What do you think?
Rate this book
The Garden Girls #4
A Gentleman Never Surrenders
Northern factory owner Silas Riverton has mastered the art of concealing his true emotions. His hidden passions are confined to the brutal realm of boxing matches or indulged only in fleeting clandestine encounters after a childhood rife with coldness from his father.
Caraway Taylor, the eldest "Garden Girl," lives a life bound by duty. Admired for her plain but steady nature, she silently nurtures an unrequited love for a childhood crush, cherishing the memories of their innocent connection. Until one fateful night, when a twist of fate compromises her honor and intertwines her life with that of Mr. Riverton,
Thrust into an unexpected marriage, Silas and Caraway are determined to protect their hearts from further anguish. Yet, as they delve deeper into each other's lives, they discover a shared vulnerability that transcends their differences.
But as their guarded hearts soften, jealous rivals and manipulative adversaries threaten to shatter their fragile union.
Will Caraway and Silas learn that true love is capable of defying all odds before it's too late?
Experience a mesmerizing journey of passion, sacrifice, and resilience in this grand finale to The Garden Girls series that will leave you breathless and longing for more with every turn of the page.
Content Note: Explicit language and steamy sexual scenes abound.
Caraway Taylor, the eldest "Garden Girl," lives a life bound by duty. Admired for her plain but steady nature, she silently nurtures an unrequited love for a childhood crush, cherishing the memories of their innocent connection. Until one fateful night, when a twist of fate compromises her honor and intertwines her life with that of Mr. Riverton,
Thrust into an unexpected marriage, Silas and Caraway are determined to protect their hearts from further anguish. Yet, as they delve deeper into each other's lives, they discover a shared vulnerability that transcends their differences.
But as their guarded hearts soften, jealous rivals and manipulative adversaries threaten to shatter their fragile union.
Will Caraway and Silas learn that true love is capable of defying all odds before it's too late?
Experience a mesmerizing journey of passion, sacrifice, and resilience in this grand finale to The Garden Girls series that will leave you breathless and longing for more with every turn of the page.
Content Note: Explicit language and steamy sexual scenes abound.
374 pages, Kindle Edition
Published June 15, 2023
18 people are currently reading
158 people want to read
About the author
Jemma Frost
16 books197 followersJemma Frost grew up in the Midwest where she visited the library every day and read romance novels voraciously! Now, she lives in North Carolina with her cat, Spencer, and dreams of stories to be written!
Instagram: @authorjemmafrost
Facebook: Author Jemma Frost
Instagram: @authorjemmafrost
Facebook: Author Jemma Frost
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 69 reviews
June 30, 2023
Note: Some of my goodreads shelves can be spoilers
Overall: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Plot/Storyline: 📖📖📖📖
Feels: 🦋🦋🦋
Emotional Depth: 💔💔💔
Sexual Tension: ⚡⚡⚡
Romance: 💞💞💞
Sensuality: 💋💋💋💋
Sex Scene Length: 🍑🍑🍑🍑
Steam Scale (Number of Sex Scenes): 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥+
Humor: A bit
Perspective: Third person from both the hero and heroine
Cliffhanger: No
Epilogue: Yes
Format: voluntarily read an advanced reader copy in e-book format
(These are all personal preference on a scale of 1-5 (yours ratings may vary depending what gives you feels and how you prefer you sex scenes written, etc) except the Steam Scale which follows our chart from The Ton and Tartans Book Club )
Should I read in order?
Its not necessary to read in order – there’s some character overlap but nothing major. That said I think you’ll get most enjoyment in order as Cara’s character might grow over the series (I have only read books 3 and 4 so far)
Basic plot:
Caraway watches as her whole family is married before her. She has her plans for her childhood crush, but her brother in laws business partner is the one distracting her.
Give this a try if you want:
- Victorian (1874)
- Manchester setting
- avoid the aristocracy – heroine is the daughter of a professor and a botanist and the hero is working class (mill owner)
- full figured heroine
- emotionally damaged hero handles feelings through boxing and bedsport (or the good ‘ole fight or fuck)
- silver fox hero
- age gap (older hero) – hero is 15 years older than the heroine
- compromised heroine
- hero feeds the heroine
- heroine teaches the hero to ice skate
- masquerade
- light touch of love triangle
- higher steam – 7 full scenes
Ages:
- Heroine is 30, hero is 45
First line:
Screams of laughter drifted over the meadow as Caraway Taylor fought her way through the tall grass.
My thoughts:
I dove into the Garden Girls in book 3 so I didn’t read the whole series – but I plan to! I have really been adoring Frost’s characters, especially her super protective and possessive heroes. I love her steamy scenes – they are so emotional and always a mix that I appreciate.
I did struggle just a touch with the pace of this one. Maybe it lost steam a bit for me because of the early-ish marriage and the n they were separated a few times. I’m not sure but parts of this one were a touch slow for me compared with the others I read. Or perhaps it was the love triangle I found tiring. Or the toxic family as I do have a history of that and sometimes find it hard to read.
BUT I still loved so much of this book. Silas was such a great hero – he’s a bit emotionally constipated but I rather loved how he expressed his emotions in the bedroom. Cara was lovely, though a bit naive about Miles – she held onto it a touch too long for me but loved how she confronted him towards the end. Overall Jemma Frost has become an author that I look forward to every release – I definitely plan on going back and reading the ones I missed as well.
Endearments
Quotes/spoiler-y thoughts:
Content warnings:
Locations of kisses/intimate scenes:
Overall: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Plot/Storyline: 📖📖📖📖
Feels: 🦋🦋🦋
Emotional Depth: 💔💔💔
Sexual Tension: ⚡⚡⚡
Romance: 💞💞💞
Sensuality: 💋💋💋💋
Sex Scene Length: 🍑🍑🍑🍑
Steam Scale (Number of Sex Scenes): 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥+
Humor: A bit
Perspective: Third person from both the hero and heroine
Cliffhanger: No
Epilogue: Yes
Format: voluntarily read an advanced reader copy in e-book format
(These are all personal preference on a scale of 1-5 (yours ratings may vary depending what gives you feels and how you prefer you sex scenes written, etc) except the Steam Scale which follows our chart from The Ton and Tartans Book Club )
Should I read in order?
Its not necessary to read in order – there’s some character overlap but nothing major. That said I think you’ll get most enjoyment in order as Cara’s character might grow over the series (I have only read books 3 and 4 so far)
Basic plot:
Caraway watches as her whole family is married before her. She has her plans for her childhood crush, but her brother in laws business partner is the one distracting her.
Give this a try if you want:
- Victorian (1874)
- Manchester setting
- avoid the aristocracy – heroine is the daughter of a professor and a botanist and the hero is working class (mill owner)
- full figured heroine
- emotionally damaged hero handles feelings through boxing and bedsport (or the good ‘ole fight or fuck)
- silver fox hero
- age gap (older hero) – hero is 15 years older than the heroine
- compromised heroine
- hero feeds the heroine
- heroine teaches the hero to ice skate
- masquerade
- light touch of love triangle
- higher steam – 7 full scenes
Ages:
- Heroine is 30, hero is 45
First line:
Screams of laughter drifted over the meadow as Caraway Taylor fought her way through the tall grass.
My thoughts:
I dove into the Garden Girls in book 3 so I didn’t read the whole series – but I plan to! I have really been adoring Frost’s characters, especially her super protective and possessive heroes. I love her steamy scenes – they are so emotional and always a mix that I appreciate.
I did struggle just a touch with the pace of this one. Maybe it lost steam a bit for me because of the early-ish marriage and the n they were separated a few times. I’m not sure but parts of this one were a touch slow for me compared with the others I read. Or perhaps it was the love triangle I found tiring. Or the toxic family as I do have a history of that and sometimes find it hard to read.
BUT I still loved so much of this book. Silas was such a great hero – he’s a bit emotionally constipated but I rather loved how he expressed his emotions in the bedroom. Cara was lovely, though a bit naive about Miles – she held onto it a touch too long for me but loved how she confronted him towards the end. Overall Jemma Frost has become an author that I look forward to every release – I definitely plan on going back and reading the ones I missed as well.
Endearments
Quotes/spoiler-y thoughts:
Content warnings:
Locations of kisses/intimate scenes:
July 14, 2023
I enjoyed the gruff hero and the story's 'North and South' vibe, as well as the level of steaminess. However, I found the writing to be somewhat dry, and the heroine's lingering preoccupation with another male character felt excessively drawn out. I mean, seriously, after 10 years, she's still hung up on this guy? It doesn't make sense to me. Overall, this book was just an okay read for me.
