I have read most of Tate James’ other books and loved all of them. I started reading this knowing that it would be a dark romance along the lines of Madison Kate and Hades, but as I loved both of those series, thought that this book would be great too.
I was wrong.
Well written, interesting plot, great characters (for the most part) - it was the actions of one character in particular that ruined this for me: Malachi/Kai.
I should note that the only warning given about the content of the book is a disclaimer included at the beginning:
“The tone and content tends to lean toward the dark, and reader discretion is advised.
Please be mindful of your own content triggers and limits.
The characters within The Guild series are not heroes or heroines, please kindly don’t hold them to a heroic standard as they will fall short of expectations. They do bad things, and they own their actions.”
Specific triggers included in the book aren’t actually listed at the beginning so that you know what you’re getting yourself into - which, in a book with this many triggers, seems unwise. Yes, it states that it leans towards the dark, and it is a book about assassins and gunrunners, so I would expect a darker tone - but I draw the line at a rapist being introduced as the fmc’s (Danny) love interest.
The rapist (Kai) sexually assaults and rapes Danny, drugs her, abducts her, has her tortured, and tells her she’s an eternal prisoner on his island. Then, to add to the icks - he spends a week refusing to use a condom during sex and actively tries to get Danny pregnant, then has the gall to keep hoping she is pregnant after she escapes. Just, ew.
I was not expecting any of the characters to be morally good heroes/heroines, but I certainly wasn’t expecting a rapist to be considered “falling short of expectations” - like, the bar is on the floor dude. To simply not sexually assault/rape someone is not that hard. Kai did several “bad things” (horrible, terrible, disgusting things) and never once “owned his actions”. There were was no apologising or trying to make up - if anything, Kai doubled down and asserted that he wasn’t sorry and he would do it again.
Kai is not a ‘dark’ or morally grey/ambiguous guy. He is not a misunderstood, lovable villain. He is a sick, disgusting creep and his behaviour shouldn’t be promoted as acceptable.
Again, I realise that this is a ‘dark romance’, but Kai and his actions were just a step too far. We see the sexual assault/rape during Danny’s POV chapters, so we as readers know that she enjoys the experience more than she expects and is happy to play along - but Kai doesn’t know that. He simply sexually assaults, then rapes Danny and enjoys it the whole time - recognising that he just sexually assaulted and raped a woman but somehow justifying his actions. To then be introduced as a current (and I’m assuming future love interest in the rest of the books) is just straight up wrong.
To be clear, I’m happy to read a book that features rape play or cnc - so long as it’s clearly listed as a trigger at the start of the book, and it plays out in the book how it should in real life bdsm; ie. a discussion about hard limits, a safe word, consent given prior.
Tate James is known for her cliffhangers and ‘are they/aren’t they dead’ characters moments, so I’m truly hoping she redeems this series by killing Kai’s character off. If a rapist love interest continues to be featured, I don’t think I’ll be reading the rest of this series.
Ps. As someone who has lived in Aotearoa her whole life, to see someone being called a “miserable pūkeko” as an insult just made me laugh, and not in a good, “that’s so funny!” kind of way. Pūkeko’s are a large, mostly flightless bird - not Aotearoa’s version of Eeyore.