. She was soon forgotten. Her very existence was managed and controlled by a tyrant of a housekeeper. Elizabeth quickly discovered that she could not change that in the short time she was there and quickly hit the wall of even her endurance.
I wonder how Lambton will feel and respond in the future when Elizabeth walks into the village with a very different last name. Yeah, that would be cool. I know, I’m being mean. She probably wouldn’t snub them, but I might. So, sue me.
>>Rating: mature: trigger warning for a near assault [unsuccessful]
>>Angst Level: up and down the scale, be prepared. Take Dramamine if you experience motion sickness.
>>Tissue Alert: Yeah, there were a few times I teared up. It was tempered with times of laughter.
>>Fan points: the thoughts and feelings of ODC were fierce and raw at times
>>Cover ART: fabulous and most excellent artwork.
>>Source: I received a promotional copy from Meryton Press with no expectations of a review. The views and opinions expressed are my own.
>>Timeline: If you’re familiar with JAFF, you know the timeline and recognize this as a window of time between major events in canon.
I somehow had a suspicion this story would be dark or brooding. The cover art best described the ambiance of the small market village of Lambton in winter. There was a tone about the story and when I started it, I had the strangest feeling of stepping into a revolving door only to discover it was going in the opposite direction. Yeah, it slapped me in the face big time. It grabbed me by the throat and ICNPID. When my eyes crossed at 2 a.m., I reluctantly went to bed and finished it the next day. Man!
On the one hand, Elizabeth felt a bit off. However, on the other hand, she was more. Does that make sense? I couldn’t quite put my finger on it. She was her stubborn self and walked into a situation that was more than she could handle. We have to remember that she was way too young to face the venture she had accepted or insisted upon. Mrs. Gardiner’s Aunt Jennings needed help and Mrs. Gardiner couldn’t be away from London [her husband and children] that long. Elizabeth was feeling that she didn’t want to be at Longbourn, and was restless in London, so she suggested that she go instead. Uncle Gardiner wasn’t sure he approved.
Elizabeth had always said she would take employment, if necessary when her father passed. The estate was entailed to their cousin and they would enter genteel poverty living on her mother’s income. This would be a good experience for her to see what that would be like. Well, let’s just say, things were NOT what she expected.
The housekeeper would be gone for several months and Elizabeth would be in charge. The housekeeper had kept vital information from Mrs. Jennings’ niece. She wrote the letters and managed what was said. Now that Elizabeth was there, she saw immediately that she would have her hands full. The staff was inadequate and either too old or too young for the job. The cook was surly and commanded her kitchen with one fist on her hip and a wooden spoon in the other. When her ire was up, it was reflected in what they would eat at their next meal. Mrs. Bennet had not allowed her daughters in the kitchen so Elizabeth had no idea about such matters. She would seek unlikely help from another housekeeper at a nearby estate.
“In small towns, people are always ready to share your troubles. If you don’t have any, they are happy to create you some.” –Marcel Jouhandeau
Elizabeth would have to walk wherever she needed to go as there was no transportation. It didn’t take long for even Elizabeth to weary of walking back and forth into Lambton. The difference was that she had to carry her purchases. That was vastly different from walking around the Longbourn estate with a book or a bundle of flowers in her hand. She also had to deal with the treatment of the locals. It wasn’t outright disrespect but Elizabeth was gently-born and no one would know that unless she stomped her foot like Lydia and announced that she was a gentlewoman. To them, she was no better than a servant and was treated accordingly. In Meryton, her family was given the first choice of products as the Longbourn estate was at the top of the social strata. Her purchases would then be delivered to the estate. In Lambton, she was cheated and given the dregs or castoffs and made to feel it. Her pride took quite a hit when she had to learn how to do chores, cook, help clean, and still care for Mrs. Jennings.
The story started with Elizabeth’s POV until about 31% when we then switched to Darcy’s POV. Oh-My-Goodness! I love this guy. Whew! I was impressed with the writing style of the dual perspectives as it flipped back and forth between ODC. Yes, we might cover the same scene or timeframe but their perspectives were so different that it was interesting to read. Many of us can quote the dialogue we all know and love. Gibson tweaked those scenes and handled information with a different approach. The same information was conveyed but from someone different. That was interesting.
Mrs. Jennings, Oh-My-Goodness. I have always loved older people. She was so sweet and such a character. She was the glue that held the story together. I realize the outcome might be considered unlikely; however, she was vital to the story. Dementia is a real problem for the elderly. Elizabeth was so gentle with her. Unless you have looked into the face of a loved one and wondered if they recognized you, you cannot understand this situation that Elizabeth faced. I have seen that look and the confusion that comes with it. What day is it? Is it morning or night? The gentle care given to this precious lady made me tear up. Elizabeth was so protective of her and worked so hard to maintain and protect her dignity.
No story is easy-peasy and it all hit the fan one frightful night. As scary as it was, Gibson tempered it with humor. The descriptions were amazing and Darcy was, once again, my hero. Man, that was so cool. His servant Sam is also my hero. I love that guy.
Villains: Can you tag an entire village as a villain? Perhaps not; however, in most JAFF stories, Lambton is presented as an extension of the Pemberley estate and they act accordingly in the presence of the Darcy family or someone they know. How would they act with strangers? How would they treat servants other than those from Pemberley or other high-status estates? Well, this story ripped the band-aid off with a flourish and we had first-hand evidence of that treatment. Mrs. Jennings’ house was at the end of the street. As Lambton grew, it went in the opposite direction. She was soon forgotten. Her very existence was managed and controlled by a tyrant of a housekeeper. Elizabeth quickly discovered that she could not change that in the short time she was there and quickly hit the wall of even her endurance.
I wonder how Lambton will feel and respond in the future when Elizabeth walks into the village with a very different last name. Yeah, that would be cool. I know, I’m being mean. She probably wouldn’t snub them, but I might. So, sue me.
November 10, 2022
Just soooo good!!
Granted an opportunity for some independence, Elizabeth embarks on a journey to Lambton to provide care and companionship to Mrs. Gardiner’s aging and widowed Aunt Jennings who lives at Frye house. Once there, and facing unexpected circumstances, she experiences a taste of what it would be like to live a domestic life below her station as a gentlewoman. Desperation will unwittingly place her once again in Mr. Darcy’s path.
