What do you think?
Rate this book
Jack and Ivy #2
To Free the Stars
The Great War consumes all in its path, but for the assassins at Talon it’s just another day on the job . . . until a new threat rises from the smoke of war-torn Europe to obliterate the world as they know it.
After successfully rescuing Phillip from the clutches of the Order of the Rising Moon, Jack Vale and Ivy Olwen are relieved to end their months-long chase across Eastern Europe and recover from their wounds back at Talon headquarters. A happy homecoming, however, is not written in the stars. Ambushed and beaten, Jack disappears into the darkness of night without a trace.
Ten years later, Ivy has long accepted her husband as dead, even though she sees echoes of him behind every doorway and in every corner. She single-mindedly focuses on the mission of Talon: to ensure good outweighs the evil in the world. But the fight against darkness has only just begun, and sometimes the enemy you should fear is the one within . . .
Completing the epic duology from bestselling author J’nell Ciesielski, To Free the Stars incorporates her signature blend of thrilling adventure, glamorous espionage, and sweeping romance.
After successfully rescuing Phillip from the clutches of the Order of the Rising Moon, Jack Vale and Ivy Olwen are relieved to end their months-long chase across Eastern Europe and recover from their wounds back at Talon headquarters. A happy homecoming, however, is not written in the stars. Ambushed and beaten, Jack disappears into the darkness of night without a trace.
Ten years later, Ivy has long accepted her husband as dead, even though she sees echoes of him behind every doorway and in every corner. She single-mindedly focuses on the mission of Talon: to ensure good outweighs the evil in the world. But the fight against darkness has only just begun, and sometimes the enemy you should fear is the one within . . .
Completing the epic duology from bestselling author J’nell Ciesielski, To Free the Stars incorporates her signature blend of thrilling adventure, glamorous espionage, and sweeping romance.
400 pages, Paperback
First published August 8, 2023
32 people are currently reading
3330 people want to read
About the author
J'nell Ciesielski
12 books898 followersBestselling author J’nell Ciesielski has a passion for heart-stopping adventure and sweeping love stories while weaving fresh takes into romances of times gone by. When not creating dashing heroes and daring heroines, she can be found dreaming of Scotland, indulging in chocolate of any kind, or watching old black and white movies. She is a member of the Tall Poppy Writers and lives in Virginia with her husband, daughter, and lazy beagle. Learn more at www.jnellciesielski.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 118 reviews
March 30, 2023
The story begins 10 years after The Brilliance of Stars & you definitely need to read the stories in order.
From the epilogue of book 1, I had a hunch on what would come about in book 2, and I was correct.
This book was a gut punch in many ways. It was dark. It was gritty. It was heartbreaking. It seriously hurt.
Ivy, bless her heart, never gave up. I admire her courage, her perseverance, and her faithfulness. I can’t even imagine being in her shoes. And Jack… my heart broke for him.
There was a character who both made me both incredibly angry & incredibly sad. I found myself not able to hate him despite his actions, but he irrevocably broke my heart.
While the first book had its dark & heavy moments, it was still rather light & hopeful. Book 2 was far different. I am super sensitive to mind-control & torture (psychological & physical), and both were abundant here. I ended up skim reading 50% of the book because it was weighing me down too much.
Content wise, there is some language, mentions of a past miscarriage, and some heavily implied physical intimacy. The latter was too much for my comfort level and different than what the author has done in the past.
I’m torn over this book. It wasn’t badly written, but the heavy content made it not for me.
*Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.
From the epilogue of book 1, I had a hunch on what would come about in book 2, and I was correct.
This book was a gut punch in many ways. It was dark. It was gritty. It was heartbreaking. It seriously hurt.
Ivy, bless her heart, never gave up. I admire her courage, her perseverance, and her faithfulness. I can’t even imagine being in her shoes. And Jack… my heart broke for him.
There was a character who both made me both incredibly angry & incredibly sad. I found myself not able to hate him despite his actions, but he irrevocably broke my heart.
While the first book had its dark & heavy moments, it was still rather light & hopeful. Book 2 was far different. I am super sensitive to mind-control & torture (psychological & physical), and both were abundant here. I ended up skim reading 50% of the book because it was weighing me down too much.
Content wise, there is some language, mentions of a past miscarriage, and some heavily implied physical intimacy. The latter was too much for my comfort level and different than what the author has done in the past.
I’m torn over this book. It wasn’t badly written, but the heavy content made it not for me.
*Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.
May 30, 2023
3.5 ⭐️
I want to highlight something I appreciated about this book and something that kept me from giving it a higher rating. Let's start with the positive first!
The author has such an engaging writing style, and it kept me turning the pages. I felt so many emotions as I journeyed alongside the characters in this story. I especially think the author has a really good grasp on writing characters who struggle with trauma and regret. There were some great themes in this book that I really loved/appreciated. And, without trying to give away any spoilers, the author knows how to write about characters who have been separated and are reunited, struggling with some sense of normalcy after being torn apart and the changes that happened to both of them because of their separation. It wasn't storm clouds, then rainbows the next page. It was a slow, gradual change that mirrored reality very well, and I really appreciated that.
I really felt like the plot wasn't super original...in all honesty, parts of it felt very much so like a retelling of Captain America + Bucky Barnes (except, instead of friends, a husband and wife) and Peeta + Katniss from The Hunger Games (where Peeta is hijacked and is trying to reclaim his memories). That took away a lot of my enjoyment for the story because it lacked that originality I really want to find in a good story.
A content warning as well: there is a fade-to-black bedroom scene, and while it was technically closed-door, it was still very descriptive in what was happening before the scene changed (described clothes coming off, etc.) and I felt uncomfortable reading it, so I skipped that scene (about 1 1/2 pages long). This is a personal conviction of mine, so if you're comfortable with these kinds of scenes, then this shouldn't be an issue for you :) A couple uses of the d* word as well.
I will say, once again, that the author is a very good writer and she knows how to tell a sad story while keeping it engaging, but the story lacked originality and felt more like a retelling of a Marvel/THG movie, hence the lower rating. Thank you to NetGalley and the author for an eARC of To Free the Stars. A positive review was not required, only my honest opinion. All thoughts are expressly my own.
I want to highlight something I appreciated about this book and something that kept me from giving it a higher rating. Let's start with the positive first!
The author has such an engaging writing style, and it kept me turning the pages. I felt so many emotions as I journeyed alongside the characters in this story. I especially think the author has a really good grasp on writing characters who struggle with trauma and regret. There were some great themes in this book that I really loved/appreciated. And, without trying to give away any spoilers, the author knows how to write about characters who have been separated and are reunited, struggling with some sense of normalcy after being torn apart and the changes that happened to both of them because of their separation. It wasn't storm clouds, then rainbows the next page. It was a slow, gradual change that mirrored reality very well, and I really appreciated that.
I really felt like the plot wasn't super original...in all honesty, parts of it felt very much so like a retelling of Captain America + Bucky Barnes (except, instead of friends, a husband and wife) and Peeta + Katniss from The Hunger Games (where Peeta is hijacked and is trying to reclaim his memories). That took away a lot of my enjoyment for the story because it lacked that originality I really want to find in a good story.
A content warning as well: there is a fade-to-black bedroom scene, and while it was technically closed-door, it was still very descriptive in what was happening before the scene changed (described clothes coming off, etc.) and I felt uncomfortable reading it, so I skipped that scene (about 1 1/2 pages long). This is a personal conviction of mine, so if you're comfortable with these kinds of scenes, then this shouldn't be an issue for you :) A couple uses of the d* word as well.
