What do you think?
Rate this book
Circle of Sin #2
To Surrender To A Rogue
An expert in antiquities, Lady Alessandra della Giamatti arrives in Bath to excavate newly discovered Roman ruins-only to find herself caught in a web of evil intrigue by a blackmailer threatening to expose her scandalous past. The one man who can help her is Lord James "Black Jack" Pierson, a fellow member of the expedition and a sinfully handsome rogue whose tempting presence ignites a different sort of danger.
Jack has clashed with Alessandra in the past, so when she suddenly surrenders her body he can't help being suspicious. Is she a scheming temptress? Or is she truly a lady in trouble? As desire and deceptions swirl around them, Alessandra and Jack must find a way to win each other's trust. For if they don't work together to uncover a shocking truth, their enemy-and their own simmering passions-may destroy them and everything they cherish.
Jack has clashed with Alessandra in the past, so when she suddenly surrenders her body he can't help being suspicious. Is she a scheming temptress? Or is she truly a lady in trouble? As desire and deceptions swirl around them, Alessandra and Jack must find a way to win each other's trust. For if they don't work together to uncover a shocking truth, their enemy-and their own simmering passions-may destroy them and everything they cherish.
Unknown Binding
First published May 14, 2010
29 people are currently reading
462 people want to read
About the author
Cara Elliott
20 books225 followersCara Elliott started creating books at the age of five, or so her mother tells her. And Mom has the proof preserved in a family scrapbook—a neatly penciled story, the pages lavishly illustrated with full color crayon drawings of horses. Cara has since moved on from Westerns to writing about Regency England, a time and place that has captured her imagination ever since she opened the covers of Jane Austen’s “Pride and Prejudice.”
A graduate of Yale University, Cara has garnered numerous accolades for her writing, including two Daphne Du Maurier Awards for Historical Mystery /Suspense and two RITAs nominations for Regency Romance.
Cara loves to travel to interesting destinations around the world—however, her favorite spot is London, where the funky antique markets, used book stores and specialty museums offer a wealth of inspiration for her stories.
A graduate of Yale University, Cara has garnered numerous accolades for her writing, including two Daphne Du Maurier Awards for Historical Mystery /Suspense and two RITAs nominations for Regency Romance.
Cara loves to travel to interesting destinations around the world—however, her favorite spot is London, where the funky antique markets, used book stores and specialty museums offer a wealth of inspiration for her stories.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews
June 1, 2010
The much-anticipated sequel / dueling match between Black Jack vs the hot-tempered Marchesa Alessandra. The story picks up where TSWAS left off, Alessandra’s outraged that Jack tied Isabella, Alessandra’s 8 y/o daughter to a tree. Their fireworks are as fine as in the prequel.
Jack is a respected war hero & the 5th son of a Duke. He has a secret luv for art (back then, it’s not something a manly man can brag about) & a fascination for antiquities. Much to Jack’s surprise, his eldest bro’ has known all along that he’s a talented artist & supports his true passion, even encourages Jack to spread his wings & march to the beat of his own drums. Jack’s not thrilled that his father is trying to hook him up w/ a biddable bride of his choice w/ a suitable pedigree & dowry. Jack takes his bro’s sage advice to heart & off he goes to Bath as a replacement in the excavation team. He has to prove to others that he’ll do his share of dirty work & doesn’t want to get special treatment just ‘cuz he’s a nobleman. He notices that behind Alessandra’s brittle façade, there are glimpses of vulnerability & his interest is piqued. Despite her initial judgemental attitude, Alessandra also gradually learns that Jack is not simply a dilettante, he earns it.
H/H somehow rub each other the wrong way & bring out the worst in each other. Jack can’t stand Alessandra’s wire-barbed tongue & thinks the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree ‘cuz the li’l imp of Satan, Isabella, has a shocking penchant for cursing, her source of colorful vocabs is Marco (Alessandra’s cousin & the hero in the upcoming book). Alessandra has been flying under the radar (somewhat reclusive) ‘cuz she harbors a dark secret that she’s never revealed to anyone – not even her BFFs in The Circle of Sin – except Marco. Much to her consternation, when she goes to Bath to dig up Roman ruins, someone from her past has come back to haunt her. She has to make a choice, either meet his demands, or pack her stuff & run away once again.
I luv the beautiful cover, w/ sparkles of the sunlight glinting off the blue sea & heroine draped all over the gleaming wet hero. There’s not much info dump pertaining to what happened in previous H/H’s story, just enuff to fill in the blanks for those who haven’t read the 1st book. The zingers between H/H are delicious. As they parry & thrust in their dance of luv amidst a nefarious plot, Jack becomes a pillar of strength for Alessandra. 2 heads are better than 1. Alessandra also proves her mettle that she's not the type who'll just roll over & take it. She discovers more betrayals that are linked to her hubby's death.
Unfortunately, just like the prequel, the annoying “Lud” is still overused here, no less than 19 X (I counted). I didn’t luv this as much as I did the prequel ‘cuz even tho’ it has the humor & the hero is the dark, brooding, capable type (vs Jack’s funny BFF, Lucas stands out more in my eyes), I wanted more interactions between H/H after heroine relaxes her guarded nature. Their relationship felt a bit rushed, due to the limited screen time & spread out focus on archaeology shop talk, the villainous blackmailer, the set up of the next characters for the next book, Kate (heroine’s friend from The Circle of sin) & Marco. Jack & Alessandra became lovers sooner than I expected. I appreciated that the H/H were not @ daggers drawn from start to finish, but I wanted ‘em to get to know 1 another better B4 tearing their clothes off. Just like the prequel, it has sensual luv scenes & a parallel plotline w/ damsel’s kid in peril + protective mommie who would do anything to keep her safe / dashing hero saves the day = HEA. The 2nd villain’s identity wasn’t hard to guess & the motive for all the villains’ scheme was too far-fetched & strained credibility, conceptual thinking was not a must. The H/H’s backgrounds were well written. I liked the dynamics between H/H & the mouthy kid, but it’s not as interesting as the prequel. The combination of the different setting, the absence of other BFFs, H/H’s rushed dalliance & external circumstances here made the prequel slightly more memorable for me. Not much internal conflict here.
I can't say that I'm excited to read the next 1, but I'll check it out.
Jack is a respected war hero & the 5th son of a Duke. He has a secret luv for art (back then, it’s not something a manly man can brag about) & a fascination for antiquities. Much to Jack’s surprise, his eldest bro’ has known all along that he’s a talented artist & supports his true passion, even encourages Jack to spread his wings & march to the beat of his own drums. Jack’s not thrilled that his father is trying to hook him up w/ a biddable bride of his choice w/ a suitable pedigree & dowry. Jack takes his bro’s sage advice to heart & off he goes to Bath as a replacement in the excavation team. He has to prove to others that he’ll do his share of dirty work & doesn’t want to get special treatment just ‘cuz he’s a nobleman. He notices that behind Alessandra’s brittle façade, there are glimpses of vulnerability & his interest is piqued. Despite her initial judgemental attitude, Alessandra also gradually learns that Jack is not simply a dilettante, he earns it.