Facing these everyday trials by herself, my eyes stung with tears in sympathy for Elizabeth’s lonely plight in having to deal with the slights endured by the merchants at Lambton, as well as the occurrences taking place at Frye house.
Told from the dual perspectives of both Elizabeth and Darcy, this heart-warming story exhibits Ms. Gibson’s expert skill in the art of conversation. She is a wordsmith extraordinaire whose brilliantly-written humorous turns of phrase tickle and delight, while other more serious, heart-rending situations and conversations grab your more tender emotions and may cause your eyes to sting with tears.
As an avid reader of this genre, I find myself completely fulfilled after reading this book. Excellence abounds all around with respect to plot, the development and depth of characters and, as always with Ms. Grace’s books, expressive and engaging dialogue. Prepare yourself for an undeniably entertaining and satisfying read. I am confident you will fall in love with Elizabeth and Darcy all over again.
Highly recommend.
Clean content.
I received an advance copy of this book from the author and am voluntarily providing a review. I also purchased the published Kindle version.
Granted an opportunity for some independence, Elizabeth embarks on a journey to Lambton to provide care and companionship to Mrs. Gardiner’s aging and widowed Aunt Jennings who lives at Frye house. Once there, and facing unexpected circumstances, she experiences a taste of what it would be like to live a domestic life below her station as a gentlewoman. Desperation will unwittingly place her once again in Mr. Darcy’s path.
Facing these everyday trials by herself, my eyes stung with tears in sympathy for Elizabeth’s lonely plight in having to deal with the slights endured by the merchants at Lambton, as well as the occurrences taking place at Frye house.
Told from the dual perspectives of both Elizabeth and Darcy, this heart-warming story exhibits Ms. Gibson’s expert skill in the art of conversation. She is a wordsmith extraordinaire whose brilliantly-written humorous turns of phrase tickle and delight, while other more serious, heart-rending situations and conversations grab your more tender emotions and may cause your eyes to sting with tears.
As an avid reader of this genre, I find myself completely fulfilled after reading this book. Excellence abounds all around with respect to plot, the development and depth of characters and, as always with Ms. Grace’s books, expressive and engaging dialogue. Prepare yourself for an undeniably entertaining and satisfying read. I am confident you will fall in love with Elizabeth and Darcy all over again.
Highly recommend.
Clean content.
I received an advance copy of this book from the author and am voluntarily providing a review. I also purchased the published Kindle version.
November 7, 2022
Lizzy and Darcy in Lambton
I must start and warn you, a spoiler is the soul of this review, so be warned.
It’s not much of a spoiler…Lizzy and Darcy are married toward the end of the book. What I would most like to share with everyone though is what makes this a 5 star rating story. The author has written the most perfect description of our dear couples perfect time together starting from Lizzy accepting Darcy’s proposal to the end of the wedding. There is no doubting the love they both have for each other by the way they are shown discussing how two people from two different spheres will have the perfect happily ever after we readers alway wish ODC could have. It was so romantic. Best I’ve read in years.
I must start and warn you, a spoiler is the soul of this review, so be warned.
It’s not much of a spoiler…Lizzy and Darcy are married toward the end of the book. What I would most like to share with everyone though is what makes this a 5 star rating story. The author has written the most perfect description of our dear couples perfect time together starting from Lizzy accepting Darcy’s proposal to the end of the wedding. There is no doubting the love they both have for each other by the way they are shown discussing how two people from two different spheres will have the perfect happily ever after we readers alway wish ODC could have. It was so romantic. Best I’ve read in years.
November 11, 2022
4.5 rounded up to 5 stars
As another review mentioned the story description sets this up for the readers very well.
Elizabeth is allowed to travel with Jane to London (Bingley and party having departed Netherfield.) to escape her mother's wrath after refusing Collins. While there her aunt receives a letter asking that she come to Lambton to take care of her elderly aunt while her housekeeper takes a leave. Elizabeth volunteers to go in her stead as her aunt cannot possibly leave her household and family for such.
Told alternatively from Elizabeth's and Darcy's POV, we read as Elizabeth faces an overwhelming situation. The servants at Mrs. Jennings house are not at all helpful When Elizabeth ruins the cook's favorite pot trying to make pork jelly she finds herself walking to nearby Pemberley to ask Mrs. Reynolds for the receipt for such. So she makes a connection with that household. A second visit to ask for help has Darcy coming upon her.
What follows are several times when Darcy interacts with Elizabeth: once in a dire emergency.
There are several new characters: including a noisy neighbor who was once a Madame. Mrs. Jennings is suffering from a loss of memory. Elizabeth is hard pressed to keep her contented, even holding her hand as she falls asleep. Elizabeth also finds herself being cheated by the Lambton vendors. However, when Uncle Gardiner is finally informed of the situation at Mrs. Jennings' he shows up and things change. Mrs. Jennings, who at this point is residing at Pemberley cannot be returned home. So plans are made to change all that.
Of course, during all this ODC falls in love. There are some thoughts about the differences in their situations and Elizabeth returns home to Longbourn before anything is settled. But we do have our HEA. My only complaint is that the story ended too abruptly for me. I wanted just a little bit more of this story.
As another review mentioned the story description sets this up for the readers very well.
Elizabeth is allowed to travel with Jane to London (Bingley and party having departed Netherfield.) to escape her mother's wrath after refusing Collins. While there her aunt receives a letter asking that she come to Lambton to take care of her elderly aunt while her housekeeper takes a leave. Elizabeth volunteers to go in her stead as her aunt cannot possibly leave her household and family for such.
Told alternatively from Elizabeth's and Darcy's POV, we read as Elizabeth faces an overwhelming situation. The servants at Mrs. Jennings house are not at all helpful When Elizabeth ruins the cook's favorite pot trying to make pork jelly she finds herself walking to nearby Pemberley to ask Mrs. Reynolds for the receipt for such. So she makes a connection with that household. A second visit to ask for help has Darcy coming upon her.
What follows are several times when Darcy interacts with Elizabeth: once in a dire emergency.
There are several new characters: including a noisy neighbor who was once a Madame. Mrs. Jennings is suffering from a loss of memory. Elizabeth is hard pressed to keep her contented, even holding her hand as she falls asleep. Elizabeth also finds herself being cheated by the Lambton vendors. However, when Uncle Gardiner is finally informed of the situation at Mrs. Jennings' he shows up and things change. Mrs. Jennings, who at this point is residing at Pemberley cannot be returned home. So plans are made to change all that.
