*deep breath* ...I can't believe I'm not 5-starring this one, but I have some niggles about it. I will happily read ANYTHING by FF. She's a writing Queen with a capital Q. I would never DNF any of her books, but if ever I came close to doing so, it was with this one.
I love the Orcsworn series. I had my problems with The Librarian and The Orc, and The Lady and The Orc, but those were more about the FMC being the issue (and because we're stuck in HER third person narrative, the whole unreliable-narrator thing worked pretty well, in the end). However, in The Governess and The Orc, alas, it was Rathgarr I didn't like. In fact, I almost ended up hating him by the end of it.
Rathgarr is of the Ash-Kai Clan, which means he's basically a Slytherin of the Orc world. They're known for lying and deceit and playing mind games and empty words, basically. Which, I'm fine with. Do what you gotta do, honey. And the other Ash-Kai members we've met have been challenging, but not downright AWFUL like Rathgarr was. He was selfish, cruel, manipulative, cowardly, self-obsessed...the list goes on. He wasn't just like that with Geva, the FMC, either. He was like that to his brother, other Orcs, his Captain, his clan members...everyone. He was just the worst. Geva would be bending over backwards to save his sorry arse, and afterwards he'd either pump-and-dump her, or say something incredibly mean. So many times, I wanted to shout at poor Geva, "YOU CAN DO BETTER!!" but alas, she couldn't hear me, because Rathgarr filled her ears with manipulative nonsense.
Honestly, most of the time this book felt like more of a brotherly drama between Kesst and Rath, with Geva's stuff on the side. She was constantly striving to help him, and he was constantly putting her down and/or disappearing for utterly useless reasons. Even the spice couldn't save it, and you KNOW that's saying something; it felt like every 2 pages, Rath was borderline-forcing Geva to pleasure him, and her pleasure was just an afterthought, if that.
This rant sounds critical, but that's only because I love this series so much. I had such high hopes - a POC character! No instant pregnancy! Fake dating! - but they were dashed because of stupid Rathgarr and his stupid toxic masculinity. If I wanted to experience life with a dude who constantly put money and his petty family sh*t ahead of me, I'd have stayed with my ex.
The 3 stars are for Geva carrying the whole romance on her shoulders, Kesst being his usual amazing self, and Cecily because I'm a sucker for neglected orphan types.