Diplomats & Admirals: From Failed Negotiations and Tragic Misjudgments to Powerful Leaders and Heroic Deeds, the Untold Story of the Pacific War from Pearl Harbor to Midway

by Dale A. Jenkins

WAS THE JAPANESE ATTACK ON PEARL HARBOR INEVITABLE?

It’s November 1941. Japan and the US are teetering on a knife-edge as leaders on both sides of the Pacific strive to prevent war between them. But failed diplomacy, foiled negotiations, and possible duplicity in the Roosevelt administration thwart their attempts.

Drawing on now-declassified original documents, Diplomats & Admirals reveals the inside story of one fateful year, including:

• How the hidden agendas of powerful civilian and military leaders pushed the two nations toward war
• The miscommunications, misjudgments, and blunders that doomed efforts at peace
• China’s role in the US ultimatum that triggered the attack on Pearl Harbor
• Why the carrier-to-carrier showdown at Coral Sea proved a fatal mistake for Japan
• How courageous US navy pilots snatched victory from defeat at the Battle of Midway

The defining events of WWII could have ended very differently. Combining perspectives from both military and civilian leaders, Diplomats & Admirals uncovers new insights into the Pacific naval battles that shaped the world—and the men behind them.

Genres: History, Nonfiction, World War II, War, Military History, Politics, Military Fiction

402 pages, Kindle Edition

Published December 1, 2022

About the author

Dale Jenkins has had a lifelong interest in the Navy and international affairs. He is a former US Navy officer who served on a destroyer in the Pacific and for a time was home-ported in Yokosuka, Japan. Pacific Fleet commitments took him to the Philippines, Taiwan, South Korea, Hong Kong, and Singapore. While on active duty, he was awarded the Navy/Marine Corps Expeditionary Medal. His business career was primarily in international banking, and he was also a staff director at the Council on Foreign Relations in New York. Dale currently serves on the Samuel Eliot Morison Committee of the Naval Order of the United Sates, New York, and as a Regional Director of the Naval War College Foundation. As a result of his active-duty experience and new revelations, Dale provides insight into the diplomacy and strategies of the Pacific region. He has degrees in history and business from Harvard and Columbia.

Reviews

[Urey Patrick · Rating 4 out of 5]

Kind of a Cliff's Notes history of the time frame from June 1941 through July 1942, specifically the evolution of events leading to the attack on Pearl Harbor through the battle of Midway. The first couple of chapters are preliminary to that 12 month period subject of the book, and read like a last minute 500 word term paper on a vast and complex era of huge repercussions... disjointed, out of context, sudden shifts from paragraph to paragraph, limited or no context. However, the following two chapters on the genesis of the US oil embargo of Japan and the diplomatic maneuverings that culminated with the attack on Pearl Harbor are very interesting and thought provoking. The rest of the book, covering Pearl Harbor, Coral Sea, the Doolittle raid, and Midway is less satisfying. Jenkins relates each battle as a stand-alone event, again glossing over context and indulging in considerable Monday-morning quarterbacking. He is, of course, welcome to his opinions, but much of his discourse on what would'a, should'a, could'a happened is speculative and again, dismissive of context and some of the realities of the times.

For example, he seems convinced that the war could have been avoided by smarter, more adept and more capable diplomacy, severely criticizing missed opportunities and personal failings of individual diplomats with no little disdain. But that ignores the reality of pre-war Japan and the pervasive influence of the extremely imperialistic blocs of government, including the Emperor. The Army and the Navy were independent elements of government; there were extensive cabals of mid-level military officers who assassinated and intimidated higher levels of government seen to oppose expansionist policies; the Emperor himself was supportive to a degree that ultimately Tojo took the fall and was executed to mask the Emperor's complicity and avoid putting him in the dock. It is highly speculative to suppose a diplomatic resolution was actually within reach at the time, but Jenkins makes that argument with certitude. That same judgmental 20/20 hindsight largely exclusive of context and influences outside the immediate event is characteristic of his narratives of the ensuing battles. He also imputes thoughts and emotions to individuals in various actions that he cannot possibly know occurred, such as the second thoughts and emotions of the Japanese air group commander at Coral Sea just before he was shot down and killed. He makes definitive judgments of key players based on superficial criteria, without substantial support, such as criticizing the suitability and effectiveness of Fletcher and Spruance commanding carrier task forces despite being “black-shoe” sailors and not aviators.