Of course, during all this ODC falls in love. There are some thoughts about the differences in their situations and Elizabeth returns home to Longbourn before anything is settled. But we do have our HEA. My only complaint is that the story ended too abruptly for me. I wanted just a little bit more of this story.
June 10, 2023
The Sun does not forget a village just because it is small. ~ African proverb
The blurb accompanying this book does an excellent job of setting the scene.
Elizabeth Bennet has traveled alone to be a temporary companion to an older relation of her Aunt Gardiner. She immediately discovers that the situation is not as the Gardiners had believed. The servants are inadequate (to say the least) and Elizabeth’s place in the local society is well below her accustomed sphere.
On her own, Elizabeth must adapt and very quickly learn skills her Mother did not want the Bennet sisters to know.
While Elizabeth is living in the village of Lambton, she repeatedly encounters Mr. Darcy. The book has a lot of page time with Our Dear Couple, who both have a lot to learn.
I loved this story!
The village is a hive of glass where nothing unobserved can pass. ~ Charles Spurgeon
The blurb accompanying this book does an excellent job of setting the scene.
Elizabeth Bennet has traveled alone to be a temporary companion to an older relation of her Aunt Gardiner. She immediately discovers that the situation is not as the Gardiners had believed. The servants are inadequate (to say the least) and Elizabeth’s place in the local society is well below her accustomed sphere.
On her own, Elizabeth must adapt and very quickly learn skills her Mother did not want the Bennet sisters to know.
While Elizabeth is living in the village of Lambton, she repeatedly encounters Mr. Darcy. The book has a lot of page time with Our Dear Couple, who both have a lot to learn.
I loved this story!
The village is a hive of glass where nothing unobserved can pass. ~ Charles Spurgeon
March 4, 2023
How hard can it be? An infamous thought before a young woman discovers how naïve she is about the workings of a household, village life from the working class perspective, and most importantly, a gentleman she was early on eager to dismiss as cold and arrogant. Grace Gibson, an author I have enjoyed in the past, wrote this engaging and often entertaining Pride and Prejudice variation where a gentlewoman experiences many hard life lessons and grows as a result before getting her chance at happily ever after.
I do believe this is the first Austen variation or historical romance I’ve read where the heroine, who is a gentlewoman, must roll up her sleeves and work as a housekeeper with all the day to day dreariness so clearly portrayed. It served as a strong element in the heroine’s personal growth and development. Elizabeth Bennet made a snap decision when her Aunt Gardiner got the letter that her aunt needed temporary care while the housekeeper had to go away for a bit. Her mother was down on her for refusing to be engaged to her imbecile cousin even if he was the heir of her home estate and her sister was languishing because her love interest didn’t pursue a courtship. She just wanted to escape and bullied her aunt to letting her go in her place, untried and inexperienced.
This was a romance as Elizabeth slowly came to see the qualities in Darcy that weren’t obvious in previous encounters and learn that she got him completely wrong even as he fights his attraction because he clings to family duty and status at first. Then he sees her strengths when she is forced to struggle, toughen, and handle an overwhelming task. However it was more than a romance. It was the series of revelations she got about herself and life in general outside the protected walls of her father’s house while tending a small, impoverished old lady suffering from dementia, a scruffy group of servants unused to keeping a well-ordered house, and tackling household and marketing on her own with shopkeepers taking advantage until she learns better that showed this was as much a story of Elizabeth’s character growth as anything else.
She makes a ton of mistakes and is dreary while stuck in that little house and village, but there are amusing moments too with her kitchen disasters, nosy neighbor, and getting caught not looking her best when visitors come. There is balance in the emotions of the story even as the gentle pace drives toward a rewarding conclusion. I loved that members of the serving class played big roles in the story as well as the familiar upper class characters.
All in all, it was something different in a Pride and Prejudice variation that not just Austen lovers will appreciate, but also historical romance fans who like a sweet, character-driven piece.
I rec’d an eARC through Meryton Press to read in exchange for an honest review.
My full review will post at Books of My Heart on Feb 15th.
I do believe this is the first Austen variation or historical romance I’ve read where the heroine, who is a gentlewoman, must roll up her sleeves and work as a housekeeper with all the day to day dreariness so clearly portrayed. It served as a strong element in the heroine’s personal growth and development. Elizabeth Bennet made a snap decision when her Aunt Gardiner got the letter that her aunt needed temporary care while the housekeeper had to go away for a bit. Her mother was down on her for refusing to be engaged to her imbecile cousin even if he was the heir of her home estate and her sister was languishing because her love interest didn’t pursue a courtship. She just wanted to escape and bullied her aunt to letting her go in her place, untried and inexperienced.
This was a romance as Elizabeth slowly came to see the qualities in Darcy that weren’t obvious in previous encounters and learn that she got him completely wrong even as he fights his attraction because he clings to family duty and status at first. Then he sees her strengths when she is forced to struggle, toughen, and handle an overwhelming task. However it was more than a romance. It was the series of revelations she got about herself and life in general outside the protected walls of her father’s house while tending a small, impoverished old lady suffering from dementia, a scruffy group of servants unused to keeping a well-ordered house, and tackling household and marketing on her own with shopkeepers taking advantage until she learns better that showed this was as much a story of Elizabeth’s character growth as anything else.
She makes a ton of mistakes and is dreary while stuck in that little house and village, but there are amusing moments too with her kitchen disasters, nosy neighbor, and getting caught not looking her best when visitors come. There is balance in the emotions of the story even as the gentle pace drives toward a rewarding conclusion. I loved that members of the serving class played big roles in the story as well as the familiar upper class characters.
All in all, it was something different in a Pride and Prejudice variation that not just Austen lovers will appreciate, but also historical romance fans who like a sweet, character-driven piece.
I rec’d an eARC through Meryton Press to read in exchange for an honest review.
My full review will post at Books of My Heart on Feb 15th.
August 16, 2025
5+ stars!
