What do you think?
Rate this book


255 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published January 1, 1984
I acquired this one, and a yellow-spine-DAW-books copy which I kept, in an eBay lot of fantasy books. I was jonesing for some sword & sorcery action (and gruesomeness) and found a little of what I was looking for here. I did not like all of the stories in this book. Some of them were just boring and written in a plain prose that lacked verve as opposed to some of the best offerings in the genre and most bordered on straight fantasy rather than sword & sorcery (and most of the S&S stories were not purely of the S&S genre either). Some of my favorites in this anthology are: Taking Heart (an enjoyable cloak and dagger drama between two rogues) by Stephen L. Burns, The Valley of the Troll (the troll’s curse was A+ level trolling of the villainous robbers) by Charles de Lint, The Sword of Yraine by Diana L. Paxson, Daton and the Dead Things (eerie and weird like sword & sorcery should be) by Michael Ward, Gate of the Damned (just plain good bloody and weird sword & sorcery) by Janet Fox, Child of Orcus (sword and sandals with sword & sorcery elements) by Robin W. Bailey, and I did also find the brief Things Come in Threes by Dorothy J. Heydt enjoyable as well as quirky.
The Sword of Yraine is a standout here and had me in the grips of some genuine suspense. In it, raiders, stragglers from a defeated army, overwhelm a temple and take the priestesses hostage and brutalize them until they reveal the location of their treasure. It focuses on SA committed against the virginal initiates and the plight of one of them, Yraine, not assaulted but comes close, who is trained in sword fighting to foment resistance and win the day after a nude sword duel. It was suspenseful and somewhat disturbing as there is the what-you-would-expect vengeance for such crimes visited upon one of the rapists (but not by our heroine). The heroine was well-written and proactive even when she was essentially helpless.
Daton and the Dead Things had a situation often found in mythology but was told in a purely weird-tales story mode. The prisoners of the monster who were so traumatized as to believe that they were “dead things” and thus “not good to eat” were interesting in concept and the monster, the titular Daton, was menacing, creepy, and pathetic all at once.
Gate of the Damned had the creepiest villain/monster out of all of these stories and has a pretty compelling protagonist in the amazon Scorpia.
Child of Orcus was pretty good until it got into its last third basically degenerating from sword and sorcery into classical myth. Other than that, it was a good one.
None of the stories made me angry that I read them, I did like seven of them though the remainder I don’t even really remember much about them. I have read Gimmile’s Songs by Charles L. Saunders before in his Dossouye. As I remember it, it’s okay (the story featured here), it has some sadness in it.
I would recommend Sword & Sorceress to those looking for some good sword & sorcery stories, seven out of fifteen isn’t that bad (approximately 48% which is much better than some other anthologies I’ve read).
The Garnet & the Glory by Phyllis Ann Karr — ★★☆☆☆
Severed Heads by Glen Cook — ★☆☆☆☆
Taking Heart by Stephen L Burns — ★★★★★
The Rending Dark by Emma Bull — ★★★★☆
Gimmile's Songs by Charles R Saunders — ★★★★☆
The Valley of the Troll by Charles de Lint — ★★☆☆☆
Imperatrix by Deborah Wheeler — ★★☆☆☆
Blood of Sorcery by Jennifer Roberson — ★★★☆☆
With Four Lean Hounds by Pat Murphy — ★★★★☆
House in the Forest by Anodea Judith — ★★☆☆☆
Sword of Yraine by Diana L Paxson — ★★★☆☆
Daton & the Dead Thing by Michael Ward — N/A
Gate of the Damned by Janet Fox — ★★★★☆
Child of Orcus by Robin W Bailey — ★★☆☆☆
Things Come in Threes by Dorothy J Heydt — ★★☆☆☆