Being a guy, I tend to watch a lot of ESPN. During COVID I worked virtually and became a pretty avid watcher of it’s morning show, “First Take”. It’s hard not to be entertained by Stephen A. Smith’s over the top delivery that includes arguing, pontificating, self-promotion, and usually some really strong sports analysis and reflection. Even with his focus shifting more towards entertainment than debate, his show has been number one in the ratings for several years.
Now Smith has decided to write his own story (which interestingly enough was published the same month as Prince Harry’s own memoir, “Spare”). The title of Stephen A’s book is almost as big as his monologue – “Straight Shooter: A Memoir of Second Chances and First Takes” – and a witty use of his show’s name.
I’ll be honest. As I read this book I really wanted to see how much Smith would let us behind the curtain of his public persona, and get exposure into his personal life. Truth be told, I have a lot of respect for Stephen A and what he’s accomplished. Even though I can get frustrated with him and his overzealous antics when he thinks he’s right, he is smart, fast on his feet, and can hold his own with anybody. I have especially appreciated his support for black colleges and other minority-based groups, as well as the moments that he has owned his mistakes and made sincere public apologies. In my mind, he has rightfully earned his success and I hoped to learn more about the factors behind it, what drove him, what things he did right, and what mistakes he made along the way.
The good news is that “Straight Shooter” delivered on that, and more. If you like watching Stephen A. on ESPN or providing analysis at sporting events (especially the NBA playoffs) you will really enjoy this book and his pulling back the curtain of his public persona to share his personal thoughts, fears, and biggest motivations. If you enjoy him from time to time or have a dislike for him, this book might just change your mind in a positive way that you won’t see coming.
Truth to be told, I was caught off-guard by Stephen’s memoir in many ways, but mostly by his honesty and willingness to share his lessons learned. Some of them were challenging and tough, and really helped provide a better understanding of who he is on television and why he acts the way he does. Is he brash? Yes. Is he outspoken? Yes. But does reading his experiences help you to reflect on your own mistakes, lessons learned, and family relationships. An absolute yes to that!
Stephen pulls no punches and holds nothing back in sharing the memoirs of his life. That is except for one area of his life, and that is the two mothers of his two daughters. Other than explaining why he’s never married, and giving them all kinds of love, he respectfully leaves them off-stage. Whether at their request, his choice, or a combination, it actually works out okay. Although, I really would have loved to have known more about them and their relationship with him, leaving them out was probably the right thing to do.
Everything else was open game and he willingly chose to use his experiences, mistakes, and lessons learned as an opportunity for us to learn from them and do better for ourselves, as well as provide some motivation for his readers to go shoot for the moon and achieve their own dreams. I know that sounds cheesy, but for me, his messages came across just fine.
Stephen A. shared his growing up in the Bronx, his tightknit family, his hero of a mother, and his challenging relationship with his father, who was not a very nice person (to say the least). How basketball got to a HBCU college, Winston-Salem State, and how a career ending injury led him into sports journalism. How his newspaper beat writing developed his strong network, and eventually led to his shot at ESPN. His rise on radio and television, and being fired in 2009 with a label of being too hard to work with.
This is where his story becomes even stronger, as he returned to FOX radio and rebuilt his image with some really hard lessons that needing learning. Even when he got his chance to return to ESPN, he made mistakes and ran into real conflicts, including an interview with Richard Sherman, his misspoken comments about Ray Rice, Ayesha Curry (Steph’s wife), Shohei Ohtani. Through these emotional and awareness building experiences, Stephen A. lets us experience his faults, his stubbornness that at times held him back, and an eventual a willingness to listen to those around him who told him what he needed to hear rather than false accolades. These chapters alone were worth the price of the book alone, which doesn’t even include his time spent struggling with max Kellerman on First Take or his near-death experience with COVID and pneumonia that forced him to rethink his priorities and family relationships.
I appreciated his honesty about his mistakes, taking ownership, and his lessons learned. He did not hold back from openly sharing his mistakes – and there were many of them along the way – and the tough lessons that came about as a result of them. His stubbornness to do it all himself and not trust those around him really stunted his growth and success at times. He lost out on opportunities at times to his own detriment. It was interesting to watch how his intelligence, drive, and desire, grew into wisdom when he started engaging, listening to, and trusting those around him who had his best interest in mind. Those were some mighty powerful lessons to learn the hard way.
Stephen A. could have held back and not fully shared as much as he did, but I give him credit for giving it his best shot. His passion for finding happiness in taking care of his family and thanking those who helped him on his journey were valuable for me. I found his personal journey very real, revealing, and left me reflecting on my own legacy and family relationships, especially that with my wife, children, and grandchildren.
On a personal note, the two biggest things that impacted in reading his memoir were these. One, his love, respect, and commitment to honoring his mother who sacrificed so much for him and his sisters was amazing. She led an inspired life and I have no doubt that she is in heaven now looking down on her family with a smile on her face. The second was his personal recognition for those around him and the positive influence they were on him. He described their strengths and support for him, many times when he didn’t deserve it. There’s too many to name (his Acknowledgements at the end of the book run 10 pages), but I appreciated that he remembered and pointed out those personal strengths and behaviors in others. It was recognition well deserved.
Thank you, Stephen A., for fully opening up yourself and sharing your life story in such a reflective and revealing manner. For me, the humanity shined through.
I may be biased, and if so, I am okay with it. This was a 5-star read.
P.S. I have thought for several years that you would eventually be a late-night host of your television show. Now I am absolutely sure of it.