May 1, 2023
“What prospect did any of us truly have?” (quote from the book)
Any book by Grace Gibson is a marvel of beautiful prose with imaginative flair. In this distinctive novel, Elizabeth Bennet’s eyes are truly opened to the realities and vicissitudes of life when she volunteers to go to Lambton to help her Aunt Gardiner’s elderly aunt, Mrs. Jennings. Besides, her Aunt Gardiner said she would be more a companion with some light duties to perform for her. How wrong they all were…
“This life, the one in which I had been unceremoniously dunked, was but a foretaste of the spinsterhood my mother so dreaded for us.” (quote from the book)
This story slowly unfurled and built to an incredible crescendo! Two points of view (Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy) are seamlessly woven together giving us a unique perspective of the same events. Their interactions together were everything I have come to love from Ms. Gibson’s imagination. I adored Mr. Darcy! Elizabeth had some rude awakenings and my heart felt for her. She refused to give up until…'Beware the Ides of March’ (Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar).
“No, I would prove to myself that I indeed was…made of sterner stuff.” (quote from the book)
This variation certainly conveyed a large dose of reality not only to Elizabeth but to the reader. As I read it over two days, I would go to bed thinking how difficult life was for the domestic staff as well as those who have fallen into genteel poverty. And I will continue to think about it for some time to come.
I highly recommend this latest offering from Ms. Gibson and look forward to her next one!
November 26, 2022
Very enjoyable once I got past the description of a 65 year old woman as “in her dotage”. Hey now, as a woman in her early 60s I was offended. I’m glad I kept reading.
I enjoyed seeing both Elizabeth and Darcy’s reactions to the events. I think this will make a great audio book and I will be looking for it.
I’ve read this author before and she keeps getting better.
I enjoyed seeing both Elizabeth and Darcy’s reactions to the events. I think this will make a great audio book and I will be looking for it.
I’ve read this author before and she keeps getting better.
May 22, 2023
Such a great book!
November 22, 2022
Never hesitate…
… to read anything by Grace Gibson. She manages romance without saccharine and angst and uncertainty without overwhelming the reader.
I would joyfully consume any book by her numerous times. Audiobook, please. I have already listened to the rest of Gibson’s audiobooks until I can recite the dialogue! I love listening as I sew and I had to stop sewing when I saw there was a new Gibson book.
Such a joy to read a well-crafted book.
Things I appreciate about the author:
1. Vocabulary and grammar. Wonderful words of the period, used correctly but not repetitively. Words are not misspelled.
2. Characters have new and interesting experiences but are true to Austen.
3. Shifts in POV - we don’t get only E or D’s perspective, but both.
4. Witty banter and comic relief.
5. Pacing is reliably excellent - the books never seem to drag on and on, keeping me engaged and entertained.
Gibson’s books are gems of the first water!!
… to read anything by Grace Gibson. She manages romance without saccharine and angst and uncertainty without overwhelming the reader.
I would joyfully consume any book by her numerous times. Audiobook, please. I have already listened to the rest of Gibson’s audiobooks until I can recite the dialogue! I love listening as I sew and I had to stop sewing when I saw there was a new Gibson book.
Such a joy to read a well-crafted book.
Things I appreciate about the author:
1. Vocabulary and grammar. Wonderful words of the period, used correctly but not repetitively. Words are not misspelled.
2. Characters have new and interesting experiences but are true to Austen.
3. Shifts in POV - we don’t get only E or D’s perspective, but both.
4. Witty banter and comic relief.
5. Pacing is reliably excellent - the books never seem to drag on and on, keeping me engaged and entertained.
Gibson’s books are gems of the first water!!
December 18, 2022
5+++*****
Not much got done around here the last two days while I picked this up every chance I got to read.
This is Grace Gibson at her most unique and excellent best yet. And I shouldn’t have to say more but not all of you have discovered her yet so I must elaborate a little. We have been in the habit of thinking of Grace as a writer of highly intelligent and exceptionally humorous stories, but this one has some quite serious themes.
Our dear girl needs a reprieve from Longbourn after Collins marries Charlotte Lucas taking away the Bennet’s security once their father dies. Mrs. B. Is her best worst haranguing self here at Lizzy. So Lizzy accompanies Jane when she goes to London to stay with the Gardiners. She then volunteers her services to the Gardiners by way of going to stay with Mrs. Gardiner’s aunt who needs a companion while her current housekeeper-companion visits her daughter for the birth of her grandchild. Everyone assumes everything will be easy peasey having little to do except entertain the Aunt. Those assumptions were never so very wrong. When an exhausted Elizabeth arrives at the Aunt’s house the housekeeper throws an enormous list of duties, demands, and rules she must follow without so much as time to write everything down before being shuttled off to bed with more instructions to follow the next morning. And that happens right after meeting the Aunt and before the housekeeper leaves. Oh my gosh, never have the words ‘bitten off more than one could chew’ be true in the circumstances Lizzy has landed in.
Of course our dear girl puts a brace face on the situation but these circumstances have been severely misrepresented to the Gardiners. A hostile cook. An utterly inept man of all work, and two untrained neglected, and poor young girl servants. And not the least an elderly woman who doesn’t know Lizzy from one day to the next, who is sweet but who gets quite unsettled at times every day. But wait. There’s more.
Elizabeth’s courage is amazing to watch, but everything that falls under her responsibilities cannot help but overwhelm her and wear her down. I’ve seldom read such a fine account of our dear girl’s bravery (we have some wonderful works in the JAFF oeuvre to list with that in mind.) She's not going to give up. Lizzy had talked her aunt and uncle into letting her do this and they reluctantly gave in. Somehow Lizzy doesn't realize Lambton is so close to Pemberley. Being told Darcy was not at home she walks to Pemberley after overhearing Mrs. Reynolds make an authoritative series of purchases at the local store and gets every respectful courtesy...the store that continues to sell Lizzy the dregs of goods she shops for. She requests a recipe from Mrs. Reynolds for Mrs. Jennings, and Mrs. Reynolds lends her a cookbook. Darcy sees her in his own home the second time she visits for advice, much to Lizzy's horror and humiliation. I'm stopping here regarding the story itself except to say this Mr. Darcy is about as swoon worthy as ever!
I highly recommend this, and if you haven’t read Grace Gibson’s books yet, do yourself a huge favor and treat yourself very soon. The depth of her excellent writing is the difference between leaving you curious (as I hope my review will do) and leaving you with the feeling of wanting to wrap yourself up around the book (or e-reader) after finishing and sighing for more. Definitely on the reread shelf.
Not much got done around here the last two days while I picked this up every chance I got to read.
