Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
Freedom Awaits, but the Consortium is Watching

When rogue drones threaten citizens and the ship’s crew falls ill, the Recorder answers their call for help, once again drawing scrutiny from the Consortium.

With no other option and under an Elder’s overbearing watch, she returns to Pallas Station where she nearly lost her life in the hope of finding something—anything—to save her friends and countless others. Her friends are determined to keep her safe, but for the Recorder, saving others comes first, no matter the cost.

417 pages, Kindle Edition

Published November 15, 2022

9 people are currently reading
200 people want to read

About the author

Cathy McCrumb

3 books175 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
131 (52%)
4 stars
91 (36%)
3 stars
25 (9%)
2 stars
3 (1%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 93 reviews
Profile Image for Lindsey (Books for Christian Girls).
2,157 reviews5,102 followers
July 10, 2024
Four take-aways from book two:

1.) this series is making me hate cockroaches more than I thought ever could (I already loath them, so thanks for this, author.)

2.) Found family trope elements make me cry every time

3.) I need a bit more romance in the third book please (but we have bigger fish to fry, so okay, whatever)

4.) but! most! importantly! the government better be burned to the ground in the third book. 🔥



thoughts & content info to come.
Profile Image for Sharon Loves to Read.
323 reviews101 followers
August 30, 2025
5⭐️ for a sci-fi?? Never thought this hater of sci-fi would see the day. These books are so heart-filled and so *human* that this lover of character-driven stories is enamored.

Regarding a certain character, I am sad to say he was a red-shirt after all.💔😭💔😭💔

On to Realm Maker’s Book of the Year and the last book in this trilogy: Guardian!!!
Profile Image for Carmen Miller.
96 reviews115 followers
May 18, 2024
Why do the endings of these books always get me??? 😭😭😭😭


RTC
Profile Image for Tales and Treats with Tay.
148 reviews112 followers
April 3, 2024
4.5 ⭐️

The first 50 pages of the book were a bit of an adjustment with a new set of characters introduced, a new setting, and a new problem for Recorder to be involved with.

Thankfully we do see Recorder fairly quickly reunited with her friends and it feels like coming home.

Cathy does an excellent job writing complex, real characters. One way she does this is with backstories interwoven into the current timeline; she does this in a way that adds depth to the character and reveals tidbits of info, including plot twists, that are essential to the current timeline. The growth in the romance is also sweet to see.


Content: death

Christian faith rating: 1/3 (hints of faith)
Profile Image for Celestria.
378 reviews461 followers
February 22, 2023
I was having a hard time getting into this book because of all the new characters and names I had to learn and I missed characters from the first book. But I finally got used to them and we met up with old friends and it got better. Loved the ending and I love the sweet romance ❤️
Profile Image for Stephanie.
274 reviews10 followers
October 14, 2022
Aberration is book two the Children of the Consortium series. So if you're interested in this book, but haven't read Recorder yet, you definitely need to so you'll know what's going on.

"Solitude and its companion, apprehension, wrapped around me like a drone's tendrils." -the first line of Aberration by Cathy McCrumb.

Continuing the story shortly after book 1 left off, we find the Recorder once again in an intensely heart-wrenching journey through chaos and confusion. She's thrown into a series of situations where disaster seems to follow, but she's determined to help save as many lives as possible.

We meet a few new characters in Aberration who end up adding more layers of intrigue and interest to the story. As in Recorder the characters are all really well-written, complex, and believable.

As I read this book, I could nearly see it happening in my mind's eye like a movie. It's that good!

If you like science fiction and/or dystopian stories, I think you'll like this series. And I still recommend it for older teen and adult readers.

My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (5/5 stars)

I received an ebook ARC of Aberration from the publisher. All opinions expressed in this review are my honest thoughts about this book.
Profile Image for J.J. Fischer.
Author 13 books286 followers
August 15, 2022
Heart-stopping, captivating, and perfectly riveting… Aberration is a roller coaster of emotions from start to finish! McCrumb takes her rich cast of characters to even deeper levels and greater heights in this stunning sequel, weaving an exquisite tapestry of words exploring the true nature of love, freedom, and sacrifice. I am itching to get my hands on the final instalment in the Children of the Consortium Trilogy!
Profile Image for Cassandra Hamm.
Author 26 books75 followers
August 29, 2023
4.5 stars rounded up. This series is incredible. <3

I only knocked off half a star because despite all the stuff happening at the beginning, it felt a little slow. I wasn’t entirely sure what was going on, though I did figure it out. And I’m glad for the new characters, like Eric and Tia and Cam, but gosh darn it, I just wanted to go back to Nate and Max and Alec and Zhen. :P but then we DID and there was much longing and I was happy (even though Nate and the Recorder had very little time together, sob, but the moments they had were so sweet!!)

