CLEAN BREAK by JACQUELINE WILSON is a story about Em and her siblings, Maxie and Vita, trying to cope when their beloved father unexpectedly walks out on their family.
Quintessentially, Wilson’s novel explores family-related trauma and stress in the non-ideal, not nuclear family but in a way that is accessible and digestible for younger audiences, allowing every child, regardless of their situation, to feel seen, which is something I have always admired. In addition to these serious concepts, which are written about so sensitively, Wilson includes themes such as: injury, abuse, disordered eating and affairs.
Our protagonist, Em is a young girl who has a very nurturing personality which really shines through when she interacts with her younger brother and sister. Although they are irritating and she can often become envious of them, she is extremely kind and a generous child. Something to praise is that she is incredibly flawed, she can be naughty and rude, she gets jealous and angry, but it really strengthens her character and makes her feel so relatable and real.
Another thing worth mentioning is Em’s struggles with disordered eating. Her grandmother is constantly nagging her throughout the book, encouraging diets, bringing attention to calories, how big her appetite is. Em already appears to be at war with her body, referring to herself as ‘a fat kid’, ‘chubby’, ‘pudgy’ and various synonyms. Initially, I was annoyed at the fatphobic attitudes she seems to harbour, placing her sister, Vita, on a pedestal for having a ‘tiny waist and totally flat stomach’ and instead insulting herself and saying she ‘looks rubbish’ and a ‘pot-bellied pig’ which is not appropriate for younger readers or kind to anyone with the same body type as Em. However, although I cannot excuse this, I have compassion and understanding. Em repeatedly refers to her ‘secret snacks’, the chocolate bars she purchases and consumes in privacy. The feeling of emptiness she experiences when she is in difficult or upsetting situations and consequently reacts by eating. That she ‘crept into the kitchen and started pulling little shreds of turkey and once [she’d] started [she] couldn’t stop’ and once she heard someone approaching she ‘leaped back, guiltily wiping [her] greasy hands in [her] skirt.’ Does that sound disordered to you? The guilt associated with satiating her hunger, her shame that she buys food to eat in secret and her emotional eating fit the criteria of that diagnosis, in my opinion. Understandably, Em has been traumatized. Thrust into a horrible and unprecedented predicament where the father she adores has suddenly disappeared and comfort eating, munching away to fill that hole or emptiness isn’t uncommon, even in the population who have a healthy relationship with food, but to me, the portrayal seems concerning. The fact it was never addressed yet her weight loss was praised was worrying. On one hand, her eating habits are being observed through an innocent perspective, of a clueless, naive child who may not be aware of how she is behaving. However, the failure to recognise this at all shows the young target audience that this is normal when it certainly is not. Published in 2005 when education was limited and eating disorders were significantly more stereotyped than they are in the present, it makes sense to an extent of why this was never acknowledged, but it doesn’t make it right.
Moving on from the protagonist and onto the side characters, I feel like they were very well done. Wilson successfully captures the annoying personalities of young children, portraying their behaviour accurately and presenting children’s trauma responses brilliantly.
The mother, at times lacked substance, but was okay. The grandmother was by far the most obnoxious character in the book and made my blood boil everytime she was mentioned. Every other character was flat and boring, completely undeveloped.
The presentation of the father was interesting. Since we have Em as our narrator, her innocence eliminates flaw, to her, he is perfect. She adores him, even after his departure. Even after observing his new life which doesn’t include her, even after seeing her mother sob, she still thinks he is remarkable. Is the depiction accurate? Was he this amazing father and lovely husband before he walks out? Or did he always have faults and Em just couldn’t see them?
Finally, the story itself. The prose was okay. Very colloquial and conversational, a stream of consciousness from a young child, which to me, a nineteen year old, was frustrating at times but I suspect to the target audience, isn’t an issue. The book definitely lacked plot and moved quite slowly, some scenes completely unnecessary. The chapter where Em meets her biological dad seemed so random and unneeded to me because it added nothing to her character development nor the story. Furthermore, I really disliked the ending, not because it was left open to interpretation or in requirement of answers, but because it was so short and quite honestly, lazy. Nothing was tied up properly and it felt rushed through, which was rather disappointing.
In conclusion, ‘Clean Break’ by Jacqueline Wilson was a story following the complexities of family relationships and unexpected events. Although not flawless, was an entertaining read nonetheless.