This is Grace Gibson at her most unique and excellent best yet. And I shouldn’t have to say more but not all of you have discovered her yet so I must elaborate a little. We have been in the habit of thinking of Grace as a writer of highly intelligent and exceptionally humorous stories, but this one has some quite serious themes.
Our dear girl needs a reprieve from Longbourn after Collins marries Charlotte Lucas taking away the Bennet’s security once their father dies. Mrs. B. Is her best worst haranguing self here at Lizzy. So Lizzy accompanies Jane when she goes to London to stay with the Gardiners. She then volunteers her services to the Gardiners by way of going to stay with Mrs. Gardiner’s aunt who needs a companion while her current housekeeper-companion visits her daughter for the birth of her grandchild. Everyone assumes everything will be easy peasey having little to do except entertain the Aunt. Those assumptions were never so very wrong. When an exhausted Elizabeth arrives at the Aunt’s house the housekeeper throws an enormous list of duties, demands, and rules she must follow without so much as time to write everything down before being shuttled off to bed with more instructions to follow the next morning. And that happens right after meeting the Aunt and before the housekeeper leaves. Oh my gosh, never have the words ‘bitten off more than one could chew’ be true in the circumstances Lizzy has landed in.
Of course our dear girl puts a brace face on the situation but these circumstances have been severely misrepresented to the Gardiners. A hostile cook. An utterly inept man of all work, and two untrained neglected, and poor young girl servants. And not the least an elderly woman who doesn’t know Lizzy from one day to the next, who is sweet but who gets quite unsettled at times every day. But wait. There’s more.
Elizabeth’s courage is amazing to watch, but everything that falls under her responsibilities cannot help but overwhelm her and wear her down. I’ve seldom read such a fine account of our dear girl’s bravery (we have some wonderful works in the JAFF oeuvre to list with that in mind.) She's not going to give up. Lizzy had talked her aunt and uncle into letting her do this and they reluctantly gave in. Somehow Lizzy doesn't realize Lambton is so close to Pemberley. Being told Darcy was not at home she walks to Pemberley after overhearing Mrs. Reynolds make an authoritative series of purchases at the local store and gets every respectful courtesy...the store that continues to sell Lizzy the dregs of goods she shops for. She requests a recipe from Mrs. Reynolds for Mrs. Jennings, and Mrs. Reynolds lends her a cookbook. Darcy sees her in his own home the second time she visits for advice, much to Lizzy's horror and humiliation. I'm stopping here regarding the story itself except to say this Mr. Darcy is about as swoon worthy as ever!
I highly recommend this, and if you haven’t read Grace Gibson’s books yet, do yourself a huge favor and treat yourself very soon. The depth of her excellent writing is the difference between leaving you curious (as I hope my review will do) and leaving you with the feeling of wanting to wrap yourself up around the book (or e-reader) after finishing and sighing for more. Definitely on the reread shelf.
May 1, 2023
5*+++
March 19, 2024
What If Elizabeth Became a Temporary Companion/Housekeeper?
Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Source: Gift from Publisher
TYPE OF NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation
THE PREMISE:
Elizabeth needs to escape her mother’s irate displeasure at Longbourn and Aunt Gardiner’s elderly aunt needs a companion/housekeeper to stay with her for three months. It is the perfect solution! At least it was before Elizabeth discovered the type of work she was expected to do, the harshness of winters in Derbyshire, the loneliness and challenges she would face, and the proximity of Lambton to one Mr. Darcy of Pemberley…
WHAT I LOVED:
- An Adventurous and Humbling “Tramp”: I so admire Elizabeth’s tenacity and fortitude. I love how she is so willing to go into an unknown situation, meet new people, and do something she has never done before. She is a marvel. And the “tramp” Elizabeth experiences in this tale is a magnificent one. It is wonderfully unique – exploring genteel poverty, the art of housekeeping, and caring for someone with memory loss in the Regency Era.
- Elizabeth is Challenged: Elizabeth prides herself in her quick wit, understanding, and capable nature. Which are all very much put to the test when she tries to run a household with an excessive amount of limitations and obstacles. I greatly appreciated seeing our dear Lizzy face such challenges and all the lessons she learned. She quickly discovers that she needs more than confidence and determination to see herself through these challenges. Elizabeth’s growth, evolution, and overall journey through these trials felt authentic and natural.
- Mr. Darcy is Schooled: Mr. Darcy is observant. He watches Elizabeth closely through her bewildering circumstances, and his eyes are opened. He sees her true opinion of him, he detects her suspicions and reproofs without her saying them, he witnesses her talent for giving pleasure and kindness to every person she meets. And he pays heed. I absolutely adored all of Mr. Darcy’s actions in this novel. He is so gentle with his concern, so thoughtful with his support, so understanding of Elizabeth’s feelings. I greatly appreciated how he grappled with his feelings of love and his parents’ expectations, with commanding authority and his need to give Elizabeth whatever she desires. Such a swoony dreamboat!
- It’s Two Sided: It felt like a bonus layer each time the point-of-view switched to Mr. Darcy’s perspective and large parts of the story were recounted from his POV. It was absolutely enough to see all these events and feel all these emotions from Elizabeth’s perspective. The story had enough details and depth with just this alone, but I’m so happy readers were able to witness it all from Mr. Darcy’s perspective too. I appreciated the timing and frequencies of these switches and how Ms. Gibson intentionally kept Mr. Darcy’s recounting succinct and often added new scenes of dialogue and developments to prevent it from feeling redundant in any way.
- It’s a Fairytale: At times this felt like an enchanting fairytale. Almost like Cinderella – Elizabeth is working as a drudge, is wickedly mistreated, and ends up being saved by a prince. The harsh realities and tribulations Elizabeth faces are beautifully balanced by the happy scenes of harmony, peace, and genuine friendship at Pemberley. I loved all the blissful and warm scenes that take place there. With Mrs. Jennings, Georgiana, and the household staff – it was all so idyllic, almost like in Beauty and the Beast before Belle was called away. I felt my heart break along with everyone else’s when their happiness was uprooted.
- The Exquisite Prose: Grace Gibson is an incredible wordsmith. Her previous novels display her sharp and clever talents with deliciously smart repartee, but in this novel she demonstrates even more talent for expressive and lyrical prose. Case in point: “I felt as though he had taken a match to my heretofore unlit heart. It poured out such a breathtaking light that I wished for nothing save the privacy and quietude to dissolve into it.”