I will say, once again, that the author is a very good writer and she knows how to tell a sad story while keeping it engaging, but the story lacked originality and felt more like a retelling of a Marvel/THG movie, hence the lower rating. Thank you to NetGalley and the author for an eARC of To Free the Stars. A positive review was not required, only my honest opinion. All thoughts are expressly my own.
July 25, 2023
Gripping books like TO FREE THE STARS, the last in a compelling histfic romance series, are the reason I auto-read anything by J'Nell Ciesielski. I suggest you read the first before devouring this. You will be completely rewarded. This second book is not for the faint of heart as we follow the continued adventures of Jack and Ivy. I experienced all the feels -- fear, anguish, hope, loss -- and will never forget it! Highly recommended.
June 3, 2023
“You are the man I love.”
“To love me will be your ruin.”
“Your love might be my damnation, but I will go to my grave with no regrets.”
First of all, I want to say I have seen some mixed reviews of this book and I feel that the negative ones are unwarranted. I believe that they base their reviews on their preferences, not to the actual merit of the book itself. (Which is well within their rights.) They have taken their preconceived notions of what to expect and not appreciated the beauty of this story. Is it perfect? No. Does it deviate from J’nell’s previous works? Yes. Is it too much? Maybe for some, but not for most. Is it deep and raw and intense? Yes! While it could have been presented safer or toned down, it wouldn’t have depicted the great suffering of their journey or the true testament of the kind of connection between the two main characters. Their love is an all consuming, all encompassing, all enduring, undying love that deserved a moment of freedom and release. I don’t want all my ramblings to be interpreted as this being “spicy”, so let me offer some context hopefully without spoiling the story. Chapter 27 has a scene between a married couple, some would say it is “fade to black”. If you have read a lot of historical romantic fiction I would place it between Mimi Matthews and Amy Harmon. It isn’t explicit, it isn’t gaudy, it is a culmination of acceptance, longing, of walls coming down; of love conquering fear, self doubt, and regret; of a healing intimacy. It is uninhibited and fierce and frenzied. The scene is descriptive of feelings and removal of clothing and all that leads up to the “inevitable”. Some people wouldn’t be comfortable with it. It is easily skipped. But it is definitely a true (albeit this is a fictional world and premise) representation of the moments between a husband and wife who have overcome many horrible experiences to finally be together again.
The other criticism I’d like to address is the originality. Like countless other stories in the big wide world of fictional writing, the author watched a movie and the wheels started turning. She took that seed of inspiration and created what I consider to be an outstanding duology. Full of history, action, suspense, romance, good vs. evil, spies, betrayals, survival.
Now that I got all that off my chest here’s my review.
To Free the Stars is book 2 in the Jack and Ivy duology. Technically you could read it as stand alone, but that would be a disservice to the efforts of the author, to the journey of Jack and Ivy, and to yourself. The Brilliance of Stars is an amazing story that jumped to the top of my all time favorites. It was fast paced and intense, with outstanding characters. At the conclusion of book 1, we are given the hints of what is to come next. Although, it is not what you want, it is what makes the next book so spectacular.
It would be too hard to discuss at length without giving away anything for either book. But I’ll make some observations and comments to give you the feel of what to expect. Jack and Ivy are highly skilled trained assassins. They spar, they test their mettle against each other, they respect one another, and love grows deep and wide. It takes awhile before they admit those feelings, but once they do their love and passion rivals that of Claire and Jamie Fraser or even Noah and Allie. It is intense. They have epic chemistry.
“Don’t close your eyes…I want you to watch me come undone. I want you to see what you do to me.”
The plot from book 1 is carried over into book 2 with some dire complications and stinging betrayal. Jack and Ivy are both pushed to the edge of their respective humanity. Evil is increasing its chokehold on them and the world they know. Friendship is tested, trust is shattered, and love is put through the refiner’s fire to either turn to ash or come out in its purest form.
With nods to Captain America: The Winter Soldier, and some hints of The Hunger Games and Mission: Impossible you are in for a wild ride of fight scenes, some torture, romantic tension, harried escapes, hard won battles and hard to except losses.
I think this book is the bomb! J’Nell is a terrific writer and is spreading her wings to fly with this duology.
“To love me will be your ruin.”
“Your love might be my damnation, but I will go to my grave with no regrets.”
First of all, I want to say I have seen some mixed reviews of this book and I feel that the negative ones are unwarranted. I believe that they base their reviews on their preferences, not to the actual merit of the book itself. (Which is well within their rights.) They have taken their preconceived notions of what to expect and not appreciated the beauty of this story. Is it perfect? No. Does it deviate from J’nell’s previous works? Yes. Is it too much? Maybe for some, but not for most. Is it deep and raw and intense? Yes! While it could have been presented safer or toned down, it wouldn’t have depicted the great suffering of their journey or the true testament of the kind of connection between the two main characters. Their love is an all consuming, all encompassing, all enduring, undying love that deserved a moment of freedom and release. I don’t want all my ramblings to be interpreted as this being “spicy”, so let me offer some context hopefully without spoiling the story. Chapter 27 has a scene between a married couple, some would say it is “fade to black”. If you have read a lot of historical romantic fiction I would place it between Mimi Matthews and Amy Harmon. It isn’t explicit, it isn’t gaudy, it is a culmination of acceptance, longing, of walls coming down; of love conquering fear, self doubt, and regret; of a healing intimacy. It is uninhibited and fierce and frenzied. The scene is descriptive of feelings and removal of clothing and all that leads up to the “inevitable”. Some people wouldn’t be comfortable with it. It is easily skipped. But it is definitely a true (albeit this is a fictional world and premise) representation of the moments between a husband and wife who have overcome many horrible experiences to finally be together again.
The other criticism I’d like to address is the originality. Like countless other stories in the big wide world of fictional writing, the author watched a movie and the wheels started turning. She took that seed of inspiration and created what I consider to be an outstanding duology. Full of history, action, suspense, romance, good vs. evil, spies, betrayals, survival.
Now that I got all that off my chest here’s my review.
To Free the Stars is book 2 in the Jack and Ivy duology. Technically you could read it as stand alone, but that would be a disservice to the efforts of the author, to the journey of Jack and Ivy, and to yourself. The Brilliance of Stars is an amazing story that jumped to the top of my all time favorites. It was fast paced and intense, with outstanding characters. At the conclusion of book 1, we are given the hints of what is to come next. Although, it is not what you want, it is what makes the next book so spectacular.
It would be too hard to discuss at length without giving away anything for either book. But I’ll make some observations and comments to give you the feel of what to expect. Jack and Ivy are highly skilled trained assassins. They spar, they test their mettle against each other, they respect one another, and love grows deep and wide. It takes awhile before they admit those feelings, but once they do their love and passion rivals that of Claire and Jamie Fraser or even Noah and Allie. It is intense. They have epic chemistry.
“Don’t close your eyes…I want you to watch me come undone. I want you to see what you do to me.”
The plot from book 1 is carried over into book 2 with some dire complications and stinging betrayal. Jack and Ivy are both pushed to the edge of their respective humanity. Evil is increasing its chokehold on them and the world they know. Friendship is tested, trust is shattered, and love is put through the refiner’s fire to either turn to ash or come out in its purest form.
With nods to Captain America: The Winter Soldier, and some hints of The Hunger Games and Mission: Impossible you are in for a wild ride of fight scenes, some torture, romantic tension, harried escapes, hard won battles and hard to except losses.
