Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Best American Comics #4

The Best American Comics 2009

Rate this book
Now in its fourth year, "Best American Comics" showcases the work of both established and up-and-coming contributers. Editor Charles Burns--cartoonist, illustrator, and official cover artist of the "Believer--"has culled the best stories from graphic novels, pamphlet comics, newspapers, magazines, mini-comics, and the web to create this cutting-edge collection. Featuring the work of such luminaries as Chris Ware, KAZ, and Robert Crumb, this volume is "a genuine salute to comics" ("Houston Chronicle)."

332 pages, Hardcover

First published October 8, 2009

6 people are currently reading
251 people want to read

About the author

Charles Burns

100 books1,106 followers
Charles Burns is an American cartoonist and illustrator.
Burns grew up in Seattle in the 1970s. His comic book work rose to prominence in Art Spiegelman and Françoise Mouly magazine 'RAW' in the mid-1980s. Nowadays, Burns is best known for the horror/coming of age graphic novel Black Hole, originally serialised in twelve issues between 1995 and 2004. The story was eventually collected in one volume by Pantheon Books and received Eisner, Harvey, and Ignatz awards in 2005. His following works X'ed Out (2010), The Hive (2012), Sugar Skull (2014), Last Look (2016) and Last Cut (2024) have also been published by Pantheon Books, although the latter was first released in France as a series of three French comic albums.
As an illustrator, Charles Burns has been involved in a wide range of projects, from Iggy Pop album covers to an ad campaign for Altoids. In 1992 he designed the sets for Mark Morris's restaging of The Nutcracker (renamed The Hard Nut) at the Brooklyn Academy of Music. He illustrated covers for Time, The New Yorker, and The New York Times Magazine. He was also tapped as the official cover artist for The Believer magazine at its inception in 2003.
Burns lives in Philadelphia with his wife and daughters.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
86 (19%)
4 stars
138 (31%)
3 stars
159 (35%)
2 stars
48 (10%)
1 star
11 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews
Profile Image for Dave-O.
154 reviews13 followers
December 11, 2009
The usual mixed bag. The usual anthology players are in here, as well they should be for the most part. The intro makes the point that comics are not read on subjective reasons so that they become more matters of taste, but I don't think that its any more or less than other art forms.

With that in mind, here are my two bits:

-For all their excellent craftsmanship, Adrian Tomine and Chris Ware are treading a thin line between being interesting and being derivative.

-Ben Katchor's comic was reproduced so small that it was unreadable.

-I admire the Crumbs' ability to tell a straightforward story (that in itself, is somewhat avant-garde), including an aside on the making of the comic.

-Dan Zettwoch's has a very inventive entry in this volume.

-Dash Shaw has the only very exceptional work in the book.
Profile Image for Courtney.
1,618 reviews43 followers
June 9, 2015
A vast majority of this collection is sub-par. Perhaps, it is because it is framed as "best" that I feel that they fall short. I was appreciative of the variety of styles, but I found many of the comics lacking actual substance.

However, I do recommend that you pick up this volume and read Laura Park's (in my copy it's page 217), as well as Jillian and Mariko Tamaki's section. I found both comics to be wonderfully (and differently) styled, and their subject matters to be compelling. Koren Shadmi'a Antoinette was funny, and Kevin Huizenga's Glenn Ganges that followed was also very good. But after that, it's all down hill again.

The section that I thoroughly enjoyed didn't even last for 100 pages. I was hopeful because I had greatly enjoyed The Best American Comics 2010. Although, I was mostly drawn to that one dues to Neil Gaiman's name.
Profile Image for Robert.
Author 43 books135 followers
October 30, 2010
Pretty much everything in here is well-done, but somehow this Charles Burns guest-edited edition, along with the Harvey Pekar-edited volume from 2006, remains for me the weakest of the series I've read thus far (with just the brand new 2010 tome left to bring me up to date). The book lacks the cohesion that Chris Ware and Lynda Barry brought to the 2007 and 2008 collections, respectively. I can see the merit in all the stories here, but little truly inspired or excited me; somehow it all remained just a mostly pleasant reading experience. As per the preface by series editors Jessica Abel and Matt Madden, comics, like all art forms, are a hugely subjective experience, so everyone will have their personal huzzahs and brickbats on the selections and the artists chosen. Some of mine, starting with the huzzahs:

Laura Park's art ("Freaks") is really beautiful in this story. She's a breakout new star in the alt-comics world for good reason.
Based on the excerpt included here, I would like to read the complete graphic novel Skim by the Tamaki sisters. Lovely.
It's always a pleasure to read Kaz's "Underworld" comic strips.
Jerry Moriarty's recent return to print is very welcome: truly the Edward Hopper of cartoonists.
Al Columbia's piece is macabre & gorgeous.
Dash Shaw's "The Galactic Funnels" is very interesting and innovative (Dash Shaw is pretty much always interesting and innovative). I read it 3x.
Michael Kupperman is just flat-out funny.
Jason Lutes: just pure respect for his BERLIN. Magnum Opus, in spades.