H/H somehow rub each other the wrong way & bring out the worst in each other. Jack can’t stand Alessandra’s wire-barbed tongue & thinks the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree ‘cuz the li’l imp of Satan, Isabella, has a shocking penchant for cursing, her source of colorful vocabs is Marco (Alessandra’s cousin & the hero in the upcoming book). Alessandra has been flying under the radar (somewhat reclusive) ‘cuz she harbors a dark secret that she’s never revealed to anyone – not even her BFFs in The Circle of Sin – except Marco. Much to her consternation, when she goes to Bath to dig up Roman ruins, someone from her past has come back to haunt her. She has to make a choice, either meet his demands, or pack her stuff & run away once again.
I luv the beautiful cover, w/ sparkles of the sunlight glinting off the blue sea & heroine draped all over the gleaming wet hero. There’s not much info dump pertaining to what happened in previous H/H’s story, just enuff to fill in the blanks for those who haven’t read the 1st book. The zingers between H/H are delicious. As they parry & thrust in their dance of luv amidst a nefarious plot, Jack becomes a pillar of strength for Alessandra. 2 heads are better than 1. Alessandra also proves her mettle that she's not the type who'll just roll over & take it. She discovers more betrayals that are linked to her hubby's death.
Unfortunately, just like the prequel, the annoying “Lud” is still overused here, no less than 19 X (I counted). I didn’t luv this as much as I did the prequel ‘cuz even tho’ it has the humor & the hero is the dark, brooding, capable type (vs Jack’s funny BFF, Lucas stands out more in my eyes), I wanted more interactions between H/H after heroine relaxes her guarded nature. Their relationship felt a bit rushed, due to the limited screen time & spread out focus on archaeology shop talk, the villainous blackmailer, the set up of the next characters for the next book, Kate (heroine’s friend from The Circle of sin) & Marco. Jack & Alessandra became lovers sooner than I expected. I appreciated that the H/H were not @ daggers drawn from start to finish, but I wanted ‘em to get to know 1 another better B4 tearing their clothes off. Just like the prequel, it has sensual luv scenes & a parallel plotline w/ damsel’s kid in peril + protective mommie who would do anything to keep her safe / dashing hero saves the day = HEA. The 2nd villain’s identity wasn’t hard to guess & the motive for all the villains’ scheme was too far-fetched & strained credibility, conceptual thinking was not a must. The H/H’s backgrounds were well written. I liked the dynamics between H/H & the mouthy kid, but it’s not as interesting as the prequel. The combination of the different setting, the absence of other BFFs, H/H’s rushed dalliance & external circumstances here made the prequel slightly more memorable for me. Not much internal conflict here.
I can't say that I'm excited to read the next 1, but I'll check it out.
March 24, 2011
Lud, what another great book from Cara Elliott (sorry couldn't resist with the lud, just cracks me up reading in in her books along with la!). This book picks right up were To Sin With A Scoundrel leaves off and while not necessary to read that one first, you do get to meet our hero and heroine for the first time there and see the sparks fly! Lady Alessandra della Giamatti is not at all amused when she is told that Lord James Pierson tied her daughter to a tree to protect her. She is, of course, very upset and says some very spirited things to Jack, along with her daughter and the two of them are dismayed to find themselves both working at an excavation site in Bath. Alessandra takes her scholarship work very seriously and is not happy that some pampered lord is allowed on the site. But when Jacks true talent as an artist emerge, she has to retreat her rude comments as Jack proves to be an excellent addition to the team.
It is Jacks love of art that helps bridge the gap between him and Alessandra daughter, Isabella and I thought the relationship these two build was very sweet. Even though Isabella is a large part of this story, she does not take over it but instead blends in nicely. I would have liked to have seen a bit more of the developing relationship between these two but was portrayed was wonderful. When Alessandra is confronted from a secret from her past and forced to do some actions against her will to protect Isabella, Jack demands to know what is bothering her. As Alessandra is deeply ashamed and appalled at her secret she refuses at first to tell him, but thankfully tells him in good time and it does not drag out too long!
Watching the sparks fly and sting between Alessandra and Jack was a bit of fun! She is quite tempermental and I loved how Jack referred to her distracting mouth as "the Mouth". Alessandra has no intention of ever accepting help from a man again and this frustrates Jack to no end. Oh, but when they finally succumb to their growing desires..wowza. It was great watching how these two relaxed into each but still stayed true to themselves. Overall, this was another fun, sexy read for me with a bit of a mystery and intrigue thrown in with a bit of a twist I didn't expect. I really enjoyed how they were on on excavation site but it was just in Bath, and not some far off exotic locale, nice change of pace. Looking forward to the final book in this trilogy that features another feisty heroine and hero, To Tempt a Rake! 4 good stars for this one
It is Jacks love of art that helps bridge the gap between him and Alessandra daughter, Isabella and I thought the relationship these two build was very sweet. Even though Isabella is a large part of this story, she does not take over it but instead blends in nicely. I would have liked to have seen a bit more of the developing relationship between these two but was portrayed was wonderful. When Alessandra is confronted from a secret from her past and forced to do some actions against her will to protect Isabella, Jack demands to know what is bothering her. As Alessandra is deeply ashamed and appalled at her secret she refuses at first to tell him, but thankfully tells him in good time and it does not drag out too long!
Watching the sparks fly and sting between Alessandra and Jack was a bit of fun! She is quite tempermental and I loved how Jack referred to her distracting mouth as "the Mouth". Alessandra has no intention of ever accepting help from a man again and this frustrates Jack to no end. Oh, but when they finally succumb to their growing desires..wowza. It was great watching how these two relaxed into each but still stayed true to themselves. Overall, this was another fun, sexy read for me with a bit of a mystery and intrigue thrown in with a bit of a twist I didn't expect. I really enjoyed how they were on on excavation site but it was just in Bath, and not some far off exotic locale, nice change of pace. Looking forward to the final book in this trilogy that features another feisty heroine and hero, To Tempt a Rake! 4 good stars for this one
June 28, 2010
Things are off to a rocky start between Lord Jack Pierson and Lady Alessandra della Giamatti. Jack has just tied Alessandra's daughter, Isabella, to a tree! It's not how it sounds-if he hadn't, adventurous and curious Isabella would surely have fallen off a cliff to her death. Jack and Alessandra fight to vigorously, they hope to never see each other again after their friends, Ciara and Hadley, are rescued. But unbeknownst to them at the time, they share a passion for antiquities. Both are assigned to a rare and important excavation in Bath. Alessandra treats Jack poorly, accusing him of being able to buy his place in the excavation party because his father is a duke. Jack can't make himself stay away from Alessandra and her equally prickly daughter, and he soon learns that both ladies are in grave danger.
Having read "To Sin with a Scoundrel", I loved how this book started off exactly where the previous book ended. It was later the very same day! I had been looking forward to what would happen between Alessandra and Jack, and especially how jack would deal with Isabella, from the set up in the first book. There's also a set up in this one for the leads in Elliott's next book, Kate and Marco.