June 14, 2023
I loved it. A romance that made me smile and hug the book when it ended. It started out a little different (in a good way) then I’m use to seeing and I love how it unfolded. Great writing. I had a front row seat to this necessary marriage and they struggled and failed. But it was all precious and told in away that I didn’t want to put it down. The romance was touching with lots of chemistry and sometimes very smexy scenes. This was more than just a romance because there was family issues and industry growth when it was frowned upon.
I highly recommend it. Strong FMC and a gorgeous misunderstood MMC. It’s an open door romance that had unique circumstances. Will I read another by this author? Absolutely!
Thanks Booksprout for this eARC, it was lovely.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I highly recommend it. Strong FMC and a gorgeous misunderstood MMC. It’s an open door romance that had unique circumstances. Will I read another by this author? Absolutely!
Thanks Booksprout for this eARC, it was lovely.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
June 16, 2023
DNF- way too cutesy. I was into the hero, but it was a fluffy read so he couldn't save it. Once the father-in-law was introduced I lost all interest. Giving stars for steamy writing and a take charge hero.
June 18, 2023
Thanks to BookSprout for a copy of this ebook and this is my freely given opinion.
This is the story about he eldest of the Garden Girls, older sister and caregiver of the family, Caraway. This story has many themes - curvy, shy, wallflower with low self esteem, a bit of grumpy sunshine, age gap, girlhood crush...
Caraway is an almost 30 year old spinster who had been caring for her sister for years - almost decades. But now that they have found love and are all forming their own families, she finds she is alone at their family cottage, no longer having to worry and care for them. She yearns for more in her life, possibly even a love of her own. She was not popular as a debutante the one time she was presented, and thinks she is too plump and plain to attract a husband. But she is hopeful, as she has had a crush on their neighbour, Owen, the Earl of Trent's childhood friend, Miles Brandon, for years. She thinks that he, having shown signs of closeness and friendship for her in the past, could be nudged into loving her and marrying her, if she gets a chance to show him what a good wife she could be.
When she finds out that he is in Manchester on business, she decides to visit her sister Hazel and her husband, Jonathan Trent, thinking she could spend time with Miles. Travers is building successful business ventures, and is onto a new investment involving a mill with innovative ideas and management. He is involved with another local successful mill owner, Silas Riverton, a brusque, taciturn older man with no use for emotions and relationships, as his father had taught him. Miles demonstrated interest in investing, and was brought in despite his lack of true interest in the effort and workings of the business. But this gives Caraway the chances to spend time with him, and Silas socially.
Despite Caraway's low opinion of her looks, Silas is immediately attracted to the lovely, curvy Caraway, but sees how she yearns for Miles. He cannot understand why a woman like her would waste her time with a layabout dandy like Miles, and not see him for what he is. He is also not interested in any kind of relationship with a woman and tamps down his desires, but finds himself pulled to her despite his efforts not to be. When Caraway's heart is broken on finding out Miles is courting another, she runs off to find solace in a privacy, not knowing that Silas has followed her to try to comfort her. They are caught in a compromising situation by their host and other guests and Silas offers marriage to save their reputations. Caraway, realizing she cannot have the love she wants, but still desiring her own household and family, agrees, and she and Silas wed.
They both decide to try to make a go of a real marriage, and they are good for each other, beyond their very compatible physical attraction to each other. Silas worships her physically as the goddess he sees her as, his Little Venus. But he also communicates with her and listens to her ideas, allowing her to be involved in his business dealings and mill, which is more open and forward thinking than many men of the time. But he is jealous of Miles, and feels threatened by her feelings and their past relationship, and this lack of trust undermines their relationship. Also, he is very emotionally shuttered and can become very cold, dismissive, and hurtful. Caraway is easily hurt, and fearful of being hurt further and neither of them are willing to admit their feelings for each other.
Couple this with threats to Silas and Traver's business ventures, and Mile's malicious interventions in their relationship, and this adds too much stress on their fragile relationship and new marriage.
I enjoyed their story. Caraway and Silas are two lonely people who desire to be loved. Caraway has a large heart and loving family, and wants to have what her sisters have. She realizes that what she felt for Miles was a silly girlish fantasy and sees that Silas is a good man who needs to be loved. Silas wants to be loved too, but may not be open to this, considering how he was raised. I am not sure what happened to his mother - I presume she died? However, considering what a cold, dismissive, hostile, prideful, jealous, insulting heartless mound of horse turds his father turned out to be, I would not be surprised if she just up and left him. Unfortunately he was left to raise the young Silas, who obviously resented his father, but also learned to emulate him at times, despite craving love and warmth. Daddy Riverton makes early Ebenezer Scrooge seem like he was full of humorous, generous bonhomie!
It is fine to whack off some limbs of the old family tree - especially the dead, rotten, diseased branches that could harm the rest of the tree.
I have enjoyed many of Jemma Frost's story and quite enjoyed this one as well. At times the language was a bit too modern and more American than I would expect from Victorian England, but otherwise a good read, with two main characters I quite enjoyed, with a nice balance of steamy romance and drama.
4 stars out of 5
This is the story about he eldest of the Garden Girls, older sister and caregiver of the family, Caraway. This story has many themes - curvy, shy, wallflower with low self esteem, a bit of grumpy sunshine, age gap, girlhood crush...
Caraway is an almost 30 year old spinster who had been caring for her sister for years - almost decades. But now that they have found love and are all forming their own families, she finds she is alone at their family cottage, no longer having to worry and care for them. She yearns for more in her life, possibly even a love of her own. She was not popular as a debutante the one time she was presented, and thinks she is too plump and plain to attract a husband. But she is hopeful, as she has had a crush on their neighbour, Owen, the Earl of Trent's childhood friend, Miles Brandon, for years. She thinks that he, having shown signs of closeness and friendship for her in the past, could be nudged into loving her and marrying her, if she gets a chance to show him what a good wife she could be.
When she finds out that he is in Manchester on business, she decides to visit her sister Hazel and her husband, Jonathan Trent, thinking she could spend time with Miles. Travers is building successful business ventures, and is onto a new investment involving a mill with innovative ideas and management. He is involved with another local successful mill owner, Silas Riverton, a brusque, taciturn older man with no use for emotions and relationships, as his father had taught him. Miles demonstrated interest in investing, and was brought in despite his lack of true interest in the effort and workings of the business. But this gives Caraway the chances to spend time with him, and Silas socially.
Despite Caraway's low opinion of her looks, Silas is immediately attracted to the lovely, curvy Caraway, but sees how she yearns for Miles. He cannot understand why a woman like her would waste her time with a layabout dandy like Miles, and not see him for what he is. He is also not interested in any kind of relationship with a woman and tamps down his desires, but finds himself pulled to her despite his efforts not to be. When Caraway's heart is broken on finding out Miles is courting another, she runs off to find solace in a privacy, not knowing that Silas has followed her to try to comfort her. They are caught in a compromising situation by their host and other guests and Silas offers marriage to save their reputations. Caraway, realizing she cannot have the love she wants, but still desiring her own household and family, agrees, and she and Silas wed.
They both decide to try to make a go of a real marriage, and they are good for each other, beyond their very compatible physical attraction to each other. Silas worships her physically as the goddess he sees her as, his Little Venus. But he also communicates with her and listens to her ideas, allowing her to be involved in his business dealings and mill, which is more open and forward thinking than many men of the time. But he is jealous of Miles, and feels threatened by her feelings and their past relationship, and this lack of trust undermines their relationship. Also, he is very emotionally shuttered and can become very cold, dismissive, and hurtful. Caraway is easily hurt, and fearful of being hurt further and neither of them are willing to admit their feelings for each other.
Couple this with threats to Silas and Traver's business ventures, and Mile's malicious interventions in their relationship, and this adds too much stress on their fragile relationship and new marriage.
I enjoyed their story. Caraway and Silas are two lonely people who desire to be loved. Caraway has a large heart and loving family, and wants to have what her sisters have. She realizes that what she felt for Miles was a silly girlish fantasy and sees that Silas is a good man who needs to be loved. Silas wants to be loved too, but may not be open to this, considering how he was raised. I am not sure what happened to his mother - I presume she died? However, considering what a cold, dismissive, hostile, prideful, jealous, insulting heartless mound of horse turds his father turned out to be, I would not be surprised if she just up and left him. Unfortunately he was left to raise the young Silas, who obviously resented his father, but also learned to emulate him at times, despite craving love and warmth. Daddy Riverton makes early Ebenezer Scrooge seem like he was full of humorous, generous bonhomie!
