I read this for a course and wanted to find it helpful. Unfortunately, even the authors admit in the book that the ideas presented are vague and idealistic. I appreciate the awareness that our model of music education chases away many minorities and that can be minimized by more creativity and a nod to student knowledge. A lot of this is being addressed in the elementary music classroom and my course gave me a few ways to concretely implement these ideals. If you teach secondary, I don't feel this book gives you a way forward. Some of the community involvement pieces were inspired, while others sounded like a quick way to get fired. The biggest positive I have for this book is confidence in some practices I've been trying to institute, like less of a concentration on notation and drawing on student interest. I am inspired to try and bring in some vetted community music groups that show "amateur" musicianship in adulthood.