I really enjoyed how the book dealt with things in a different way than most historical romance. Alessandra admitted her weakness to herself-that she was lonely. She even admitted that her weaknesses were what caused her to reach out to Jack, and why she loved being near his strength and noble nature. I think it's rare for a heroine to be able to admit to herself how vulnerable she is throughout the story.
Also, Jack was very straight forward about his nature. He spent the first years of his adult life as a successful soldier, to fulfill his duty and to please his family. But with his war years over, his interests lie in drawing, art, and scholarly pursuits. He admits this to himself and pursues art, even though he thinks his family will never approve of his choices.
I loved how Jack's relationship with Alessandra's spunky daughter proceeded. I think he never knew how much a child could add to his life because he'd never been around children before. Isabella was as much of a firecracker as her mother and her arguments with Jack were so funny!
Jack and Alessandra's secret rendezvous were hot and exciting, but you could still tell they had true feelings for each other. Elliott shapes fantastic, lovable characters and really lets us know what's going on inside their heads.
I'd recommend this book to any fan of historical romance. This book has everything for the historical romance reader, a great leading couple, fun supporting cast, humor, and of course, love.
This book was provided for review by Hachette Books.
reviewed for: http://inthehammockblog.blogspot.com/
Having read "To Sin with a Scoundrel", I loved how this book started off exactly where the previous book ended. It was later the very same day! I had been looking forward to what would happen between Alessandra and Jack, and especially how jack would deal with Isabella, from the set up in the first book. There's also a set up in this one for the leads in Elliott's next book, Kate and Marco.
I really enjoyed how the book dealt with things in a different way than most historical romance. Alessandra admitted her weakness to herself-that she was lonely. She even admitted that her weaknesses were what caused her to reach out to Jack, and why she loved being near his strength and noble nature. I think it's rare for a heroine to be able to admit to herself how vulnerable she is throughout the story.
Also, Jack was very straight forward about his nature. He spent the first years of his adult life as a successful soldier, to fulfill his duty and to please his family. But with his war years over, his interests lie in drawing, art, and scholarly pursuits. He admits this to himself and pursues art, even though he thinks his family will never approve of his choices.
I loved how Jack's relationship with Alessandra's spunky daughter proceeded. I think he never knew how much a child could add to his life because he'd never been around children before. Isabella was as much of a firecracker as her mother and her arguments with Jack were so funny!
Jack and Alessandra's secret rendezvous were hot and exciting, but you could still tell they had true feelings for each other. Elliott shapes fantastic, lovable characters and really lets us know what's going on inside their heads.
I'd recommend this book to any fan of historical romance. This book has everything for the historical romance reader, a great leading couple, fun supporting cast, humor, and of course, love.
This book was provided for review by Hachette Books.
reviewed for: http://inthehammockblog.blogspot.com/
June 16, 2010
Lady Alessandra della Giamatti is not just another pretty face, but she's also one of the foremost experts in Roman artifacts and archeology. She's intelligent, sharp-tongued, and harbors a secret. A secret large enough to cause her to flee Italy in the hopes that England can help her hide from her past.
"Black Jack" Pierson is the best friend of Lucas (our hero from To Sin With A Scoundrel) and since Alessandra also happens to be a very good friend of Ciara (our heroine from TSWAS), they've had several encounters - all which have been rather unpleasant. Jack is more reserved and temperamental than Lucas. He also has a secret- although his isn't quite as deadly as Alessandra's. His is more of a secret talent and passion.
Alessandra lends her expertise to a crew working on excavating some very valuable Roman finds in the city of Bath. Unbeknown to her, Lord Jack Pierson was also invited to attend the same excavation so that he can employ his artistic skills and historical knowledge. Alessandra received word that her past is quickly catching up with her so she hopes that this trip to Bath will provide her some measure of safety. She certainly doesn't expect to not only encounter Jack who is infuriating and deliciously tempting at the same time, but a menace from her past who has found his way into her present. Her life and that of her daughter's are now being threatened if she doesn't help with his evil plot. Jack overhears several conversations between Alessandra and said villain, but is she really in trouble? Or is she in cahoots with him to steal what would be a very valuable ancient artifact?
Alessandra doesn't just dump her past into the story, but rather gives you bit by bit so that you [as the reader:] can go filling in the blanks. I also loved the dialogue between Alessandra and Jack. Their "zingers" at each other will keep you smiling. Eventually, Alessandra realizes that she's in over her head and allows Jack to help her. He becomes her proverbial "pillar of strength".
Overall, I enjoyed this second installment in Cara Elliott's Circle of Sin series. One of my favorite elements of her stories are her characters. I love to read about characters who are strong, intelligent and well-developed. Characters who have secrets and vulnerabilities just like all of us, but are still confident and know what they want. I also like the mystery and plots that Cara weaves into her tales. Her stories have romance, passion, dastardly villains, and enough mystery to keep you intrigued. What I would have liked to have seen is their relationship stretched a little more. There was rather limited screen time in which to fit in a budding romance, archeological "shop talk", a nefarious plot with a villainous blackmailer, and the set-up of the third book in the series.
I remain a fan of Cara Elliott's work. She is a delightful person and very talented author. I would recommend her books to all lovers of romance. I am looking forward to Kate & Marco's story next!
"Black Jack" Pierson is the best friend of Lucas (our hero from To Sin With A Scoundrel) and since Alessandra also happens to be a very good friend of Ciara (our heroine from TSWAS), they've had several encounters - all which have been rather unpleasant. Jack is more reserved and temperamental than Lucas. He also has a secret- although his isn't quite as deadly as Alessandra's. His is more of a secret talent and passion.
Alessandra lends her expertise to a crew working on excavating some very valuable Roman finds in the city of Bath. Unbeknown to her, Lord Jack Pierson was also invited to attend the same excavation so that he can employ his artistic skills and historical knowledge. Alessandra received word that her past is quickly catching up with her so she hopes that this trip to Bath will provide her some measure of safety. She certainly doesn't expect to not only encounter Jack who is infuriating and deliciously tempting at the same time, but a menace from her past who has found his way into her present. Her life and that of her daughter's are now being threatened if she doesn't help with his evil plot. Jack overhears several conversations between Alessandra and said villain, but is she really in trouble? Or is she in cahoots with him to steal what would be a very valuable ancient artifact?
Alessandra doesn't just dump her past into the story, but rather gives you bit by bit so that you [as the reader:] can go filling in the blanks. I also loved the dialogue between Alessandra and Jack. Their "zingers" at each other will keep you smiling. Eventually, Alessandra realizes that she's in over her head and allows Jack to help her. He becomes her proverbial "pillar of strength".
Overall, I enjoyed this second installment in Cara Elliott's Circle of Sin series. One of my favorite elements of her stories are her characters. I love to read about characters who are strong, intelligent and well-developed. Characters who have secrets and vulnerabilities just like all of us, but are still confident and know what they want. I also like the mystery and plots that Cara weaves into her tales. Her stories have romance, passion, dastardly villains, and enough mystery to keep you intrigued. What I would have liked to have seen is their relationship stretched a little more. There was rather limited screen time in which to fit in a budding romance, archeological "shop talk", a nefarious plot with a villainous blackmailer, and the set-up of the third book in the series.