It is fine to whack off some limbs of the old family tree - especially the dead, rotten, diseased branches that could harm the rest of the tree.
I have enjoyed many of Jemma Frost's story and quite enjoyed this one as well. At times the language was a bit too modern and more American than I would expect from Victorian England, but otherwise a good read, with two main characters I quite enjoyed, with a nice balance of steamy romance and drama.
4 stars out of 5
June 19, 2023
With her three sisters married and families of there own, Caraway Taylor, the oldest of the Garden Girls, is still unmarried. The man she has pined for since childhood, has yet to make an offer. At thirty, Caraway is determined to take the next opportunity to catch his attention. Instead she finds herself in a compromised position with an older man, Silas Riverton. Silas is a very successful businessman and carries his own demons from growing up with a cold, unloving father. Attracted to Caraway, he wants her for his wife, even though another man stands between them. Their compatibility in the bedroom isn't the problem, it's the outside forces of insecurity and interference in the shaky foundation of their marriage. At times extremely sad and heartbreaking, it's one of my favorite tropes with an older couple struggling to find love.
Descriptive extreme heat!
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book.
Descriptive extreme heat!
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book.
June 24, 2023
I confess I would not read this book because I found the previous ones average, but I read some reviews and ended up changing my mind, And honestly, I don't know why.
Very long, always repeating the same things over and over again and I was already fed up with "little Venus"!
The pearl part was really... different...
The epilogue which was pretty cute, but overall, for me, it was an average book.
Very long, always repeating the same things over and over again and I was already fed up with "little Venus"!
The pearl part was really... different...
The epilogue which was pretty cute, but overall, for me, it was an average book.
June 27, 2023
This totally would’ve been a 5 star read if it hadn’t been the unnecessary and gross details of the hero’s putrid, grotesque manwhore past. I don’t know why authors insist on writing heroes with overused syphilitic dicks as if this somehow brings the swoon. It doesn’t. Std-traps aren’t sexy or admirable and I’m tired of reading about heroes who indiscriminately stick their dicks into whatever skank will spread their legs for them as if this is somehow an accomplishment.
And for a man who is supposedly cold and controlled the whole aspect of him sliming from whore to whore kinda reflects a serious lack of self-control. I wish authors would be consistent in their characterization.
It’s a pity because this would’ve been a wonderful book otherwise. The emotional connection and intensity between the MCs was palpable. The heroine has believed herself in love with a childhood friend since childhood and she has been unable to move past that childhood crush. Her longing for a family and to find a place of belonging was heart wrenching and her plucky attempts to forge a better future for herself, one in which she could have a family, was admirable.
The road to the MCs HEA was a bit bumpy as the specter of the heroines unrequited crush often loomed in the background. Thankfully there was never any intimacy between the heroine and OM, and she eventually realizes that what she felt wasn’t love for him, but a desire for love.
Safe-ish. Hero’s past is mentioned as nauseum to the point I was nauseated. Heroine is a virgin and belongs only to her hero. Lots of OM drama, but no sexual intimacy of any kind between them. No cheating, no sharing, no abuse. HEA with epilogue
And for a man who is supposedly cold and controlled the whole aspect of him sliming from whore to whore kinda reflects a serious lack of self-control. I wish authors would be consistent in their characterization.
It’s a pity because this would’ve been a wonderful book otherwise. The emotional connection and intensity between the MCs was palpable. The heroine has believed herself in love with a childhood friend since childhood and she has been unable to move past that childhood crush. Her longing for a family and to find a place of belonging was heart wrenching and her plucky attempts to forge a better future for herself, one in which she could have a family, was admirable.
The road to the MCs HEA was a bit bumpy as the specter of the heroines unrequited crush often loomed in the background. Thankfully there was never any intimacy between the heroine and OM, and she eventually realizes that what she felt wasn’t love for him, but a desire for love.
Safe-ish. Hero’s past is mentioned as nauseum to the point I was nauseated. Heroine is a virgin and belongs only to her hero. Lots of OM drama, but no sexual intimacy of any kind between them. No cheating, no sharing, no abuse. HEA with epilogue
September 28, 2023
Wonderful story written around a couples passion for love and family life. Silas and Caraway ( I love her name by the way) are truly two people that I was so happy to come together. The story is based on a older couple who has come together by a forced marriage. I think that Caraway should be very pleased to have a husband come home every night wanted to bed her. I know that I would. I really enjoyed the story process of sharing the many ups and downs with Silas and his Venus. The story has its realistic elements when came to family and their ever persistent nature of knowing each others personal business and added non needed advice. It’s these moments that I thought that rather entertaining. Silas is my favorite character, because of his dominance throughout the book. His mark was Caraway and he didn’t stop working for her until he got her, but that’s were his mistake began. Caraway realized this and used that to her advantage. I enjoyed this romantic love story and I look forward to reading more. I give this story two snaps and a twist. Until next time my fellow readers. Read on! I received a copy of this book from the author in exchange for an honest review.
#AGentlemanNeverSurrenders #JemmaFrost #Goodreads #Bookbub #Booksprout
#AGentlemanNeverSurrenders #JemmaFrost #Goodreads #Bookbub #Booksprout
June 23, 2023
I enjoyed this read but I found it less engaging than her other books.
June 8, 2023
I received an ARC of this book from the author via Booksprout. Apparently, it’s the last in the Garden Girls series. I haven’t read any other books in this series, but since this is a standalone, that’s okay. That said, I’d like to. The other sisters appear in this book, now happily married and starting families. We come to understand that, as the oldest, Caraway always put the needs of her sisters first. Now, nearing thirty, she feels lonely and disappointed in the course her life has taken. Recalling a childhood friend who once expressed an interest in her, she has now built him up to god-like heights of perfection and vows to pursue and remind him of his ‘promises’ to her. In truth, Miles is just a flirt and meant nothing by his comments to her, as she is soon to find out.
Meanwhile, she is introduced to Silas, a man fifteen years older than her, austere and cold in his manner, and much to his own surprise, inexplicably drawn to her. She has always considered herself plain while he views her as the most beautiful woman he has ever seen. Pretty quickly, he recognizes that she is enamored with Miles and he is loathe to admit, even to himself, that he is jealous. More than anything, he can see that Miles is a thoughtless flirt and dandy, and he wishes he could make Caraway see that—so that she might focus on him instead.
After Miles blithely announces he is courting a younger woman, Caraway is broken-hearted and excuses herself to a private room to grieve. Silas, knowing what she is feeling, follows her and suggests he can distract her from her unwarranted attraction to Miles. The kiss is witnessed by the hosts of the party and they are compelled to marry to avoid scandal. Caraway holds out hope that Miles will propose at the last minute and save her, but when he speaks to her, it’s only to suggest he once thought they’d end up together but now circumstances have taken them in different directions so, whatevs. By now, it’s becoming clear that he is narcissistic and manipulative (redundant, I know). He wants to hold onto Caraway’s ‘love’ for him, even as he courts another.
Feeling she has little choice, she agrees to marry Silas—even though she had hoped to marry for love—comforting herself that, at least, they are physically compatible. Since Silas never expected to marry at all, and certainly not for love, he is perfectly happy to wed a woman for whom he feels a strong sexual attraction. That’s the setup. Their story truly begins once Caraway and Silas are married, as each tries to protect their hearts from hurt by keeping their relationship superficial.
It’s not an entirely new story, but it’s told well and it has different components and different reasons for why they each protect their hearts. Caraway has low self-esteem and doesn’t believe Silas truly finds her attractive. She also harbors affection for Miles, although she would never act on that attraction now that she has promised herself to Silas. Silas, raised by a self-centered, money-oriented, and nasty father, has never known love. The first sign he might be in love is the jealousy he feels toward Miles. Unfortunately, as is often the case, jealousy compels him to do some unwise things. It isn’t until he stops demanding Caraway’s heart that he receives it. And because he has long been emotionless and cold, it isn’t until he admits his love for her that she feels safe admitting she loves him as well.
There are some anxiety-producing occurrences in the story that will have you yelling, “No!” Caraway is a bit more trusting than might be considered safe, having little notion of how to protect herself. For Silas, it’s usually his jealousy that causes problems. When they finally reach the understanding that their marriage is actually based on love, the HEA ensues. Because the story delves into low self-esteem and how it can be covered by caring for others, as well as fear of intimacy that can be covered by aloofness, this isn’t a simple romance. It addresses issues that affect all of us at one time or another. Reading how Caraway and Silas overcome their weaknesses can be an inspiration for others to do the same. In its totality, I found it to be an enjoyable and relatable story.
