I don't enjoy giving one star reviews, but I can't honestly say that I liked or enjoyed Resolution by Robert B. Parker. I was not aware that Resolution is a sequel (the second book in Virgil Cole & Everett Hitch series) when I was reading it, but now that I think of, a number of past events was implied in this book so I should have guessed it. Virgil Cole doesn't appear right away in this one, but he steps on the scene soon enough.
Western genre doesn't particularly appeal to me, but that's not the main issue I had with this book. My main issue is the predictable, slow, uninteresting, and cliched plot. Moreover, the characters aren't well developed and the writing leaves much to be desired. I didn't mind the clipped macho dialogue as such but these dialogues take too much space. The first few dialogues I read were alright, I could imagine the dramatic silences and start to visualize the characters. However, after page and page of the same clipped dialogue sentences, it gets incredibly repetitive not to mention it doesn't add any information. One cannot seriously base one's entire novel on such dialogues and expect it to be anything but boring and cliche, especially when the prose isn't descriptive either. It could work for a short story, even for a few chapter not for the entire novel. The best way I can describe the prose in this novel is non-descriptive and repetitive. Repetition would make for a better title then Resolution. This isn't a terrible novel but it isn't a good either.
I wouldn't particularly mind there aren't any memorable female characters in this novel if there were ANY developed characters. I've read a lot of books without any notable female characters and liked them (for example works of Joseph Conrad, R.A. Heinlein and so on) well enough. As long as there is still something in it for me, it's fine but I didn't find anything for me in this novel, so the fact that there were no strong female characters is just another minus. The only female characters in this novel are prostitutes and a lady who is hopelessly in love with an abusing husband and sorry for the spoiler but she doesn't really fall out of love with him. There is also some mention of Virgil Cole's old love interest Allie but she doesn't actually manifest herself in this one. Maybe Virgil Cole & Everett Hitch were better developed in the first book in the series, but in this one they weren't. The only insight we get to them is through their talk of duty and honour but it was always the same old talk and repetition ruined it. When the same dialogue gets repeated over and over again, it stops making sense.
I'm neither a politically correct reader nor one particularly sensitive to foul language. However, the swear words didn't really add anything to this novel and sounded like empty macho talk. I dislike when writers use foul language without a reason. There were some other things that bugged me, for example the way Indians were described. That phrase about herding Indians into reservation made me a little sick in my stomach. The Indians were only mentioned briefly, but it was unpleasant to read. I know such were the views of that time, but as a writer you can add some perspective.
The plot is pretty basic and if it wasn't painfully slow, it wouldn't be so bad. From the start it is obvious that Everett Hitch is a typical macho western protagonist. This 'gun for hire' character settles in a new town where he shows a soft side to him by saving prostitutes from being raped and not killing people unless he is paid to (or if he wants to save the prostitutes). Nothing much happens until his buddy Virgil Cole arrives and then nothing much happens (except some building tension and saving the above mentioned abused woman) until the final confrontation that is about half a page long (plus a few pages of build up to it). The end. This book didn't teach me anything new and failed to entertained me, so one star ranking it is.