4.5/5
I love it when an author can take a character who appears to be a shallow, self absorbed, womanizer and turn him into one of the most loveable men on the planet. Such is the case with Julian Salvatore. Book 1, Trial by Fire and book 2, Under Fire both showed him to be quite the ladies man. He’s carefree, no strings, no commitments, sex on demand and seeming to never, never taking life or any part of it, seriously. I couldn’t imagine exactly how Ms. Davis was going to turn him into a compelling, compassionate hero who I’d identify with and want to care about, but she did.
Grace Mckenna, Kat Paxton’s sister, made her very first and very brief appearance in the series in book 1, Trial By Fire. We know her to be totally absorbed in her work, not interested in a relationship with a man… blah blah blah. Same story, different heroine. I didn’t find anything really exciting about her which is unfortunate because Julian is such an exceptional character.
I find the team dynamic very interesting and enjoy the way the author creates interactions between each person that are often times funny, sometimes heartbreaking, but always believable. Frequently in families there will be one person who keeps everyone together – that one relative who everyone looks up to and depends on to keep things going. When something happens and that person is no longer able to do that job, or to be that person to act as the glue keeping everything in place, someone else has to step in and do it. Such is the case with the Station 5 family. Sean Tanner might be the Captain, but Howard Paxton seems to be the boss. He’s the one everyone turns to, depends on, and whose opinion is most valued.
Slight spoiler
I guess what has me thinking along these lines is the team intervention which was planned to help Sean see how much everyone cared about him, for his wellbeing and how desperately they wanted to help him. They spoke openly and while the words weren’t flowery or eloquent, they were from the heart. I appreciated the authenticity with which that scene was written, and without going into too much detail, the realism of how it turned out. End spoiler
For me, the bottom line is that I appreciated the honesty with which this story was written. Julian’s past, the nightmares, the confrontation, then the self doubt… all very realistic to me. However, after reading the first three books in the series, I’ve come to the conclusion that part Jo Davis’ writing style depends on coincidence to be able to tell the story or resolve the conflicts. While Hidden Fire is my favorite of the three I’ve read, we see a continuation of chance, happenstance and luck playing a big part in propelling the story which then takes me from believing it to being skeptical of it.
See, the thing is, Jo Davis’ writing is very good. She has this amazing ability to give us tormented, complicated, interesting heroes and heroines, which she has proven with Julian, Howard Paxton, Sean Tanner, Zack… but their stories themselves, which start out very good, end up being… meh. I mean no disrespect, truly I don’t, but what could be a 5 star read falls short for me. Maybe she just loves writing with lots of coincidence in her plots, but it doesn’t work well – or at least as well as it could – for me. Lord knows I couldn’t write a book and I’m the last person on the planet who should be criticizing, but this is how it feels, how it seems to me.
Book 4, Line of Fire is next and I’m hoping for a great read!