I remain a fan of Cara Elliott's work. She is a delightful person and very talented author. I would recommend her books to all lovers of romance. I am looking forward to Kate & Marco's story next!
June 23, 2010
I did enjoy this book. I just had my expectations too high from the previous book, which could have been written to order for me. This one seemed much more ordinary. I don't think there was anything wrong with it, but nothing jumped out as being particularly special, either.
I wish we'd had more of the Circle of Sinners, and that Alessandra had confided her predicament to them. They only were present in this book enough to remind me of how interesting they all were before, and to set up the character of Kate for the next book.
I never really felt Jack was more than a stereotype of a romance hero. He's tough! He has a bad reputation! His brothers used to beat him up! But underneath it all is the soul of an artist, which no one knew until this book began!
Lady Alessandra was a little more complex, but I've never been fond of the I hate him! He's terrible! He's so attractive! I can't help myself, I must have sex with him! I still hate him! We'll have sex again! Now I know he's trustworthy and the love of my life! This is very common in romance novels, so I can't count this as an objective flaw, but it is one for me.
The book was well written, so I won't count the author out in the future, and this still may be the right book for you. It just wasn't one of my favorites.
I wish we'd had more of the Circle of Sinners, and that Alessandra had confided her predicament to them. They only were present in this book enough to remind me of how interesting they all were before, and to set up the character of Kate for the next book.
I never really felt Jack was more than a stereotype of a romance hero. He's tough! He has a bad reputation! His brothers used to beat him up! But underneath it all is the soul of an artist, which no one knew until this book began!
Lady Alessandra was a little more complex, but I've never been fond of the I hate him! He's terrible! He's so attractive! I can't help myself, I must have sex with him! I still hate him! We'll have sex again! Now I know he's trustworthy and the love of my life! This is very common in romance novels, so I can't count this as an objective flaw, but it is one for me.
The book was well written, so I won't count the author out in the future, and this still may be the right book for you. It just wasn't one of my favorites.
August 18, 2010
I did something I never do, I let the good reviews for this book lead me to buy it. I have no idea why this book had a 5 star rating across the board at Ami. It was definitely over rated! The first 100 pages was so boring and did nothing to grab me and make me want to read it. In the beginning I liked the foul mouth child of the heroine and then it dawned on me that the child alone would not be able to keep this book entertaining, and I was right.
January 21, 2012
This would have been a fairly pedestrian historical romance had it not been for the art, architecture, and archaeology.
It wasn't until I was well into this novel that I realised it was the second in a trilogy, centred around a group of unique but perhaps anachronistic (I'm not sure of this) bluestockings -- ladies of wealth, leisure, personality and intelligence who gather to pursue their scientific interest in male-dominated fields of research.
Not until I'd finished the book and begun checking out the other titles in the trilogy did I discover that, apart from each volume focusing one one of the members of the Circle, there's almost no cross-pollination of narrative and characters. In other words, I don't regret jumping into this series in mid-trilogy and don't think I missed out on anything by so doing.
The background for this romance between a wealthy Italian widow and a British aristocrat is the excavation of Roman ruins in, or near, the city of Bath. The romance itself is predictable and the characters, or their clones, appear in hundreds of books by dozens of other authors. The meticulous details of the archaeological dig, the roman artefacts, the pictorial documentation of the finds, and use of Regency Bath instead of London raised To Surrender To A Rogue above the ranks of utterly forgettable historical romances. A subplot concerning political machinations in Italy and Austria added breadth and historical authenticity to the story, a refreshing change from the claustrophobic genre stereotypes that, should they ever stray beyond the narrow stage of London town houses and country mansions, make do with perfunctory references to Napoleon and his campaigns or exile.
The joy of this book is the balance it maintains between diverse elements. My five-star rating reflects both the quality of the writing and my enjoyment of the book.
It wasn't until I was well into this novel that I realised it was the second in a trilogy, centred around a group of unique but perhaps anachronistic (I'm not sure of this) bluestockings -- ladies of wealth, leisure, personality and intelligence who gather to pursue their scientific interest in male-dominated fields of research.
Not until I'd finished the book and begun checking out the other titles in the trilogy did I discover that, apart from each volume focusing one one of the members of the Circle, there's almost no cross-pollination of narrative and characters. In other words, I don't regret jumping into this series in mid-trilogy and don't think I missed out on anything by so doing.
The background for this romance between a wealthy Italian widow and a British aristocrat is the excavation of Roman ruins in, or near, the city of Bath. The romance itself is predictable and the characters, or their clones, appear in hundreds of books by dozens of other authors. The meticulous details of the archaeological dig, the roman artefacts, the pictorial documentation of the finds, and use of Regency Bath instead of London raised To Surrender To A Rogue above the ranks of utterly forgettable historical romances. A subplot concerning political machinations in Italy and Austria added breadth and historical authenticity to the story, a refreshing change from the claustrophobic genre stereotypes that, should they ever stray beyond the narrow stage of London town houses and country mansions, make do with perfunctory references to Napoleon and his campaigns or exile.
The joy of this book is the balance it maintains between diverse elements. My five-star rating reflects both the quality of the writing and my enjoyment of the book.
June 29, 2010
This book had great characters, a pretty good plot, and was written well. I think I read it too fast. It only took me two days to finish it, and I think I read it too fast to really let myself connect to the story.
I did like Alessandra though. She was sharp witted, and usually had a sharp response ready to go. Even her daughter had quite the mouth on her. I also liked Black Jack and his retorts. He really seemed to keep Alessandra on her toes. Plus he made a great hero for the story. The "Circle of Sin" was also entertaining. They didn't play a huge part in the story, but they were a nice addition.
There were some intense scenes in this one. Alessandra seems to get herself into a bit of trouble by trying to hide her secret from all of England.
Like I said, despite having all the makings of a really good book I just didn't connect to it like I normally do. I'm going to have to reread this one and let myself get drawn into the story. I think I would like it even more if I had not sped through it.
I did like Alessandra though. She was sharp witted, and usually had a sharp response ready to go. Even her daughter had quite the mouth on her. I also liked Black Jack and his retorts. He really seemed to keep Alessandra on her toes. Plus he made a great hero for the story. The "Circle of Sin" was also entertaining. They didn't play a huge part in the story, but they were a nice addition.
There were some intense scenes in this one. Alessandra seems to get herself into a bit of trouble by trying to hide her secret from all of England.
Like I said, despite having all the makings of a really good book I just didn't connect to it like I normally do. I'm going to have to reread this one and let myself get drawn into the story. I think I would like it even more if I had not sped through it.
August 26, 2011
Book 2 of the series. Well, I could cut and paste a lot of my review of book one.
1) Stop with the overuse of the expression "lud"!!
2) Yes, I get that the heroine and hero irritate each other but the extreme bitchiness of the heroine over minor things just drove me nuts.