Meanwhile, she is introduced to Silas, a man fifteen years older than her, austere and cold in his manner, and much to his own surprise, inexplicably drawn to her. She has always considered herself plain while he views her as the most beautiful woman he has ever seen. Pretty quickly, he recognizes that she is enamored with Miles and he is loathe to admit, even to himself, that he is jealous. More than anything, he can see that Miles is a thoughtless flirt and dandy, and he wishes he could make Caraway see that—so that she might focus on him instead.
After Miles blithely announces he is courting a younger woman, Caraway is broken-hearted and excuses herself to a private room to grieve. Silas, knowing what she is feeling, follows her and suggests he can distract her from her unwarranted attraction to Miles. The kiss is witnessed by the hosts of the party and they are compelled to marry to avoid scandal. Caraway holds out hope that Miles will propose at the last minute and save her, but when he speaks to her, it’s only to suggest he once thought they’d end up together but now circumstances have taken them in different directions so, whatevs. By now, it’s becoming clear that he is narcissistic and manipulative (redundant, I know). He wants to hold onto Caraway’s ‘love’ for him, even as he courts another.
Feeling she has little choice, she agrees to marry Silas—even though she had hoped to marry for love—comforting herself that, at least, they are physically compatible. Since Silas never expected to marry at all, and certainly not for love, he is perfectly happy to wed a woman for whom he feels a strong sexual attraction. That’s the setup. Their story truly begins once Caraway and Silas are married, as each tries to protect their hearts from hurt by keeping their relationship superficial.
It’s not an entirely new story, but it’s told well and it has different components and different reasons for why they each protect their hearts. Caraway has low self-esteem and doesn’t believe Silas truly finds her attractive. She also harbors affection for Miles, although she would never act on that attraction now that she has promised herself to Silas. Silas, raised by a self-centered, money-oriented, and nasty father, has never known love. The first sign he might be in love is the jealousy he feels toward Miles. Unfortunately, as is often the case, jealousy compels him to do some unwise things. It isn’t until he stops demanding Caraway’s heart that he receives it. And because he has long been emotionless and cold, it isn’t until he admits his love for her that she feels safe admitting she loves him as well.
There are some anxiety-producing occurrences in the story that will have you yelling, “No!” Caraway is a bit more trusting than might be considered safe, having little notion of how to protect herself. For Silas, it’s usually his jealousy that causes problems. When they finally reach the understanding that their marriage is actually based on love, the HEA ensues. Because the story delves into low self-esteem and how it can be covered by caring for others, as well as fear of intimacy that can be covered by aloofness, this isn’t a simple romance. It addresses issues that affect all of us at one time or another. Reading how Caraway and Silas overcome their weaknesses can be an inspiration for others to do the same. In its totality, I found it to be an enjoyable and relatable story.
June 8, 2023
This is an amazing story between two very different people. Miles and Caraway were raised in very different ways. Caraway had loving but absent parents as both were botanists and spent their days leaning and working with plants. They loved their children but were easily lost in their books. They had three girls, Caraway is the oldest, then Hazel, Lily and their cousin Iris. Caraway was known for being practical and mature at a young age. She was responsible for pretty much raising the younger girls. Seeing to them doing their lesson and chores. Sias on the other hand was raised by a father who only thought was his status in the ton and making money. Emotions were not allowed and no love or affection given. After their parent are killed in an accident, she is all they had. Now with all the girls grown and married, Caraway is nearing thirty and feeling alone in the empty family cottage. She decides to go visit her sister and try to rekindle with her childhood crush. Miles, was nice to her when they were younger and she has built up the time with him into a love match in her mind. Unfortunately, Miles is not the man she thinks he is. She decides to go and visit her sister, Lily and her husband Owen. It will be the perfect place to run into Miles and show him what he is missing. Owen tries to warn her too about Miles and to be careful. She meets Owen partner and friend Silas, a big, stern looking man with dark eyes. For reasons she can’t figure out she is strangely drawn to him and his dark beard. Silas is shocked by what he is thinking after meeting Owen’s sister-in-law. Most women would not want a hard man like him. He is known for getting rid of his frustrations with bare knuckle boxing and lose woman. At forty-five he has never been as attracted to a woman before. Caraway is short and curvy in all the right places with lovely dark brown curls too. At the first ball she attends with her sister and brother-in-law he announces his engagement to other. Heartbroken she escapes to an empty room to try recover. Silas follows her and after a heated kiss they are caught in a scandal! Forced to marry to save her reputation both are at wits end how to make this work. These two have so much stacked against them. Both are smitten with the other, and she is knows what is expected of her as a wife. They have much to overcome, with Miles the third person in their new life. Caraway can’t seem to let her feeling for him go. So much emotion, passion, misunderstanding and secrets. Also, a villain out to ruin their business too. So many twists and turns once you start reading you can’t put it down. You will cry, want to slap them both to wake up and cheer them on too. Wow what a read. Sorry, this is so long but I didn’t know how to shorten it. This is one of the best books I’ve read this year and I read a lot. You don’t want to miss this one. I received and ARC from the author and wish to thank her. This is my honest opinion and am freely given it.
June 15, 2023
A Gentleman Never Surrenders by Jemma Frost is the first book that I read by this author. It is the conclusion in her Garden Girls series. While it was fine as a standalone book, I was intrigued enough by the characters that I went and got the previous 3 books and the prequel so that I could read from the beginning. And I will reread this book after I finish the other 4.
We first meet Caraway Taylor and her crush Miles Brandon in the prologue and so a reader could be forgiven thinking this book would be about them. Fast-forward fourteen, almost fifteen years and we see Caraway living alone in the family cottage as her sisters have all moved away and married. Caraway (Cara) is still pining for Miles and decides to follow him to Manchester to prove that she was worthy of him as his wife. Cara goes to stay with her youngest sister and while there we meet Silas Riverton, a factory owner in business with her brother-in-law.
From the minute that Silas appeared on the page, I stood up and took notice, sort of like Cara does, although she was much more discreet. Silas was the product of a harsh upbringing, as his father showed no love or affection, and we get the feeling that he felt unlovable. He was immediately attracted to Cara, or his Venus as he liked to call her. Miles proves to be unworthy as he breaks her heart and Cara is subsequently compromised, forcing her to marry Silas to save her reputation.
The author does a wonderful job of showing the push-me-pull-me dynamic between Silas and Cara. Both are craving love, the need to feel wanted and cared for, yet Silas is sometimes held hostage to his upbringing and Cara to her stubborn belief that Miles was who she wanted. Add the reappearance of Silas’ father (nasty piece), issues with the factory as someone is trying to sabotage the progressive changes Silas is trying to put in place for workers both at his factory and the new one, he is opening with Cara’s brother-in-law, and you have some moments that I both wanted to shake them and hug them at the same time. Ms. Frost really brought the characters to life for me. I really liked them; my heart broke with them and at times I was frustrated with them as they were frustrated with each other. To me that is what makes me fall in love with a story.
I loved the family relationship of the Garden Girls, the friendships and I really loved the awakening of trust and love between Cara and Silas, while admitting where they may have gone wrong. I highly recommend this book and in fact the whole series as I have gone back to read the prequel. While this may have been my first book by Jemma Frost, it won’t be the last. Oh, and there is definitely steam between the couple, which in my opinion is never a bad thing!
I received an ARC of A Gentleman Never Surrenders by Jemma Frost from Booksprout and voluntarily read the book.
We first meet Caraway Taylor and her crush Miles Brandon in the prologue and so a reader could be forgiven thinking this book would be about them. Fast-forward fourteen, almost fifteen years and we see Caraway living alone in the family cottage as her sisters have all moved away and married. Caraway (Cara) is still pining for Miles and decides to follow him to Manchester to prove that she was worthy of him as his wife. Cara goes to stay with her youngest sister and while there we meet Silas Riverton, a factory owner in business with her brother-in-law.
From the minute that Silas appeared on the page, I stood up and took notice, sort of like Cara does, although she was much more discreet. Silas was the product of a harsh upbringing, as his father showed no love or affection, and we get the feeling that he felt unlovable. He was immediately attracted to Cara, or his Venus as he liked to call her. Miles proves to be unworthy as he breaks her heart and Cara is subsequently compromised, forcing her to marry Silas to save her reputation.