WHAT I WASN’T FOND OF:
Nothing! How I wish I could stay at this Pemberley forever!
CONCLUSION:
With 1500+ ratings on Amazon and 75% of them being 5 stars, any praise I could give at this point is superfluous. But I shall give it anyway – this Pride and Prejudice variation is a remarkably moving tale about persevering courage and loving with understanding. Full of thoughtful creativity, rich character development, and powerful and palpable emotions – this exceptional journey with Darcy and Elizabeth is not one to be missed!
Austenesque. Reviews
Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Source: Gift from Publisher
TYPE OF NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation
THE PREMISE:
Elizabeth needs to escape her mother’s irate displeasure at Longbourn and Aunt Gardiner’s elderly aunt needs a companion/housekeeper to stay with her for three months. It is the perfect solution! At least it was before Elizabeth discovered the type of work she was expected to do, the harshness of winters in Derbyshire, the loneliness and challenges she would face, and the proximity of Lambton to one Mr. Darcy of Pemberley…
WHAT I LOVED:
- An Adventurous and Humbling “Tramp”: I so admire Elizabeth’s tenacity and fortitude. I love how she is so willing to go into an unknown situation, meet new people, and do something she has never done before. She is a marvel. And the “tramp” Elizabeth experiences in this tale is a magnificent one. It is wonderfully unique – exploring genteel poverty, the art of housekeeping, and caring for someone with memory loss in the Regency Era.
- Elizabeth is Challenged: Elizabeth prides herself in her quick wit, understanding, and capable nature. Which are all very much put to the test when she tries to run a household with an excessive amount of limitations and obstacles. I greatly appreciated seeing our dear Lizzy face such challenges and all the lessons she learned. She quickly discovers that she needs more than confidence and determination to see herself through these challenges. Elizabeth’s growth, evolution, and overall journey through these trials felt authentic and natural.
- Mr. Darcy is Schooled: Mr. Darcy is observant. He watches Elizabeth closely through her bewildering circumstances, and his eyes are opened. He sees her true opinion of him, he detects her suspicions and reproofs without her saying them, he witnesses her talent for giving pleasure and kindness to every person she meets. And he pays heed. I absolutely adored all of Mr. Darcy’s actions in this novel. He is so gentle with his concern, so thoughtful with his support, so understanding of Elizabeth’s feelings. I greatly appreciated how he grappled with his feelings of love and his parents’ expectations, with commanding authority and his need to give Elizabeth whatever she desires. Such a swoony dreamboat!
- It’s Two Sided: It felt like a bonus layer each time the point-of-view switched to Mr. Darcy’s perspective and large parts of the story were recounted from his POV. It was absolutely enough to see all these events and feel all these emotions from Elizabeth’s perspective. The story had enough details and depth with just this alone, but I’m so happy readers were able to witness it all from Mr. Darcy’s perspective too. I appreciated the timing and frequencies of these switches and how Ms. Gibson intentionally kept Mr. Darcy’s recounting succinct and often added new scenes of dialogue and developments to prevent it from feeling redundant in any way.
- It’s a Fairytale: At times this felt like an enchanting fairytale. Almost like Cinderella – Elizabeth is working as a drudge, is wickedly mistreated, and ends up being saved by a prince. The harsh realities and tribulations Elizabeth faces are beautifully balanced by the happy scenes of harmony, peace, and genuine friendship at Pemberley. I loved all the blissful and warm scenes that take place there. With Mrs. Jennings, Georgiana, and the household staff – it was all so idyllic, almost like in Beauty and the Beast before Belle was called away. I felt my heart break along with everyone else’s when their happiness was uprooted.
- The Exquisite Prose: Grace Gibson is an incredible wordsmith. Her previous novels display her sharp and clever talents with deliciously smart repartee, but in this novel she demonstrates even more talent for expressive and lyrical prose. Case in point: “I felt as though he had taken a match to my heretofore unlit heart. It poured out such a breathtaking light that I wished for nothing save the privacy and quietude to dissolve into it.”
WHAT I WASN’T FOND OF:
Nothing! How I wish I could stay at this Pemberley forever!
CONCLUSION:
With 1500+ ratings on Amazon and 75% of them being 5 stars, any praise I could give at this point is superfluous. But I shall give it anyway – this Pride and Prejudice variation is a remarkably moving tale about persevering courage and loving with understanding. Full of thoughtful creativity, rich character development, and powerful and palpable emotions – this exceptional journey with Darcy and Elizabeth is not one to be missed!
Austenesque. Reviews
November 12, 2022
Pure delight!
I love this author for her exceedingly enjoyable stories! I hope there will be many more.
Following Elizabeth's refusal of Mr. Collins's hand, Mrs. Bennet has long-term plans for Elizabeth's punishment. When Lizzy can bear no more, she and Jane travel to London to visit the Gardiners. Mrs. Gardiner receives an urgent plea for her to come to Lambton to take care of her aunt so her caretaker can take a leave.
Mrs. Gardiner cannot possibly comply, so Elizabeth agrees to go. When she arrives, she finds Mrs. Jennings is suffering from dementia and needs constant care. She has no one to help her and the servants treat her with disrespect and consider her beneath them. And then there's that rude, nosy woman next door.
26
I love this author for her exceedingly enjoyable stories! I hope there will be many more.
Following Elizabeth's refusal of Mr. Collins's hand, Mrs. Bennet has long-term plans for Elizabeth's punishment. When Lizzy can bear no more, she and Jane travel to London to visit the Gardiners. Mrs. Gardiner receives an urgent plea for her to come to Lambton to take care of her aunt so her caretaker can take a leave.
Mrs. Gardiner cannot possibly comply, so Elizabeth agrees to go. When she arrives, she finds Mrs. Jennings is suffering from dementia and needs constant care. She has no one to help her and the servants treat her with disrespect and consider her beneath them. And then there's that rude, nosy woman next door.
26
November 27, 2022
I loved the story and the writing. This author does a wonderful job of building characters with personalities, that evoke empathy and emotions. There is a moment when Elizabeth is overwhelmed by her sadness and that scene was just beautiful. There is a lovely HEA and just enough angst to make the HEA really satisfying.
December 8, 2022
This book. This author. These characters.
