“EVERYTHING WAS SO BEAUTIFUL!”
John Preston is one of the gay community’s iconic writers. He is probably most famous for the novel Mr. Benson. His novel Franny, the Queen of Provincetown is one of my favorite gay novels. Winter’s Light: Reflections of a Yankee Queer was posthumously published by the University Press of New England in 1995. John Preston was lost to AIDS in April 1994, at the age of 48. The book is edited by Michael Lowenthal, who also contributes an introduction. Andrew Holleran provides the foreword. A valuable list of the complete works of John Preston appears at the end of the book.
In his foreword, Andrew Holleran writes, “Preston zeroes in on the gay, and human, dilemma: How to find a home.” John Preston eventually found a home—and community—in Portland, Maine. The first four and the last of the six sections in Winter’s Light–The Importance of Telling Our Stories, The Men of Maine, Letters from Maine, A New England Chorus, and Down East—contain fascinating essays that describe Preston’s search for home and community, how he found it in Maine, and his life in Maine.
In 1986, John Preston was diagnosed as HIV-positive. The fifth section in Winter’s Light is titled Some of Us Are Dying and includes powerful writings on AIDS. In the essay titled “Some of Us Are Dying,” Preston writes, “If we allow our fears to let us deny our connection with people who are facing death, we make a mockery of our attempt at a communal existence.” Community was of the utmost importance to John Preston. The last line of “Some of Us Are Dying” is, “No one should have to fight . . . [the] battle alone.”
In “AIDS Writing,” a speech which John Preston delivered at OutWrite 1990, he emphasizes that the problem with writing about AIDS is that “the emotions are too raw. And the scale is too great.” Preston describes himself as “a scribe,” “not the author of the story, but the means for telling the story, the tool used by people to let the world, their families, their friends, understand what is going on.”
Michael Lowenthal considers the essay titled “Living with AIDS, 1992” to be John Preston’s “Most profound attempt to document and make sense of his illness.” Preston begins this harrowing essay: “I woke up one morning in May of 1991 with excruciating pain. It was so strong that it made any movement impossible.” While in the hospital, Preston finds out that he has “a bizarre form of pneumonia,” but it is not Pneumocystis. He tells us, “I had escaped death, barely.” Preston is told that he can check out of the hospital after ten days. He couldn’t wait for anyone to come and get him: “I was too eager to leave. I was so weak I could barely walk, but I managed to get dressed and get by the nurses and leave on my own energy. Whan I first got outside the building I thought I was still under the influence of drugs. Everything was so beautiful!”
In his editor’s note to “Down East,” the last essay in Winter’s Light, Michael Lowenthal observes, “’Down East’ is the New Englander’s equivalent of ‘over the rainbow,’ more a state of mind than an actual location.” In the first paragraph of “Down East,” John Preston writes, “You can never reach Down East. As soon as you arrive in a place, it can no longer be Down East. Down East must be somewhere else.” He says, “I’ve heard at least twelve versions of one story in the years I’ve lived in Maine.” This story involves a bar in a fishing village Down East where the fishermen go. These fishermen are all gay. They feel no need to go to cities to be gay because in the village they have each other, they have community. Preston feels that if he were to go to this village, he “might find a wonderful reality . . . but I would never have the dream again.”
John Preston ends “Down East” with the following memorable sentence: “And that’s the risk of striving to make dreams come true, that as good as the reality might be, I can never know if it will equal the splendor of the fantasy I can hold forever.”
Winter’s Light was supposed to contain more material than it does, but John Preston died before the book was completed. We are fortunate to have these beautifully written essays by John Preston.