There is a distinctive transportive quality to Orwell's work that feels paradoxically akin to both time travel and timelessness; the essays he writes are deeply rooted in their milieu, though his criticisms and ideas are still ever present in current sentiments. It was also a fascinating character study, as when you move through each essay, you are witness to the evolution of the author: every experience crystallizes or challenges his beliefs, and each thought branches and flowers. In turn, these entries preserve a slice of his perspective, while the collection itself serves as the progression of the distinctive Orwell character we know today (note the collection is non-chronological - I think back to Qiu Miaolin's insistence that "they can be read in any order" for her last semi-autobiographical work, though I feel the order of things does have an impact, there is a human urge to create a timeline). Each essay chronicled below:
Why I Write (1946) - Stands on its own just fine (title is self explanatory), but is doubly enjoyable when you play the game of connecting his four motives for writing with his subsequent/previous work. His love of writing informs his criticisms of it, lending said criticisms precision.
Decline of the English Murder (1946) - I found an interesting point of this to be partial desensitization/reprioritization, in that what we see to be extreme violence has shifted in media significantly (how often are murders reported now, compared to the last few years? given atrocities in the world today, has the definition itself been modified in the zeitgeist/Overton window?).
Books vs Cigarettes (1946) - Contains a financial breakdown of the cost of living in the 1940s, done to justify reading as a relatively affordable recreation. I feel it would be an eye-opening exercise to do this myself to see if this argument still holds water (for the record, I got this copy for $6.99, though that price is rare now direct from print).
My Country Right or Left (1940) - Explores the feelings of patriotism prior to WWII. A particularly interesting tidbit is when Orwell recalls the artillery fire at the front during the Spanish Civil War to be lacking compared to his imagination, given his cadet-corps and Etonian upbringing. It brings up questions of how war is presented to us, and ties in with how feelings of patriotism manifest.
The Lion and the Unicorn: Socialism and the English Genius (1941) - I believe the longest essay in this collection, and one of the two that Orwell did not want to publish posthumously (see prev.). Written during the Blitz, the essay is urgent, and the essayist, frustrated. He lays down a six point plan for England and its place on the global stage, arguing that the war can only be won if England relinquishes its grasp on capitalism. His writing is evocative and designed so for the era of warfare: "A generation of the unteachable are hanging upon us like a necklace of corpses.", "the British dealers were tumbling over one another in their eagerness to sell Germany tin, rubber, copper and shellac... [knowing] that war was going to break out in a week or two. It was about as sensible as selling somebody a razor to cut your throat with." Much of his grievances with the powers-that-be are still applicable today (war profiteering running more rampant than ever, present demagogues that frighteningly mirror the past). Though I definitely don't agree with everything here (owed to prescience), a strong historical outlook I cannot deny.
Future of a Ruined Germany (1945) - Post war ruminations in a desolate Germany. Marks the cost of war, the difficulty in rebuilding, which we see today with the devastation of Palestine. This quote stuck with me: "To walk through the ruined cities of Germany is to feel an actual doubt about the continuity of civilisation."
Politics and the English Language (1946) - The seeds of 1984 are evident in this essay. This is one of my favourites, as it paints the importance of language as an instrument of thought. An incisive criticism that prompts more active and deliberate engagement with everything we read/write. Similar to "Why I Write", the fun is also in catching Orwell breaking his own rules.
Some Thoughts on the Common Toad (1946) - I've never been the biggest fan of springtime, but this essay convinced me otherwise. I love the message of appreciation as a political act, and the depiction of such is full of whimsy and endearment; a welcome contrast, I might add, after the hard hitting war essays.
Shooting an Elephant (1936) - I originally wish this essay was earlier in the compilation, as it so vividly and pointedly demonstrates an origin of Orwell's anti-imperialist stance, but changed my mind. This one reads more like a short story in flow and allegory, and leaves more up to the reader. Orwell does not shy from being unlikable here, frank in his relief after a horrible incident, putting his flaws on display in an echo to the ease of empire.
A Hanging (1931) - One of Orwell's most famous essays, describing a prisoner being herded to his execution. A brutal depiction of cognitive dissonance, best gone into blind.
Charles Dickens (1940) - Imagine my surprise when we cap off this adventure with an analysis of Dickens! 60 odd pages, at that. As I have (unfortunately) not read much of him, I will need to revisit it in the future. My current thought is that it is funny that I now have a framework to understand Dickens, the author, but little background to draw upon. The countdown to read Great Expectations begins anew.
All in all, a highly enjoyable essay collection! I recently acquired Down and Out About Paris and London, so I'm looking forward to reading that in due time. Several, if not all, of Orwell's essays are also available online, so I'm excited to read the ones that haven't been featured here.