February 23, 2023
Set after the Netherfield Ball, Elizabeth Bennet agrees to travel to Lambton to help an extended relative of her Aunt Gardiner. She learns some real life lessons while seeing the real Fitzwilliam Darcy.
The author varies the point of view by section so you read most of the timeline 2x, each from a Elizabeth and Darcy’s perspective. She also created wonderful relationships between the characters.
The author varies the point of view by section so you read most of the timeline 2x, each from a Elizabeth and Darcy’s perspective. She also created wonderful relationships between the characters.
January 12, 2023
An interesting concept for the plot and some re-readable prose make this a better than average book, though not quite what the hype made it out to be. Overall technical lapses result in loss of a full star. Conflict of interest prevents a full review.
November 29, 2022
Now in my top five.
Having read hundreds of these variations I will place this one with the very best It is insanely well written and even overcame my aversion to stories that are done in the first person. This is one I will read again.
With a background in history I found the historical accuracy welcomed. I do not like to nitpick but in the recency era they would not of spoke of raising a steel works. Steel was a rare metal difficult to make in any quantity until Bessemer's process in the 1850s. They would have raised an iron works or a forge to make cast iron.
The dialog was excellent and the characters thoughts and reflections well written. For a change Georgiana Darcy changed and developed as the story progressed. This is a worthwhile read.
Having read hundreds of these variations I will place this one with the very best It is insanely well written and even overcame my aversion to stories that are done in the first person. This is one I will read again.
With a background in history I found the historical accuracy welcomed. I do not like to nitpick but in the recency era they would not of spoke of raising a steel works. Steel was a rare metal difficult to make in any quantity until Bessemer's process in the 1850s. They would have raised an iron works or a forge to make cast iron.
The dialog was excellent and the characters thoughts and reflections well written. For a change Georgiana Darcy changed and developed as the story progressed. This is a worthwhile read.
November 7, 2022
I found the attempt at dual perspectives rather jarring and tedious - you’d read the story up to a point and then it would reverse itself back to the beginning but from the other person’s perspective - not a natural integration of dual POV in my view. The story itself was fine, but I didn’t feel it was as romantic as it was trying to be - there was really quite limited conversation between ODC prior to their engagement. The plot itself of course pushes the limits of suspension of belief, and while I don’t personally mind that, anyone concerned with accuracy of propriety and class distinctions in the regency period will likely wish to avoid this.
November 26, 2022
5 Stars PLUS!
March 7, 2025
Pride and Prejudice revision.
Reread March 5, 2025. I wish I could give this 10 stars. Usually, when I reread a book, it's a matter of remembering what I liked about it on the first read, and if I read a bit slower than the first time, sometimes I see flaws I didn't notice the first time. But this is such a thoughtfully written book that rereading only served to improve my opinion of it. I especially like the inclusion of some quotes from Stoics.
Review December 4, 2022
In this variation on Pride and Prejudice, after the Netherfield party leaves for London, Mrs. Bennet is still miffed with Elizabeth over refusing Mr. Collins. Elizabeth sees her near future home life looking unpleasant, so she asks her father to let her accompany Jane to London to stay with their aunt and uncle Gardiner.
While they're visiting, Mrs. Gardiner receives a letter from her elderly aunt in Lambton, and becomes concerned for her. The older woman's housekeeper is to be away for weeks, and she's not sure she can get on without her. Mrs. Gardiner doesn't want to leave her children for such a length of time. So Elizabeth volunteers to go help out. At first her uncle objects, but he finally gives in, and Elizabeth plans to set off to Derbyshire. When she inquires of her aunt what her duties are likely to be, she's told she shouldn't likely have much more to do than pay out wages, decide what will be served for dinner, and support Mrs. Jennings as a companion.
At this point, in this variation, Lizzy has no idea that Pemberley is only five miles from Lambton. In fact she has no desire or expectation to ever see Mr. Darcy again.
But she soon learns that she will have to be much more than a companion for a lonely old lady. Mrs. Jennings, her great-aunt by marriage, is terribly disabled by memory loss. She can't recall who someone is without constant reminders, and she's quite feeble. She's become so dependent on the housekeeper, Mrs. Burke, that Lizzy wonders if the housekeeper has been writing her letters for her. There is marketing and some cooking that Elizabeth is expected to do, in spite of a surly full-time cook on the premises. She has never had to do either task in her life, but she assures Mrs. Burke she will manage.
The shopkeepers in town see her inexperience at once and take mean advantage of it, and she's soon burdened with more stinking tallow candles than she can use, a burnt pot she attempted to use to make pork jelly and ruined, and a nosy neighbor woman whom she has yet to learn used to run a brothel. The cook seems always on the verge of quitting her job. The two house maids have more work than they can manage, so Elizabeth has to pitch in with their work as well, if she wants the house truly clean, and her elderly aunt requires a lot of care.
Lizzy is soon exhausted and unable to cope with her situation. One day, in a shop, she spies a capable-looking woman wearing a coat of quality, talking to the shopkeeper in an authoritative manner. She's so impressed with her that after the woman leaves, Lizzy asks who that was.
'"Mrs. Reynolds. She is housekeeper at the great house."
'"The squire's housekeeper?"
'"No, miss. She keeps Pemberley."'
Shocked, Elizabeth inquires as to Pemberley's location. A day later she decides to beg some advice from Mrs. Reynolds, certain that she will not encounter any of the family if she's just there to see the housekeeper.
This is one of those stories that had me so anxious to know what would happen next that I sped through it. It's written from two different first-person points of view, alternating between Elizabeth Bennet and Fitzwilliam Darcy. The times of their sections of the story sometimes overlap, so sometimes we read the same scene, first from one's point of view and then from the other's, and I found that interesting because their perceptions were different. But it's not presented in a way that seems at all repetitive, and only a few scenes are repeated that way. This is one of the best P&P variations I've read this year, possibly ever.
Reread March 5, 2025. I wish I could give this 10 stars. Usually, when I reread a book, it's a matter of remembering what I liked about it on the first read, and if I read a bit slower than the first time, sometimes I see flaws I didn't notice the first time. But this is such a thoughtfully written book that rereading only served to improve my opinion of it. I especially like the inclusion of some quotes from Stoics.
Review December 4, 2022
In this variation on Pride and Prejudice, after the Netherfield party leaves for London, Mrs. Bennet is still miffed with Elizabeth over refusing Mr. Collins. Elizabeth sees her near future home life looking unpleasant, so she asks her father to let her accompany Jane to London to stay with their aunt and uncle Gardiner.
