James Patterson has several bestselling series, each carrying different levels of readership popularity. Detective Alex Cross is his coveted franchise and most successful series, followed by the Women’s Murder Club, Detective Michael Bennett, NYPD Red, and the Private novels.
The Detective Michael Bennett series is one of Patterson’s better feel-good characters. Bennett is a successful Detective working special crimes in New York City. His home life and (very large) family are really the center of his world and provide the primary reason for the readers to cheer him on. Bennett’s first wife, Maeve, died after fighting a losing battle with cancer, leaving him with their 10 adopted children to raise, along with his sour grandfather and catholic priest, Seamus. During most of the books, Bennett has moved on by falling in love and getting married to his wonderful housekeeper, Mary Catherine, in-between solving crimes and stopping serial killers along the way.
The good news is that most of the books in this series have been pretty enjoyable and worth reading for the most part. The first nine books in the series were co-authored by Howard Roughan and built up a nice consistency and rhythm in the plotting and overall character development. However, from the tenth book on there was a change in co-authors, and not necessarily a good one at first. To be honest, I personally found the first three of the four books co-written with James Born to be less than pleasing due to weak plotting and several characters acting inconsistently. They were definitely my least liked Bennett books in the series. I felt like Born was struggling in his understanding of the characters, especially after having Bennett’s son arrested for selling drugs. That just made no sense at all and was so completely out of character, I am still trying to figure out how this move was consistent to any of the character’s previous history.
However, four of the next five books showed improvement for the most part and the last one – “Shattered” – was my favorite in the series co-written with Born. I felt like the authors hit their happy place with the characters, plotting, and locations. Now, their six book together – “Obsessed” – is out, and having finished it I am ready to share my review.
The primary mystery that drives “Obsessed” is Bennet’s hunt for a serial killer that is murdering young college aged women, including a close friend of Michael’s oldest daughter. The sub-plots involved Mary Catherine and Michael’s looking into fertility treatments while they think about having a child, dealing with three of their sons being bullied nearby their school, and Michael coaching one of his daughter’s school basketball team.
All three plotlines play out, focusing on Detective Bennett’s police procedural search for a killer with the two sub-plots sprinkled in between moments of the investigation in standard James Patterson style. It really felt like this book was a toned-down version of Bennett, with a straight-forward, peel the onion, hunt for a serial killer (with several red-herrings to increase the page count), and more time was spent with the Bennett family. To be honest, I rather liked the increased focus on Mary Catherine and several of the children, including Fiona’s developing basketball talent and how they dealt with the physical bullying challenges. This book certainly reminded us of how much a family man Michael Bennett is above all else. It is what drives and motivates him, which shows in the writing.
However, the overall murder/serial killer plotline felt rather run of the mill, basic formula type, with several red herrings along the way to make sure there were over 300 pages of content. It was interesting to see how Bennett used several other law enforcement resources (and one criminal) in order to help him hunt down the killer. I liked them and they played solid secondary roles.
For me, there wasn’t as much suspense or tension in the mystery elements, and it lacked some of the “psychological thriller” type label that comes with this series. Even the ending 40-page chase scene felt a bit predictable. That is not to say that this was a bad book, but more a casual, light reading version, in the Michael Bennett series. I basically read it in two sittings within 24 hours because it was just a fast basic read.
Overall, this was a middle of the road book. The good news is that it didn’t feel disjoined like some of the prior Patterson/Born co-authored books had been. It also engaged me with the family better than in had in the recent books. It felt like the authors had a better understanding and grasp of the characters and how they should really behave. On the flip side, it didn’t necessarily challenge me as a reader. Those were the tradeoffs.
I am in the 2.5 to 3.0 stars out of five rating range.