Mike Mentzer is called "the thinking man's bodybuilder" for a reason. Everything laid out in this book seems logical and well explained. In this book Mike Mentzer, a world class bodybuilder and Olympia winner lays out a high intensity low volume training system which goes completely against the training systems of other popular and successful bodybuilders such as Arnold Schwarzenegger and Lee Haney which give a large importance to volume. I think Mike is saying a lot of valuable stuff which must definitely have some truth to it and its hard to argue with his physique, his results, as well as the results of Dorian Yates speak for themselves. Theoretically Mike's logic seems very sound and quite irrefutable for the most part, excluding a comparison made in this book from Arnold gaining 23 pounds of mass over 4 months and 500 hours versus Casey Viator Gaining 63 pounds of mass in one month and under 15 hours of training. Mike also completely breaks the neanderthallic gym bro stereotype/mold and seems to be very intelligent and mentally developed with interests in philosophy among other intellectual pursuits which makes him a breath of fresh air around a large portion of men with high level physiques who are only developed physically.
However, I did give this book 3 stars for a reason. While I will be implementing many principles into my own training, I find it hard to completely buy into the "Heavy Duty" training philosophies of Mentzer and Arthur Jones. Mike himself says he trained more than he thought he theoretically should be training as insurance. Franco Columbo who trained at the same Gold's Gym as Mike said that Mike would be at the Gym training as long as himself and Arnold(This isn't necessarily trustworthy as Franco and Arnold had reasons to hate Mentzer, but it should still be taken into account). Dorian Yates, six time Olympia winner and the biggest success story of High Intensity Training also did more sets than Mike advised theoretically as well(however there is something to be said about High Intensity Training seeing that Dorian is said to have had the best back of all time, the back being a group of muscles which is traditionally said to require high volume, being one who trains low volume high intensity). Additionally following the 1980 Olympia(which I do believe was an unjust contest), Mike fell into addictions to varieties of drugs, was arrested for a variety of "crazy behavior" and was institutionalized a number of times. I hate to make an ad hominem argument but it is a bit scary to follow a philosophy that runs counter to everything everyone tells you about bodybuilding when the philosophy was largely popularized by someone who went crazy and became a meth user. I like Mike though and I don't like the way the body building community has completely discarded him and his teachings.
This book was fantastic and bodybuilding enthusiasts that want to think about what they are doing in the gym or take their interest in the hobby to the next level should definitely read this book. Currently the opportunity cost of Mikes Training turning out to be bad in practice outweighs the benefit that he is right, so I will not be following the Heavy Duty system at the moment. What I can say though is that Mike has inspired me to turn away from high volume training and experiment with intensity focused training. I will probably start following the DC training program because I am scared to follow Mike and train to little out of fear of subpar progress or lack of results entirely.
Straight forward, thought provoking. I am glad to hear from such a great bodybuilder. I will especially remember the importance of intensity, all or nothing muscle contraction, and the interesting strategy of implementing a super set with an isolation exercise followed by a compound, for example with pec flys and then dips, to attain fuller chest exhaustion from dips, which are limited by the triceps. It is nice to see a rational approach to lifting. I also am sympathetic to Mentzer's view of psychology.
Algumas avaliações aqui os ensinamentos do livro não devem ser colocados em prática. Discordo.
Quase nada aqui está ultrapassado. Muito do que está escrito passou a ter respaldo científico posteriormente e algumas coisas são meramente questões abertas. Além disso, os pontos cruciais foram testados e confirmados pelo próprio Mentzer, como o treino de alto volume em pouco tempo, em vez de pouco volume em muito tempo. Resultado? Teve bastante, basta ver seu físico.
Worth reading if you just want to acquaint yourself with older BB culture and just be able to understand the dynamic between Mike Mentzer and everyone else around that era. This is more of a piece of history than an actual training book.
You shouldn't follow this advice but that doesn't discredit Mike's influence or writing ability at the time.
Entirely changed my workout philosophy, and I have laid out a plan to implement his routine and workout schedule starting next week. I would recommend this book to anyone starting their journey into fitness and bodybuilding.
This ancient book, a classic among bodybuilders of a certain generation, was given to me by local bodybuilder/occasional Olympia competitor Johnnie Jackson when I complained to him about the effects of aging (I'm 32 and have been involved in competitive athletics since I was 12), falling short with heavy-volume work, etc. Jackson noted that even things like Rippetoe's 5x5 and Wendler's 5-3-1 will fail when the loads are heavy enough (as mine are; 405/495/625 were my final 5-3-1 targets) and the trainee is a light (turinabol, anavar, 1-2cc of equipose, etc.) steroid user or a non steroid user. At a certain point, no amount of ibuprofen, fish oil, yoga, and rest will keep those joints fully lubricated. Mentzer's system, which can be played with a bit to include things you're fond of (high 50"+ box jumps, sprints, jump rope/double unders, ERG sprints in my case) allows you to get through the "big three" barbell exercises with reasonable, efficient progress and enough time to do other shit in your life, like work and maintain friendships. Mentzer's a surprisingly graceful writer, too, better than Rippetoe in many places (not, of course, at explaining HOW to do exercises; he simply stresses good form and the importance of the "pre-stretch" move at the bottom of a lengthening contraction (see description here, eccentric and concentric are somewhat misleading terms: https://www.ptonthenet.com/content/ar... actual weightlifting/powerlifting advice, continue looking to Rippetoe, Wendler, and Dan John). HIT, which has you doing one or two sets slowly to failure with some supersetting, shouldn't be confused with CrossFit, which stresses exercise completion to the detriment of everything else, except at the ridiculous games, when KB swings (a great assistance exercise, but an assistance exercise nonetheless) are getting no-repped for failure to lock at the top (which is of course fine for me, I can hold a 2 pood suspended in front of me for 15-20 seconds, but we've got some 165 pound competitors doing this with at best 165 pound strict presses and it's just LOL). Anyway, I get carried away with this stuff, but there you have it. Also, Mike Mentzer, for all of his claims to the contrary, was like fellow HIT pioneer Casey Viator an absolute steroid fiend...but both proved this shit worked (also both are dead), and Dorian Yates drove the point home with a bunch of Olympias.
This book is within the top 5 workout of ALLTIME. Others are steve reeves building the classic physique, frank Zane symmetry and Arnold's encyclopedia. It's a must buy if you're into getting big and aesthetic. Mike mentzer is the only bodybuilder to receive a PERFECT 300 (twice)!
Short n simple so it leaves u wanting for more. The language is a bit technical so it myt require a few more readings than normally does for a few ppl.
As I close in on 41 years of Mike's teachings, this book stands the test of time...as does the original '70's version. Mike was ahead of his time, and those who try to refute "Heavy Duty doesn't work", I have seen enough trainees over the past four decades to see how people short change themselves. Mike provided "guidelines", in the hopes others would tweak them to suit their individual needs. So all Mike's books are landmarks on his journey to master Heavy Duty's methods, the onus is on the reader to adapt them--as needed--to suit themselves.
Today I woke up to find I am at my biggest; 253#! My workouts are down to 6-minutes average. The kicker is a 3/4" waist drop, despite not eating any differently. As I approach my life-long goal of 260#, Ray Mentzer's weight ... one of the original mass-monsters, I know I'll have to cut back even more.