I tend to prefer longer narratives, novellas, novels and epics to short stories. I delight in watching characters develop and change in response to certain situations, discover romance, find redemption for a post wrong, accomplish a quest or come into their own as human being.
As a result, I tend to shun short stories. And had the author of this collection not been my friend Sarah Hoyt and had Glenn Reynolds not touted it on his blog, I likely wouldn't have read it. That said, I am glad I did.
To be sure, I wouldn't give five stars to all the stories in this collection. I felt a few overlong and one a bit short, but those I loved I truly deeply loved,, particularly the one that I thought was too short. But, that story, "What She Left Behind," is worth more than the five stars I gave this whole book. With the right director, it would make an amazing movie one as powerful (and meaningful) as "Pan's Labyrinth" (and set on the same peninsula).
The story is most touching about how a boy growing up in difficult circumstances adapts to the knowledge of his supernatural origins and reacts when he must make a choice between the world where he felt an outsider and the world where he, because of his birth, supposedly belongs. And in making the choice that he does, he reminds us what it means to be human. It is most beautiful -- and would make a touching film where only those with hearts of stone would leave without tears in their eyes.
Other stories explore the choices creative people must make, with some playing with the muse's divine (daemonic?) origin. And then there are the nuns in space.
Yes, to be sure, it can be a bit jarring to be reading your kindle and to finish one story and then to start another and finding yourself in another world altogether (when you would rather learn a bit more about the world of the story just completed), but there are enough stories in this collection which make you think and one at least which really makes you feel.
A good read and a quick one with one story which stays with you long after you have finished it. Well, at least it is staying with me.