While they're visiting, Mrs. Gardiner receives a letter from her elderly aunt in Lambton, and becomes concerned for her. The older woman's housekeeper is to be away for weeks, and she's not sure she can get on without her. Mrs. Gardiner doesn't want to leave her children for such a length of time. So Elizabeth volunteers to go help out. At first her uncle objects, but he finally gives in, and Elizabeth plans to set off to Derbyshire. When she inquires of her aunt what her duties are likely to be, she's told she shouldn't likely have much more to do than pay out wages, decide what will be served for dinner, and support Mrs. Jennings as a companion.
At this point, in this variation, Lizzy has no idea that Pemberley is only five miles from Lambton. In fact she has no desire or expectation to ever see Mr. Darcy again.
But she soon learns that she will have to be much more than a companion for a lonely old lady. Mrs. Jennings, her great-aunt by marriage, is terribly disabled by memory loss. She can't recall who someone is without constant reminders, and she's quite feeble. She's become so dependent on the housekeeper, Mrs. Burke, that Lizzy wonders if the housekeeper has been writing her letters for her. There is marketing and some cooking that Elizabeth is expected to do, in spite of a surly full-time cook on the premises. She has never had to do either task in her life, but she assures Mrs. Burke she will manage.
The shopkeepers in town see her inexperience at once and take mean advantage of it, and she's soon burdened with more stinking tallow candles than she can use, a burnt pot she attempted to use to make pork jelly and ruined, and a nosy neighbor woman whom she has yet to learn used to run a brothel. The cook seems always on the verge of quitting her job. The two house maids have more work than they can manage, so Elizabeth has to pitch in with their work as well, if she wants the house truly clean, and her elderly aunt requires a lot of care.
Lizzy is soon exhausted and unable to cope with her situation. One day, in a shop, she spies a capable-looking woman wearing a coat of quality, talking to the shopkeeper in an authoritative manner. She's so impressed with her that after the woman leaves, Lizzy asks who that was.
'"Mrs. Reynolds. She is housekeeper at the great house."
'"The squire's housekeeper?"
'"No, miss. She keeps Pemberley."'
Shocked, Elizabeth inquires as to Pemberley's location. A day later she decides to beg some advice from Mrs. Reynolds, certain that she will not encounter any of the family if she's just there to see the housekeeper.
This is one of those stories that had me so anxious to know what would happen next that I sped through it. It's written from two different first-person points of view, alternating between Elizabeth Bennet and Fitzwilliam Darcy. The times of their sections of the story sometimes overlap, so sometimes we read the same scene, first from one's point of view and then from the other's, and I found that interesting because their perceptions were different. But it's not presented in a way that seems at all repetitive, and only a few scenes are repeated that way. This is one of the best P&P variations I've read this year, possibly ever.
November 13, 2022
Lovely, just lovely
November 9, 2022
This book was everything.
It has its flaws but the character growth, witty dialogue and inspiring romance more than make up for it. I LOVED ODC.
I feel like evey single character in this story was a real person, what an amazing feat.
Can't wait for the next book by this very talented author, I'm never disappointed.
It has its flaws but the character growth, witty dialogue and inspiring romance more than make up for it. I LOVED ODC.
I feel like evey single character in this story was a real person, what an amazing feat.
Can't wait for the next book by this very talented author, I'm never disappointed.
September 26, 2023
Oh, this one is such a delight. Grace Gibson is SO funny--there were many points where I laughed out loud.
The tale is told from both Elizabeth's and Darcy's point of view, and sometimes the author has to back up quite a bit to re-tell the story from the other perspective. But I never felt things were being needlessly rehashed. Instead, I would read the scene the first time and feel agog with suspense wondering what the OTHER character was thinking, only to be delighted to read the other perspective.
A very interesting and different plot, which explores something that is not often examined in JAFF: the world of poverty that threatens Lizzy's family should Mr. Bennet die. There is also careful and insightful attention to a matter often ignored by many JAFF authors but was certainly a significant preoccupation for women of the period: the difficulties that can arise in interactions with servants, some of whom are definitely not overjoyed with their situation.
I loved the concept of "friendly grapeshot" as a means of skating over acute social embarrassment.
Well done. I will come back to this one again and again.
The tale is told from both Elizabeth's and Darcy's point of view, and sometimes the author has to back up quite a bit to re-tell the story from the other perspective. But I never felt things were being needlessly rehashed. Instead, I would read the scene the first time and feel agog with suspense wondering what the OTHER character was thinking, only to be delighted to read the other perspective.
A very interesting and different plot, which explores something that is not often examined in JAFF: the world of poverty that threatens Lizzy's family should Mr. Bennet die. There is also careful and insightful attention to a matter often ignored by many JAFF authors but was certainly a significant preoccupation for women of the period: the difficulties that can arise in interactions with servants, some of whom are definitely not overjoyed with their situation.
I loved the concept of "friendly grapeshot" as a means of skating over acute social embarrassment.
Well done. I will come back to this one again and again.
November 8, 2022
Stunning
Really five stars is not enough. Oh Ms Gibson you have done it again. This two hander between Elizabeth's and Darcy's points of view is thoroughly immersive, capturing and deeply subtle. Please, please read it to see the craft of JAFF at its very best and most engaging. The tender portrayal of their individual journeys to self knowledge and to deep and abiding love has never been bettered. And the gentle and respectful treatment of dementia, also tender and true. Brava.
Really five stars is not enough. Oh Ms Gibson you have done it again. This two hander between Elizabeth's and Darcy's points of view is thoroughly immersive, capturing and deeply subtle. Please, please read it to see the craft of JAFF at its very best and most engaging. The tender portrayal of their individual journeys to self knowledge and to deep and abiding love has never been bettered. And the gentle and respectful treatment of dementia, also tender and true. Brava.
December 23, 2023
5++ stars. A beautifully written story. I live this author's Darcy, arrogant and authoritative on the outside and sweet and gooey on the inside and her Elizabeth too, proud and witty on the outside and vulnerable and insecure on the inside, they are the perfect fit. This story is no exception. The author has a wonderful waybof writing scenarios that are funny but with a underlying thread of melancholy which will tug at your heart which can and will only be cured by Darcy, for Elizabeth as well as us readers.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 180 reviews