I think this book is the bomb! J’Nell is a terrific writer and is spreading her wings to fly with this duology.
August 10, 2023
Thank you @jnellciesielski @tnzfiction for the book and having me on tour!
“Fate is fickle and the stars are silent, but I do know this: No matter how difficult the circumstances or how savagely the world tries to tear us apart, I am here with you.”
TITLE: TO FREE THE STARS
AUTHOR: J’Nell Ciesielski
PUB DATE: 08.08.2023 Pre Order Now
This white-knuckled conclusion to The Brilliance of Stars takes readers on a breathless adventure from the speakeasies of America to the Horse Guards Parade in London, an ancient cemetery outside Paris, and back to the Eastern European strongholds where the Vales’ tragedy first began.
Thoughts:
Don’t let the cover fool you, this book is intense, and a suspenseful ride - Book 2 continues immediately from where The Brilliance of Stars left off, and immediately dives in to Jack and Ivy’s story. Moving forward ten years ahead and be still my heart not only for the triumphant writing of the action adventure scenes but the sweeping romance that gutted me. TO FREE THE STARS is a deftly written historical fiction that had me in tears, and all kinds of emotions. An exuberant duology must read for any historical fiction lover.
“Fate is fickle and the stars are silent, but I do know this: No matter how difficult the circumstances or how savagely the world tries to tear us apart, I am here with you.”
TITLE: TO FREE THE STARS
AUTHOR: J’Nell Ciesielski
PUB DATE: 08.08.2023 Pre Order Now
This white-knuckled conclusion to The Brilliance of Stars takes readers on a breathless adventure from the speakeasies of America to the Horse Guards Parade in London, an ancient cemetery outside Paris, and back to the Eastern European strongholds where the Vales’ tragedy first began.
Thoughts:
Don’t let the cover fool you, this book is intense, and a suspenseful ride - Book 2 continues immediately from where The Brilliance of Stars left off, and immediately dives in to Jack and Ivy’s story. Moving forward ten years ahead and be still my heart not only for the triumphant writing of the action adventure scenes but the sweeping romance that gutted me. TO FREE THE STARS is a deftly written historical fiction that had me in tears, and all kinds of emotions. An exuberant duology must read for any historical fiction lover.
March 3, 2023
This is hard review to write. J'nell is a gifted writer and she has crafted a beautiful story, but...
In book 1, we have an overall lighthearted story. Jack and Ivy and Phillip have lots of hope, even while they fight. This book is very heavy and dark. My heart hurt from the beginning and by the end I was almost numb.
One thing I appreciated was that the story flowed well. Many times, when characters are dealing with heavy things, the story can seem to get stuck in an endless cycle of guilt and shame and self-pity. That didn't happen here.
Another thing that I really liked was Ivy's perseverance and commitment. She NEVER gave up and never betrayed her vows. She fought for what was important to her and it was very admirable. I also liked her desire to forgive and give the benefit of the doubt to her betrayer. Ivy is a pretty incredible character. She has her flaws and failings but she is also very strong and I admire her.
It never seems quite fair to me to dock stars for a book being just not exactly my kind of story and while that is not truly the reason for my three star review, it is a part of it. This is a heart-rending book. Ivy has lost so much and loses more still. I do NOT like stories where family and friends are pitted against each other. This story reminded me of my least-favorite parts of Pirates of the Caribbean and of Captain America: The Winter Solider (that movie broke my heart). I can't say much more without spoilers.
That in itself would probably have made me give this a four star review but we have another problem. There was an extended intimate scene again. I had to skim ahead. I have nothing but the previous book to compare it to (and I skimmed that too) so I can't say if it is graphic or not, but it is too intimate in my opinion. Yes, it's all in the covenant of marriage, but I don't think it belongs in books and I think it is an important warning for people to know about.
Those two things together gave it three stars. I do also have to mention that the "d" word and the "h" word are used, although usually to talk about the place or something being "d***nd" so I get it. One character does actually swear though, in anger, but still. Not something I expect to find in my Christian fiction and I feel it bears mentioning. This does not play into my star rating though.
Let's summarize it like this: it's three stars instead of two because it is a well-written story but it it weren't for the intimate scene, it would be four stars.
I do have to say that the ending is quite satisfactory and absolutely perfect for Ivy in particular.
I have read several books by J'nell Ciesielski and the others are not like these. I'm not sure what is different about the Jack and Ivy books that made her include things she hasn't in some of her other works. I don't recall intimate scenes in the other books I've read by her. She is a very talented storyteller and writes beautiful stories. This is a beautiful, deep, moving story, it's just too heavy and sad for my tastes. If you want to read a J'nell Ciesielski book, I would recommend "Beauty Among Ruins", "The Socialite", or "The Ice Swan" in place of this duology. They are stunning books and, as I said, I don't believe they have any problematic scenes.
Not recommend for under 21 because of intimacy. I probably would not recommend for unmarried women either.
Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of this book. All opinions are my own and a favorable review was not required.
In book 1, we have an overall lighthearted story. Jack and Ivy and Phillip have lots of hope, even while they fight. This book is very heavy and dark. My heart hurt from the beginning and by the end I was almost numb.
One thing I appreciated was that the story flowed well. Many times, when characters are dealing with heavy things, the story can seem to get stuck in an endless cycle of guilt and shame and self-pity. That didn't happen here.
Another thing that I really liked was Ivy's perseverance and commitment. She NEVER gave up and never betrayed her vows. She fought for what was important to her and it was very admirable. I also liked her desire to forgive and give the benefit of the doubt to her betrayer. Ivy is a pretty incredible character. She has her flaws and failings but she is also very strong and I admire her.
It never seems quite fair to me to dock stars for a book being just not exactly my kind of story and while that is not truly the reason for my three star review, it is a part of it. This is a heart-rending book. Ivy has lost so much and loses more still. I do NOT like stories where family and friends are pitted against each other. This story reminded me of my least-favorite parts of Pirates of the Caribbean and of Captain America: The Winter Solider (that movie broke my heart). I can't say much more without spoilers.
That in itself would probably have made me give this a four star review but we have another problem. There was an extended intimate scene again. I had to skim ahead. I have nothing but the previous book to compare it to (and I skimmed that too) so I can't say if it is graphic or not, but it is too intimate in my opinion. Yes, it's all in the covenant of marriage, but I don't think it belongs in books and I think it is an important warning for people to know about.
Those two things together gave it three stars. I do also have to mention that the "d" word and the "h" word are used, although usually to talk about the place or something being "d***nd" so I get it. One character does actually swear though, in anger, but still. Not something I expect to find in my Christian fiction and I feel it bears mentioning. This does not play into my star rating though.
Let's summarize it like this: it's three stars instead of two because it is a well-written story but it it weren't for the intimate scene, it would be four stars.
I do have to say that the ending is quite satisfactory and absolutely perfect for Ivy in particular.
I have read several books by J'nell Ciesielski and the others are not like these. I'm not sure what is different about the Jack and Ivy books that made her include things she hasn't in some of her other works. I don't recall intimate scenes in the other books I've read by her. She is a very talented storyteller and writes beautiful stories. This is a beautiful, deep, moving story, it's just too heavy and sad for my tastes. If you want to read a J'nell Ciesielski book, I would recommend "Beauty Among Ruins", "The Socialite", or "The Ice Swan" in place of this duology. They are stunning books and, as I said, I don't believe they have any problematic scenes.
Not recommend for under 21 because of intimacy. I probably would not recommend for unmarried women either.
Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of this book. All opinions are my own and a favorable review was not required.
October 30, 2023
3.5 Stars
There's a lot about this book that I appreciate yet some things that really bothered me. Let's start with the positives.
This series, and this book in particular, was was so different than what I typically read. I liked the action, intrigue, and even the weird bits of history thrown in. The characters show their love by being self-sacrificial and their witty conversations were amusing. I was truly rooting for them.
Now for what I didn't love.
While in the middle of an intense fight scene or when in imminent danger, would you stop to have a long conversation? I don't think so, yet several times, when I would be booking it out of danger, the characters get chatty with each other. It drove me NUTS.
The dialogue and descriptions were often repetitive.
The handful of swear words were completely unnecessary.
It was dark. The storyline, the character's grief, and the evil they faced was all so heavy. I had to stop several times just to do something to lift my spirits.
There's a lot about this book that I appreciate yet some things that really bothered me. Let's start with the positives.
This series, and this book in particular, was was so different than what I typically read. I liked the action, intrigue, and even the weird bits of history thrown in. The characters show their love by being self-sacrificial and their witty conversations were amusing. I was truly rooting for them.
Now for what I didn't love.
While in the middle of an intense fight scene or when in imminent danger, would you stop to have a long conversation? I don't think so, yet several times, when I would be booking it out of danger, the characters get chatty with each other. It drove me NUTS.
The dialogue and descriptions were often repetitive.
The handful of swear words were completely unnecessary.
It was dark. The storyline, the character's grief, and the evil they faced was all so heavy. I had to stop several times just to do something to lift my spirits.
July 6, 2024
A heart-achingly deep & enthralling story. And what a romance! Full review to come.
July 31, 2023
3.5 stars
To Free the Stars by J’nell Ciesielski happens ten years after The Brilliance of Stars. I highly recommend readers read the first book before they dive into this one. Yes, the novel could stand alone; however, there are many plot points that reference moments in the first novel. Again, plenty of moments of action. Chasing through the globe in different locations as the Talon try to destroy the enemy. Ivy and Jack must overcome some obstacles together to solve and stop the assassination attempts. While the plot could be interesting because of the spy element and chasing around the world, it was a little dry for a good chunk of the novel. The romance is building a little more in depth this time around. If readers were thrown for how much romance was in the first book, then one is kicked back a notch, but it is there. Ciesielski does a wonderful job at inviting readers into her settings. She uses just enough description to keep the readers actively involved in the story and the setting. The writing is wonderful. Nicely shown and dived deeply into the character’s train of thoughts. Overall, To Free the Stars by J’nell Ciesielski does tie up the story from The Brilliance of Stars; however, there were moments that the story was pretty dry for me. I wanted more action.
I received a complimentary copy of To Free the Stars by J’nell Ciesielski from Thomas Nelson Publishing, but the opinions stated are all my own.
To Free the Stars by J’nell Ciesielski happens ten years after The Brilliance of Stars. I highly recommend readers read the first book before they dive into this one. Yes, the novel could stand alone; however, there are many plot points that reference moments in the first novel. Again, plenty of moments of action. Chasing through the globe in different locations as the Talon try to destroy the enemy. Ivy and Jack must overcome some obstacles together to solve and stop the assassination attempts. While the plot could be interesting because of the spy element and chasing around the world, it was a little dry for a good chunk of the novel. The romance is building a little more in depth this time around. If readers were thrown for how much romance was in the first book, then one is kicked back a notch, but it is there. Ciesielski does a wonderful job at inviting readers into her settings. She uses just enough description to keep the readers actively involved in the story and the setting. The writing is wonderful. Nicely shown and dived deeply into the character’s train of thoughts. Overall, To Free the Stars by J’nell Ciesielski does tie up the story from The Brilliance of Stars; however, there were moments that the story was pretty dry for me. I wanted more action.
I received a complimentary copy of To Free the Stars by J’nell Ciesielski from Thomas Nelson Publishing, but the opinions stated are all my own.
June 30, 2023
I picked up this book because I was convinced I had read the first one, but I can't actually find any proof of it, which is baffling.
In any case, I was able to follow the story and understand the backstory as the narrative went on.
This is the continuation of Ivy and Jack and Phillip's story, and the opening is not a good one for the characters. The narrative then jumps ten years ahead and leads to a moment where the characters meet again, but things are not the same.
There's a fight between good and evil, a fight to recover love and overcame impossible odds, a fight to do what is right at the expense of sacrifice. It's fast-paced, with danger and suspense, and also tender moments.
I received a copy from the publisher via NetGalley and this is my honest opinion.
In any case, I was able to follow the story and understand the backstory as the narrative went on.
This is the continuation of Ivy and Jack and Phillip's story, and the opening is not a good one for the characters. The narrative then jumps ten years ahead and leads to a moment where the characters meet again, but things are not the same.
There's a fight between good and evil, a fight to recover love and overcame impossible odds, a fight to do what is right at the expense of sacrifice. It's fast-paced, with danger and suspense, and also tender moments.
I received a copy from the publisher via NetGalley and this is my honest opinion.
July 5, 2025
4.3/5⭐️
I’m crying so bad right now. This was so much more that I could have expected from the sequel and I’m just amazed with this story and characters. Oh to have a beautiful soulmate-like type of love like Jack and Ivy’s💖💖💐🥹✨♾️😍😭
“Do you feel like you’re home now?”
He nodded. “You?”
“With you, always”
I’m crying so bad right now. This was so much more that I could have expected from the sequel and I’m just amazed with this story and characters. Oh to have a beautiful soulmate-like type of love like Jack and Ivy’s💖💖💐🥹✨♾️😍😭
“Do you feel like you’re home now?”
He nodded. “You?”
“With you, always”
August 31, 2023
Read if you like: action/adventure historical books, Marvel/Captain America
-
The book takes place ten years after the first book and Jack and Ivy need to work together to end the Order of the Rising Moon.
-
I loved reading more about Jack and Ivy. The author did such a good job setting up their love story in the first book. The ten-year jump took me a bit to adjust to but the book was action-packed and I loved all the twists and turns!
-
Thank you Thomas Nelson for the copy of this book.
-
The book takes place ten years after the first book and Jack and Ivy need to work together to end the Order of the Rising Moon.
-
I loved reading more about Jack and Ivy. The author did such a good job setting up their love story in the first book. The ten-year jump took me a bit to adjust to but the book was action-packed and I loved all the twists and turns!
-
Thank you Thomas Nelson for the copy of this book.
September 4, 2024
Another DNF just over half way through.
I can’t with this book. I found the whole thing cliche and not well written. Full RTC to come
Content Concerns
A mention of a woman’s bare legs, with garters.
3 use of B***ard
A mention of a woman reaching into her brassiere to retrieve a hidden paper, (no details)
A mention of going to a speakeasy, with multiple mentions of women having rouged knees.
Multiple mentions of a woman wanting to be taken into a man’s arms
2 D words
2 H word used descriptively
A mention of a woman wanting to be smothered in kisses
A mention of a marriage bed being lonely with just one person
Mentions of wanting to be touched and kissed.
A woman kisses a mans scared shoulder, and she says how she will shower all his scars in kisses, (mildly detailed)
A man says how he is scared of if he takes one step closer to a woman he might not be able to resist touching her, which the woman tells him to touch her, and takes one step closer to the man.
