Before starting this book, I was already very familiar with Jan Broberg’s story. I had watched the Dr. Phil episode, Abducted in Plain Sight, and A Friend of the Family, so I knew what I was walking into. But this book still reiterated what all three of those mediums had already made very clear to me: Jan Broberg is a real-life superhero.
To go through what she went through and come out of it with the forgiveness, faith, strength, and freedom that she has is one of the most incredible things I have ever seen. Jan could have turned bitter and angry and no one would have blamed her. Instead, she took her pain and poured it outward into sharing her story, raising awareness, and becoming an advocate for others.
I realize a lot of people get angry with Bob and Mary Ann, and that is valid. They clearly let their daughter down. However, I do think it is important to remember, before we completely cast judgment on them, that this crime took place in the 1970s in Pocatello, Idaho, and Bob and Mary Ann were LDS. To me, they come across as incredibly naive people who lived in a world where they wanted to believe everyone was good. They were isolated in a way that maybe people from bigger cities would not have been, and they were completely unprepared for someone like B.
And let’s not forget that B was a master manipulator. I compare him to predator priests who are able to get families to let their guard down because they present themselves as safe, trustworthy, and godly. They convince people to hand over access to their children because they know how to perform goodness. I think B had that same kind of power and control over the people in his life. He knew exactly how naive and trusting they were, and he used that against them.
Bob and Mary Ann were people who seemed to be trying to live their lives in a good and decent way, and they assumed other people were doing the same. That does not erase the harm or excuse every choice they made, but it does help explain how someone like B was able to get so close and cause so much damage.
I do recommend this book to anyone looking to learn more about Jan’s story, but be warned: it is just as frustrating as the documentaries and dramatizations. Still, the main takeaway should always be Jan herself. Her resilience, her power, and her ability to reclaim her own story are what stay with you the most.