Of course mistakes are made in war, and of course with hind sight it is possible to identify what could have been done better. That also requires an unbiased inclusion of circumstances, context and a realistic understanding of what was possible and what happened despite the limitations of time, events, material and personalities. Jenkins approach is less comprehensive, more superficial and judgmental than I think is warranted by the times and the players.

[Steven Leonard · Rating 5 out of 5]

Rather than a standard review of the events, Jenkins offers a deep-dive into the political, diplomatic, and military actions that drove the U.S. and Japan toward war. Although the book also addresses Pearl Harbor and Midway, the author's emphasis on "the road to war" makes for fascinating reading.

A more lengthy review: https://news.clearancejobs.com/2023/0...

[Soniaa · Rating 5 out of 5]

The date in time is November 1941. Japan and the US are teetering on a knife-edge as leaders on both sides of the Pacific strive to prevent war between them. But failed diplomacy, foiled negotiations, and possible duplicity in the Roosevelt administration thwart their attempts.

Could this conflict have been avoided? former US Navy officer Dale A Jenkins has spent many years studying the ins and outs of the behind the scenes political actions and decisions that lead to the conflict between Japan and America during WWII.

I highly recommend Diplomats & Admirals to anyone with an interest in the history War, or even someone who doesn’t read such a genre specific type of book, but is interested in a deeper understanding of World War II. The book was very well put together, and it didn’t feel heavy going despite such important subject matter. I will look out for more by Jenkins in the future.

[Zeta Dionn · Rating 4 out of 5]

Zdionn1@outlook.comThis is quite an entertaining read that manages to pack a lot of facts into a book in an entertaining way, rather than the stuffy feel non-fiction sometimes has. You can tell while reading that the author must have spent an exhaustive amount of time and energy on gathering this much information and translating it into an entertaining and educational story. I tend to lose interest in history books that spew endless dates and facts without meaningful context, but Diplomats & Admirals I found to be the opposite of that. I would have learnt a lot more about history in school if the text books had been structured in this way.

[Viclari · Rating 5 out of 5]

Diplomats & Admirals: From Failed Negotiations and Tragic Misjudgments to Powerful Leaders and Heroic Deeds, the Untold Story of the Pacific War from Pearl Harbor to Midway by Dale A. Jenkins is a well-written and riveting examination of the conflict between the U.S. and Japan in WWII. For those who love military history, this is the perfect book to delve into because it is so well-researched and detailed. You will certainly learn a lot even if you know nothing of this time frame and world wars. The Pearl Harbor tragedy is thoroughly discussed and explored, enabling you the reader to truly understand this horrific battle. Overall a great read and one that is highly recommended.

[Grady · Rating 5 out of 5]

Learning from mistakes in the past

Author Dale Jenkins earned his degrees in history and business from Harvard University and Columbia University and has served in international banking, and service in the US Navy in the Pacific, and holds significant positions with the Naval War College Foundation and the Naval Order of the United States. Jenkins’ exploration of the major battles of WW II - Pearl Harbor and Midway - is well researched and weighed and evaluated in this easy to read book, offering views that alter our understanding of the consequential war with Japan. It is refreshing to visit the events of 1941- 1942 as seen through the eyes of an expert on military, business, and foreign affairs, information that in retrospect relates that the cost of lives and the after effects of those conflicts may have been preventable. Decisions and events are examined carefully - ‘Most works covering this period largely fall into two camps: either a recounting of events based in economics and international relationships orchestrated by civilian leaders, or a military chronology of strategies and tactics commanded by senior officers of the armed forces. Diplomats & Admirals recognizes that the two are not independent but are very closely connected. One of the tragedies of this period was the abject failure of effective interaction and communications between the civilian leaders in Roosevelt’s War Council and the commanders of the armed forces. The same occurred in the councils of the government of Japan…the defining events of this period could have been very different.’