A woman jumps into water in her underclothes and later stands before her husband wearing only that, though it is now translucent from the water, she begins to take them off, and her husband turns his head to her disappointment. Her thinking how it has been so long since he looked at her with desire and appreciation, how his eyes used to look at her with longing, and which she’d ravenously returned. She scolds herself for thinking this, and thinks perhaps that will come with time. She goes behind a screen and grabs a towel and quilt to cover herself before appearing again. (Written mainly as said above)
Hel*ish is used as a description.
A man while his head is on a his wife’s neck, notices how it smells, and he thinks how he used to kiss her there.
A man notices how he used to kiss a woman behind her ear, but how he should take their romance slow, and not just, “Throw her over his shoulder and carry her upstairs.”
A mention of a man who had ordered Gosple records and instead ragtime had shown up, so he sold the records for half price, a woman remarks that the man wouldn’t know good music if it bit him on the ear.
A man and woman tipple over while dancing landing on top of one another this later leads to them kissing. (Mildly detailed to detailed, I ended up skimming this scene) Mentions of touching, wanting to touch etc.
A mention of a man wanting to kiss a woman’s lips until they bruise
A man looks away from a woman in her nightgown, which she berates him for, saying he can look at a knife wound, but turns into a blushing virgin at the sight of a woman in her nightie.
A mention of wanting to send a woman to H*ll with another man
I can’t with this book. I found the whole thing cliche and not well written. Full RTC to come
Content Concerns
A mention of a woman’s bare legs, with garters.
3 use of B***ard
A mention of a woman reaching into her brassiere to retrieve a hidden paper, (no details)
A mention of going to a speakeasy, with multiple mentions of women having rouged knees.
Multiple mentions of a woman wanting to be taken into a man’s arms
2 D words
2 H word used descriptively
A mention of a woman wanting to be smothered in kisses
A mention of a marriage bed being lonely with just one person
Mentions of wanting to be touched and kissed.
A woman kisses a mans scared shoulder, and she says how she will shower all his scars in kisses, (mildly detailed)
A man says how he is scared of if he takes one step closer to a woman he might not be able to resist touching her, which the woman tells him to touch her, and takes one step closer to the man.
A woman jumps into water in her underclothes and later stands before her husband wearing only that, though it is now translucent from the water, she begins to take them off, and her husband turns his head to her disappointment. Her thinking how it has been so long since he looked at her with desire and appreciation, how his eyes used to look at her with longing, and which she’d ravenously returned. She scolds herself for thinking this, and thinks perhaps that will come with time. She goes behind a screen and grabs a towel and quilt to cover herself before appearing again. (Written mainly as said above)
Hel*ish is used as a description.
A man while his head is on a his wife’s neck, notices how it smells, and he thinks how he used to kiss her there.
A man notices how he used to kiss a woman behind her ear, but how he should take their romance slow, and not just, “Throw her over his shoulder and carry her upstairs.”
A mention of a man who had ordered Gosple records and instead ragtime had shown up, so he sold the records for half price, a woman remarks that the man wouldn’t know good music if it bit him on the ear.
A man and woman tipple over while dancing landing on top of one another this later leads to them kissing. (Mildly detailed to detailed, I ended up skimming this scene) Mentions of touching, wanting to touch etc.
A mention of a man wanting to kiss a woman’s lips until they bruise
A man looks away from a woman in her nightgown, which she berates him for, saying he can look at a knife wound, but turns into a blushing virgin at the sight of a woman in her nightie.
A mention of wanting to send a woman to H*ll with another man
August 29, 2023
2.5 stars.
I was really excited for this read, after enjoying The Brilliance of Stars (book 1 in the duology). Unfortunately, it really expanded on the things I didn't enjoy about Book 1--A Lot of violence, and a fade-to-black that could/should have ended way earlier (for my taste anyway). No faith element whatsoever, and a handful of swear words, sealed the deal as a disappointing read; I ended up skimming the last quarter or so just to see how it would all pan out.
The Ice Swan was much more my cup of tea, and one I would return to again, as well as recommend to readers over this series. Which is sad; many elements of it remind me of Captain America: The Winter Soldier--one of my favorite Marvel movies--but it continues past where the movie left off, leaving little to the imagination in every sense.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
I was really excited for this read, after enjoying The Brilliance of Stars (book 1 in the duology). Unfortunately, it really expanded on the things I didn't enjoy about Book 1--A Lot of violence, and a fade-to-black that could/should have ended way earlier (for my taste anyway). No faith element whatsoever, and a handful of swear words, sealed the deal as a disappointing read; I ended up skimming the last quarter or so just to see how it would all pan out.
The Ice Swan was much more my cup of tea, and one I would return to again, as well as recommend to readers over this series. Which is sad; many elements of it remind me of Captain America: The Winter Soldier--one of my favorite Marvel movies--but it continues past where the movie left off, leaving little to the imagination in every sense.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
September 6, 2023
I Am Speechless! This Could Be A Movie!
I thought the first book was amazing and this second book took you even further into a crazy world of intrigue and emotions.
I am anticipating another book with what has been shared in the Epilogue!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
*Audiobook
Narrated by Ariel Hanson & Callan Friesen I forgot that I was NOT a fan of the first book Audiobook. I went through the same emotions. I struggled with both female and male voices being read by whoever is reading that chapter. It is confusing and doesn’t sound right all the time. Just my opinion. I needed to get some cleaning/decluttering done and chose to listen when I was doing this task. I’ll give it 4 stars.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
*Audiobook
Narrated by Ariel Hanson & Callan Friesen I forgot that I was NOT a fan of the first book Audiobook. I went through the same emotions. I struggled with both female and male voices being read by whoever is reading that chapter. It is confusing and doesn’t sound right all the time. Just my opinion. I needed to get some cleaning/decluttering done and chose to listen when I was doing this task. I’ll give it 4 stars.
August 14, 2023
Excellent. From the get-go I was sucked in and couldn’t put it down without thinking about it all over again. Pretty sure I loved this one more than the first book.
The combination of suspense, action and romance was a fantastic one, and one that J’Nell did an amazing job of writing. I felt what the characters felt, was hoping for them, cheering for them (or railing against their enemies), and on the edge of my seat on how they were going to all pan out.
I thought the PTSD portions were really well done, and the fight of Ivy for Jack and not letting him go was incredible. I felt like it was realistic and both heartfelt and heart wrenching at the same time. Really loved this one a lot.
The combination of suspense, action and romance was a fantastic one, and one that J’Nell did an amazing job of writing. I felt what the characters felt, was hoping for them, cheering for them (or railing against their enemies), and on the edge of my seat on how they were going to all pan out.
I thought the PTSD portions were really well done, and the fight of Ivy for Jack and not letting him go was incredible. I felt like it was realistic and both heartfelt and heart wrenching at the same time. Really loved this one a lot.
June 7, 2024
It is hard for me to describe how much I loved this duology! Captain America: Winter Soldier meets WWI Spy Novel meets swoony romance! Jack and Ivy are such amazing characters, and their journey is wonderfully exciting and utterly romantic! Jack is a dreamy hero that would burn the world down to protect Ivy, and Ivy will stop at nothing to be with Jack. They go through the worst things imaginable to come out on the other side for their happy ending. I love their story of happily ever after with trauma ❤️
This is one I will reread again and again, and I cannot recommend these books enough! So incredibly worthy of 5 stars!
This is one I will reread again and again, and I cannot recommend these books enough! So incredibly worthy of 5 stars!
September 15, 2023
This white-knuckled conclusion to The Brilliance of Stars takes readers on a breathless adventure from the speakeasies of America to the Horse Guards Parade in London, an ancient cemetery outside Paris, and back to the Eastern European strongholds where the Vales' tragedy first began.