I’m glad this one returned to the giant cockroaches from the previous book because I wanted to know what the heck was happening and why the heck they existed but also THEY WERE DISGUSTING, NOPE NOPE NOPE. They need to be burned.

Love me a good character-driven sci fi with powerful themes and found family and the sweetest slow burn <3 and we got more of “the Recorder isn’t a human” to “I must protect her!!” and I am a fan. She’s so odd and so lovable. You can’t help but adore her. <3
Profile Image for Kayleigh P.
372 reviews41 followers
April 24, 2023
Wow. 4.5 stars. This story had me gripped for 400 pages read in 36 hours. This a sequel to Recorder. We meet up with the Recorder after she has been returned to the Consortium and is awaiting punishment. A virus breaks out on her new ship home and she returns to all of her old friends on Thalassa, where she finds out her punishment will be to encounter the source of the outbreak and work on a cure. We meet many new friends along the way, while still enjoying old favorites.

I’ve been curious to see how Covid will trickle into fiction and it was so well done here (albeit in a fictional virus). The discrimination, the fear, the choices that become necessary in a pandemic, all accurately portrayed.

This is Christian fiction, and there is much more faith exploration in this book. Lots of talk about what our gifts mean for other people, sacrificial love, chaos vs order, and how all of humanity is flawed but that doesn’t move us beyond hope, redemption, and forgiveness. I loved Larik’s story arc so much.

I need to know Recorder’s name! I really hope there is a third book as planned.
Profile Image for Ron.
Author 2 books170 followers
June 8, 2023
“He is not defective.” “We’re all defective.”

Perils of Pauline in space continue. Good storytelling and character building. The protagonist is a slow learner, which is part of the fun. A redemption story. In fact, several folks are transformed.

“Fear and resignation did not drive him. Sacrifice only had meaning when it was made in love.”

The same quibbles as the first book: improbable technology. Incandescent lights on spaceships? No power yet they recycle dead bodies? Portable generators? Powered by what? “Ancient lava tubes” on an asteroid?

“See what you can find in the databases that’ll help protect us. Vitamins, meds, face paint, or burning feathers. I don’t care. Anything.”

Another cliffhanger instead of an ending.

‘But I had now. Now had to be enough.’
Profile Image for The Book Bunch (Sam).
123 reviews43 followers
February 22, 2023
The start was an adjustment but after 50 pages it felt just like book one. It is full of so much heartbreak, pain and kindness. These books are the definition of bittersweet. An essential read. Cannot wait for book 3.
Profile Image for Briana Briggs.
243 reviews20 followers
February 2, 2024
A good continuation of the story, hard to say much without spoilers, but I just want to say, having just read Persuasion last month, I loved the hint to that story! Definitely need to continue on with the series!
Profile Image for Crystal Grant.
Author 19 books112 followers
May 22, 2023
Cathy continues to amaze me with this series. The characters capture my heart. I got quite emotionally involved with this sequel and now I’m anxiously awaiting book 3. A GREAT sci-fi read. (But watch out for the giant roaches!)
Profile Image for Becky.
639 reviews26 followers
January 2, 2023
Excellent science fiction. There was a bit more backstory switching than I expected, and quite a few more characters added. It would be very confusing if the first book in the series wasn’t read first.
Profile Image for Emily Barnett.
Author 22 books79 followers
August 24, 2023
Well-written and immersive! The last half had me on pins and needles and I'm so excited to find out how this series wraps up! I especially love the theme of worth that each person holds. Beautiful.
Profile Image for Coralie.
701 reviews134 followers
December 28, 2023
First and foremost, I must address the mouthwateringly stunning cover. Not gonna lie, this cover is the reason I picked up the first book to read the series (on top of much reaaaaalllly good feedback from friends and professionals). Isn't is GORGEOUS?! Loook at it! It gives me such Iron Giant vibes! And I just love the colors so much.

*ahem* Okay, but for the story itself in between those ooey gooey covers.

McCrumb continues the high tension, page turning, heart felt story from Recorder. We meet some endearing new characters. And though we got to see some of the old beloved ones, I did miss that original dynamic from the original crew <3 It's still neat to see Recorder growing and expanding her friend group and to see her natural leadership, selflessness, and wit garner loyalty from those around her. The characters are what make this story for me, truly. Oh, the Elder. Be still my heart! Also, *squeals* NATE! I need my own personal Nathanial Timmons in my life. Asap!

We got to explore little pockets of the world in this one and there's one place hinted at that I reallllly hope we get to see more of in the final book (which also has a stellar cover!). I really liked how McCrumb deepened much of what she started in the first installment. We see the crew expand, the ship and world and even Pallas Station expand. We see a depth of understanding of the cultures, characters, and plot unraveling a layer at a time. It was so cool to feel like we just surged forward into a natural expansion of Recorder.

