I liked this one, though it had quite a few flaws. One good thing: we have a h who doesn't have that (ad nauseum) titian red hair, she doesn't have a bad case of the snarks, and isn't acting like an immature teenager, as so many of Ms. Graham's heroines seem to go overboard on. She did have a couple of moments, like when she dumped a vase full of flowers on the H's head, but believe me, he deserved that!!
I give this h credit for looking out for her mom, putting aside her own plans for college to help care for her baby half-sister when Mom became a basket case, then taking on the role of single mom when her mom passed away, and no matter how tough things got, she never fell apart, or looked for help from her (crap) family. The way she was treated by her dad and older sister, as well as her brother (not in the story, but who apparently acted like she didn't exist) did a number on her self-confidence (and was probably the reason for her stutter, which should have been more of a focal point in the story), but she didn't let insecurities stop her from working hard to be independent and provide for her sister.
The misunderstandings stem from people (including the H) thinking the h was the toddler Rosie's mother, and when the h gets fired from her job as a house cleaner (due to that incident with the vase), the H comes to the rescue and offers her the job of looking after things in his house, which is being renovated. It turns out, he has an agenda, which involves her older sister (the OW in the story), whom he used to date and who (along with the h's father) he has reason to resent.
Trouble begins when the sister decides to leave her husband (whom she married on the rebound after the H dumped her), despite being pregnant, and try and get the H back. (I'm sure the fact that he inherited millions from his late father had nothing to do with it.) She tells the h that she's ready to have an abortion so her estranged husband won't have any claim on her, making it easier to pursue the H, who she's certain will want her back. The h is horrified and comes up with an impulsive scheme to save her unborn niece or nephew. She tells her sister that Rosie's really her daughter and the H is the father hoping that'd send her back to her husband. Instead, she tells the H!!!
Because of an incident a few years back (when she was a chubby teenager and heard more than one snark remark, including some from the H), when she helped the H back to his room after he drank too much, thinking it would help a slight head injury he received after crashing his car, not too bright, was he? He had grabbed her and kissed her and later seemed to forget about it, and she let him think it had gone further than that and Rosie was the result.
She had planned to tell him the truth once she was sure her sister would change her mind and not have the abortion, but everything backfired, and she ended up married to the H, who had learned the truth but decided to make her pay!
What a mess!!!
The characters in this book are very flawed, including the H, whose upbringing was terrible. His mom was pregnant and set to marry his dad when she caught him in bed with another woman (he was a real himbo), broke it off and for spite kept the baby away from him. Then, she herself turned into a bimbo, claiming she still loved her ex (who married someone else and cheated on her, too) and kept searching for a man to make her forget. When she died while searching, his grandfather reluctantly got custody, and apparently couldn't stand either of his parents and just tolerated his grandson. He had troubles in school, became a playboy/bad boy with an attitude and had women galore ready to throw themselves at him, but it only made him more bitter and cynical.
He later rejects his father's attempts to reconcile and shows no desire to get to know his half-brother and sister, so it doesn't seem right that when they're all killed in an accident, he gets all the millions. This made him feel guilty (though not enough to give it up) and added to his cynical outlook.
You know the old adage about the love of a good woman? Well, it takes a while for him to figure that one out, and he could be really cruel in the process.
As for the h's family: her father was a bad-tempered bully who specialized in verbal abuse. He won the lottery and thought by buying a big house in a classy neighborhood and showing off artwork and other expensive trappings he'd be a hit with the upper class, but with his crap personality he couldn't have been more wrong! He took it out on his wife (who was happier before) and drove her into the arms of a younger man, who charmed her and used her (counting on her getting a big divorce settlement) and married her without bothering to tell her that he had another wife! When he was caught and jailed, she was 45 and pregnant and that started her downward spiral.
The h's sister was gorgeous on the outside but ugly on the inside. She fell for the H, got miffed when he wouldn't get serious about her, decided to make him jealous by letting him catch her in bed with another guy, to make him see how desirable she was. Instead, it made him see what a 304 she was, and he dumped her. She and her crappy father (who wanted the H to marry her) work out a revenge plan, using his grandfather, that determined the H to get his revenge.
You're never told exactly how he planned to do that, but when the h's dad goes bankrupt (the H had nothing to do with that) he decides that's good enough for him, and the whole plan for him to revenge himself on the sister was dropped.
As for the sister's husband: talk about the world's biggest wimp! (Or should I say simp?) Is there a male term for "Mary Sue"? How about "Larry Lou"? Well, he sure was one! He fell for her, married her, even though he knew she was rebounding from the H, put up with her complaints about him not having enough money, being too boring, etc., knew she left him because she wanted to try and win the H back, and yet he still loved her and was willing to forget everything and start again! WTF!!!! Did he find out about the baby and what she had planned to do??? That was never revealed (she didn't know she was pregnant when she left him), but even so he has to be the world's biggest fool! If she dumps him later on for another guy and leaves him with the kid (assuming she doesn't "miscarry") it's just what he deserves!
This book is full of toxic people, and the H at times acts toxic to the h. While it's understandable he'd be hurt and disillusioned by the lie she told, she really believed it was for a good reason and the way he acted for a time was payback.
There's a HEA, but it seemed like forever to get there, and I'd have like some more time for the couple to get closer and overcome a lot of stuff without that lie getting in the way.
I think the best thing about this story was little Rosie. She was so adorable; you wish she was real so you could give her a big hug!
Flawed, but worth reading.