1. A Brush with Love. Oh boy. I snort laughed at the end reflecting on how ridiculous it all was, but I also cried a little? So, there are some conflicting feelings. It was a fine enough premise with emotional depth or at least potential (girl badly scarred in a fire and stood up by her high school love interest now faces that love interest years later when he returns to town, forcing her to face her insecurity--QUITE forcefully, I might add), but the pacing and emotion felt off and just up and down to me. I had to laugh inside at the Christian timeline of getting married in 0.75 seconds, but that's fairly fitting. The whole bit with staying at the house up the muddy lane was a smidge too cheesy for me, especially being rescued with a horse. And good heavens, the novella is rather preachy at times, but then this girl is just lifting up her shirt to reveal her scarred back and side with zero cares for modesty??? That had me laughing. 3 stars.
2. Love in the Details. This one was substantially better, in my opinion. The story was much more plausible. Holly was "forced" to break up with Josh many moons ago, they reunite in present day, both are still obsessed with each other but too afraid to say it. Seemed mildly unrealistic to me (despite me just saying it was more plausible), but I think that's just my cynical nature coming through here. I definitely rolled through some of the deeper messages and such because I can't handle those topics right now, and yet I appreciated it was there without being TOO in your face and/or cheesy. 4 stars.
3. An October Bride. Leaps and bounds, my favorite...but it was Katie, so I'm not surprised. I was hooked within pages, and I'm not entirely sure if it's because I love the fake relationship trope or the I've-always-loved-you trope or if it's just the magic of Katie's writing, but it was all truly wonderful. Emma's dad has a terminal cancer diagnosis, she accidentally finds his bucket list and discovers the item to "walk Emma down the aisle," and her secret childhood crush/brother's-best friend very philanthropically and selflessly offers to be her fiancee for a "fake" but "real" wedding to make that dream come true. I could have read this expounded as a whole novel in and of itself, easily, yet I didn't feel cheated with its brevity as a novella. It incorporated classic chick lit elements, somehow without being cheesy (Small town festival?! Declarations in the rain?!) or making me roll my eyes. I also liked that it incorporated heavier topics without being heavyhanded or ridiculous, and it wasn't dissonant--it all meshed well. 5 stars.