With that informed heeding this fine book escorts the reader through the steps and missteps and consequences of the lack of communication and understanding that resulted in the grave events between the US and Japan: the leaders are examined as are the faulty decisions and the result is a fascinating and important visit into history! Recommended
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book

[Janalyn, the blind reviewer · Rating 5 out of 5]

When I read the summary for this book the first thing I thought is wow… What an undertaking this must’ve been. Now after having read it all I can think is yes that must’ve been exhausting!!! First of all we get short bios on every key player from America and Japan then we get their strategies and it seems Japan had the better one and that was the stay out of the Americas way but true to American form we let our egos and our ignorant run the show. Needless to say no one en Roosevelts cabinet really had foreign relation experience in those who did were swiftly ignored or not contacted at all. That’s not to say Japan didn’t have their own miscommunications and faux Paz I am just trying to say when it comes to the Americans we can put it down under because of their ego… just for example Japan got together dozens of intelligent men to strategize and put down and black and white numbers what were the chances they would beat America? The answer none… They said they would win a couple of battles but overall be overwhelmed by the American forces and we head on our side for ego driven politicians one who is the secretary of the interior discussing our chances at war… Thanks America! I could go on and on but you’ll have to read the book it is so good from beginning to end it’s interesting at first as I said it tells you about the different ways they grew up the schools they went to their home structure and then it gets to the nitty-gritty the blunders the mistakes and oh yes everything that Japan did. I found this book so interesting I know I said that but anyone who loves non-fiction should definitely read Diplomats and Admirals it is a definite five star read and you will read communications in this book that I and I have a reader of nonfiction have never read anywhere else so kudos to the author this must’ve been exhausting but I’m glad you did it what a great book! Please forgive any mistakes as I am blind and dictate my review.

[Austin Wu · Rating 3 out of 5]

I reviewed this book for the Cedar Rapids Gazette in the article "Deconstructing dad history": https://www.thegazette.com/staff-colu...

[Swati Tanu · Rating 4 out of 5]

"Diplomats & Admirals" by Dale A. Jenkins provides a comprehensive and in-depth look at the Pacific War from Pearl Harbor to Midway. The author explores the key players and events leading up to the war, delving into the failed negotiations and tragic misjudgments that ultimately led to conflict.

He also sheds light on the powerful leaders and heroic deeds that characterized the war. Through meticulous research and vivid storytelling, Jenkins presents a fresh perspective on a well-known chapter of world history. This book is a must-read for anyone interested in World War II, military history, and international diplomacy.

You might like to wander through a few artistic journals — they’re full of sparks and surprises.

[Philip Van · Rating 3 out of 5]

What if questions about the run up to Pearl Harbor and the War in the Pacific - 3.5 stars

There were many possibilities of World War II in the Pacific. This book attempts to show some broad strokes with failed communication, failed leadership, and military experts who just wanted to duke it out, both Japanese and American.

Hundreds of citations of material that was available long after the conflict are included with people on both sides keeping their own cohorts in the dark. Decoded and open secrets that were not shared in a timely fashion with military and political officers on the same sides showed that the attack at Pearl Harbor could have been avoided "if only".

In the battles of Coral Sea and Midway, line officers of both the Japanese and American navies tried to do things their own way and starving their allies from receiving crucial information.

In the author's opinion, after the Japanese lost their aircraft carriers at Midway, it was impossible for Japan to ever recover. Both sides had leaders whose plans were overruled and, if executed, the outcome would have had drastically different. Luck, or good fortune, put a thumb on the outcome of the tragic, bloody conflict.

For historians who are knowledgeable about the war in the Pacific, this scholarly report may help with the research of the people who made the decisions that cause Pearl Harbor. This was not light reading but was readable. After reading this, I was surprised that a small number of people made most of the decisions leading up to war and the strategy for fighting the first carrier vs carrier war.

[Paul Echausse · Rating 5 out of 5]

Finely researched book uncovers some new insights, miscommunications and poor decision making that lead to the tragedy of the raid on Pearl Harbor and America’s recovery to recapture the Pacific

[John599 · Rating 5 out of 5]

Diplomats & Admirals by Dale A Jenkins provides the reader with an in-depth look at WWII, the Pacific War from Pearl Harbor to Midway. Jenkins does an excellent job of putting the events of the war into context and explaining the larger strategic decisions being made by the Allied powers. This helps to give a more complete understanding of the war and its impact.

I’ve read and watched quite a lot of documentaries about this particular period of our history, but I have to admit I did find some refreshing insights by Jenkins in this book. It is also an entertaining read, packed full of history, and the author must have spent a great deal of time and energy on gathering this much information and translating it into such an educational and entertaining read. The book is written in an easy to digest way, especially considering there is such a large intake of historical facts, notes, diary entries, pictures and maps.