3) This one did have more sex scenes (yes, I like them) than the first book and I felt they were better done (forgot to include that in my review of book one). My thoughts of the sex scenes in the first one were that they were kind of like shampoo instructions "Lather. Rinse. Repeat" and there, we're done, time to move along.
4) You really need to read the first book before reading this one because you are dropped into the middle of the hero and heroine's relationship and there's some backstory that is necessary from book 1. It's the reason why I couldn't read book 3 without reading the first two books of the series.
And now it's time for me to move along to book 3.
1) Stop with the overuse of the expression "lud"!!
2) Yes, I get that the heroine and hero irritate each other but the extreme bitchiness of the heroine over minor things just drove me nuts.
3) This one did have more sex scenes (yes, I like them) than the first book and I felt they were better done (forgot to include that in my review of book one). My thoughts of the sex scenes in the first one were that they were kind of like shampoo instructions "Lather. Rinse. Repeat" and there, we're done, time to move along.
4) You really need to read the first book before reading this one because you are dropped into the middle of the hero and heroine's relationship and there's some backstory that is necessary from book 1. It's the reason why I couldn't read book 3 without reading the first two books of the series.
And now it's time for me to move along to book 3.
June 3, 2010
Oooo, the heroine needs a good slap in this one. She comes across as totally superior, very unpleasant, with very few redeeming character traits at all, and in the process of raising a horrible brat as a daughter. So what if she looks gorgeous? The hero's OK, but there's too much going on with him. He's an artistic, sensitive type hidden behind a dark, brooding, warrior exterior, which seems a bit much in one character. I really found myself wandering why he'd find such a shrew attractive even if she is built like a goddess. I didn't manage to finish this one - I may go back to it - the heroine just really irritated me.
September 9, 2010
For me this book let me down in many ways. It had so much potential to be great. The two main characters are very headstrong and very passionate and when they are near eachother sparks fly. My problem is that there is so much inner dialogue and not enough with the eachother. Also, when they realize their feelings for eachother, I felt that it was not natural and forced. I never felt that either character had any true feelings besides lust for the other. To be honest I was more interested in the side story set up for the next book.
June 6, 2011
Not my favorite read. The ebook was poorly created and wouldn't allow me to adjust the font from a tiny size that was hard on my eyes. The plot was interesting enough, but the dialogue was repetitive and the characters often said the same thing over again in multiple languages, which, while I understand the author's desire to give her readers a translation, is not something that most people do in real conversations. The story often got bogged down by the scientific details which made it a somewhat dull and slow read. But I did like the characters and their development.
October 31, 2012
I could not take the stubborness of Lady Giamatti. After a while she was bordering on being rude already. She just kept on badgering and after a while it was not fun reading anymore. The romance was no where in the making and I was already half of the book. Too much attention on the intrigues that romance was put on the side.
I lost ineterest after a while and did not even bother to finish the book.
I lost ineterest after a while and did not even bother to finish the book.
July 7, 2025
My only problem with the hero is that he’s just had a mistress arrangement with a buxom blonde while he was still lusting after Alessandra. Although there was no on page scene with the mistress, but it was implied that he still went to get his pleasure with her while on a dispute with Alessandra. I understand that there had been no understanding concluded between these two, but still, the knowledge only
exacerbated my troubled mood. Wish he’d still stay true to Alessandra regardless. Anyway, just a minor concern if mine!
But other than that, as someone who isn’t an art connoisseur but enjoys the richness that artistic detail can bring to a story, I was pleasantly surprised by how Cara Elliott wove painting and art into the fabric of To Surrender to a Rogue. Often, books featuring painter characters skim over the surface—treating the profession as a mere backdrop. Here, the artistic element feels lived-in and emotionally resonant
The use of painting as both euphemism and metaphor added a unique depth to the characters, especially the romantic dynamic. I love the scene where Jack wishes to paint Alessandra with a colour theory and specific brushstrokes. Alessandra then replied him that his ‘preliminary sketches’ certainly seemed promising. Ooohh it’s not always I get to see characters flirting with artsy nuances!
A very very unique setting and characterisation indeed! Wish it has a much higher rating for stepping slightly outside of your usual Regency romance bounds!
exacerbated my troubled mood. Wish he’d still stay true to Alessandra regardless. Anyway, just a minor concern if mine!
But other than that, as someone who isn’t an art connoisseur but enjoys the richness that artistic detail can bring to a story, I was pleasantly surprised by how Cara Elliott wove painting and art into the fabric of To Surrender to a Rogue. Often, books featuring painter characters skim over the surface—treating the profession as a mere backdrop. Here, the artistic element feels lived-in and emotionally resonant
The use of painting as both euphemism and metaphor added a unique depth to the characters, especially the romantic dynamic. I love the scene where Jack wishes to paint Alessandra with a colour theory and specific brushstrokes. Alessandra then replied him that his ‘preliminary sketches’ certainly seemed promising. Ooohh it’s not always I get to see characters flirting with artsy nuances!
A very very unique setting and characterisation indeed! Wish it has a much higher rating for stepping slightly outside of your usual Regency romance bounds!
January 23, 2025
4.5
We have Marchesa Alessandra della Giamatti and her daughter Isabella they both have used Italian bad words to and on Lord James (Jack) Jacquehart Pierson the 5th son of a Duke!
They are each other’s throat constantly even from the previous story! Definitely a thin line between lust, likes and loathing!
Well Alessa has somewhat of a good reason as Jack had tied Isabella to a tree! Definitely funny and for her own good!
Alessa left her past in Italy and yet it has followed her and Isabella to England! Alessa is brave, beautiful and passionate and it the last flaw that questions her judgement!
Jack is very skilled on the battlefield and word play Alessa is tempted to trust him but is afraid that the enemy will hurt him or her daughter!
But is always the strong silent types and Jack is good at listening while working!
But Alessa enemies have grown bold unless she trusts someone she won’t have to worry about a past or a future!
Can these two stop arguing long enough to realize they are on the same side!
Will it be too late for Alessa to realize who her friends are? Bravo love this series!
Can we get an Epilogue or 2?
We have Marchesa Alessandra della Giamatti and her daughter Isabella they both have used Italian bad words to and on Lord James (Jack) Jacquehart Pierson the 5th son of a Duke!
They are each other’s throat constantly even from the previous story! Definitely a thin line between lust, likes and loathing!
Well Alessa has somewhat of a good reason as Jack had tied Isabella to a tree! Definitely funny and for her own good!
Alessa left her past in Italy and yet it has followed her and Isabella to England! Alessa is brave, beautiful and passionate and it the last flaw that questions her judgement!
Jack is very skilled on the battlefield and word play Alessa is tempted to trust him but is afraid that the enemy will hurt him or her daughter!
But is always the strong silent types and Jack is good at listening while working!
But Alessa enemies have grown bold unless she trusts someone she won’t have to worry about a past or a future!
Can these two stop arguing long enough to realize they are on the same side!
Will it be too late for Alessa to realize who her friends are? Bravo love this series!
Can we get an Epilogue or 2?
