One night while preparing for a date with her boyfriend, Police Sergeant Tom Molloy, Benedicta ‘Ben’ O'Keeffe gets a startling call from her parents’ neighbor, claiming that they’ve seen a handful of strangers living in their home. After calling multiple times and getting no response, she and Molloy race down to Dublin hoping that everything is okay.
Arriving at their doorstep, Ben is thankful, and disturbed, by the fact that the only person in the house besides her parents is their mysterious boarder. Not exactly a man Ben is a fan of, she’s relieved the next morning to learn that he’s fled in the night. At the same time, however, she’s uncomfortable leaving her parents alone—until she gets a handle on what’s going on, at the very least.
Back in Glendara, the town is in the midst of getting ready for the annual literary festival, Glenfest. This year is going to be extra special as the local bestselling albeit reclusive writer, Gavin Featherstone has agreed to participate. A boon to the event, it’s sure to bring attention to their little pocket of the world and everyone is excited for the weekend to get underway.
But at Featherstone’s first interview in twelve years, things quickly go downhill despite a dazzling start. After all, when the illustrious writer stands up to give a brief reading from his upcoming book, he collapses right there on the stage. Rushed to the hospital, it is with great shock and sadness when he’s pronounced dead, but for Molloy his suspicion is instantly aroused. Was it really a fluke heart attack or was something much more sinister at play?
Meanwhile, Ben discovers that Featherstone’s will was prepared by her predecessor leaving the estate now in her own capable hands. From the outset it appears a cut and dry case, but quickly turns into a battle between the deceased man’s family and his resident assistant. But as the investigation unfolds and a postmortem is done, the already complicated matter only gets worse. For it seems that Featherstone did not, indeed, die a natural death—it was murder—and a killer cannot profit from their crime.
The sixth book in the Inishowen Mystery series, Death Writes brought me back to the endearing characters and mesmerizing setting of Glendara, Ireland. Much like the first five books, the well-written Agatha Christie-esque plot took me for quite the ride all while easily interweaving both crime fiction and mystery. Already a diehard fan of Andrea Carter, I was unsurprised by how at home I felt as I settled down to rejoin this delightful, quirky cast of characters.
One of my favorite aspects to this series has always been the evocative descriptions, specifically regarding Inishowen. Captivating to the extent that I could easily see it all in my mind, this book was no different. With stunning illustrations of the shore and small town, it left me desperately wanting to visit this fictional Irish village. If only I could plant myself in the corner of Phyllis’s bookshop or grab a pint at Tony’s pub… But, alas, they were all magically plucked from Carter’s rather impressive mind.
The plot itself, however, was somewhat slower than I’ve grown to expect from Carter. Slightly more of a long, slow burn, the deftly interwoven dual storylines had my attention from the very start, just the same. Between the drama with Ben’s parents and the murder of a famed writer, there was no short supply of red herrings and perfectly poised suspicion. While the pace didn’t really pick until quite near the end, my eyes never once wandered from the page. After all, the direction in which this was headed totally evaded my attention and I was well and truly shocked by the final revelation.
The characters themselves, however, were undeniably the best piece to this winning novel. From the blossoming relationship between Molloy and Ben to the various townspeople who I’ve grown to love over the years, their development was steady and true. While they did, at times, perhaps have a classic mystery vibe, they also came across as true-to-life to my eye. Bravo, Ms. Carter, on crafting profoundly unforgettable personas.
All in all, while the pace of this novel was a bit of a letdown in comparison to the prior books, I still inhaled this quick, easy read from beginning to end. If you’re a fan of Deborah Crombie or Agatha Christie herself, you won’t go wrong grabbing a copy of this heartwarming yet compelling murder mystery. A tangled web of secrets and lies, I challenge you to try to work out the truth before the end. I, for one, didn’t stand a chance. Rating of 4.5 stars.
Thank you to Andrea Carter and Oceanview Publishing for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
PUB DAY: December 5, 2023
Trigger warning: drug overdose, gaslighting, attempted suicide, adoption, mention of: infidelity, alcoholism, cancer