"Fate is fickle and the stars are silent, but I do know this: No matter how difficult the circumstances or how savagely the world tries to tear us apart, I am here with you."
Ten years have passed since Jack and Ivy, elite operatives for the secret agency Talon, rescued their friend Philip and completed their fateful mission. The 1920s are in full swing as American speakeasies thrive amid Prohibition, and despite the team's best efforts, the deadly cult, the Order of the Rising Moon, lives on in the shadows. Which is no surprise to Ivy; nothing has gone as she expected since that day after Poenari Castle.
When a wave of assassinations strikes world leaders, intel confirms the Order's involvement. Ivy holds them responsible for the tragedy that changed her life, and she is determined to find and destroy the villains once and for all--but she must do so before their relentless assassin eliminates his next target. Her.
Except, there's something oddly familiar about the way he moves, the way he anticipates each of her moves. It's as if he knows her. But that's not possible. Is it? Ivy will have to rely on every skill she's learned if she hopes to survive--and save those she loves. No matter the cost.
This is second book in the series about Jack & Ivy with the highly secret & covert organisation know as Tallon. An absolutely brilliant read - I could not put it down! Page after page, chapter after chapter and I was hooked - I did not want it to end! The novel is another thrilling adventure filled with glamorous espionage and a boundless romance.
Will Ivy and her fellow Tallon members manage to destroy the Order of the Rising Moon before they can take over the world? Is Jack still alive? If so, where and what has happened to him over the last ten years? This book will have you on the edge of your seat!! Once again, J'nell Ciesielski has not disappointed. I have absolutely loved this series and highly recommend both books - “The Brilliance of Stars” and “To Free The Stars” 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
"Fate is fickle and the stars are silent, but I do know this: No matter how difficult the circumstances or how savagely the world tries to tear us apart, I am here with you."
Ten years have passed since Jack and Ivy, elite operatives for the secret agency Talon, rescued their friend Philip and completed their fateful mission. The 1920s are in full swing as American speakeasies thrive amid Prohibition, and despite the team's best efforts, the deadly cult, the Order of the Rising Moon, lives on in the shadows. Which is no surprise to Ivy; nothing has gone as she expected since that day after Poenari Castle.
When a wave of assassinations strikes world leaders, intel confirms the Order's involvement. Ivy holds them responsible for the tragedy that changed her life, and she is determined to find and destroy the villains once and for all--but she must do so before their relentless assassin eliminates his next target. Her.
Except, there's something oddly familiar about the way he moves, the way he anticipates each of her moves. It's as if he knows her. But that's not possible. Is it? Ivy will have to rely on every skill she's learned if she hopes to survive--and save those she loves. No matter the cost.
This is second book in the series about Jack & Ivy with the highly secret & covert organisation know as Tallon. An absolutely brilliant read - I could not put it down! Page after page, chapter after chapter and I was hooked - I did not want it to end! The novel is another thrilling adventure filled with glamorous espionage and a boundless romance.
Will Ivy and her fellow Tallon members manage to destroy the Order of the Rising Moon before they can take over the world? Is Jack still alive? If so, where and what has happened to him over the last ten years? This book will have you on the edge of your seat!! Once again, J'nell Ciesielski has not disappointed. I have absolutely loved this series and highly recommend both books - “The Brilliance of Stars” and “To Free The Stars” 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
October 7, 2023
Wonderful conclusion to the series! Readers definitely need to read the books in order to appreciate the storyline. Plot and characters are a continuation of the previous story.
The author penned a wonderful fast-paced story, filled with spies, action, romance and so much more. This story is partially a fantasy in that there are elements of a 'Captain America' ish character. There are heroes and villains, and those that fall somewhere in between. It is set in the 1920's, following WWI.
The mood of the story is not as light as some of the other books penned by the author. That may or may not appeal to all audiences, but I found the story a wonderful sequel to the first novel. The themes of good vs. evil, and of justice vs. mercy will have readers contemplating the power of grace.
Content warning: references to PTSD, and details of an intimate relationship of married couple that may be too descriptive for some readers.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher thorough Netgalley and was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
The author penned a wonderful fast-paced story, filled with spies, action, romance and so much more. This story is partially a fantasy in that there are elements of a 'Captain America' ish character. There are heroes and villains, and those that fall somewhere in between. It is set in the 1920's, following WWI.
The mood of the story is not as light as some of the other books penned by the author. That may or may not appeal to all audiences, but I found the story a wonderful sequel to the first novel. The themes of good vs. evil, and of justice vs. mercy will have readers contemplating the power of grace.
Content warning: references to PTSD, and details of an intimate relationship of married couple that may be too descriptive for some readers.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher thorough Netgalley and was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
July 14, 2024
Thank you Thomas Nelson for accepting my request to read and review To Free the Stars on NetGalley.
Stars: 2.5
Reading this duology in order would be my recommendation. I have not read the first book and I don't see it in my future.
The story is not fast paced or gripping as the blurb suggests. I did find gaps in thinking causing me to ponder did I skip a page. Midway through the book I found out this was book two.
My personal experience is 50/50 on reading a series in order. To Free the Stars may have been more enjoyable if I had a previous relationship with Jack and Ivy. As it stands I liked Jack but equally did not care for Ivy.
Additionally, I don't relate to a female spy holding her own with men. These characters are always written without acknowledging what all women fear by male strangers. Ivy is bold and crass and never garnered any concern by me.
The story could be told in a 90 minute program and I would watch wondering why smart female spies aren't written.
This also was a GoodReads Giveaway Physical Book Win for me. I am appreciative and will pass the book on.
Stars: 2.5
Reading this duology in order would be my recommendation. I have not read the first book and I don't see it in my future.
The story is not fast paced or gripping as the blurb suggests. I did find gaps in thinking causing me to ponder did I skip a page. Midway through the book I found out this was book two.
My personal experience is 50/50 on reading a series in order. To Free the Stars may have been more enjoyable if I had a previous relationship with Jack and Ivy. As it stands I liked Jack but equally did not care for Ivy.
Additionally, I don't relate to a female spy holding her own with men. These characters are always written without acknowledging what all women fear by male strangers. Ivy is bold and crass and never garnered any concern by me.
The story could be told in a 90 minute program and I would watch wondering why smart female spies aren't written.
This also was a GoodReads Giveaway Physical Book Win for me. I am appreciative and will pass the book on.
July 27, 2023
After successfully rescuing Phillip from the Order of the Rising Moon, Ivy and Jack are looking forward to some rest and recovery back at the Talon headquarters. But an ambush derails all of Ivy’s plans as she watches Jack disappear into the darkness. Ten years later, Ivy has accepted that her husband is dead and is focused on bringing down the Order that took him from her. She’s in the midst of her reckless revenge when she comes face-to-face with someone she never thought she’d see again.
This book was so good! Full of action and intrigue. Betrayal and reconciliation. And a lovely romance. So many wonderful things in this story. I felt there was a perfect balance of action and romance. I thought all the action scenes were very well done and exciting. And the romance was sweet and hopeful. Ivy and Jack have a rough, emotional journey but it’s so worth the read and so satisfying in the end. Just a really well written story that sucks you in. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
If you’re looking for historical fiction with intrigue, action, and romance then pick up this duology, “The Brilliance of Stars” and “To Free the Stars”.
