2.5/5 stars, lots of potential but ultimately a let down
Thank you to Penguin Teen and Razorbill for the arc through netgalley in exchange for an honest review!
When I initially requested an arc of this book it was the cover that caught my attention, I loved the red and how the characters were centered. On top of that, the synopsis sounded really interesting, modern-day vampires and boarding schools. However, I was unable to read the book until now and I read this while reading other reviews for this book, and I wanted to contribute my own opinions. I ended up being really disappointed with this book because of how much I was anticipating it.
Just as sensitivity and other arc readers noticed the poor attempt to handle too many topics at once, I also noticed this. This book is supposed to be a romance in a sense, but it also tried to tackle and discuss so many problems that exist in the world today. These included things like racism, bullying, ethics, poverty, elitism, homophobia, and more. However, because this book tried to focus on all of these subjects it frankly failed in discussing them in a non-performative way and led many of these topics to not be focused on enough, falling instead to the wayside. Many were glanced over and never discussed again, which did make me uncomfortable at times, especially when so many POC characters felt like they were just used as props. Many of their stories were just used (including other diverse characters like those in the LGBTQ+ community) to uplift and influence the main character's story who appeared as a performative activist.
The main character, Kat, was not just a white performative activist, she was also honestly just annoying sometimes. I understood her position suddenly coming from the world of humans into this school for all vampires, things were bound to be awkward. I say that she was a performative activist because it felt like she never took time to actually talk to the people of color and what they wanted. On one hand, I believe that there is room in literature and the world for the discussion of how Caucasian people should aid and lead discussions about such topics listed above, I don't believe the discussions should be dominated by them. This was what this book seemed to imply, it felt a bit like it was taking over the discussion of the individuals who are POC to give this image of a perfect white girl.
I felt that Taylor was more of a secondary main character, even though there were many chapters from her perspective within the book. While I understood sometimes why she acted the way she did because of her past, but also sometimes she was just really mean for no reason. Also, did she really need to be friends/hooking up with a character who acts homophobic all the time? I'm just not sure her character was used in the right way.
One thing that I did really enjoy about this book was the atmosphere, especially at a prestigious and private vampire academy. Vampires are not usually my first choice of supernatural creatures, I prefer Fae, but this book made me really interested to read more from this area of books. However, I didn't completely love that the entire Vampiredom was racist, homophobic, etc. I do understand though that they've been around for hundreds of years and have their ways, but that also could've been flipped and seen them accept everything as they've lived so long.
The plot was just okay, there were times that it really seemed to drag in the beginning, though it did pick up a bit more in the second half. But I didn't totally connect on every level, the mystery was pretty good but I felt like it needed something more. As well, the ending wrapped up way too nicely for my tastes, everyone was suddenly happy and the bad things were gone. Unfortunately, it didn't really take into account the complexities of all the topics it was trying to tackle.
Finally, this book was supposed to be a romance and in the beginning, I was very excited to see how the romance was going to play out because it seemed like childhood friends to strangers/enemies to lovers (which I've found I love lately). But I didn't see the chemistry between Kat and Taylor at all, both treated each other not amazingly and I didn't see why they liked each other. It was very complicated, as many teenage romances are, but I just couldn't get myself to ship them.
[TW: knife cut, blood, fictional clinical disease, death of a parent, racism, homophobia, bullying, alcohol, underage drinking, dead bodies, death of a loved one, homelessness]