If you like facts rather than fiction, different perspectives instead of just one and a book written by someone with a wealth of knowledge within the field of the prose and something that has plenty of research to back it up then i would definitely recommend reading this book. A 5 star rating from me!

[RomeroCKevin]

The wars in those times implied many circumstances that could confuse people, but what the author tries to imply is that wars are not as bad as many consider, so with that we can conclude that I totally agree with what The author recounts that all this happened for a solution, and that is how life is handled, although sometimes it takes many tragic decisions, as the author well mentions. All of this may sound a bit aggressive, but we must take a little confidence and take into account the decisions of each one of us who read books to give our critical point of view.

[Craig · Rating 5 out of 5]

Great story

It was a good in depth story and even though I am very well read on the subject I still learned a few things. It was an enjoyable read for anyone into the subject!

[Samuel30 · Rating 5 out of 5]

The pacing in this book was spot on. It kept me engaged, and I couldn't wait to see how everything would unfold.

[Young Kim · Rating 3 out of 5]

Points out the simple, true reasons of the Pacific War and why Japan lost

On p. 130
In a rare spirit of compromise, the Japanese army and navy agreed on a comprehensive plan to invade the Malay Peninsula on December 8 (Tokyo time) [the day of Pearl Harbor Raid, so they were simultaneous attacks], together with a first attack on the Philippines and Guam. Further rapid expansion would follow into the Dutch East Indies, other Pacific islands, and ultimately Singapore. The Pearl Harbor attack to destroy the US Pacific Fleet forces would protect the flank of the invasions. If Japan invaded any Pacific islands, Yamamoto was resigned to the United States entering the war [anyway]. The desired goal, therefore, was a fast attack in which a powerful Japanese navy and a destroyed Pacific Fleet would lead to a negotiated settlement giving Japan access to the oil and other resources embargoed by the US asset freeze. If the United States became involved in the European war [against Hitler's Nazi forces], there would be even greater incentive for the United States to come to an agreement with Japan. However, because Japan was committing all its amphibious forces to the South Pacific, the Pearl Harbor attack plan was limited to carriers, other surface units as necessary, and submarines. It would be a raid, not an invasion.

The book points out the simple, true reasons of the Pacific War behind all the dramatic scenes we learn in textbooks and media.

On p. 115
...Japanese ships were banned from using Panama Canal by the United States...

On p. 82
...before the whole oil reserve in Japan drained...
...before Japan’s grand military machine could be immobilized due to lack of oil...

It was, indeed, all about resources and supply chains, and it was the Japanese hardliners’ key argument about the "inevitable" conflict.

A summary of p. 94
Why the United States had to support Britain: It was still the United Kingdom of Great Britain, which was the global hegemon of the world ocean, trade and economy, but the worldwide British supply chains were at risk under the Japanese attack on British colonies and vital water passages between the Pacific and Indian Ocean.

The leaders already knew the consequence: Either Japan would win the war in 6 to maximum 12 months or the US would be victorious after all should the fight last more than a year.

On p. 105
...had an industrial capacity twenty times that of Japan. Even though in 1941 Japan had the world's most powerful navy, eventually it would be overwhelmed...

And the book mentions the crystal-clear reason again why Japan was to lose.

The hardliners were self-contradicting themselves. Their reasonable principle was lost:
On p. 111
...who believed the power of the samurai spirit would overcome any material and resource imbalance...

There goes the famous dictum: "Amateurs talk about strategies while professionals talk about logistics."

This all tells a lot about the possible consequence of the upcoming conflict of our time.

And the different interests between the US and her allies. Ukraine today is a great example:
On p. 164
Hull sat at his desk in a quandary. He was concerned by the British opposition to the modus vivendi but could understand their apprehension about any possible lessening of US support for their interests in the Far East. However, he was completely shaken by the intense, adamant opposition by the Chinese, including the mobilization of their powerful influence in the government and the Washington press. He was staggered by the power of the Chinese effort in Washington that was pulling out every possible ploy and leverage to prevent a settlement between the United States and Japan. Hull felt stuck to the commitment to them as allies, even though their interests were very different from those of the United States.

Really? So what was the true US interest at the time? We wouldn't be able to see the United States we know today if the country didn't enter the war against Japan and Germany over the Pacific, Indian and Atlantic Oceans.

Would you willingly give up the way of your life today?