I said this for the previous book, but it still kind of amazes me here in the sequel, but the way McCrumb so deftly uses flashback to pry open and reveal so much with only a single memory astounds me. It's so beautifully done! It makes me itch and yearn to know more about these characters and their pasts. The least boring flashbacks I've ever seen in fiction. I keep sitting at the edge of my seat wondering which character McCrumb will flip on their head next.

I'm drying to read the next one and absolutely thrilled with this sequel! I can't more highly recommend the books. They strike such a beautiful balance of just fun sci-fi world building, endearing characters, thrilling plot, and deeply heartfelt themes. She continues to explore the themes of humanity, grace, mercy, and morality in such a resonate way.

Content: clean romance, no swearing, some mild sci-fi violence. Deals with some topics of poverty, abuse, neglect, and oppression, but all in such a hope-filled way. I'd feel fine giving the book to a preteen.
Profile Image for Camille Mosemann.
212 reviews36 followers
October 12, 2025
That ending?!?! Absolute cutest thing ever! It was so happy and yet I was holding back tears because of everything that’s unresolved.

I’m really anxious to read Guardian because I want to know what happens next! This series is so so so good! I already know I’m going to be sad to say goodbye to these characters, but I’m ready for them to be happy because they’ve gone through so much. I still love the theme that all people are valuable and we also added MORE found family so that was awesome! I’m so glad I have the last book on hand!
Profile Image for Cassie Porath.
8 reviews9 followers
January 2, 2025
Cathy McCrumb did it again! I’m more of a fantasy reader in general. I rarely dabble in Sci-fi. Space travel and high tech generally isn’t my vibe (I’m more for princesses, dragons and fairies). That being said, McCrumb sucked me in with Recorder and so I had to come back for book 2 and it DID. NOT. DISAPPOINT! <3

I LOVE the main character! McCrumb did an amazing job making me care for her and want to follow her journey.

The only thing I would say is it was a little difficult getting into this one just because there were a bunch of new friends (Tia, Cam, Eric…)for Recorder to bond with and I missed the old friends (Zhen, Max, Alec, NATE…). But over all, I loved that the Recorder had the opportunity to make new friends with all that she learned from the previous book.

Often, when you have a trilogy you find the second book tends to be the saggy-middle where things are slow and boring. Not Aberration. Cathy McCrumb pulled me in (with the exception of the very beginning) and kept the action going. This is definitely a series I will read again!

And, this has nothing to do with the story itself but this cover is absolutely stunning! The digital picture here doesn’t quite do it justice. You NEED this book for your collection! And if you love Sci-fi you need to read this series.
Profile Image for Teddi Deppner.
Author 15 books12 followers
November 17, 2022
"Recorders cannot have friends, just as we cannot have names. We live to redeem our gifting, and personal involvement would betray that purpose." ~ the nameless one who was a Recorder, lost the drone that enabled her role in society, and now exists in an identity-less limbo.

Later: “Zeta?” Watkins fixed her blue-grey eyes on him. “You named it, Thompson? I know you’re from the belt and things are less civilized there, and I know you’re slow, but everyone knows if you feed it or name it, you have to take it home.”

Ha!

The best of science fiction wrestles with how humanity deals with life. This story manages to balance some heavy topics like "who decides what's best for society?" and "does an individual have a right to their life and freedom to live it?" while surprising me with a laugh like this... or the heartwarming value of a simple gift like a pair of socks. Don't even get me started on the socks. It takes a skilled author to wield a mere pair of socks to create high suspense and plot twists.

In this sequel, the Recorder we rooted for in the first book is even more vulnerable, and in even more danger. Moment by moment, running barefoot through halls where deadly drones roam, denied a weapon or other form of protection--or even a change of clothes--this woman kept me glued to the story. Her courage, her humility, her dedication to what she knows is right. These traits make an admirable protagonist, but it was how they were engaged by the cast of characters around her that delighted me again and again.

New characters are introduced during the chaotic opening moments, but they quickly became familiar. Their squabbles, their motivations, their foibles and their own moments of failure or nobility... They were so engaging that I ended up hoping *their* stories worked out, too. I love a story where the protagonist's nature of self-sacrifice and honor inspires loyalty and the same beautiful traits in those around her. (Ahem, Miles Vorkosigan, anyone? Fans of Lois McMaster Bujold's space opera will probably love this.)

This story reveals more about the inner workings of the Consortium and the Elders who pull the strings and keep everybody in line. There are horrors revealed (what happens to aberrant or damaged Recorders?) and hope revealed (who knew there were so many other Recorders, even Elders who harbored dreams of individual freedom?) through the course of the book.

