3.5/5 ⭐
3/5 🌶️
Tropes
- Small Town Girl Trying to Make It Big
- Reverse Harem
- "The Quest"
- The OG Isekai
- Dark Romance
- Fairytale Retelling
📖 My Thoughts
As a dark retelling of The Wizard of Oz, I wasn't sure what I was getting into. I'm glad I didn't go in with any expectations, because they would have been blown away the moment the slaughter started. 😂 We start off with our FMC Dorothy, who is a small town girl who tried and failed to get her big break in Hollywood. She's on her way home to Kansas with more trauma in her bag than clothes, alongside her emotional support pup, Toto. Honestly the modern language and slang threw me off at first. I got used to it, but it's definitely something I didn't end up liking. Que tornado and one way trip to Oz, and here's where things start to take a turn. Everything happy and light about the original book and movie has been twisted and warped into something horrifying and sick. And I loved every minute of it! There's blood, and gore, and murder, and cannibalism, as well as extreme kinks and messed up situations. Really this book had it all. And the twist at the end? Never saw it coming! Overall, the Scarecrow "Crowe" was my favorite character, and I wish we had gotten even more of him than we already did.
What I liked:
- The darkness of the world of Oz is really intriguing and gives the story something unique.
- I also really liked the characters. Each of them are traumatized and broken in their own ways and the metaphor of them healing mentally while physically on a quest to break their curses is very satisfying.
What I didn't like:
- The tonal shifts. One moment you're covered in blood and gore, and the next you're joking around. It was very jarring and I feel like it could have been handled a little better if the author wanted something like a dark comedy, which is essentially what this is.
- I also felt like this could have been a little darker. Each witch is supposed to be evil and we kind of get an explanation as to why, but I feel we needed more time to explore Oz and really see the fruits of their crimes. This book just needed to be longer and have less filler/more worldbuilding.
- By the same token, I felt like I didn't get enough time with the MMCs either even with all the camping and traveling, with Tobias (Toto) being the exception. Even when it was the MMC's pov, I felt like we didn't learn as much about them as I wanted. Two of the MMCs don't get together with Dorothy until the last 3rd of the book, and it just feels like their relationships had no time to develop.
⚠️ Triggers
Dubious Consent, Gore, Violence, Kidnapping, References to Cannibalism (not depicted), Murder of minor characters, Fear and Blood used in sexual context, Voyeurism, Exhibitionism, Threats of dismemberment (not depicted), Knife Play, Blood Play, Choking, Abusive/Toxic Relationships
!!! Representation
Two of the MMCs seem to have a thing with eachother. There's one small scene and then some mentions, but I wish it was more explicitly explored.
🌶️ Spice
The spice was certainly interesting, and well-written. There's approximately eight spicy scenes in this book, most of which are pretty vanilla apart from one very messed up Dubious Consent scene that has some fear and bloodplay, and ends in murder. 😂 As well as an end scene with DP.