While the first book was a downer, I thoroughly enjoyed the other two and am excited to read the rest of this series! These were also super fun to discuss with my mom as we buddy read all three together. ☺️
🌹Beauty and the Beast—2 Stars🌹
I don’t normally like Beauty and the Beast retellings (there are exceptions, of course), so I wasn’t thrilled that this was the first book, but I decided to give it a shot anyways because I enjoy other books by this author.
Needless to say this isn’t one of them.
It started off kinda slow but with enough intriguing bits that made me keep going, even though the plot is just random events that happen with no context or meaning beyond pushing the characters together romantically. Overall not great, but it was fine enough that I was leaning towards a 3 star rating until I reached the last three chapters.
Oh, my gosh, those three chapters made me SO TICKED!!! I got whiplash at least four times, events happened for no reason, people got mad at each other for no reason then weren’t in the next chapter without explanation, and the ending was so abrupt it made my head spin. Just WHAT?!?! Needless to say that’s how this book got dropped to a 2 star rating and made me so mad I got into a reading slump for two days.
I’m still continuing with the series as I LOVE other books by this author, but certainly not this one. If you don’t like B&TB retellings then I’d suggest skipping this one, and if you do, maybe check out reviews from others who love this book. Because I sadly didn’t.
‼️Content‼️
Language: danged
Violence: a girl falls through a glass roof and breaks her leg; injuries and blood (not detailed); a boy mocks a girl and throws a rock at her; a crutch is thrown at a boy and knocks him out of a tree; an evil witch wants to cut out a girl’s heart and eat it; a character kills an evil witch; assassins try to kill a character
Sexual: a kiss (not detailed)
Drug/Alcohol: characters drink alcohol
Other: magic; a character is cursed to look like a beast; a character is illegitimate
🦢The Wild Swans—4 Stars 🦢
After reading Beauty and the Beast (and, um, not really liking it 😬) I was a bit skeptical of how I would like this one even though The Princess and the Pea had restored a little of my faith in the series.
However. This book has a love triangle. And we all know how much I ADORE those. 😒🙄
So naturally I really liked this book. 😆
The love triangle is actually hardly there at all—I know, SHOCKER, Elise was actually more concerned with breaking the curse and rescuing her kingdom rather than mooning over two boys. THE MATURITY PEOPLE!!!! It was amazing! Also the author literally allows you to choose through the epilogues at the end which guy you want Elise to end up with. I know the author got a lot of backlash for how “lazy” this was, but honestly I thought it was creative and even nice to those who maybe wanted Elise with the other guy. While one IS more suited personality and interest wise (I’m not gonna say who) I originally wanted her with the other guy until my mom (who I was buddy reading this book with) and I discussed it and I realized, yeah, Elise would actually work better with the other guy then the one I wanted to choose. 😆
Love triangle aside, Elise’s character growth is AMAZING. She goes through so much and finds her worth and value in herself and in her family without having to be perfect all the time, and it just blew me away by how WELL her arc was handled and done to the point where I was cheering for her wholeheartedly by the end even though at the beginning I found her rather stiff. All seven brothers have arcs too, and I loved how much closer the siblings grew together through all their various hardships.
From what I remember of the original tale this retelling is very close while also taking liberties to flesh things out (as all good fairy tale retellings do). The climax did feel a tiny bit of “that’s it?” in defeating the villain, HOWEVER I was able to overlook it due to just seeing how far Elise had come in that, yes it was an “easy win” but she never would have been able to defeat them at the beginning and therefore her new strength was what kept the climax from falling completely flat.
I enjoyed this book WAY more than I thought I would—my faith in this series has been restored! Hopefully all the other books are just as good or better than this one!
‼️Content‼️
Language: what the; gee
Violence: a hunter nearly shoots a swan; a girl throws rocks at a hunter; a man grabs a girl by the wrist and throws her over his shoulder (she gets away); a character is tied to a stake and nearly burned to death; a character fights soldiers; a character is killed by magic and their face boils before they turn to ash (not detailed)
Sexual: kissing (not detailed)
Drug/Alcohol: characters drink alcohol at meals
Other: magic; enchanters; magical abilities, objects, and creatures; characters are cursed into swans
👠Cinderella and the Colonel—4 Stars👠
This is the most unique retelling of Cinderella I’ve ever read! Rather than making Cinderella poor and a mistreated servant, she’s actually a Duchess of an in debt estate due to a war where her country was conquered by another and she really dislikes them for it (understandably). So already with this new take the story starts out WAY differently then your normal Cinderella tale which also takes things a step further by making her Prince Charming a colonel that at first she wants nothing to do with, lol.
I loved Cinderella and Friedrich and seeing their relationship move from irritating each other to friendship to more was so well done and flowed so naturally I was almost as surprised as Cinderella by the change (but not really, lol 😆). Cinderella herself goes through such a change and while she still has the kindness she’s so well known for, she also has a more fiery and sometimes even petty side that makes her an entirely different yet familiar character all at once. And under all his charm Friedrich is such a sweetheart and I love him for it. 🥰
So far this is my favorite in the series, and I can’t wait to continue!
‼️Content‼️
Language: darn it; darned
Violence: arrows are shot at characters; characters are chased and attacked by assassins; a character kills an assassin (not shown); a mage captures a woman and tries to choke her; an arrow hits a guy’s shoulder; fighting with magic and farm tools as weapons; a girl slaps a guy
Sexual: mild suggestive hints/comments; kissing (not detailed)
Drug/Alcohol: characters drink alcohol
Other: magic; mages, enchanters, a fairy godmother, and magicians; magical objects and powers; death
[Read as one of my 2023 Specific New Books to Read goal]