And the slow burn of our protagonist's love story progresses when we finally see Nathaniel again! Happy moments for those who like a thread of romance in their science fiction.

I look forward to seeing the next book and discovering whether the Consortium and its firm grip on society will be cracked wide open by this humble woman's insistence on being and doing what she believes in right... and whether she herself will find a chance at love and a life of freedom and peace.
Profile Image for Connie Hill.
1,881 reviews47 followers
December 8, 2022
Aberration is a science fiction book that is written by Cathy McCrumb. This is the second book in the Children of the Consortium series. I have read both books - and would recommend that you read them in order. You may find yourself lost and unsure of what is going on.

We see the Recorder back in another adventure. The Recorder answers a call for help and will always put others first. The situation that she is thrown into seems bleak - but she will always try and rescue as many lives as possible. Even if that means putting herself in danger. The Recorder (also known as Zeta) is being accused of spreading a virus. This virus is spreading through the ship so fast. It's crazy that the Elders will destroy the recorders - and how they try and control everyone. Zeta stands her ground and will try and save others.

This book is outside my normal genre. It is however, a good read and kept my attention. This book took me on a emotional roller coaster. Thank you to the author, publisher and Celebrate Lit for allowing me to read a copy of this book - all thoughts are my own.
Profile Image for C.S. Johnson.
Author 107 books631 followers
October 3, 2022
Much like "Recorder," McCrumb's sequel asks the questions of what it means to be human, addressing themes of perseverance through trial, endurance through despair, and joy amidst suffering. This time, Recorder takes us further up and further in as she races to save her friends and follow what she believes to be right, despite the opposition all around her. With its lovely, lyrical prose, I highly recommend this book!
Profile Image for Shannon McNear.
Author 24 books968 followers
December 17, 2023
I normally do not care for hard SF, but the concept of this series drew me in and would not let me go. Definitely a more "thinky" story but it's an accessible nerdliness ... and I loved the question of whether human emotion and attachment are worth the risk they pose. (Okay, that might have just been where I was and not necessarily what the author intended ... but it's what I saw woven through this series.)

So excited to hear there's a third book coming!
Profile Image for T.E. Bradford.
Author 18 books96 followers
October 13, 2023
Incredibly riveting and touching

How so much action and drama can be mixed with so much emotion and humanity, I can hardly say. This author captures the best of both. Book 2 started a bit slower than 1, but ended with an even bigger wallop, if possible. Fantastic story, characters you wish you could visit with, and crazy action. One of my top 3 all time favorites as of this moment. Bravo!!!!!
Profile Image for Lizzy Hite.
261 reviews
January 31, 2024
Well, now I desperately need to know what happens, lol. Looking forward to the next book!
Profile Image for Vanessa E. Howard.
Author 8 books4 followers
December 19, 2024
I loved the continuing story of Recorder figuring out who she really is and what's really important to her.
Profile Image for Leanne Root.
107 reviews3 followers
February 28, 2025
I had a hard time getting into the book, and I got a bit lost with all the characters. The ending was by far what saved this book for me. I still want to continue the series.
Profile Image for Sarah.
Author 8 books154 followers
June 5, 2025
A harder read than the first book — there's more direct cruelty and prejudice directly on display, especially in the first third — but still so good.
Profile Image for Angela Jones-Cuéllar.
1,058 reviews114 followers
August 23, 2022
4.5 stars
If you enjoyed the first book, then you'll also love this sequel which further builds up this fascinating sci-fi journey. As you've probably already read the first book, you should be familiar with the pacing which is somewhat slow though still intriguing. After reading so many other books between Recorder and Aberration it did take me a bit to recalibrate to the Recorder's unique thought/narration style and to the slower narrative pacing, but once I did it all felt familiar again and I gently slid back into the story. We begin with the Recorder on a new ship with a new crew and the nightmare bioweapon plot discovered in the previous book returns with a swift-acting vengeance. I liked getting to know more recorders, reuniting with Nate and the Thalassa's crew, meeting some new allies, and the further deepening and building of characters and this fascinating futuristic world. I remain excited to read the next book!

Thank you to the publisher for sending me a copy to review!
Profile Image for Jessica Gwyn.
122 reviews10 followers
August 24, 2022
Oh my goodness! Where do I even start?! Cathy McCrumb’s Aberration is the best book I’ve read in a long time. This continuation of the story of the multi-name, yet un-named recorder who isn’t, is thrilling, deep, intense, awe inspiring, and absolutely addictive. The world McCrumb has built is rich and full and it engulfs the reader.
I couldn’t put it down and by the end, I was a blubbering mess. I cannot recommend the whole Children of the Constortium series enough and I’m going to have a difficult time waiting for the third book to release.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 93 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.