What do you think?
Rate this book


148 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1963
The first and second parts of this book are very instructive to newcomers to Guénonian Traditionalism who wish to find an easy-to-digest textbook. But, as it is natural to Guénonian Traditionalism, it is distressing to read the third, that Benoist dedicates to Western Esotericism (or Esoterism, as the Sophia Perennis publishers prefer to render the word ésoterisme in English).
The reason is that Luc Benoist, at the time, still believed in Guénon's fantasy that Freemasonry was ever a part of Christian esoterism/mysticism—or that you can be Catholic and a Freemason at the same time. It seems Benoist grew out of that. At any rate, this very illuminating interview of the late Fr. Rama P. Coomaraswamy (Ananda K.'s son) to Joaquín Albaicín is noteworthy for the following comments (I'm eliding Albaicín's questions, except for the first):
Albaicín: Do you believe in the possibility of a future Church/Masonry reconciliation?
Coomaraswamy: Not with the traditional Church. It more or less exists in the post-conciliar Church. As for Masonry, I think Guenon was always looking for a pattern in Christianity that paralleled the sharia and haqiqa distinction in Islam. Such does not exist in Christianity where there is more a "sliding scale" of esoterism.... As for Masonry, I consider all forms to be false and part of the counter-initiation.... It is important as a Catholic never to step outside the bounds of sound doctrine and true faith and such organizations have been condemned both by Guenon and traditional writers, as well as the Church.... As to initiatic groups retiring to the East, this was one of Guénon's theories. All these things seem to me to be speculations. Guénon also said salvation would come from the West. What is important is for Catholics to be Catholic.