Re The Devil's Pawn - there aren't too many books in HPlandia that can out wreck this one. All angst junkies take notice, cause YW did the wrecki-angst in spades and it is a rollercoaster of a read. TDP is probably the closest one will get in HPlandia to a choose your own adventure book.
The believability of the HEA is entirely dependent on the reader's personal outlook, cynics will find much to amuse themselves with in this one, and those who have a more rosy glasses attitude (or an adult beverage or six beforehand,) can find enough evidence to support their side as well.
I vacillate on this one a lot, that more than anything is one of the reasons I think this should be one of the higher rated books in the HP lineup. Milage always varies tho, so grab your rose tinted specs, cuddle up to your favorite vino or throw a couple extra big pillows on the wall across the room. This one is for certain going to be a bumpy ride.
The story starts with the h being told that her father owes a gigantic debt to a certain man who over the past year has been randomly showing up at the same social events the h goes to. He seems to be silently stalking her and he makes her very uncomfortable. The h is an nice, reserved and quietly compassionate young lady - she is also a librarian, so while she appears meek and mild, no one ever wants to rile her by messing with the books, cause she has a bite that can pierce metal.
The father tells the h that unless he can get more time to pay on the huge loan he owes this man, her mother's beloved home will have to be sold and the family will be bankrupt. The dad feels sure that he will get a local firm's big construction contract which will allow him to pay off the loan. At this point, the man himself offers the h's dad more time if the h will marry him for a year to be his whipping boy and toy. The h feels certain there is some deep animosity between the two men, but neither will discuss it. So the h, to save her mother strain, stress and the trauma of losing her lifestyle, gives into the blackmail and agrees to marry the H.
It becomes apparent from the first night of the marriage where the H exults in raping the virgin h, that this man has some serious demons and some serious rage. The h does her best to fight him off, but he has his wicked way and while she verbally gives all to defend her own, it is really her inner reserve that the H mistakes as haughtiness that saves her from outwardly appearing to be too damaged. The reader only know's differently because the h has such intense inner musings and this man with his mad lovemaking skillz is driving her insane with internal conflict between rage and longing.
She feels herself falling in love based on his physical prowess at night,
(and at this point I wanted her address to send her an intimate electronic device catalog to help her get over this fixation,)
but the H is truly, truly despicable and cruel during the day. He humiliates and belittles her at every turn, she tries to offer sympathy when he tells her his parents are both dead and he savages her.
The h also overhears an argument with his sister about exacting revenge from the h and her father, so the h has some clues that some terrible past deed has been hidden. This mystery and the H's abusive behavior during the day scares and worries the h so much that eventually she confronts her father about the past.
Dear old dad avoids and deflects as much as he can, but the first really significant blow the h absorbs is realizing how weak and self-serving her father really is when he tells her that he was responsible for an injury done to the H in the past and refuses to tell the h's mum about what is going on. The h realizes it isn't to shelter her mum from hardship, but to protect her father's own ego and she has been sacrificed for her father's egocentric narcissism - sadly she is stuck and she is physically enraptured by the H so she knows nothing good is going to be happening at any time in the next year.
Her illusions about her father are fully shattered and this is beginning of the h's fall. The next huge blow comes from her husband, who invites his mistress to spend the weekend with him and the h. The mistress is an expensive sorta skank and pretty rude to the h.
The h tolerates it with a certain reserved hauteur, but the H decides to sleep in the mistress's room that night and takes off for his private cottage with the mistress the next day. (here is where the book hits the wall every time, I finally wised up and put some padding out when I reread this.)
The h was invited to the cottage tête-à-tête, but luckily she had to work and refused to skip her shift, or she probably would have been forced to sip tea while the H and mistress got it on.
She attempts to spend the night at her parent's home but the H comes and drags her back and she sends him off to his mistress's bed - the H can't believe she would think that he would be the kind of man who would do that in front of his wife - she has no problem firing back that he is exactly the kind of man to do that and plus he was at his private lurve nest all day and he doesn't deny he was shagging it up.
Then, (and here is where I routinely don a crash helmet to bang my OWN head against the wall,) the h winds up sinking into a morass of hurt feelings and pretty much begs the H to lurve her up. The h manages to pass it off later as late night nerves and physical hormones and the H forces her to participate in the big mistress send off the next afternoon where it is made perfectly clear the H is continuing his amorous pursuits. The h walks away to read a book and the H tries to get a rise out of her again, she plays it cool though --so score one little point for the h.