The author does a wonderful job of showing the push-me-pull-me dynamic between Silas and Cara. Both are craving love, the need to feel wanted and cared for, yet Silas is sometimes held hostage to his upbringing and Cara to her stubborn belief that Miles was who she wanted. Add the reappearance of Silas’ father (nasty piece), issues with the factory as someone is trying to sabotage the progressive changes Silas is trying to put in place for workers both at his factory and the new one, he is opening with Cara’s brother-in-law, and you have some moments that I both wanted to shake them and hug them at the same time. Ms. Frost really brought the characters to life for me. I really liked them; my heart broke with them and at times I was frustrated with them as they were frustrated with each other. To me that is what makes me fall in love with a story.
I loved the family relationship of the Garden Girls, the friendships and I really loved the awakening of trust and love between Cara and Silas, while admitting where they may have gone wrong. I highly recommend this book and in fact the whole series as I have gone back to read the prequel. While this may have been my first book by Jemma Frost, it won’t be the last. Oh, and there is definitely steam between the couple, which in my opinion is never a bad thing!
I received an ARC of A Gentleman Never Surrenders by Jemma Frost from Booksprout and voluntarily read the book.
June 14, 2023
🌸 TikTok || Instagram 🌸
─────────────────────⋇⊶⊰❣⊱⊷⋇─────────────────────
Story 📖📖📖
Depth 💔💔💔
Steam 🔥🔥.5
Spice 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️+
Comm. 🗣️🗣️🗣️.5
Growth 💗💗💗
Overall ⭐⭐⭐.5
A Gentleman Never Surrenders certainly holds up it claim to be a steamy Victorian romance, with no less than five wonderful spicy love scenes involving our main characters. But while it delivers in terms of eroticism, it drags in its story.
Silas is a debonair older businessman, in charge of his own mill and pushing for changes to better both the workers and production. By his own admission, he is a man who doesn't show much emotion and works diligently to maintain a controlled façade. However, once our heroine Caraway comes into play, everything goes out the window. Caraway, the oldest of four sisters, is now on her own with his sisters all married, and finding herself feeling lonely. Not wanting to remain a spinster, she absolves to become the woman her childhood crush would want to marry.
Silas and Caraways are characterized fairly early on, as well as additional characters meant to drive the plot. But somewhere around 45-50% the story begins to wander and certain key moments that should have been major scenes in the plot end up nothing more than two or three sentences in passing. The Childhood Crush is a huge point of contention between Silas and Caraway but his actual actions throughout the books feel forced. While the attraction between the mains was evident, I felt that there was a lack of actual tension to explain their chemistry and ramp up their desires.
There were a number of miscommunications were resolved early and quickly, but they kept happening, to an unnecessary point. There's also a "nefarious villain" plot that pops up so late it was a bit overkill. I would have preferred a combination of Big Miscommunication leading up to Nefarious Villain Scheme that then gives our characters a chance to resolve, instead of the roller coaster that went on a bit too long.
Altogether it just wasn't something that stood out to me as a memorable story. The spicy was genuinely well written, with some seriously creative moments that will live definitely rent free, I just wish there was more tension.
─────────────────────⋇⊶⊰❣⊱⊷⋇─────────────────────
Thank you to BookSprout and Jemma Frost for this ARC; all thoughts are my own and shared willingly.
─────────────────────⋇⊶⊰❣⊱⊷⋇─────────────────────
Story 📖📖📖
Depth 💔💔💔
Steam 🔥🔥.5
Spice 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️+
Comm. 🗣️🗣️🗣️.5
Growth 💗💗💗
Overall ⭐⭐⭐.5
A Gentleman Never Surrenders certainly holds up it claim to be a steamy Victorian romance, with no less than five wonderful spicy love scenes involving our main characters. But while it delivers in terms of eroticism, it drags in its story.
Silas is a debonair older businessman, in charge of his own mill and pushing for changes to better both the workers and production. By his own admission, he is a man who doesn't show much emotion and works diligently to maintain a controlled façade. However, once our heroine Caraway comes into play, everything goes out the window. Caraway, the oldest of four sisters, is now on her own with his sisters all married, and finding herself feeling lonely. Not wanting to remain a spinster, she absolves to become the woman her childhood crush would want to marry.
Silas and Caraways are characterized fairly early on, as well as additional characters meant to drive the plot. But somewhere around 45-50% the story begins to wander and certain key moments that should have been major scenes in the plot end up nothing more than two or three sentences in passing. The Childhood Crush is a huge point of contention between Silas and Caraway but his actual actions throughout the books feel forced. While the attraction between the mains was evident, I felt that there was a lack of actual tension to explain their chemistry and ramp up their desires.
There were a number of miscommunications were resolved early and quickly, but they kept happening, to an unnecessary point. There's also a "nefarious villain" plot that pops up so late it was a bit overkill. I would have preferred a combination of Big Miscommunication leading up to Nefarious Villain Scheme that then gives our characters a chance to resolve, instead of the roller coaster that went on a bit too long.
Altogether it just wasn't something that stood out to me as a memorable story. The spicy was genuinely well written, with some seriously creative moments that will live definitely rent free, I just wish there was more tension.
─────────────────────⋇⊶⊰❣⊱⊷⋇─────────────────────
Thank you to BookSprout and Jemma Frost for this ARC; all thoughts are my own and shared willingly.
June 11, 2023
Having raised her three younger sisters and seeing them happily wed, Caraway Taylor feels she should finally go after her childhood crush. A visit to her sister in Manchester is in order. Overcome by emotion when she learn the man set his cap after an heiress, she runs out at a ball followed by her brother-in-law’s business partner. Only to be found in a compromising kiss moments later.
Wedding the man seems inevitable. Her husband turns out attentive, open to her ideas for improving the workers conditions in his factory and scandalously delicious. Her heart torn between the present and the past. Who would love a plain and plump spinster anyway?
Manchester cotton mill owner Silas Riverton is a cold man who finds his release in boxing and meaningless trysts. But when his business partner’s sister-in-law comes for a visit, he finds himself completely taken by the little sensuous, curvaceous goddess.
Compromising her might not have been the greatest start, but she’s bossy, clever and completely irresistible. When malicious talk causes trouble at the factory and his newest project, she stands strong by his side. Hidden emotions rise to the surface. Jealousy an unwanted companion in their frail relationship. Can he conquer them? Can he conquer her?
📚 Theirs is a passionate and tumultuous love story. He’s never known love, comfort and warmth, and she’s the forgotten sister struggling with low self-esteem. Watching them deal with their own weaknesses, growing together with ups and downs, and eventually learning they perfectly complete each other, is a thing of beauty. So well-written! Captivating, touching, naughty and sweet with family and resilience at the centre of it all. On top of that a bit of mystery and a rather unexpected bad guy. This was a fascinating read! Definitely worth it!
📚 Possessive hero, curvy heroine, steamy, open door, age gap 45/30, unrequited love
Thank you to Jemma Frost, The Arrowed Heart and Booksprout for this eARC. All opinions expressed are my own.
Wedding the man seems inevitable. Her husband turns out attentive, open to her ideas for improving the workers conditions in his factory and scandalously delicious. Her heart torn between the present and the past. Who would love a plain and plump spinster anyway?
Manchester cotton mill owner Silas Riverton is a cold man who finds his release in boxing and meaningless trysts. But when his business partner’s sister-in-law comes for a visit, he finds himself completely taken by the little sensuous, curvaceous goddess.
Compromising her might not have been the greatest start, but she’s bossy, clever and completely irresistible. When malicious talk causes trouble at the factory and his newest project, she stands strong by his side. Hidden emotions rise to the surface. Jealousy an unwanted companion in their frail relationship. Can he conquer them? Can he conquer her?
📚 Theirs is a passionate and tumultuous love story. He’s never known love, comfort and warmth, and she’s the forgotten sister struggling with low self-esteem. Watching them deal with their own weaknesses, growing together with ups and downs, and eventually learning they perfectly complete each other, is a thing of beauty. So well-written! Captivating, touching, naughty and sweet with family and resilience at the centre of it all. On top of that a bit of mystery and a rather unexpected bad guy. This was a fascinating read! Definitely worth it!
📚 Possessive hero, curvy heroine, steamy, open door, age gap 45/30, unrequited love
Thank you to Jemma Frost, The Arrowed Heart and Booksprout for this eARC. All opinions expressed are my own.
