"Glad Tidings" was actually 2 books - "There's Something about Christmas" and "Here Comes Trouble." I did not like these 2 books as much as the past several books I have read by Debbie Macomber. I seem to prefer her books with angels in them. I'm not sure why yet. I preferred the first book, "There's Something about Christmas" & didn't care as much about the 2nd one, "Here Comes Trouble." In the 2nd book, I could not believe Maryanne liked, never mind loved the man, Nolan. I felt he was so mean to her, right from the beginning. I think this is such a terrible lesson to teach young women: that never mind how mean a guy is, as long as he's good looking, go after him. In the first book, Emma was suspicious of the man, Oliver, but he was, at least, a decent man, for the most part. However, he was too pushy & should have respected Emma's repeated "no's," even if he did think she was uptight. . She had a bad father, so she didn't trust Oliver, right from the start, because he was good looking & self-confident. But he was never mean to her, although he should have not pushed her so much and, instead let her see what a great guy he was.
In the 2nd book, Nolan was mean to Maryanne right from the beginning. Yet, she felt she had to prove herself to him, when she did not need his approval.
I don't know why the 2nd book was in Glad Tidings; it was not a Christmas story. The first story was a nice Christmas story. I sure learned a lot about fruitcake, & I may now even try it again. The first story was a feel-good story, while the 2nd one was irritating all the way through it.
I would have given the first story 4 stars & the second story only 2 stars. So, I averaged them out & gave the book 3 stars.