THE MAIN ENEMY: THE CIA, THE KGB AND A WAR THAT DID NOT END
The Main Enemy: The Inside Story of the CIA's Final Showdown with the KGB, by Milton Bearden and James Risen (Random House, 2003)
I first read The Main Enemy when it came out in 2003. I have just read it again, and it has improved with age, though not in the way its authors would have intended.
Milt Bearden was a senior officer in the CIA's clandestine service. He ran the agency's covert support for the Afghan resistance in the late 1980s, and then headed the Soviet/East European Division as the Soviet Union collapsed. James Risen was an intelligence reporter for the New York Times. Together they tell the story of the last decade of the Cold War. The book follows Bearden and his CIA colleagues, and it also follows their KGB counterparts, among them Rem Krasilnikov in counterintelligence and Leonid Shebarshin, later head of the First Chief Directorate. The book is broken into short sections, each headed by place, date and time, so it reads like a thriller.
The central story is the disaster of 1985, the "Year of the Spy." By June of that year the CIA had more highly placed agents inside the Soviet Union than ever before, most of them volunteers who had walked in rather than been recruited. One of them was Adolf Tolkachev, an aviation engineer who handed over thousands of pages of documents on Soviet fighter radar. Within six or seven months, the CIA lost most of these agents, and many of them were executed. Many years later the agency traced the losses to two traitors. One was Aldrich Ames, a CIA officer his colleagues dismissed as a "terminal GS-14," but who beat the CIA’s polygraph and managed to explain away how he paid cash for a half-million-dollar house in Arlington. The other was the FBI’s Robert Hanssen. The book also describes how Edward Lee Howard, a fired CIA trainee, slipped FBI surveillance and escaped to Moscow. It tells the story of Vitaly Yurchenko. He defected, leaving his family behind, then went back to Moscow after his former lover told him she had loved "a KGB colonel, not a traitor."
The Afghanistan chapters are the heart of Bearden's own story: the Stinger missiles, the Chinese mules, the unreliability of our Pakistani partners and Congressman Charlie Wilson, "a Texan who could strut while sitting down." The chapters on the collapse of the Berlin Wall in 1989 and then of the USSR in 1991 are just as good. An East German Politburo member, Günter Schabowski, opened the Berlin Wall almost by accident. He was briefing reporters on new travel rules, adlibbing that they took effect "immediately." It seems clear that Schabowski had never read the new rules!
Then came the August 1991 coup and the symbolic toppling of the Dzerzhinsky statue outside the Lubyanka, the KGB headquarters in Moscow. The book also has its share of humor, such as the MiG-29 pilot who refused the CIA’s choice of code name for him, "Spaniel," because it was a dog, and the East German defector who agreed to bring out a surface-to-air missile if the CIA would "bring a big truck." [They did.]
Reading the book again in 2026, two passages stand out. Acting CIA Director Dick Kerr told the KGB chairman that the 20th century "began in 1914 in the Balkans and ended in August '91 in Moscow." It was a fine line, but it was wrong. More prophetic was the note that KGB officers painted on the empty pedestal where the Dzerzhinsky statue had stood a few days earlier. "Dear Felix, we are sorry that we couldn't save you, but you will remain with us." As the book says, that turned out to be true. Within a decade a former KGB lieutenant colonel was running Russia, and he still is. The epilogue also celebrates the rout of the Taliban in less than five weeks in 2001. The Taliban came back to Kabul in August 2021.
Having lived and worked in Moscow in the years that followed the events of this book, I read it as a first-rate account of the end of one chapter of a long rivalry, not the end of the story. It is well written, well sourced and, strangely, often quite funny. I recommend it highly.