Thank you Netgalley and Thomas Nelson Publishers for the opportunity to read this book. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
This book was so good! Full of action and intrigue. Betrayal and reconciliation. And a lovely romance. So many wonderful things in this story. I felt there was a perfect balance of action and romance. I thought all the action scenes were very well done and exciting. And the romance was sweet and hopeful. Ivy and Jack have a rough, emotional journey but it’s so worth the read and so satisfying in the end. Just a really well written story that sucks you in. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
If you’re looking for historical fiction with intrigue, action, and romance then pick up this duology, “The Brilliance of Stars” and “To Free the Stars”.
Thank you Netgalley and Thomas Nelson Publishers for the opportunity to read this book. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
September 6, 2023
I Am Speechless! This Could Be A Movie!
I thought the first book was amazing and this second book took you even further into a crazy world of intrigue and emotions.
I am anticipating another book with what has been shared in the Epilogue!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
I thought the first book was amazing and this second book took you even further into a crazy world of intrigue and emotions.
I am anticipating another book with what has been shared in the Epilogue!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
August 1, 2023
I want to start by saying you need to read the prequel, “The Brilliance of Stars”, before reading this book. This book will not make a bit of sense to you if you don’t read the prequel first. The last book ended on a big cliffhanger, and this one takes off right after those events. This story is full of heartbreak, betrayal, love, and loyalty, but the main theme is reconciliation. Jack and Ivy are cruelly separated for ten years, not even knowing if the other is alive. When they are finally reunited it is not what we would have hoped for. They are not the same young lovers we knew in the last book. They’ve each been through their own Hell and must work to become partners/lovers again. Is there a way back for them? Their love for each other is still there, but the obstacles seem insurmountable. Thankfully they’re not your typical couple and along their journey there’s plenty of action and romance to keep us on the edge of our seats throughout the story. I did not want this story to end because I was so invested in Jack and Ivy’s relationship and their development as characters. I love these two books and I highly recommend them if you like thrilling spy stories with plenty of romance, humor, and heartache.
This is my honest opinion based on the complimentary review copy sent by the author and the publisher. I was not required to give a favorable review.
This is my honest opinion based on the complimentary review copy sent by the author and the publisher. I was not required to give a favorable review.
July 12, 2023
4.25/5⭐️
This was the second in an historical thriller/romance/fantasy, and the conclusion of the Jack and Ivy series set in the world of 1920s espionage.
Ivy, an agent for the Talon espionage agency, has had to live with heartache and regret for the past 10 years. But hunting down and destroying members of the evil deadly cult, the Order of the Rising Moon, has helped her resolve some of her need for revenge and vengeance. But as long-buried secrets and lies are unearthed, she finds herself struggling to forgive unimaginable deceit from an unexpected source.
I enjoyed this one and found it a satisfying conclusion to the series. It was interesting to see the character growth/interactions after the passage of 10 years, and while there were some heartbreaking surprises from some of the characters, one in particular was especially sad. However, I could see it coming and understood its inclusion in the story.
Well written (I always enjoy Ciesielski’s books), good plot development and a pleasing conclusion.
My sincere thanks to the author, NetGalley and Thomas Nelson for the complimentary early arc of To Free the Stars for review. The opinions are strictly my own.
This was the second in an historical thriller/romance/fantasy, and the conclusion of the Jack and Ivy series set in the world of 1920s espionage.
Ivy, an agent for the Talon espionage agency, has had to live with heartache and regret for the past 10 years. But hunting down and destroying members of the evil deadly cult, the Order of the Rising Moon, has helped her resolve some of her need for revenge and vengeance. But as long-buried secrets and lies are unearthed, she finds herself struggling to forgive unimaginable deceit from an unexpected source.
I enjoyed this one and found it a satisfying conclusion to the series. It was interesting to see the character growth/interactions after the passage of 10 years, and while there were some heartbreaking surprises from some of the characters, one in particular was especially sad. However, I could see it coming and understood its inclusion in the story.
Well written (I always enjoy Ciesielski’s books), good plot development and a pleasing conclusion.
My sincere thanks to the author, NetGalley and Thomas Nelson for the complimentary early arc of To Free the Stars for review. The opinions are strictly my own.
August 15, 2023
3.5 🌟 but I wanted to round up because I adore J'nell's work and who she is as a person and you should still read this book!
I binged read this over two plane flights when I should have been sleeping... safe to say it kept me engaged through its entirety.
A mix of some of my favorite things, this duology has a big place in my heart. Is this a perfect novel? No I don't think so, there were some character choices that were not my favorite and sometimes I was just left wanting more from certain moments. But no matter, the world that Ciesielski has built is full and fleshed out.
Jack and Ivy are so such a beautiful couple and their story is devastating and hopeful at the same time, a balance so well kept by the author. It reminded me a lot of what Jamie and Claire in Outlander went through in season 1 and 2 of Outlander. Also lots of comparisons to Bucky Barnes, obviously.
Jack and Ivy is where this novel shines and their journey is what will stay with me!
I do think Brilliance of Stars is a stronger novel but this is a worthy sequel. I only wish it was a trilogy because I just cannot see this being the end of these characters.
I binged read this over two plane flights when I should have been sleeping... safe to say it kept me engaged through its entirety.
A mix of some of my favorite things, this duology has a big place in my heart. Is this a perfect novel? No I don't think so, there were some character choices that were not my favorite and sometimes I was just left wanting more from certain moments. But no matter, the world that Ciesielski has built is full and fleshed out.
Jack and Ivy are so such a beautiful couple and their story is devastating and hopeful at the same time, a balance so well kept by the author. It reminded me a lot of what Jamie and Claire in Outlander went through in season 1 and 2 of Outlander. Also lots of comparisons to Bucky Barnes, obviously.
Jack and Ivy is where this novel shines and their journey is what will stay with me!
I do think Brilliance of Stars is a stronger novel but this is a worthy sequel. I only wish it was a trilogy because I just cannot see this being the end of these characters.
October 13, 2023
If you're a fan of Captain America: The Winter Solider you'll enjoy this book. However, I must admit to being extremely disappointed that although published by a Christian publisher there was absolutely no faith story at all. Even more distressing because it would have been the perfect segue for darkness, death and betrayal, to turn into light, life and forgiveness. Instead, we're constantly beaten over the head with revenge, violence and bloodlust. I get that it drives the characters and plot to an edge of your seat thriller, but how much better it would've been (in my opinion) if there was a redemptive story that would have pointed to God....the true Light against darkness.
October 27, 2024
Such a disappointing duology. The excessive foul language was unacceptable in a Christian book.
Jack was a fantastic hero even when he felt lost and broken. It was completely heartbreaking what he was forced to do.
Other than Ivy’s gutter language, I liked her as a character.
The plot was complex with brainwashing, betrayal, hope, and action.
Content: excessive expletives, speakeasies, swearing by the stars, replacement profanity, tobacco, violence and torture, tavern, tattoos, profanity, alcohol, drugs
Jack was a fantastic hero even when he felt lost and broken. It was completely heartbreaking what he was forced to do.
Other than Ivy’s gutter language, I liked her as a character.
The plot was complex with brainwashing, betrayal, hope, and action.
Content: excessive expletives, speakeasies, swearing by the stars, replacement profanity, tobacco, violence and torture, tavern, tattoos, profanity, alcohol, drugs
September 5, 2023
Jack and Ivy! Jack and Ivy! The series included everything its marketing promised—action and intrigue and romance and more. I was impatient for this second book in the series the second I finished the first one, and I was not disappointed! J'nell Ciesielski has become a fave of mine over the past few years and I'm already watching her social media for any hints as to what comes next. :)
September 5, 2025
Two important notes before I begin my review:
Seeing how this book has generally higher reviews than 2 stars, this book’s inability to keep me entertained may be because I am not big on romance heavy stories. But I wanted to write a review because it’s not often that I actually give up trying to finish a book, romance or not.