Negatory:
Even though I understand that he's very talented, I've never gotten the big love for Adrian Tomine: always found his art uninteresting and I'm sorry but derivative (of Daniel Clowes) and his writing one-note, and the fact that this piece from his graphic novel Shortcomings mines the wearisome I'm-a-Twentysomething-Asshole-Het-Guy trope (reminiscent of Joe Matt) doesn't change my lack of regard for his work one iota. So sorry, sue me.
Ron Rege's adaptation of a chapter of Lynda Barry's Cruddy illuminates nothing of Barry's brilliant text.
I love Ted Stearn's Fuzz and Pluck, but don't think this excerpt works so great. Some stuff just excerpts better than others - he's a wonderful cartoonist's cartoonist, irregardless.
Peter Bagge and Doug Allen's stories, respectively: Meh. Really, these were among the BEST comics of the year? I figure they are included as pals of Burns's and per their past individual bodies of work, and that's okay, but both guys have done much, much better than these trifles.

Onward. Looking forward to the 2010 edition, edited by Neil Gaiman, in which he selected a story by Steve MacIsaac & Todd Brower, "Ex-Communication," which originally appeared in the anthology I edited, The Book of Boy Trouble Volume 2 (Green Candy Press). That selection alone is gratifying, for obvious reasons.
Profile Image for Imogen.
Author 6 books1,806 followers
October 16, 2009
Man, either these are all excerpts from longer comics, or Charles Burns hates comics with resolutions. About five times I had to crinkle the last page of a comic to be like, 'that's it?' Which is fine, if that's where comics are going right now, I can get with that. When it works- like in Adrian Tomine's piece here- it can totally knock you over and be awesome. And when it doesn't work, I'm usually still like 'that was nice.'

I could have done without... um, I don't remember his name, the mod guy who has I think four pieces spread out across the book. But I could have done without the comic reprinted here that ends in 'father beats up daughter and then incest, ahaha!' but otherwise this was totally awesome. I laid in Alex's bed all morning and read it while my dog flipped out because she had flea medicine all over her back.
214 reviews2 followers
June 11, 2011
I always enjoy the Best American Comics series, but 2009 was a bit of a disappointment. I suppose I'm just not of the same mindset as Charles Burns, the series editor. He seems to go for more dark, male-oriented, "dumb" jokes type of comics. There are some good choices that I enjoyed, such as Skim by Jillian and Mariko Tamaki, Freaks by Laura Park, and the comics by Dash Shaw and Ben Katchor. The rest, however, seemed fairly mundane and didn't grab me on an intellectual level. But, I think the point of the series is to highlight a variety of comics. You will gravitate towards some and quickly forget others. I wish I liked a few more in this series, but it was a fun read nonetheless.
Profile Image for Regan.
877 reviews5 followers
March 28, 2020
OK. So Charles Burns and I don't appear to see eye to eye on "what's good" (per Burns' introduction). I like Charles Burns. I like some of the artists represented in the 2009 collection. However, overall I really did NOT like what Burns determined to be the "best" of 2009.

Some of it is clearly his preferred style. He really has a soft spot for what reads to me as "old school" comics.


Tim Hensley's "Archie" style art - which receives four coveted spots in the collection - is not interesting to look at, not interesting to read, and often just leaves me feeling bewildered. I have no CLUE why this would be a "best" of anything, much less worthy of FOUR spots when every other artist receives only one.

There's also a lot of "small" art which I just find irksome. If the drawing AND the lettering is too small to see without a magnifying glass I don't care if it's the best thing ever in the history of man, it's going to be really hard to get me invested in it.

Burns also seems very attracted to the "just stop" method of comic closure. Or else there's been a paradigm shift and stories no longer need any sort of ending but just a final panel and I missed the memo. Either way, it's not my favorite approach to the medium. Sometimes I found myself wondering where the rest of the pages were and actually LOOKING for them.

On the flip side, the things I liked I REALLY liked. Adrian Tomine (even with the "just stop" finale), Mimi Pond, Gabrielle Bell, Jerry Moriarty (no words, which I liked more than I expected to), Laura Park, Kevin Huizenga, and especially Jillian and Mariko Tamaki all really worked for me and I will seek out more of each of their work.

I wish the Gilbert Hernandez piece had spoken to me more. I've always found Gilbert's work the least interesting of Los Bros Hernandez, but this was just a non-starter for me.

