Thanks to Netgalley for a copy of this ebook, and this is my freely given opinion.
I was a bit conflicted about this story. I enjoyed the dynamic of the ladies and friendships of the spinsters of the Isle of Synne, and the second chance - but felt like it was doomed not to be - romance between Katrina and Sebastian. But I found I had a strong visceral negative reaction to some of the characters and their actions. Of course, they were meant to be the villains of the piece, in essence, so really that is not a negative reflection on the story telling.
Katrina was at the top of her game, as a belle in Society. Beautiful, dowered, from a noble family. She had caught the eye of Sebastian, a Marquess at the time, and they were lightly flirting, and tentatively stepping towards courting. Sebastian was a cocky rakish man about town at this time, but starting to think that he wants to explore the relationship with Katrina, when he is suddenly called away to attend to his father, the Duke. While he is away, Katrina is felled by a massive scandal, where she is a victim of an unwanted admirer who invades her room, and even though nothing happens she is forced into the center of a massive drama that tears apart her family, ruins her reputation, sends her brother down a destructive, despairing spiral, and sees her exiled to the Isle of Synne, penniless, and taking on employ as the companion of Lady Tesh.
Sebastian is ignorant of all this, because when he was called away all those years ago he ends up in his own spiral of despair and his own family scandal which forces him to inherit an impoverished, indebted duchy, to care for his sisters, and to repair his family reputation which was destroyed by his father's gambling, and actions leading to defrauding other members of Society.
Sebastian has no choice but to try to wed an heiress for wealth, but he is being manipulated by the future bride's father, who uses Sebastian to babysit his wayward son, who has fallen in love with an unsuitable woman. He essentially wants Sebastian to rusticate with the son on the Isle of Synne to help the son forget about his mistress, whom he wants to take to wife.
Synne becomes the romantic backdrop where Sebastian and Katrina rediscover their attraction, find out what they have lost over the years, and fall in love again. But they despair of anything coming from their love, as they both have such burdens to carry - Katrina's reputation takes a hit again as her nemesis from the past returns, and she is being torn to shreds by the Synneful citizens, amongst other ills, and Sebastian has to wed his heiress to save his family.
A charming love story, with wonderfully quirky, and lovingly interfering and intrusive friends. But poor Katrina is so very much wronged and forced to suffer for the actions of others, and then to shoulder their blame and downfalls - the unwanted suitor... her brother and his downfall. Their behaviours directly caused her misery and she had no fault but then was forced to suffer over and over again, and be treated so poorly by others for things that were outside of herself. The injustice of it made me livid. Admittedly, I have angsty angry relationships right now with some brother figures in my life, so that may be colouring my opinions a bit (seriously, if I were to find out my brother in law died tomorrow, I would likely want to dance on his grave.) But her brother needed a serious kick with steel toed boots to the bollocks for his treatment of her and then to show up when she gains something positive. He needed a good club upside the head and there was no satisfaction on that front. At least the dog should have been allowed to bashed his man-bits to pieces a couple of times
Damned patriarchal world where the women have to suffer from the stupidity of men!
4 stars out of 5