If the current US and its allies' control over the global waters is lost, the fast deliveries with cheap price tags you've all been enjoying so far will be gone too.

It wouldn't just affect your personal belongings. It would impact the whole industry and business environment of your country. Materials do not arrive on time. They are more expensive. So the products will be more expensive as well while your salary remains the same.

Many businesses will collapse, and millions will lose their jobs. There'll be less consumption, and it will be a harsh reality for any businesses to just survive. Our societies as a whole will go down the toilet.

You will have to decide to fight before that happens to you unless you voluntarily accept the change and just live with it without complaining, thus the word "inevitable."

On p. 164
For anyone to think that war between the United States and Japan was inevitable, the strong doubts expressed by the British and the strident efforts of the Chinese leadership to prevent an agreement are proof that it was not inevitable. In fact, Hull had been about to avoid war by submitting the final modus vivendi to the Japanese diplomats. Togo and the Japanese government, as evidenced by their plaintive and desperate pleas for an agreement, surely would have embraced it...

Here's my conclusion to those last lines just above:
On p. 136
...All this endorsed the strategy of Delay, but Delay was not going to avoid war.

It is a well-written book. It does show the professional quality. Unfortunately, the book, however, self-contradicts itself at the end.

[Sameer Gudhate · Rating 4 out of 5]

In "Diplomats & Admirals: From Failed Negotiations and Tragic Misjudgments to Powerful Leaders and Heroic Deeds, the Untold Story of the Pacific War from Pearl Harbor to Midway" by Dale A. Jenkins, the author takes readers on a riveting journey back to November 1941, a pivotal moment in history when Japan and the US stood on the brink of war. Jenkins delves into the intricacies of diplomatic maneuvers and military strategies that ultimately led to the fateful attack on Pearl Harbor.

Jenkins masterfully weaves together declassified documents to uncover the complex narrative that transpired behind closed doors. He explores the hidden agendas, miscommunications, and foiled attempts at peace negotiations, shedding light on the roles of both military and civilian leaders in shaping the course of events.

Jenkins' writing is both engaging and informative, seamlessly blending historical facts with personal anecdotes. His prose grips the reader from the outset, providing an immersive experience that makes history come alive.

The book not only focuses on the prominent figures of that era but also highlights the lesser-known players whose decisions had far-reaching consequences. The clash of ideas, the power struggles, and the dynamics between these figures are meticulously portrayed.

Jenkins skillfully constructs a chronological narrative, allowing readers to follow the sequence of events leading up to the attack on Pearl Harbor. The pacing keeps the tension taut, mirroring the tense atmosphere of the time.

The book explores themes of diplomacy, the costs of misjudgments, and the complexity of wartime decision-making. It also sheds light on the human side of history, showcasing heroism and the sacrifices made by those on both sides.

"Diplomats & Admirals" evokes a profound emotional response as readers delve into the minds of leaders who held the fate of nations in their hands. The narrative elicits a mix of empathy, frustration, and awe.

The strength of the book lies in its meticulous research and the unbiased presentation of facts. However, at times, the sheer volume of information can be overwhelming for readers seeking a lighter historical overview.

Jenkins' work is a testament to his dedication to uncovering historical truths. The book's detailed approach offers a fresh perspective on the events that shaped World War II, and its impact lingers long after the final page.

"Diplomats & Admirals" stands as a powerful exploration of the factors that contributed to the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. Dale A. Jenkins' meticulous research, vivid storytelling, and insightful analysis make this book an indispensable addition to the shelves of history enthusiasts and anyone seeking a deeper understanding of the events that shaped our world.

[Gemie · Rating 4 out of 5]