May 2, 2024
It was very entertaining! I loved how Jack who was seen as the devil won the heart of the mother and daughter. Isabella was adorable. I wish we had had more moments with her.
The last part of the plot resolution was bit boring and it took me some time to finish the last few pages because to be honest the bad guys were annoying and not that interesting but I loved the epilogue when we meet Jack's father and brothers. I liked that interaction.
The last part of the plot resolution was bit boring and it took me some time to finish the last few pages because to be honest the bad guys were annoying and not that interesting but I loved the epilogue when we meet Jack's father and brothers. I liked that interaction.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 18, 2018
DNF. Maybe you really have to have read the first book (usually I don’t jump into a series midway through) but I could not stand it. The ebook was riddled with grammatical errors, which made it difficult to read and pay attention. From the few chapters I read, the pace was too slow and felt sluggish. Maybe I’ll try this book again if I start from the first book in the trilogy. Maybe.
February 22, 2019
This had kind of a swash-buckling tone to it - I liked it!
October 23, 2020
"the earthy scent of him made her a little dizzy. Sandalwood and tobacco mixed with a dark spice that she could not quite define."
August 3, 2025
Just okay.
January 9, 2011
TO SURRENDER TO A ROGUE by Cara Elliott
Book #2 in The Circle of Sin Series
June 2010 - Grand Central Publishing - Mass Market Paperback, 384 Pages
Wow this book is too wonderful for words –
Lord James “Black Jack” Jacquehart Pierson had been a soldier who fought bravely regardless of the situation and without fear. He always stood strong with his brothers and friends doing right by those he felt had been wronged. But when he is going toe-to-toe with Marchesa Alessandra della Giamatti with her lecturing him on his behavior the man is truly at a loss for words and finally understands the meaning of fear. Granted he had tied her daughter to a tree but that was to protect the little imp from causing more chaos to an already out of control situation yet she kept on lecturing. Jack thought they might have a few cross words and part company but little did he know that the fiery Italian would keep coming back to haunt his day time hours and have him up with night time fantasies.
Alessandra was a rare woman of her times a financially independent widow with a superior intelligent who belonged to a unique group of women known as The Circle. Each woman in the group brought a unique gift to the mix which helped their scientific discussions and experiments. Jack had never come across such a female before even though he harbored a unique talent himself as an artist. He could not display his talent as freely as he would have liked for the males of his time did not behave in such a manner, a clash of swords was considered to be a true manly objective not capturing the sunset on a cloudy day. But Jack loved the feel of brush against canvas and knew he had a calling even though it was not something he could freely discuss.
But Jack has an ally in his oldest brother who understands Jack’s dream and steps up to help him move forward with his talent by securing Jack a job at an excavation site not knowing that the one person Jack did not want to see was the person in charge - Alessandra. Jack and Alessandra start heating thing up almost immediately because polite society is not around now and they unleash their passion for one another and act upon their desires. Jack is more than willing to show her the fire he has built inside for her but Alessandra is not quite so sure that she is ready to return his affection. But with a little persuasion and allot of warm kisses Alessandra loses all clear thought and learns to trust again.
Yet everything changes when an evil stranger from her past shows up to remind her of what she had done and why she was forced to leave Italy. Can she truly go along with this monster’s plan and again ruin her reputation but she knows her choices are gone when it means she has to in order to save her daughter. But is it possible Jack can help her and be the knight she seeks in her darkest hour or is he just using her to relieve some built up tension.
Lovely is a mild word for this dazzling book with fiery characters and a mystery to keep you guessing what will happen next. While it is the second in the series it easily stands alone with a captivating setting for the story and characters that jump out at you from every page. The mystery is dark and leaves you wondering what Alessandra could have done that she can be blackmailed so easily. You are also shown a refreshing side the male-female role in a time and place when men and women had defined positions to play and moving out of those was a herculean feat of character.
Book #2 in The Circle of Sin Series
June 2010 - Grand Central Publishing - Mass Market Paperback, 384 Pages
Wow this book is too wonderful for words –
Lord James “Black Jack” Jacquehart Pierson had been a soldier who fought bravely regardless of the situation and without fear. He always stood strong with his brothers and friends doing right by those he felt had been wronged. But when he is going toe-to-toe with Marchesa Alessandra della Giamatti with her lecturing him on his behavior the man is truly at a loss for words and finally understands the meaning of fear. Granted he had tied her daughter to a tree but that was to protect the little imp from causing more chaos to an already out of control situation yet she kept on lecturing. Jack thought they might have a few cross words and part company but little did he know that the fiery Italian would keep coming back to haunt his day time hours and have him up with night time fantasies.
Alessandra was a rare woman of her times a financially independent widow with a superior intelligent who belonged to a unique group of women known as The Circle. Each woman in the group brought a unique gift to the mix which helped their scientific discussions and experiments. Jack had never come across such a female before even though he harbored a unique talent himself as an artist. He could not display his talent as freely as he would have liked for the males of his time did not behave in such a manner, a clash of swords was considered to be a true manly objective not capturing the sunset on a cloudy day. But Jack loved the feel of brush against canvas and knew he had a calling even though it was not something he could freely discuss.
But Jack has an ally in his oldest brother who understands Jack’s dream and steps up to help him move forward with his talent by securing Jack a job at an excavation site not knowing that the one person Jack did not want to see was the person in charge - Alessandra. Jack and Alessandra start heating thing up almost immediately because polite society is not around now and they unleash their passion for one another and act upon their desires. Jack is more than willing to show her the fire he has built inside for her but Alessandra is not quite so sure that she is ready to return his affection. But with a little persuasion and allot of warm kisses Alessandra loses all clear thought and learns to trust again.
Yet everything changes when an evil stranger from her past shows up to remind her of what she had done and why she was forced to leave Italy. Can she truly go along with this monster’s plan and again ruin her reputation but she knows her choices are gone when it means she has to in order to save her daughter. But is it possible Jack can help her and be the knight she seeks in her darkest hour or is he just using her to relieve some built up tension.
Lovely is a mild word for this dazzling book with fiery characters and a mystery to keep you guessing what will happen next. While it is the second in the series it easily stands alone with a captivating setting for the story and characters that jump out at you from every page. The mystery is dark and leaves you wondering what Alessandra could have done that she can be blackmailed so easily. You are also shown a refreshing side the male-female role in a time and place when men and women had defined positions to play and moving out of those was a herculean feat of character.
September 27, 2019
Stars 3/4 (Kate Pearce, Maureen Driscoll, Elisa Braden)
Hey fellow readers I don’t summarize the books (as there are always great full summaries written that I read myself).
I only give it my personal, general, summary of 5 stars to 1 star.
3 stars: This book is worth a read but didn’t really have me excited about interacting with the book where I could not put it down. It lacks the excitement and well roundness of my personal markers for a great read throughout the book.
Development and interest in main characters, secondary characters, humorous, movement of the book, writing/conversation and romantic/sexual content (1-2 scenes or too much unnecessary).
Read it once and that is enough for me.