I have not read any of the earlier books about Jack and Ivy, and this may have also played a part in my opinion of the characters. I have no intentions of reading any of the other books.
I will never say that an author is a terrible writer as each has their own style. But I found almost every character in this book lacking depth. Ivy - the main character- had no personality beyond that of her husband’s and her grief for him. While I understand the author was trying to portray trauma and loss, it was very easily and plainly laid out at the start, and I got tired of hearing the same exact inner monologue from Ivy. I feel like she wanted Ivy to be a “Black Widow,” but Ivy seemed to struggle with thinking before she did much of anything. She was extremely predictable.
I did appreciate, however, the portion of the book that focused on her and Jack at the house. They both had good development and it flowed quite well.
Jack is Bucky Barnes with a wife. There isn’t much else to say about him.
Ivy’s brother whose name I have already forgotten - not only did the author point out at the beginning that he appeared to have little personality, he truly didn’t. While I understand that again he was a representative of emotional response from trauma - I never felt bad for him. And for someone raised to be a secret agent/spy, he became a coward far too easily. I don’t buy that he was still being mentally manipulated when he chose to do the things that he did. He was intended to be a shocking plot twist, but his story was too shallow. I could not manage making any emotional attachments to this character.
The plot. Some aspects were original, but overall it was repetitive. Some of the fighting scenes felt a little cheesy (cheesy worked in Star Wars but doesn’t really work here). The point I stopped reading was when Jack was taken hostage again towards the end of the book. This felt like another lazy and sloppy plot twist, except it wasn’t a plot twist because they kept saying how the enemy was intending to capture him again. The plot made full circle and started over again with only a few chapters left.
This was a brutal review but I can’t remember the last time I actually gave up reading a book. If you are hyper focused on romance, this book will probably be more enjoyable than I found it.
Seeing how this book has generally higher reviews than 2 stars, this book’s inability to keep me entertained may be because I am not big on romance heavy stories. But I wanted to write a review because it’s not often that I actually give up trying to finish a book, romance or not.
I have not read any of the earlier books about Jack and Ivy, and this may have also played a part in my opinion of the characters. I have no intentions of reading any of the other books.
I will never say that an author is a terrible writer as each has their own style. But I found almost every character in this book lacking depth. Ivy - the main character- had no personality beyond that of her husband’s and her grief for him. While I understand the author was trying to portray trauma and loss, it was very easily and plainly laid out at the start, and I got tired of hearing the same exact inner monologue from Ivy. I feel like she wanted Ivy to be a “Black Widow,” but Ivy seemed to struggle with thinking before she did much of anything. She was extremely predictable.
I did appreciate, however, the portion of the book that focused on her and Jack at the house. They both had good development and it flowed quite well.
Jack is Bucky Barnes with a wife. There isn’t much else to say about him.
Ivy’s brother whose name I have already forgotten - not only did the author point out at the beginning that he appeared to have little personality, he truly didn’t. While I understand that again he was a representative of emotional response from trauma - I never felt bad for him. And for someone raised to be a secret agent/spy, he became a coward far too easily. I don’t buy that he was still being mentally manipulated when he chose to do the things that he did. He was intended to be a shocking plot twist, but his story was too shallow. I could not manage making any emotional attachments to this character.
The plot. Some aspects were original, but overall it was repetitive. Some of the fighting scenes felt a little cheesy (cheesy worked in Star Wars but doesn’t really work here). The point I stopped reading was when Jack was taken hostage again towards the end of the book. This felt like another lazy and sloppy plot twist, except it wasn’t a plot twist because they kept saying how the enemy was intending to capture him again. The plot made full circle and started over again with only a few chapters left.
This was a brutal review but I can’t remember the last time I actually gave up reading a book. If you are hyper focused on romance, this book will probably be more enjoyable than I found it.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 5, 2023
"You must go on, love. For me. For us."
Consumed by bitterness, plagued with regret, he is the most important rescue mission of her life...this time, she will not fail.
If you've read J'nell Ciesielski's novel Beauty Among the Ruins, take that fairy tale retelling and imagine something the complete and total polar opposite. And voila! I present to you To Free the Stars, the second book in the Jack and Ivy series.
Do not pick up this story without reading The Brillance of Stars first! Set ten years after the first story ends, To Free the Stars had me on the edge of my seat! The story is fast paced as the members of Talon work to eradicate a group of psychotic occultists. The tone of the story starts with a bright-ish feel before plunging into the dark and oppressively evil nature of the Order. There were plenty of twists and turns to keep the story interesting and one twist in particular left me feeling pretty angry with one of the characters. I enjoyed this adventure, even though it is a little darker than my usual read and left me with a heaviness in my soul. It's the kind of story that you just can't let go of after you've finished reading.
If I were to get nit-picky... Once again, like the first book, I would not classify this story as Christian fiction. Having read the first story I was prepared for the language included in this novel, but I still found it disappointing coming from a Christian publishing house. (b****rd, d***n, were used 11 times throughout). There was also an intimate scene that was mildly descriptive and didn't really bother me but might be bothersome to others. Other content warnings: torture, drugs, gun violence, murder.
Choose as your next read if you like:
Revenge
Betrayal
Strong female main characters
Second chances
Justice vs. Mercy
If you liked Captain America - The Winter Soldier, or enjoyed The Heart of Betrayal by Mary E Pearson, I think you would like this book.
Thank you, J'nell Ciesielski, Thomas Nelson, and Net Galley for the complimentary copy of this book. The opinions expressed here are my own.
Consumed by bitterness, plagued with regret, he is the most important rescue mission of her life...this time, she will not fail.
If you've read J'nell Ciesielski's novel Beauty Among the Ruins, take that fairy tale retelling and imagine something the complete and total polar opposite. And voila! I present to you To Free the Stars, the second book in the Jack and Ivy series.
Do not pick up this story without reading The Brillance of Stars first! Set ten years after the first story ends, To Free the Stars had me on the edge of my seat! The story is fast paced as the members of Talon work to eradicate a group of psychotic occultists. The tone of the story starts with a bright-ish feel before plunging into the dark and oppressively evil nature of the Order. There were plenty of twists and turns to keep the story interesting and one twist in particular left me feeling pretty angry with one of the characters. I enjoyed this adventure, even though it is a little darker than my usual read and left me with a heaviness in my soul. It's the kind of story that you just can't let go of after you've finished reading.
If I were to get nit-picky... Once again, like the first book, I would not classify this story as Christian fiction. Having read the first story I was prepared for the language included in this novel, but I still found it disappointing coming from a Christian publishing house. (b****rd, d***n, were used 11 times throughout). There was also an intimate scene that was mildly descriptive and didn't really bother me but might be bothersome to others. Other content warnings: torture, drugs, gun violence, murder.
Choose as your next read if you like:
Revenge
Betrayal
Strong female main characters
Second chances
Justice vs. Mercy
If you liked Captain America - The Winter Soldier, or enjoyed The Heart of Betrayal by Mary E Pearson, I think you would like this book.
Thank you, J'nell Ciesielski, Thomas Nelson, and Net Galley for the complimentary copy of this book. The opinions expressed here are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 118 reviews