June 14, 2023
Caraway is the oldest daughter and after her parents deaths she took care of her younger sisters, who are all married now. She was always quiet, and not as attractive as her sisters, and resigned herself to be the spinster Aunt, but reconsiders and decides to go after Miles, the man she has admired since childhood.
She goes to stay with her sister since she knows her husband is friends with Miles and she’ll have an opportunity to put her plan into action. She also meets Silas Riverton, a successful businessman and business partner with her brother-in-law.
Silas is immediately attracted to Cara but he notices her flirtation and interest in Miles. When Miles, announces his courtship to another young lady, she is devastated and leaves the gathering to be alone. Silas follows her and they are found in a compromising position and marriage is the only alternative to save her reputation. Cara is furious as she feels all options have been taken away from her by Silas and reluctantly agrees to marrying him.
To say, their marriage starts off rocking is an understatement, but Silas truly cares for her, which she doesn’t believe, she has trouble letting go of her resentment towards him. They settle into their marriage, she is a help to him in his business, he respects her ideas, their physical relationship is steamy, and in time they grow close.
Silas was a bit controlling, and jealous but the depth of his feelings for Cara was astonishing, I was frustrated with Cara for her immaturity in thinking she could feel so much for Silas physically but not be falling in love with him, and how long it took her to see Miles for the man he was and that Silas was the right man for her.
I enjoyed this story very much, it was well written, filled with misunderstandings, an unexpected villain, a myriad of emotions, steamy love scenes, and two people who had to let go of their insecurities, and doubts to find happiness together.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
She goes to stay with her sister since she knows her husband is friends with Miles and she’ll have an opportunity to put her plan into action. She also meets Silas Riverton, a successful businessman and business partner with her brother-in-law.
Silas is immediately attracted to Cara but he notices her flirtation and interest in Miles. When Miles, announces his courtship to another young lady, she is devastated and leaves the gathering to be alone. Silas follows her and they are found in a compromising position and marriage is the only alternative to save her reputation. Cara is furious as she feels all options have been taken away from her by Silas and reluctantly agrees to marrying him.
To say, their marriage starts off rocking is an understatement, but Silas truly cares for her, which she doesn’t believe, she has trouble letting go of her resentment towards him. They settle into their marriage, she is a help to him in his business, he respects her ideas, their physical relationship is steamy, and in time they grow close.
Silas was a bit controlling, and jealous but the depth of his feelings for Cara was astonishing, I was frustrated with Cara for her immaturity in thinking she could feel so much for Silas physically but not be falling in love with him, and how long it took her to see Miles for the man he was and that Silas was the right man for her.
I enjoyed this story very much, it was well written, filled with misunderstandings, an unexpected villain, a myriad of emotions, steamy love scenes, and two people who had to let go of their insecurities, and doubts to find happiness together.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
June 16, 2023
Has Fate Intervened ? . . .
Caraway Taylor is the oldest of her sisters and at her age is considered to be a spinster. When she visited her sister Hazel, who was delayed meeting her as she dealt with her son Callum, her brother-in-law remembers to introduce her to a northern factory owner, Silas Riverton. He seems to flirt with her a little, but she is certain she is mistaken since no man really takes such notice of her.
Caraway had always longed for Miles Brandon and never gave up hope… at least not until she found at the ball she attended that he was courting Miss Bradshaw! Silas was also there and would have asked her to dance at that moment, but she ran off and he followed her as he noticed the tears. She dashed into an empty room but the door opened behind her. Silas told her Brandon did not deserve her tears. He gently wiped the tears from her cheeks, then he asked if she would like to forget Brandon, at least for the moment – and he kissed her lips, her first ever! He wrapped his arms around her and pulled her closer as she stood there in shock. Then suddenly they were interrupted by Lord and Lady Gibbons, the ball’s hosts. Jonathan and Caraway’s sister Hazel ran in and apologized for being a few moments late meeting them, trying to protect Caraway’s reputation, assuring the onlookers that nothing could have happened being alone with a man for those few moments. Jonathan assured her that he would make sure that Riverton does right by her, but the thought of marrying him filled her with horror. But she must marry someone quickly or be ruined. And Caraway’s thoughts immediately turned to whether she might convince Brandon to reconsider and marry her. He could be her dashing hero. But he wasn’t. And Silas came by to ask her to marry him, sliding a pearl ring on her finger when she said yes. Can the two of them find happiness with each other? Or will she pine away for Brandon who truly did not deserve either her or her tears?
Caraway Taylor is the oldest of her sisters and at her age is considered to be a spinster. When she visited her sister Hazel, who was delayed meeting her as she dealt with her son Callum, her brother-in-law remembers to introduce her to a northern factory owner, Silas Riverton. He seems to flirt with her a little, but she is certain she is mistaken since no man really takes such notice of her.
Caraway had always longed for Miles Brandon and never gave up hope… at least not until she found at the ball she attended that he was courting Miss Bradshaw! Silas was also there and would have asked her to dance at that moment, but she ran off and he followed her as he noticed the tears. She dashed into an empty room but the door opened behind her. Silas told her Brandon did not deserve her tears. He gently wiped the tears from her cheeks, then he asked if she would like to forget Brandon, at least for the moment – and he kissed her lips, her first ever! He wrapped his arms around her and pulled her closer as she stood there in shock. Then suddenly they were interrupted by Lord and Lady Gibbons, the ball’s hosts. Jonathan and Caraway’s sister Hazel ran in and apologized for being a few moments late meeting them, trying to protect Caraway’s reputation, assuring the onlookers that nothing could have happened being alone with a man for those few moments. Jonathan assured her that he would make sure that Riverton does right by her, but the thought of marrying him filled her with horror. But she must marry someone quickly or be ruined. And Caraway’s thoughts immediately turned to whether she might convince Brandon to reconsider and marry her. He could be her dashing hero. But he wasn’t. And Silas came by to ask her to marry him, sliding a pearl ring on her finger when she said yes. Can the two of them find happiness with each other? Or will she pine away for Brandon who truly did not deserve either her or her tears?
June 16, 2023
This is my first novel from Jemma Frost. Although it is the last book in a series, it was not difficult to follow the Garden Girls' love stories as all of them have found their HEAs in this one & they do make an appearance in this book.
The plot in this book starts as a marriage of convenience to resolve the scandal when the MMC & FMC are found in a compromised situation, but the insta-lust between Cara & Silas develops into a happy marriage. What I really liked is the struggle they both went through, as most authors do not explore this part. It is very real. Sometimes it gets very ugly & hurtful & the author described these scenes very well. The reader could feel all the heartbreak, angst, frustrations & regret from the characters.
Silas, the MMC is an older, yummy hero who boxes his frustrations & has childhood neglect issues being raised by a cold & unlovable father. He is an adorable, broody, jealous hero (I mean her calls her 'goddess mine!' sigh!) who demands little - his wife's care. Cara on the other hand, the glue who held the family, raised her sisters & finds herself lonely & without purpose as an empty-nester. I must say, there were times when I could not like her, her determination & certainty in wanting to marry Miles (scumbag that he is!) is not worthy of Silas. The love scenes, HOT, and Silas brought a new meaning to "pearl clutcher"! However, some of it I found, was quite mechanical without emotions. I still think Silas deserves a better version of Cara.
There is more to this book than romance. There is family ties, business relationship turned personal, babies, improving the working conditions of industrial workers & attempts to derail effort by the characters. All in all a page-turner. I will definitely read the rest in the series!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review. Thank you to Booksprout & Jemma Frost for this ARC!
The plot in this book starts as a marriage of convenience to resolve the scandal when the MMC & FMC are found in a compromised situation, but the insta-lust between Cara & Silas develops into a happy marriage. What I really liked is the struggle they both went through, as most authors do not explore this part. It is very real. Sometimes it gets very ugly & hurtful & the author described these scenes very well. The reader could feel all the heartbreak, angst, frustrations & regret from the characters.
Silas, the MMC is an older, yummy hero who boxes his frustrations & has childhood neglect issues being raised by a cold & unlovable father. He is an adorable, broody, jealous hero (I mean her calls her 'goddess mine!' sigh!) who demands little - his wife's care. Cara on the other hand, the glue who held the family, raised her sisters & finds herself lonely & without purpose as an empty-nester. I must say, there were times when I could not like her, her determination & certainty in wanting to marry Miles (scumbag that he is!) is not worthy of Silas. The love scenes, HOT, and Silas brought a new meaning to "pearl clutcher"! However, some of it I found, was quite mechanical without emotions. I still think Silas deserves a better version of Cara.
