Checkmate is my first book by Annmarie McKenna, and I hope not my last. It was a good story, very quick read, and I had no problem buying into the existence of shape shifters and Ms. McKenna's world.
Actually, this book would have been just fine without the inclusion of shifters and in fact didn't really stress it as part of the plot. The twin shifters, Caelmon (featured in Mate 1) & Eli, live together in the wonderful kind of home that is split for privacy and joined together for communal eating. Eli shifts only once, to show his mate (Nikki). Otherwise, their "wolf" only comes out in their possessiveness and dominance of their women.
The premise of this book is also its failure, however, IMO. Nikki has been in love with Eli forever; he's been around her because he's best friends with her brother, Derek, and has only seen her (she thinks) as "the kid sister". Eli has been out of the country for most of the past year, but has thought about her and realized that she is his mate. While he's gone, Nikki is attacked by 3 men and gets badly hurt escaping them. She begs her brother not to tell Eli and thinks that the remaining scars will scare him off. She is also now terrified of men. And to top it off, while Eli is coming home from his mission, Nikki discovers her three best friends horribly murdered and mutilated (by weres?) - and the murderer sees her.
The problem I had was that Nikki's attraction to Eli overshadowed her fear pretty easily. So all the build-up about her fears, of walking to her car for instance, are quickly deflated by Eli's hotness. That just wasn't believable. Also, even though we're led to believe the two should be and will be together, it happens just a little TOO easily. Like, Derek smacks Eli in the jaw while driving him home - and after asking him to help protect his sister - when Eli admits he's planning to mate with Nikki. But that's it, just a smack. No tension before or after.
I think that Ms. McKenna has a great imagination and can be a great writer someday with a bit more time to learn some of the art of writing. And I look forward to that time!