Great book. Loved it. Can’t explain why.
But I’m gonna try.
Maybe it was because of the Sontarans. I just like them. Not as those „haha funny potato villains“ but as an interesting alien species with their own power structures and way of thinking and stuff.
Maybe it was because I liked the characters. The teenagers were not too annoying, they were right between cute and bitchy. The parents, the major, the mayor… Yes, we have a major AND a mayor and for half of the book stupid german me was like „Damn it, can’t you decide how to type that title?“… yeah.
Maybe it was because I liked the setting with the retro-looking settlement, the big flower show in the gardens, all the shiny starships arriving, the old-fashioned hotel… it felt a bit like a place where you could spend a nice holiday at.
Maybe because the death count was very low (a few poor human soldiers) and the brutality was quite moderate. Definitely something appropriate for a tv episode.
Maybe because of the kinda clever theme of „people settle somewhere, then more new people come, but the „old new“ people don’t want more new people, so they stop being welcoming and spread evil rumors about the new people, and a very angry, very loud dude tells the „old new“ people to vote for him so he can get rid of all those dirty criminal new people… Jfc, they should’ve called the settlement „Acirema“ to make it even more obvious… But okay, this whole social pattern is pretty universal so… humans never change and history repeats itself is the message. Sad but true.
Maybe because the tenth Doctor was very well written. He was cheerful, he was wary, he was asking the right questions, he was trying to rescue everyone, AND he was NOT the god-like genius he is in most other stories (especially in the Moffat era… cough…). Let me explain: He does not figure out who the villain is, he is actually told who it is and he’s like „Aaaah, I should’ve known!“ which was cute. Let me explain a bit more: There are situations where he does not know how to hack into a certain computer system and needs help AND a situation where he doesn’t know the names of starships and gets help again. THAT is how I like my Doctor! Because if he were an all-knowing, perfect god there would be no point in him travelling at all. He travels to see new things, to learn new things, and here he does.
And last but not least, maybe it was because the very last sentence of the book made me gasp!
You can decide for yourself if you go and read the book! I’d recommend it!