There is more to this book than romance. There is family ties, business relationship turned personal, babies, improving the working conditions of industrial workers & attempts to derail effort by the characters. All in all a page-turner. I will definitely read the rest in the series!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review. Thank you to Booksprout & Jemma Frost for this ARC!
June 18, 2023
I love a good marriage of convenience romance, and A Gentleman Never Surrenders goes all in for that. I loved that Silas is so emotionally repressed that he has no clue that he’s basically fallen in love at first sight, while Cara is so invested in the “convenience” part of her marriage of convenience that she can’t recognize what’s right in front of her.
A Gentleman Never Surrenders has wonderful elements—a northern English mill town setting (shades of Gaskill!), a portrayal of the Victorian middle class, and the evolution in mill working conditions. I also loved that Caraway (named for a plant, but let’s get real, all I thought of was the seed!) truly wanted to be a wife and run her own home. But Silas has no idea what a home truly is, so seeing them move gradually into creating something together, including dealing with setbacks, was enthralling.
I had a few quibbles with this book. Silas is supposed to be a man who frequents prostitutes and fights, but that stops almost immediately with no reference to it after he meets Cara (unless it’s convenient for the plot). Cara has a childhood crush that she simply won’t let go of long after I felt she should have, and her crush behaved quite oddly with assumptions that didn’t make sense to me. Other characters were stock villains, practically twirling their proverbial mustaches, and some of their actions didn’t jibe with their societal positions.
But I still had a blast reading this book. When you find a romance that works well with your favorite trope, it’s a joy, and A Gentleman Never Surrenders certainly fit that bill!
A Gentleman Never Surrenders has wonderful elements—a northern English mill town setting (shades of Gaskill!), a portrayal of the Victorian middle class, and the evolution in mill working conditions. I also loved that Caraway (named for a plant, but let’s get real, all I thought of was the seed!) truly wanted to be a wife and run her own home. But Silas has no idea what a home truly is, so seeing them move gradually into creating something together, including dealing with setbacks, was enthralling.
I had a few quibbles with this book. Silas is supposed to be a man who frequents prostitutes and fights, but that stops almost immediately with no reference to it after he meets Cara (unless it’s convenient for the plot). Cara has a childhood crush that she simply won’t let go of long after I felt she should have, and her crush behaved quite oddly with assumptions that didn’t make sense to me. Other characters were stock villains, practically twirling their proverbial mustaches, and some of their actions didn’t jibe with their societal positions.
But I still had a blast reading this book. When you find a romance that works well with your favorite trope, it’s a joy, and A Gentleman Never Surrenders certainly fit that bill!
June 6, 2023
It started out a little slow and I got worried I wasn’t going to enjoy it. When it came to the scene where she started plotting her trip to Manchester to make Miles Brandon fall for her, I had to go back and read the description. That was enough to keep me going.
Good thing too. It’s like a Greek dish, most people probably haven’t heard of it, Cincinnati Chili, it tastes rich and kind of sweet, but then it has this slow burn that catches up to you.
That would be A Gentleman Never Surrenders.
I have to say though, they really could have used marriage counselors who specialized in spousal communication back then. I’ve never laughed or yelled so much at two people misunderstanding each other so much. I mean come on already!?!?!?!?!? How either of them could really think for one hot second that they could have that kind of mind blowing, hot, steamy out of the world sex, and not love their spouse? Well its beyond me how they could be so slow, but it sure did make for entertaining reading!
This is my first book by Jemma Frost but it certainly won’t be my last. I like historical romances, especially the ones that have dominant alpha men in them. Silas definitely liked to the boss. But Jemma did a really good job writing their relationship, Caraway even at 30, was still innocent in many ways that Silas wasn’t. I really enjoyed how she wrote the two of them working together, building a business, making it better, while at the same time building their marriage.
You won’t regret this sweet and steamy novel!
Good thing too. It’s like a Greek dish, most people probably haven’t heard of it, Cincinnati Chili, it tastes rich and kind of sweet, but then it has this slow burn that catches up to you.
That would be A Gentleman Never Surrenders.
I have to say though, they really could have used marriage counselors who specialized in spousal communication back then. I’ve never laughed or yelled so much at two people misunderstanding each other so much. I mean come on already!?!?!?!?!? How either of them could really think for one hot second that they could have that kind of mind blowing, hot, steamy out of the world sex, and not love their spouse? Well its beyond me how they could be so slow, but it sure did make for entertaining reading!
This is my first book by Jemma Frost but it certainly won’t be my last. I like historical romances, especially the ones that have dominant alpha men in them. Silas definitely liked to the boss. But Jemma did a really good job writing their relationship, Caraway even at 30, was still innocent in many ways that Silas wasn’t. I really enjoyed how she wrote the two of them working together, building a business, making it better, while at the same time building their marriage.
You won’t regret this sweet and steamy novel!
June 16, 2023
Such a good story! Cara has been in love with Miles since she was fifteen. Now, at the age of thirty, her sisters are all happily married and she is determined to make him see her as ideal wife material. While staying with her sister Hazel and her brother-in-law Jonathan, Cara puts her plans into action. When her emotions get the best of her after an unpleasant discovery, she finds hereself in a compromising situation with Jonathan’s business partner Silas, and when Miles doesn’t jump to save her reputation, she and Silas marry. And so begins a relationship filled with emotional conflict, uncertainty and lust. Textile mills, innovation and the proper treatment of employees all act as the backdrop for this story. They also provide a vehicle for Cara and Silas to bond. Silas, the rough and tough pugilist, has a hard time saying no to Cara, and implements some of her unconventional ideas. It is fun to watch her bring out a different side of him.…but any way you look at him, he’s a hot ticket! This story includes three villians, all of whom I wanted to shake or smack. Clearly I was not alone in this, as at some point Silas did that for me. There is a lot going on in this tale, some above and some below the surface, but all of it is essential. I found this to be an exciting, emotionally charged story with wonderful characters, lots of challenges, lusty scenes and a few surprises. Loved it!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
June 14, 2023
No one writes rough, coarse, unrefined, but oh so passionate heroes like Jemma Frost! She’s the Queen of self-made, strong and swoon-worthy men with a touch of a**holery!
I loved Silas, but I loved even more that he is 45 and has never fallen in love… until now! I really gushed over him and I felt for him and his cold childhood. On the contrary I was kind of annoyed with Caraway for most of the book for her obsession for her youthful crush despite everyone telling her what an unreliable person he really was. She certainly took her time to see reason! Yes, in this aspect I would have trimmed the book a little bit, because I really hated seeing the push and pull between the main characters. But I gather that the slow burn (meaning the slow falling in love, because the steamy chemistry between them is there from the start, thanks heaven!) was necessary. They didn’t know each other at all and Silas certainly came across as cold and unfeeling, while Caraway seemed the typical elder sister/know-all, despite feeling much less confident than what she appeared. So some time to adjust was certainly in order. But maybe not so much… Anyway, the book is a five-star read all the same and the emotional lovemaking between the two is worth all the angst! On to new gorgeous books, Jemma Frost!
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I loved Silas, but I loved even more that he is 45 and has never fallen in love… until now! I really gushed over him and I felt for him and his cold childhood. On the contrary I was kind of annoyed with Caraway for most of the book for her obsession for her youthful crush despite everyone telling her what an unreliable person he really was. She certainly took her time to see reason! Yes, in this aspect I would have trimmed the book a little bit, because I really hated seeing the push and pull between the main characters. But I gather that the slow burn (meaning the slow falling in love, because the steamy chemistry between them is there from the start, thanks heaven!) was necessary. They didn’t know each other at all and Silas certainly came across as cold and unfeeling, while Caraway seemed the typical elder sister/know-all, despite feeling much less confident than what she appeared. So some time to adjust was certainly in order. But maybe not so much… Anyway, the book is a five-star read all the same and the emotional lovemaking between the two is worth all the angst! On to new gorgeous books, Jemma Frost!