However, if this book is part of a series, I would read the next book (pervious book) in the series as it would still peek my reading interest.
I’ll continue reading from this author. I wouldn’t cross the author out of my potential reads in the future.
Hey fellow readers I don’t summarize the books (as there are always great full summaries written that I read myself).
I only give it my personal, general, summary of 5 stars to 1 star.
3 stars: This book is worth a read but didn’t really have me excited about interacting with the book where I could not put it down. It lacks the excitement and well roundness of my personal markers for a great read throughout the book.
Development and interest in main characters, secondary characters, humorous, movement of the book, writing/conversation and romantic/sexual content (1-2 scenes or too much unnecessary).
Read it once and that is enough for me.
However, if this book is part of a series, I would read the next book (pervious book) in the series as it would still peek my reading interest.
I’ll continue reading from this author. I wouldn’t cross the author out of my potential reads in the future.
June 29, 2010
I love Cara Elliott's Circle of Sin series. The heroines aren't the usual helpless, lost women looking for a wealthy and powerful lord to save them from their circumstances. Instead, the members of the Circle of Sin are well educated, unconventional, and deeply interested in learning. These women have interests that go well beyond fashion, men, and children. Each woman has a different area of expertise and the heroine of To Surrender To A Rogue is the archeologist Lady Alessandra della Giamatti.
Lady Alessandra played a role in Elliott's earlier novel To Sin With A Scoundrel (Circle of Sin Trilogy), where she had clashed with the dashing Lord James Pierson ("Black Jack").
The heroes in Cara Elliott's novels just as fun and satisfying. They're smart, successful, and they're not threatened by the unconventional. Elliott creates just a romantic hero that I can't help but fall for! Deep sense of honor, kind, funny, athletic, protective, generous, and always strikingly attractive!
In To Surrender To A Rogue, Alessandra and her daughter have been forced to leave Italy for England. As they adjust to their new circumstances, Alessandra agrees to participate in a prestigious and exciting archeological dig. Both the English and the Italian delegation defer to her expertise in planning and the actual excavation. The dig brings many surprises -- both pleasant and unwelcome. Black Jack is a bit of both -- the interaction between Jack and Alessandra is great fun. The banter, the uncertainty and their yield to their mutual attraction is well done and kept me thoroughly entertained. Cara Elliott has a deft touch for historical romance -- she mixes just the right amount of intrigue, uncertainty, and foreshadowing.
If you enjoy historical romance novels with spirited heroines, twisty plots, and constant banter, grab To Surrender To A Rogue! It's a fun, romantic read and a perfect summer escape! My mother stayed up all night reading it -- and then I did too!
ISBN-10: 0446541311 - Mass Market Paperback
Publisher: Forever (June 1, 2010), 384 pages.
Review copy provided by the publisher.
Lady Alessandra played a role in Elliott's earlier novel To Sin With A Scoundrel (Circle of Sin Trilogy), where she had clashed with the dashing Lord James Pierson ("Black Jack").
The heroes in Cara Elliott's novels just as fun and satisfying. They're smart, successful, and they're not threatened by the unconventional. Elliott creates just a romantic hero that I can't help but fall for! Deep sense of honor, kind, funny, athletic, protective, generous, and always strikingly attractive!
In To Surrender To A Rogue, Alessandra and her daughter have been forced to leave Italy for England. As they adjust to their new circumstances, Alessandra agrees to participate in a prestigious and exciting archeological dig. Both the English and the Italian delegation defer to her expertise in planning and the actual excavation. The dig brings many surprises -- both pleasant and unwelcome. Black Jack is a bit of both -- the interaction between Jack and Alessandra is great fun. The banter, the uncertainty and their yield to their mutual attraction is well done and kept me thoroughly entertained. Cara Elliott has a deft touch for historical romance -- she mixes just the right amount of intrigue, uncertainty, and foreshadowing.
If you enjoy historical romance novels with spirited heroines, twisty plots, and constant banter, grab To Surrender To A Rogue! It's a fun, romantic read and a perfect summer escape! My mother stayed up all night reading it -- and then I did too!
ISBN-10: 0446541311 - Mass Market Paperback
Publisher: Forever (June 1, 2010), 384 pages.
Review copy provided by the publisher.
August 18, 2010
To Surrender To A Rogue is a good read. It is the second book in the Circle of Sin series, but the best thing about trilogies like this, and what I appreciate the most, is that it isn't necessary to read the other books in the series to understand the story-line of any of the others. The main characters of To Surrender To A Rogue are different than the first book.
The first several chapters of the book up until the dig starts were a bit slow. And by that I mean nothing really happened with the plot. The character interactions were good, but the story was lacking.
Once the dig began, the story got more interesting even though it was somewhat predictable and very little thought was required to figure out what was going to happen next. There was one aspect of the ending that was surprising, but that was about it. The climax of the plot was a bit on the anti-climatic side and rather rushed.
What I liked most about this book was the character development, interactions, and conversations. I like how Cara Elliot alternated the narration of the story between Alessa and Jack's perspectives. The time I spent in Jack's head, so to speak, was rather enjoyable since he is unlike any aristocrat I've ever read about. He was confident without being cocky and arrogant. He was intelligent and talented, but he was very modest. He was charming and sensitive, but strong and a little bit dangerous too. Alessa on the other hand had odd, contradicting behavior for a woman who is supposed to be for all intents and purposes, a womens libber. She's described as a strong, independent woman, but she's very insecure, unsure of herself, and quite rude at times. She is smart yes, but extremely judgmental.
With everything said, what makes To Surrender To A Rogue a good book is the the clash of wills and battles of wit. The romance is eh, okay. Jack is what makes this book worth while.
And I do have to say that from the excerpt in the back of the book, Book 3 seems like it will be even better.
The first several chapters of the book up until the dig starts were a bit slow. And by that I mean nothing really happened with the plot. The character interactions were good, but the story was lacking.
Once the dig began, the story got more interesting even though it was somewhat predictable and very little thought was required to figure out what was going to happen next. There was one aspect of the ending that was surprising, but that was about it. The climax of the plot was a bit on the anti-climatic side and rather rushed.
What I liked most about this book was the character development, interactions, and conversations. I like how Cara Elliot alternated the narration of the story between Alessa and Jack's perspectives. The time I spent in Jack's head, so to speak, was rather enjoyable since he is unlike any aristocrat I've ever read about. He was confident without being cocky and arrogant. He was intelligent and talented, but he was very modest. He was charming and sensitive, but strong and a little bit dangerous too. Alessa on the other hand had odd, contradicting behavior for a woman who is supposed to be for all intents and purposes, a womens libber. She's described as a strong, independent woman, but she's very insecure, unsure of herself, and quite rude at times. She is smart yes, but extremely judgmental.
With everything said, what makes To Surrender To A Rogue a good book is the the clash of wills and battles of wit. The romance is eh, okay. Jack is what makes this book worth while.
And I do have to say that from the excerpt in the back of the book, Book 3 seems like it will be even better.