Overall it was a tepid experience. I even skipped a few that I just could NOT get through. While I may like Charles Burns as an artist and writer, we clearly don't share tastes when he's a collector and editor. Alas.
Profile Image for Theresa.
Author 2 books5 followers
August 11, 2017
I'm not a huge fan of the large comic-book universe, and I mainly picked up this book to see more of Mimi Pond's work (Over Easy, which is excerpted here). I found Gabrielle Bell's piece "When I Was Eleven," and I really enjoyed the story. Graphic novels or memoirs provide such a unique spatial aspect to reading, where traditional novels or memoirs are very linear. I also was interested in Jerry Moriarty's pieces, and Laura Park's "Freaks." Unfortunately, the rest of the selections were not that appealing, but for comic-book fans, this would likely be a book of interest.
Profile Image for Chad.
10.4k reviews1,060 followers
May 13, 2025
I'm surprised at how poor the 2009 volume was. I thought it'd be great given the creators involved. Plus Charles Burns edited it and I love his comics. The best thing in here was Jason Lutes's Berlin and I'd already read it all the way through. I think part of it may have been there were a lot of excerpts in this one and it's hard to pull my interest when you just get 10 pages out of the middle of an entire graphic novel. Fuzz and Pluck in Splitsville did seem interesting. I'll see if I can find that one.
Profile Image for Kat Hulu.
242 reviews
January 4, 2020
Fully half (18 of 36, by my count) of the works excerpted in this collection were also represented in one of the prior two years’ collections—the excerpts are different, but the work does not vary significantly. Most of the double-dips are from 2007, so I’m not sure how they can count for both years (were they serials?). It’s still a pretty good collection, but it was confusing to flip through immediately after digesting the prior two volumes, and discover that every other page was familiar.
Profile Image for Jay.
455 reviews
March 9, 2022
Not my style, honestly skipped through several sections because they were gorey or discomfiting illustrations. Adrian Tomine is an excellent character builder(even if they're jerks). Enjoyed Laura Park, and Kevin Huizenga. I've read Mimi Pond, it's strange to see excerpts of enormous graphic novels in anthologies - I think I'm used to collections where artists/authors submitted shorts.
Profile Image for Aaron.
282 reviews12 followers
June 30, 2017
More of what you'd expect from this series. Happy to see more CF, Sammy Harkham, and even an Al Columbia feature!
Profile Image for Cyborg.
217 reviews1 follower
Read
January 6, 2022
Another great installment of this series. I have some authors I need to look up. Which ones? I don't remember.
Profile Image for Shriya.
48 reviews38 followers
October 3, 2024
loved the pieces in the middle but not start & end 🧐 not what i would expect
Profile Image for Pip.
8 reviews
July 26, 2019
A bestseller by the most popular postwar writer for children of all ages.
Profile Image for Tristy.
754 reviews56 followers
June 13, 2012
I love the eclectic mixes of these anthologies. I also love how they always reflect the editor's style and taste. I'm not the biggest fan of Charles Burns's comics, because he runs a bit too dark for me and this anthology reflects that darkness (but not as much as you would expect!). I discovered some new (to me) artists, which was really a treat. I also really loved Charles Burns's introduction, especially his ode to Tintin comics! My favorite artists/pieces in this anthology are: the collaborative comic by Robert Crumb & Aline Kominsky-Crumb and the pieces by Dan Zettwoch, Mimi Pond, Gabrielle Bell, CF, Tony Millionaire, Ted Stearn, and Jillian Mariko Tamaki.
Profile Image for Andres.
279 reviews39 followers
January 30, 2010
I really like the Best American series (even the knockoffs) and I enjoyed this one a lot, even though some of the comics were out and out strange, or left you wanting more since they were just snippets of a larger whole. This is an enjoyable peek at the wide variety of comics that are out there, and certainly a great starting point in finding what suits your individual tastes. Like with other anthologies, I'll list what caught my attention the most (but without my usual one-sentence summary).

Justin M. Damiano by Daniel Clowes

Our Beloved Tape Dispenser by Robert Crumb and Aline Kominsky-Crumb

Shortcomings (Excerpt) by Adrian Tomine
I did end up seeking out, reading, and enjoying the whole of this one.

When I Was Eleven by Gabrielle Bell

Berlin (Excerpt) by Jason Lutes

Jordan W. Lint by Chris Wares

Freaks by Laura Park

Skim (Excerpt) by Jillian and Mariko Tamaki

Antoinette by Koren Shadmi

Glenn Ganges in Pulverize by Kevin Huizenga

5:45 A.M. by Al Columbia

Profile Image for Sundry.
669 reviews28 followers
January 19, 2010
I've decided that the new edition in this series is my annual winter treat. I always enjoy it, and always find a couple of new graphic novelists or memoirists whose work I want to spend more time with. This year, it's Kevin Huizinga, Tony Millionaire and Jillian & Mariko Tamaki who sent me running to the library database to put titles on hold.