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
March 25, 2024
A well written, enduring and steamy story about love, friends and family. This is a story about people, not Dukes or Lords or Earls. Silas Riverton is a man of business, not a Lord or Duke. He has worked hard, played hard, and has make his way as a successful businessman. He has forward-thinking ideas on how factory workers should be treated, and he finds himself a threat to some factory owners who are not willing to change. His upbringing by a harsh father, cruel and overbearing results in very strained relationship. Caraway Taylor is a sister-in-law to his friend and partner Jonathan Travers. She is visiting and is planning a strategy to win the heart of a childhood friend, Brandon. There is concern in the family that Caraway’s passion may be misplaced. The path to love is not always straight forward and she and Silas become entwined. Caraway brings with her intelligence, warmth, and the ability to reach out and identify issues and find solutions. She is forward-thinking and complements Silas and his partner’s plans for their factories. Both Sila and Caraway stumble along the way, obstacles must be managed, trust must be developed, and love ensues. I really loved this book; the characters were well developed and their growth and commitment to each other and their marriage was heartwarming. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
June 12, 2023
I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.
This was my first time reading Jemma Frost and I am asking myself (with all the HR's I've read over the years) how can that be?!? I REALLY liked her writing style and I enjoyed this book so much! Obviously haven't read any of the others in the Garden Girls series but this one can be read as a stand alone.
I LOVED the North & South vibes of this book! I enjoyed both the main characters - so many misunderstandings as these two try to make their marriage work. I really had a soft spot for Silas Riverton - poor man was basically alone his whole life and his father was abjectly horrible (almost ridiculously so) - I groaned and moaned so many times in sympathy for him as he learned how to open up and be a person.
Caraway was a sweet character and they were cute together. She made some bad decisions regarding the 'love triangle' storyline so I was very glad she came to her senses, learned some hard truths and admitted them to herself before I had to start hating her. Stop hurting Silas! There were a few hints around power dynamics in their relationship that I wish were further explored - particularly in the marriage bed.
Now please excuse me while I go and add Jemma Frost's whole catalogue to my MUST READ list.
This was my first time reading Jemma Frost and I am asking myself (with all the HR's I've read over the years) how can that be?!? I REALLY liked her writing style and I enjoyed this book so much! Obviously haven't read any of the others in the Garden Girls series but this one can be read as a stand alone.
I LOVED the North & South vibes of this book! I enjoyed both the main characters - so many misunderstandings as these two try to make their marriage work. I really had a soft spot for Silas Riverton - poor man was basically alone his whole life and his father was abjectly horrible (almost ridiculously so) - I groaned and moaned so many times in sympathy for him as he learned how to open up and be a person.
Caraway was a sweet character and they were cute together. She made some bad decisions regarding the 'love triangle' storyline so I was very glad she came to her senses, learned some hard truths and admitted them to herself before I had to start hating her. Stop hurting Silas! There were a few hints around power dynamics in their relationship that I wish were further explored - particularly in the marriage bed.
Now please excuse me while I go and add Jemma Frost's whole catalogue to my MUST READ list.
June 11, 2023
I really enjoyed this book. So much that I ended up reading it in one day. This is the story of Caraway and Silas that end up getting married due to her being compromised. I was happy to see that Caraway was not your usual beautiful, slender character. That she was on the plump side and Silas loved that she was plump. There need to be more books where the characters are like this. At the beginning of the book I did find Caraway a little annoying and immature due to her pining after a man that had never given her any affection but she held a candle for him for decades. Silas was a well-developed character and throughout the book you see why he was so cold and detached. Both of the characters evolved through the novel slowly, which was nice to see. The intimate times were pretty steamy and it was nice to see some bed sport outside of the bedroom. I received this as an ARC and am glad that I was able to read this book. The characters are well-developed; the story flowed well and very steamy.
June 14, 2023
I love the rough, wrong side of the tracks, gruff male characters and Jemma has a knack for writing them in such a loving way. Enter Silas. Oh yeah, he’s rough, gruff, not a man to mess with and I loved him. What I also really liked about this story is that he is 45 and Caraway is 30. Couples that are a little older really know what is going on and what they like. Now, onto their frustrating communication issues. I totally get Silas and his vulnerability about Caraway being infatuated with another man. Communication people. And bless her heart, Caraway didn’t know which way was up. Learning each other and slowly coming to realize that their love was real and beautiful was such a satisfying read. So technically this is a slow burn but not slow heat. Burns up the pages. Both of these characters deserve love and I found their journey to be amazing and such a joy. I found Jemma’s writing and I never want to let go. So many emotions are brought to the page. Silas is my favorite hero of hers so far.
I received a complimentary copy.
I received a complimentary copy.
June 8, 2023
Oldest daughter Caraway grew up being responsible for her younger sisters. Now that all of the sisters were married off, Caraway wanted to address the issue of her eminent spinsterhood. She decided that it was time to make a daring play for Miles, the man that had held her heart since childhood. Silas Riverton, a successful businessman, finds Cara attractive. He seeks to make a bold move of his own. Due to his machinations, he and Cara risk getting embroiled in a scandal unless they marry. Cara is initially resentful that Silas has made it impossible for her to pursue Miles. However, with the passage of time, Silas and Cara build a life together and Cara realizes that she is with the right man.
This was a light and pleasant read. Older man Silas was a sexy hero and this book has plenty of steam. Cara is a curvy heroine, but this aspect of her character is fortunately not overdone.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
This was a light and pleasant read. Older man Silas was a sexy hero and this book has plenty of steam. Cara is a curvy heroine, but this aspect of her character is fortunately not overdone.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
June 12, 2023
The Last Caraway Daughter to Fall in Love!
Silas knew he was instantly attracted to Caraway when he first met her but he thought her far above him and didn’t think he had a chance.
Caraway had fallen in love with a suitor at a younger age and now wanted to do something about it, to make him notice her as a woman and not just a friend unfortunately nothing seemed to change and when she was caught in a compromising situation with Silas, she knew her life was about to change.
Silas had been brought up not to show or have any emotions and that’s why he was great at business but with Caraway he just couldn’t resist her!
A beautiful well written love story, with steamy moments showing so many emotions on both sides and how both lonely hearts managed to find each other along the way to bring the storyline to a beautiful HEA!
Wonderful addition to the series!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Silas knew he was instantly attracted to Caraway when he first met her but he thought her far above him and didn’t think he had a chance.
Caraway had fallen in love with a suitor at a younger age and now wanted to do something about it, to make him notice her as a woman and not just a friend unfortunately nothing seemed to change and when she was caught in a compromising situation with Silas, she knew her life was about to change.
Silas had been brought up not to show or have any emotions and that’s why he was great at business but with Caraway he just couldn’t resist her!
A beautiful well written love story, with steamy moments showing so many emotions on both sides and how both lonely hearts managed to find each other along the way to bring the storyline to a beautiful HEA!
Wonderful addition to the series!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
June 15, 2023
A Gentleman Never Surrenders by Jemma Frost was an outstanding steamy read! Caraway and Silas have fiery chemistry that starts off as enemies to lovers once they’re caught and she’s compromised, however, their relationship evolves in a complex but beautiful way.
Sometimes super steamy stories can feel like the actual relationships are filler between the love scenes, but I never felt that way in this book. Ms. Frost took care to develop her characters and also added mystery and intrigue.
I’m a sucker for a hot silver fox, and Silas definitely fits the bill. Make him a silver fox who adores a woman with curves, and you’ve got my catnip. I only wish that this story wasn’t the end of the Garden Girls series. I can’t wait to read what Ms. Frost writes next. I’ve got a new one-click author!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Sometimes super steamy stories can feel like the actual relationships are filler between the love scenes, but I never felt that way in this book. Ms. Frost took care to develop her characters and also added mystery and intrigue.
I’m a sucker for a hot silver fox, and Silas definitely fits the bill. Make him a silver fox who adores a woman with curves, and you’ve got my catnip. I only wish that this story wasn’t the end of the Garden Girls series. I can’t wait to read what Ms. Frost writes next. I’ve got a new one-click author!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
June 24, 2023
Really enjoyed this book, especially loved Silas. He's a great character. It's fun to read, it's a decent "growing to love your partner" story. I'm not a huge fan of stories like this but it was done well. I wish we got to see more of Silas' life, more of what he's thinking and why. And i feel like there's a missing few sentences (unless i missed them) about her discovering that he goes to a boxing club. It was such a non-issue and that felt a bit unreasonable.
I like that Caraway is explicitly plump and that's a feature Silas likes about her. This definitely could have been explored a bit more.
I'm also a little bit disappointed that some kinky sex was teased near the start of the book, and this is completely vanilla. Though i guess that's each person's perspective.
I like that Caraway is explicitly plump and that's a feature Silas likes about her. This definitely could have been explored a bit more.
I'm also a little bit disappointed that some kinky sex was teased near the start of the book, and this is completely vanilla. Though i guess that's each person's perspective.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 69 reviews