The big contract is awarded and guess who got it, (hint, it isn't the h's dad.) The H, in a repulsive show of domination, forces his sister and the h to drink to his success. The h modifies the toast to hoping the H's need for vengeance is satiated. The sister tries to convince the h that she needs to care for and help her psycho brother, but the h gets a call from her mum that her father has collapsed and is in hospital.
The h confronts the H and he explains that his vengeance is meted out because 18 years earlier his father had sub-contracted a building being done by the H's dad. There wasn't sufficient steel for the structure and two men died and people were injured. The H's dad had pointed out there wasn't enough but the h's dad denied there was a problem. In court the H's dad got blamed and as a result the H's dad committed suicide.
The h realizes her dad is weak but to her knowledge, her dad had always been honest in business and she points out that there must have been some horrible mistake. Either way, she rages at the H that he would not drive her father to put a gun to his head, even though he hated his father for not fighting back. She goes to the hospital where her mum explains that she knows everything, is disappointed in the h's mocking of marriage and that she will help her husband start over.
The mum also explains that the accident years before was an error in accounting, the right amount of steel had been ordered but a mix-up occurred and it was not all delivered. The dad had tried to find the H to put things right, but they had disappeared so he left it alone. He did not try to stop the H's revenge because he felt he deserved it (and apparently was happy that it was his daughter taking the brunt of it, not him).
The h meets the H upon exiting the room and finally tells him she has had enough and she is leaving. She starts packing to leave when the sister comes in to her room and it is strongly hinted that the sister will forcibly restrain her to keep her in the house. Apparently the sister feels it is up to the h to fix the obession of the H.
At this point the H shows up, explains he believes the mum and is going to make amends to her father. The h doesn't care, she is leaving and also leaving town after her dad recovers. The H offers to help her find a job and the use of his city apartment, she refuses and continues to pack. The H sorta panics but he needs to go make amends to the dad, he asks the h to wait til he gets back, (and in another head banging moment,) the h does.
When the H returns he then sorta apologizes, kinda begs the h to stay and tells the h he lurves her and explains that he only invited the mistress to make the h jealous - the mistress supposedly just came to visit to tell the H about her new fiance. The h confesses she loves the H back and HEA.
Now I have to confess that a lot of my pleasure comes from reading this book when I am in a cynical deviant mood and rewriting the ending. I have had hours of guilty enjoyment doing this and my favorite make my own ending actually goes a bit like this:
The h gets to the hospital only to find her father has died. The mum explains the situation and then collapses and sadly she too dies, she just can't bear to be parted from her husband. The H shows up and tries to apologize but the h leaves and goes to pack. The sister does physically attack the h to keep her from leaving and the h calls the police and has the sister arrested for assault. As the sister is a doctor, when she is convicted of bodily harm she loses her hospital privileges and has to go to overseas to Africa to work as a doctor there helping poor tribesmen with ebola.
The h, after arranging the funeral and selling all her families belongings to pay the H back, files for divorce and cites adultery and names the mistress as co-respondent, the mistress is served the summons as she and her fiance are rehearsing for their wedding.
The fiance is appalled that she has been sleeping with a married man and the details will be discussed in open court, he leaves her at the altar. The notoriety from the staff testifying that the H shacked up with the mistress just down the hall from the room his wife was in greatly devalues her wealthy man mistress prospects.
She is now infamous and wealthy men don't like public accusations of infidelity and don't like mistresses who are so widely known as marriage wreckers. She is forced into more and more demeaning liaisons, until her looks fade and she winds up in state assisted living, a broken, drug addicted woman with a fatal social disease.
During the divorce trial, it also comes out that the H used some dubious business practices to drive a fairly respected businessman to his death. Since he made a lot of enemies in his climb to the top, a combination of ruthless competitors and government corruption investigations cause him to lose all he has worked for.
In a final event just after the H has been informed he is bankrupt and a prison sentence for corruption is likely, he shoots himself in his study - just as his dad did years before.
The h decides to apply for a job as a librarian in New Zealand, as she needs a fresh start after all the past losses. She meets a former World Cup rugby captain who falls madly in love with her, treats her like an enthroned queen and she happily marries him and has 2 cats, 2 kids and one dog and a blissful HEA.
Like I said earlier, this really can be a great choose your own outcome HP. May everyone have very happy reading, no matter what side of the rosy glow or passionate revenge side you fall on.