I have always loved the mundane parts of history. Some may argue that most of history is mundane, with laboriously worded documents and men arguing with each other over the same issue for decades, but what I mean are the day to day actions of our past, the seemingly unimportant moments at the time. The Shocking Secrets of American History provides context and "behind the scenes" understanding for events that we may know a lot or a little about, without the censorship and omission that our education performs.
Drawing back the curtain, Coate provides humorous and valuable insight into what was really going on during certain parts of our nation's history. It is hilariously written, knowing full well the absurdity of our forefathers and how their actions influence our lives today. Often ending each short story with a joke or pun, Coate demonstrates how history can be fun and entertaining, especially when providing an explanation for things we may never have before questioned. In the same vein, Coate doesn't shy away from mistakes or the absurd, allowing us to understand how people in the past suffered and made mistakes just like we do today. Whether it is now or 200 years ago, we are all subject to the folly of human nature.
Coate often poses the question "Where would we be if things had turned out differently?".
It is a question that anyone versed in history has been asked, but it is interesting to see it applied to very specific and often minute instances. How would World War II have panned out if Hitler's last name was actually Schicklgruber? How would our nation be different if Lincoln had listened to his prophetic dreams before attending the theatre? Given what has been deemed important to teach us in schools now versus what this book uncovers, Shocking Secrets is really the epitome of hindsight being 20/20.
I didn't love the organization of the book. The majority is made up of the revolutionary era through the wild west, taking great care of the time that spanned between them. It jumps very quickly into the twentieth century and doesn't leave us with as much material as the prior sections. It felt a little disingenuous given the care given to earlier timelines, but that could very well be due to the widespread availability of knowledge in our more recent history, thus providing less unknown content than in the earlier time periods.
Each little story is no longer than a page and a half to two pages, doing away with the long winded texts that history books tend to provide. This makes Shocking Secrets a quick and entertaining read, keeping your attention from one story to the next. While not something I would normally go looking for, it was a surprisingly delightful second hand shop find, and I would recommend it to anyone trying to get into history and nonfiction, but are fearful of potential monotony. Don't worry- people were just as goofy then as they are now.
Overall, I'm left with a sense of eeriness after reading. There are so many strange coincidences outlined in this book, that one has to wonder- are the conspiracies true? Is there a greater force at play in our history? Like the people in this book, we may just have to wait a few centuries to find out.