Okay, first, he's specifically addressing individuals, hence the underwhelming amount of work done in ecclesiology in this book. Lines like "it seems to me that most life change occurs alone with God," highlights this inclination toward the individual's relationship with God without the nuance of community.
Second, you've gotta gut the evangelical inclination to drop theological trusism that make you cringe. Eg. "Theology 101, God is smart, he knows things I don't know..." Yuck.
Third, you have to hope that things didn't happen exactly like he tells the stories. Stories where he asks people point blank "you've been abused, haven't you?" Or "you're a homosexual, aren't you," because "the Holy Spirit prompted me" just confuses and makes me, as a pastor, thoroughly uncomfortable. There's a tenderness, gentleness and level of trust to ask people questions of that nature, and I don't think the approach he takes does that. (I give him the space to nuance that, but as it stands in the book, that's how he's articulated it.)
However
You never know where healing is going to come from, and although he's got a dozen things in here that leave me shaking my head, there were a number of stories and directives that challenged and hit me in very meaningful ways. Although I've had a personal hesitance to working with soul care resources (I've seen this stuff go horribly wrong) I found myself putting the book down to have a cry once or twice as I read.
Regardless of your opinion of Reimer, he's someone who is constantly seeking intimacy with God and is willing to do the work he needs to abide in God.
Do I thoroughly, disagree with a number of things he says, absolutely, but I agree with a number of things he calls for you to do like:
-finding your roots of bitterness and dealing with them so you don't live out of them
-figuring out your identity, and living from a place of belovedness
-learning what it means to actually process your emotions rather than just talking about them
-encouraging systemic and cultural health
-continuously challenging us to identify and deal with our insecurities
(My gosh if I had a nickel for every time I witnessed someone ministering or teaching from a place of insecurity, myself included)
-seeking intimacy with God as a central, not peripheral, part of the faith
"The church in the West has adopted a largely knowledge-based discipleship approach. It isn't adequate and it isn't working." (6)
What I appreciate is, unlike so many right now, Reimer doesn't just name something like this and walk away from it; he challenges you to use your intellect and knowledge to seek intimacy with God. He proposes a model of discipleship that takes confession, repentance and vulnerability. In other words, he tells you to get some skin in the game.
So while Reimer has gone in several directions I find questionable, and some reprehensible, something like this book that says, "hey, you're loved by God, deal with your trash in his loving embrace and learn what it means to love the world" is a great place to start and to come back to throughout a life of faith and ministry.
I'd love to see him, or someone else in the Alliance, write a book on communal formation and discipleship. While this largely pushes individuals to God, I'd love to see something that equally pushes individuals together toward God.