I didn't give this a terribly high numerical ranking because I agree less with the guest editor Mr. Burns than I have with other guest editors about what constitutes a good comic. While I love good, weird, quirky, or accomplished graphics, the best stuff has a good narrative, for me.

Charles Burns' needs are different from mine. Think I'll check out some of the stuff that the series editors Jessica Abel and Matt Madden put on their honorable mention list. What a great job, huh? Reading comics and graphic novels!
Profile Image for Chris.
80 reviews12 followers
October 22, 2009
I'm only two stories in so far, but Daniel Clowes' entry about an online movie reviewer was a spot on critique of juggling the self-importance of judging other peoples work with the self-awareness of how your life impacts your outlook.

UPDATE: Overall this was a great selection of comics. I feel like I've been missing out on not reading Jason Lutes' Berlin, which is gritty and violent, but strewn with intriguing characters. I also think I need to check out more of Matt Broersma. Of course I love the comics from Art Spiegelman, R. Crumb, Chris Ware, Adrian Tomine, Peter Bagge. Overall, I love collections like this. They remind of the glory days of RAW. If you want to venture outside the safe havens of superheroes, this is a great starting point for what is happening now.
Profile Image for Penelope.
284 reviews15 followers
January 2, 2011
Not a bad collection, but also not a great collection. I just finished this a week or so ago, and I can only remember a few strips off the top of my head...the rest were forgettable.

Glancing back through the table of contents, here are some highlights from the collection and some strips I think it could have done without:

Highlights:
"Skim" by Jillian and Mariko Tamaki (excerpt)
"The Galactic Funnels" by Dash Shaw
"Antoinette" by Koren Shadmi

Not a fan:
"Gropius" by Tim Hensley (multiple strips scattered throughout)
"Fuzz & Pluck In Splitsville" by Ted Stearn (excerpt)
"Dal Tokyo" Gary Panter
Profile Image for Raina.
1,718 reviews162 followers
November 28, 2009
Well, I liked Black Hole, but I don't have the same taste as Charles Burns. Or maybe I just have a very accessible, non-sophisticated graphic novel-enthusiast taste. There were five or six selections in this that I really liked, out of a very long collection of excerpts of graphic novels. Nonetheless, I enjoyed seeing the wide variety of material and discovered a couple of new authors.
Profile Image for Peacegal.
11.7k reviews102 followers
December 9, 2010
A disjointed review ™:

The editors must be getting lazy! Best American Comics includes entries from graphic novels that were published in the previous edition. (Do we really need more yuppie ennui from Shortcomings?)

However, I was overjoyed to find reprints of “Maakies” in this one.

I think I should take a break from graphic novels for awhile. They’re giving me weird dreams.
Profile Image for Kyla.
1,009 reviews16 followers
January 28, 2011
What I love about comic anthologies is the almost visceral sense you get the minute you turn the page - ugh, I'm going to hate this one or hmm, this looks interesting. And I will freely admit that if it looks not to my taste - I skip it. With no guilt. For new to me artists, I really liked Michael Kupperman and some Tim Hensley and the Dan Zettwoch. Oldies like Peter Bagge and Dan Clowes had some of their better stuff that I've seen lately. Could always use more women, and that's just a fact.
Profile Image for Shaunterria.
388 reviews32 followers
April 17, 2016
I really felt like I should have enjoyed it more than I did... I read a pretty wide variety of comics, but I just couldn't get into the mix that was presented here. It could have been the format, which consisted of excerpts of some comics, that kept me from fully engaging with the storytelling. As pure art, I did appreciate the quality of many of the strips as shown in the book, but I was pretty disappointed in most of the narratives.
Profile Image for Edwin Arnaudin.
523 reviews10 followers
December 7, 2009
It's impossible for me not to love these annual anthologies. They feature wonderfully delicious snippets of one of my favorite forms and frequently turn me on to larger collections or graphic novels. I look forward to this issue each year and already feel a bit cheated that my current dose is used up.
Profile Image for Budha.
5 reviews3 followers
April 19, 2009
You're not gonna see any superman or batman (although they tried for batman and dc pussed out) it's an all around good book that had me thinking about lots of differnt comics and wanting to head down to the shop and go looking around.
Profile Image for A.
103 reviews
July 29, 2016
Love discovered for:
Tim Hensley
Peter Bagge
Michael Kupperman
Gabrielle Bell
Laura Park
Al Columbia

Love reaffirmed for:
Tony Millionaire
Dan Clowes
Ben Katchor
CF
Jillian/Mariko Tamaki

Indifference reaffirmed for:
Adrian Tomine
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.