Pretty much everything in here is well-done, but somehow this Charles Burns guest-edited edition, along with the Harvey Pekar-edited volume from 2006, remains for me the weakest of the series I've read thus far (with just the brand new 2010 tome left to bring me up to date). The book lacks the cohesion that Chris Ware and Lynda Barry brought to the 2007 and 2008 collections, respectively. I can see the merit in all the stories here, but little truly inspired or excited me; somehow it all remained just a mostly pleasant reading experience. As per the preface by series editors Jessica Abel and Matt Madden, comics, like all art forms, are a hugely subjective experience, so everyone will have their personal huzzahs and brickbats on the selections and the artists chosen. Some of mine, starting with the huzzahs:
Laura Park's art ("Freaks") is really beautiful in this story. She's a breakout new star in the alt-comics world for good reason.
Based on the excerpt included here, I would like to read the complete graphic novel Skim by the Tamaki sisters. Lovely.
It's always a pleasure to read Kaz's "Underworld" comic strips.
Jerry Moriarty's recent return to print is very welcome: truly the Edward Hopper of cartoonists.
Al Columbia's piece is macabre & gorgeous.
Dash Shaw's "The Galactic Funnels" is very interesting and innovative (Dash Shaw is pretty much always interesting and innovative). I read it 3x.
Michael Kupperman is just flat-out funny.
Jason Lutes: just pure respect for his BERLIN. Magnum Opus, in spades.
Negatory:
Even though I understand that he's very talented, I've never gotten the big love for Adrian Tomine: always found his art uninteresting and I'm sorry but derivative (of Daniel Clowes) and his writing one-note, and the fact that this piece from his graphic novel Shortcomings mines the wearisome I'm-a-Twentysomething-Asshole-Het-Guy trope (reminiscent of Joe Matt) doesn't change my lack of regard for his work one iota. So sorry, sue me.
Ron Rege's adaptation of a chapter of Lynda Barry's Cruddy illuminates nothing of Barry's brilliant text.
I love Ted Stearn's Fuzz and Pluck, but don't think this excerpt works so great. Some stuff just excerpts better than others - he's a wonderful cartoonist's cartoonist, irregardless.
Peter Bagge and Doug Allen's stories, respectively: Meh. Really, these were among the BEST comics of the year? I figure they are included as pals of Burns's and per their past individual bodies of work, and that's okay, but both guys have done much, much better than these trifles.
Onward. Looking forward to the 2010 edition, edited by Neil Gaiman, in which he selected a story by Steve MacIsaac & Todd Brower, "Ex-Communication," which originally appeared in the anthology I edited, The Book of Boy Trouble Volume 2 (Green Candy Press). That selection alone is gratifying, for obvious reasons.