June 16, 2010
The second book in the Circle of Sin triology, TO SURRENDER TO A ROGUE seems to pick up where the first book left off. Now, the very first thing I'll say here is that I have not read Cara Elliott's first book in this series. Because of this, I think there may have been some key elements that I missed. From the beginning I will recommend that readers pick up To Sin With a Scoundrel. From what I can gather by my quick flipping through the pages of a borrowed copy, TO SURRENDER TO A ROGUE would be much more enjoyable with this backstory.
Alessandra and Jack make an excellent pair. There is obvious passion between these two although each has their own small personality flaws. Alessandra especially left me wanting to strangle her on occasion while I imagine steering very clear of her less than obedient daughter. Jack is handsome and has that air of danger around him, but at times it feels like there's a little too much danger. Still, the passion between the two is obvious and Ms. Elliott triumphs in creating a pairing that gets our adrenaline pumping.
What I loved more about TO SURRENDER TO A ROGUE was Ms. Elliott's way with words. Her writing is clear and flows quite well. The story here actually got a bit complex at times with the mystery and intrigue, but it was written so well that the unfolding events were easy to follow. Instead of simply reading a book, the reader is able to experience this story; jumping in after the hero and heroine and following them on their adventure to discover the truth.
Fans of historical romance should find something to love within the pages of TO SURRENDER TO A ROGUE. Ms. Elliott has a fantastic way of describing things beautifully - the clothes, emotions, and landscape all contained beautiful and refreshing detail. If you're looking for a book full of adventure and romance, TO SURRENDER TO A ROGUE will suit your needs wonderfully.
Alessandra and Jack make an excellent pair. There is obvious passion between these two although each has their own small personality flaws. Alessandra especially left me wanting to strangle her on occasion while I imagine steering very clear of her less than obedient daughter. Jack is handsome and has that air of danger around him, but at times it feels like there's a little too much danger. Still, the passion between the two is obvious and Ms. Elliott triumphs in creating a pairing that gets our adrenaline pumping.
What I loved more about TO SURRENDER TO A ROGUE was Ms. Elliott's way with words. Her writing is clear and flows quite well. The story here actually got a bit complex at times with the mystery and intrigue, but it was written so well that the unfolding events were easy to follow. Instead of simply reading a book, the reader is able to experience this story; jumping in after the hero and heroine and following them on their adventure to discover the truth.
Fans of historical romance should find something to love within the pages of TO SURRENDER TO A ROGUE. Ms. Elliott has a fantastic way of describing things beautifully - the clothes, emotions, and landscape all contained beautiful and refreshing detail. If you're looking for a book full of adventure and romance, TO SURRENDER TO A ROGUE will suit your needs wonderfully.
June 28, 2010
"To Surrender to a Rogue" is the second in the series THE CIRCLE OF SIN. I didn't read the first book "To Sin With a Scoundral" but I felt as though I should have as it took me a little bit to get into the story because I felt like I was missing something but as I read on I got more and more into it and really did enjoy this book. I thought that Alessandra and her daughter were just a bit to powerful of characters than I usually like and I just got the feeling that they were above Jack at times. I guess I am used to the characters being portrayed as strong but not that strong but then again I think that is one reason I liked the book it is different than what I am use to reading. I thought that there could have been more time spent on the relationship with Alessandra and Jack towards the end of the story as I felt that I was missing something with them. I think that Cara Elliott is a wonderful writer and her details to the characters and places are really very good and you can tell there has been a lot of reasearch done and I really appreciate that in a book. You should check her site out (http://www.caraelliott.com/index.html ) and see the virtual tour of Bath's famous ruins I think that it is great. I can say I did enjoy this book but I feel that I would have liked it more had I read the first book. I am going to pick up the first book to this series as I would very much like to read it and be ready for the third book to the series.
August 7, 2010
Alessandra della Giamatti is an archeologist with a secret to hide. When her only child is threatened, can she trust Lord James Jacquehart Pierson (Black Jack) to help her?
I picked up this book because I had promised it to someone else and thought I would skim it before passing it on. It looked like all the other books with half-naked people on the cover and I wasn't expecting much. I wasn't very happy when the book started with the main characters bickering like an old married couple. I'm glad I continued reading because it turned out to be an exciting and entertaining story.
There was a good amount of sex and body part description. There was also a lot of eyebrow arching (both in the book and by me while reading).
Over all, this was a much better read than I thought it would be. I would consider picking up the other books in the series.
My five year old son took a look at the cover of this book and explained, to me, that the book is about two people who are swimming in the ocean without their swimsuits.
I picked up this book because I had promised it to someone else and thought I would skim it before passing it on. It looked like all the other books with half-naked people on the cover and I wasn't expecting much. I wasn't very happy when the book started with the main characters bickering like an old married couple. I'm glad I continued reading because it turned out to be an exciting and entertaining story.
There was a good amount of sex and body part description. There was also a lot of eyebrow arching (both in the book and by me while reading).
Over all, this was a much better read than I thought it would be. I would consider picking up the other books in the series.
My five year old son took a look at the cover of this book and explained, to me, that the book is about two people who are swimming in the ocean without their swimsuits.
September 17, 2010
Mini Book Review: Delightfully sinful read full of beautiful strong women and handsome rogues. The perfect read for a day at the beach, a cold Canadian night or just while sitting in your office and reading it instead of doing your boring job -- not mine of course ; ) The characters were intriguing and not stereotypical like in many novels of this genre. Lady Alessandra and Jack have an intense chemistry, but there are also many light moments between them. Also Lady Alessandra's daughter is a delightful character and would have liked more scenes with her. The story flows nicely and it keeps you interested. I was quite ticked off one day that my bus was on time and had to put the book down. I look forward to picking up more books in Cara Elliott's "Circle of Sin" series.
3.5/5 Dewey's
3.5/5 Dewey's
March 27, 2011
Lady Alessandra della Giammatti is lucky in that her contemporary male figures accept that she is an expert in antiquities. She is asked to go to Bath and help organize the dig of an ancient Roman ruins. What she didn't know is that "Black Jack" Pierson, the fifth son of a duke, was also going to be on the dig. She first experienced him in "To Sin with a Scoundrel" when he was angrily leaving her friend's house and then when he tied her daughter to a tree. He had good experiences for both but Alessandra has no respect for a scoundrel who has done nothing with his life, even if he is an excellent artist, is instrumental in helping with the dig and has even befriended her daughter. But she'll need his help when her past comes back to haunt her.
December 17, 2012
The Heroine Alessandra and the Hero Jack share the same characteristics and plot of the previous Circle of Sin book. Feisty rude bluestocking beautiful female, alpha male rogue who is secretly an intellectual, every time they get together they kiss, culminating in sex halfway through. Female is in danger towards the end and rogue saves her. Even the phrases are the sme, Lud, "Go to Hell" in Italian, Grotto of Venus, and rogue growling. I expect the final book 3 in the series to follow the same formula. This is formulaic Regency writing. I am giving this a 3 for that reason. I did read it through and it kept me entertained but wished for more originality. Now started reading book 3 with Lady Kate and Comte Marco and alas I was right.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews