In the first decade of the 1900s, the number of UFO sightings in Alberta increased rapidly, according to an article I reviewed many years ago. The number of UFO sightings across the continent also probably increased once the Wright brothers found a way to fly. I wanted to find a similar context for sightings of a monster that inhabits New Jersey’s Pine Barrens, but authors James McCloy and Ray Miller Jr. didn’t do that level of research for their book The Jersey Devil.
I’m fascinated by the critters that may inhabit the world’s hinterlands (literally or metaphorically) occasionally making sorties into communities to feed, steal, frighten, and learn: Sasquatch, Yeti, Chupacabra, the Loch Ness monster, Ozark Howler, Peuchens, Kokopelli, and Sigbin to name a few. I enjoy learning about the context of when the sightings and interactions occur, as well as who the humans are. This book, unfortunately, is more of a compilation of sightings than a historical investigation into the incidents.
The authors offered some possible explanations including misidentification of sand hill cranes as the Devil but they seemed to accept “mass hysteria.” The third week of January 1909 featured dozens of incidents. The Jersey Devil allegedly attacked a dog, peeped through windows, scared livestock to death, escaped posses, and dodged countless bullets. Witness descriptions were similar but not exact, which also is curious but hardly addressed in the book. Mass hysteria falls short in explaining sightings hundreds of miles apart in a pre-social media world.
I know why my dad, a fan of HP Lovecraft and similar authors, bought the book, but it’s a shallow attempt to explain this regional monster. The Jersey Devil deserves better.