Disclaimer: I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review.
I’m rarely at a loss for an opinion, on anything, but I confess I’m not quite sure what to think about The Misguided Empath. I can’t say that I disliked it, but I’m also not sure I understood it completely either. The story, such as it is, follows Drew Shaw, a nomadic sort of guy, decent and imperfect and very human, abused as a child and with a prison record from his younger days. Everything is seen through his eyes, so the exact location and time of what’s happening is vague in many spots, and it’s sometimes a little confusing to figure out where, or when, you are. There are also no other characters’ voices to provide a touchstone for what is real and what is entirely Drew’s perception.
It’s difficult to provide a story summary, because there isn’t really a linear story, per se. The reader doesn’t follow along with the narrator, watching what happens, so much as ride along in his head, seeing some of the action, and hearing more of his thoughts and feelings. One wonders sometimes if Drew is the Empath, or if the reader is meant to be. By definition, an “empath” is a person with the paranormal ability to apprehend the mental or emotional state of another individual, and while Drew does show some signs of empathy, he also shows some signs of precognition and, on a less paranormal plane, signs of paranoid schizophrenia, PTSD, and bipolar disorder.
A few items appeared to be errors in research by the author, but they could have also been simply perspective issues on the part of the protagonist. Drew describes being attacked by a “200-pound pit bull.” Ignoring that there is no such beast, most of what are called “pit bulls” are Staffordshire Bull Terriers and they top out at about 70 pounds. The Bull Terrier, aka the Target Dog, may also reach 70 pounds and the other dog most frequently mistaken for the Pit Bull, the American Bull dog, only gets up to 100 pounds. In one scene, Drew (a young white man) says he’s been locked in a jail cell with 39 non-white murderers, when arrested for theft. Again, exaggeration by Drew, or is there really a jurisdiction somewhere cramming 39 black adult males into a 3’ x 7’ holding cell with one white burglar?
The Misguided Empath is interesting, just different. Conventional novels tend to be “This is what happened to Bob” stories, whereas this unconventional read is more “This is what Bob thought about everything that happened to him.” This provides the ultimate in character development, from the inside. Drew is one of the good guys, standing up for the underdogs in society, a little troubled by his own history but working hard on becoming a kinder, more decent person as he goes. The reader also gets two “bonus” stories, provided by Drew himself. Deals like that don’t come along every day – I recommend it all.