Modern relationships, murder and mystery in a moderately over written story with guts and heart.
A body found floating in the pool at the La Reine Gardens apartment complex brings police lieutenant, Mike Gardner, and his new, and often belligerent partner, Bert St. Croix to investigate. Mike is going to need Kim Reynolds’ insight and sensitivity to emotions to solve this one, which gives him one more reason to spend time with the gun-shy librarian. Mike has two problems: solving the murder and convincing Kim to marry him. Kim has other plans, and so, it seems, does the murderer.
Just to make things interesting, Jacqueline Seewald takes a simple murder and turns it into a commentary on relationships, love, loyalty and greed in The Drowning Pool. This second mystery for Kim Reynolds and Detective Mike Gardner is layered with lies, subterfuge, nightmares, violence, dysfunctional relationships and fear of intimacy. Among the darker elements, are the relationships between Mike, his daughters and Kim that contain the most believable elements of the story.
The mystery is not contrived nor is the investigation lacking in any way, but one red herring seems to have been tossed in to make the book longer without adding anything tangible to the solution of the mystery or unmasking the murderer. This particular plot point is based on a husband and wife refusing to talk to each other, and there is quite a lot of that going around with most of the couples implicated in the murder. One thing is certain, Seewald knows how to write dysfunctional relationships and she has loaded The Drowning Pool with several.
Aside from the obligatory red herrings and a bit of scenery chewing, The Drowning Pool is well plotted and fast paced with enough conflict and sexual tension to fuel more outings for Kim and Mike. The chemistry and emotional push-pull between the main characters kicks the heat up a few notches and gives what would be an otherwise garden-variety mystery depth, texture and heart.