2021 Update: I got to page 368 and finally decided that I'd allowed it enough space in my brain and on my shelf. This is a literary ransom note made of snipped-up Bible phrases and fortune cookie messages, but what do you expect from a literal child? It should have stayed snug in a drawer or on a computer, to be looked over years later out of a sense of nostalgia. Instead it's the inciting event of yet another story of internet humiliation. Just go read some of the blogs reviewing Maradonia, they're shorter, wittier, and they have no delusions of grandeur.
2018 Update: This book's biggest flaw in terms of readability is definitely the pacing. Whether it's awkwardly placed descriptions, rambling conversations or even the quirk of using two descriptors for each thing (i.e., "They were interested in building a control station and outpost"), this book just drags.
Yes, I've added a star to this review. This book has caused much laughter throughout my household, and since the purpose of fiction is to entertain, it qualifies. Maradonia and the Seven Bridges is the worst fantasy book I've ever read--if one can even honestly call it a book. It is one of those rare, magical moments where everything goes wrong--characters, plot, pacing, mythology, description, dialogue, continuity, grammar, spelling, punctuation, even the FONT inspires giggles.
If anyone is confused, I have read through a very detailed sporking of this book, and have recently begun reading the original--hence the review for a book I have technically not finished.
The plot is hackneyed, unoriginal and disjointed, and my spell-checker would have a heart attack at the sight of one page. Random "words" get "quotation marks," italics or "both." I've seen better formatted fanfiction. The "characters," Maya and Joey, are paper-thin idiots treated as intelligent heroes. Joey is especially unbearable, constantly spouting "wisdom" that anyone with a teaspoonful of brains could deflate and outdoing all of the villains put together in selfishness and pointless cruelty. The most unique element of this story is the outright plagiarism from the Bible. Some passages are nearly word-for-word--and yet, Miss Tesch completely misses the point of the passages she inserts.
Here is one shining example of all of my greatest problems with this book: Joey decides to test their troops by declaring that nobody can eat or drink for three days. Maya doesn't like the plan at first, but after seeing the results she calls it splendid and brilliant. On the third they cull the army with a "who drinks straight from the river vs using their hands" test.
One: a healthy human cannot live for three days without water. I know this through Google. A large portion of the army are teens and children, explicitly stated to be younger than the 14-year-old Joey, not healthy adult men. They should all be dead.
Two: this is a mashup of two Biblical stories, 1st Samuel 14:24-46 and Judges 7:4-7. The first was when King Saul made a (rash) vow that nobody should eat or drink until he'd avenged himself on an enemy--and then went and fought a battle. Guess what, everyone including his own son said it was a stupid decision, and it didn't even last an entire day. The second is part of the story of Gideon, where God trims down Gideon's army to the point of absurdity, so that when they win there's no doubt that He was the reason they had the victory. There is no good reason for the "Encouragers" to do this to their army.
Three: On the third day, Joey proceeds to wander through the camp eating and drinking. I assume the only reason he wasn't immediately lynched was because his "men" (again: mostly teenagers and kids) were too weak to move, which is a pity.
Miss Tesch, if you stumble across this while Googling yourself, please don't take this personally. I'm a homeschooled girl who likes to write, like you, and I'm not jealous of you. I know how painful it can be to have some story you've worked hard on criticized. I don't hate you--though if you paid the "editor" of your book, you were ripped off. I even "saved" it from being removed from this site. Please, stop embarrassing yourself with deceptive, self-aggrandizing advertisement, and go back and read the Book you've plagiarized so very often with a willingness to be taught, absorbing the meaning, not just the style.