I wanted to like this book. I had reason to, it is similar to my own personal philosophy, which includes a little bit of everything. If I was forced to label myself I would call myself a Zen, Hasidic, Jesus admiring landscape worshiping mystical earth ecstatic. The scope of this author’s spiritual forays and experiments is staggering, I think she has tried everything but voodoo, and with some fairly powerful people/celebrities. I know someone who has attended some retreats at her institute and who thinks I would love it. But. Several things rubbed me wrong, her mention of celebrity being so insincere and unnecessary being the most obvious. Secondly, she wrote extremely brief chapters, a page or two, and while I am trying to learn that, to learn how to condense and get the point across quickly, I felt it was less powerful that way. Third, her own personal transformation story, her own “Phoenix Process” was ridiculous and unnecessary. I am not judging, she had to find her own way, but she started the book talking about how hard her divorce was, how she struggled with it, breaking up her family, but she implied that it was not her fault, when she cheated and did so spectacularly. But that was her example of being “broken open” and I imagine I am being too harsh and expecting too much of someone who is trying to be a spiritual leader. She has amazing heartbreaking examples of other people who have suffered far more than her, but then goes into a ridiculous story of her “Shaman Lover” and her sexual awakening that broke her open. It was cheesy and trite and stupid. If she had not gone into detail, I would have enjoyed the book more because there were gems in it. Last, I don’t think she is a very creative or lyrical writer, or even a good one: it felt like a book that would be featured on Oprah, because, after all, she does know famous people like Ram Dass, and included a little anecdote of how insensitive he was, though a friend, until his stroke and then she visited him and all the sudden he was kind, and I think she was taking the credit for it. Or maybe she is aiming for a movie of her life like eat, pray, love. It all makes sense that way: and the author of that book also was undone by a divorce, but I think was a much better writer and more authentic. At least a little more so.
Oh well, I will not see the movie. I can appreciate her openness and insatiable beautiful curiosity, it echoes within me.
“A broken heart is not the same as sadness. Sadness occurs when the heart is stone cold and lifeless. On the contrary, there is an unbelievable amount of vitality in a broken heart. “ Rabbi Schnuer Zalman