In the ever-expanding realm of World War II literature, Dale A. Jenkins' "Diplomats & Admirals" offers a unique and thought-provoking perspective on a time period fraught with tension and conflict. Embarking on an analysis of the year leading up to the Pacific War, Jenkins focuses on the events from June 1941 through July 1942, specifically examining the circumstances that led to the attack on Pearl Harbor and the ensuing Battle of Midway.
The book is quite clearly meticulously researched, which shows Jenkins' dedication to shedding light on the political maneuvers, diplomatic missteps, and tragic misjudgments that precipitated the conflict between Japan and America during this pivotal time​. The author's background as a former US Navy officer and his significant positions with the Naval War College Foundation and the Naval Order of the United States lends credibility to his accounts​.
I found the narrative to be well-structured, presenting an overview of each key player involved in the conflict, from both American and Japanese sides. This includes their respective strategies and the myriad of complexities that contributed to the outbreak of war​. The book's comprehensive approach to such a complex era is commendable, maintaining an engaging and educational tone throughout​.
I think it is important to note that Jenkins' analytical lens is not without its flaws. His exploration of the possibility that the war could have been avoided through more adept diplomacy has sparked some controversy. Critics argue that he relies heavily on speculative hindsight, seemingly dismissing the contextual realities of pre-war Japan and the extensive influence of the country's imperialistic blocs of government​. This inclination to impute thoughts and emotions to historical figures, along with making definitive judgments on key players based on superficial criteria, may leave some readers questioning the depth of his analysis​.
Despite these criticisms I definitely think "Diplomats & Admirals" remains a compelling read for anyone interested in World War II history. For me at least it offered a fresh perspective, challenging conventional narratives and providing a deeper understanding of the period leading up to the Pacific War. While the book may not be the standout of the year, it is a worthy addition to the shelf of any history enthusiast, offering a nuanced and detailed account of a period of profound global change.
While "Diplomats & Admirals" may not be the shining star of historical narratives, it is a valuable exploration of the diplomatic and military complexities of the pre-World War II period. It is a fascinating dive into the characters and decisions that shaped a crucial era, marred only by the occasional indulgence in speculative hindsight.

[DuckyEGG · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book is pretty much what you'd expect from a history-based nonfiction. Rooted in the era of the US' 32nd President Franklin D Roosevelt, the author dives deep into the political climate between the US and Japan.

The attack on Pearl Harbour takes a significant portion in the book - something I found to be the most interesting hook. Of course, details like negotiations between the two nations are extensively spread across the entire book. Personally, though, these bits weren't much of an interest for me.

The early pages sets the basis for your reading experience by offering background information on Franklin and Takano Isoroku, (who became Commander-in-Chief of the Imperial Japanese Navy, Yamamoto Isoroku). Expect to come across letter transcripts, particularly written during Franklin's days at Harvard.

While I understand nonfiction books of this nature mainly focus on a systematic craft of historical facts, I would have enjoyed it better had there been more thought-invoking content. I've read some similar books which afforded me that effect. Truth be told, I'm not an avid reader of historical books, but my go-to experience for most, if not all books, would be at least one of two things - they've got to impact my emotions or trigger some personal thoughts. With this? I basically had a buffet of information but that was as far as my reading experience took me.

All told, the book covered great grounds, but impact wise was more on the average side for me.

[Christina F · Rating 5 out of 5]

Diplomats & Admirals is a book about the events that occurred between July 1941 to June 1942 and is told through the leaders who shaped the events. This includes both American and Japanese leaders such as President Franklin D. Roosevelt and Japanese Premiers Konoe and Tojo. These are a few of the leaders of the time that determined policies, strategies, and tactics that ultimately resulted in a changed world. This book is really fascinating because it uses de-classified documents and original materials that show the ineffective communications, failed leadership, and mistakes made by these leaders. The author believes that had there been effective communication and strong leadership the events could have been drastically different. The book is well researched, very detailed, and well worth the read. I love history and enjoy reading about it, but I know for some this may not be the most fascinating topic, but I do believe the author takes this topic and makes it an interesting and great read.

[Pegboard · Rating 5 out of 5]

Dale Jenkins takes declassified reports from WWII and devolves his opinion of how this war could have been different if vital information was given in a timely fashion. Diplomats & Admirals is a fantastic look at a war that changed the very fabric of world policies. "What ifs" give an endless supply of possibilities that is compelling to envision.

I find historians a passionate group of people that makes great authors, teachers, and public speakers. Dale Jenkins takes his passion for history and naval strategies and created a mesmerizing military historical read. Diplomats & Admirals is mesmerizing as the author reveals insightful information that keeps you glued to the pages. You feel the energy and devastation of an important time in our history. There is always the vision of how lives could have been saved and wars prevented. Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book and would recommend it to those who love the history genre.

[David Wurster · Rating 4 out of 5]

I find there are two ways to assess the lessons of this book:
1. What might have been different in WWII if individuals had been more competent in the 1930s and 1940s?
2. How could the world be better today if leaders were chosen for competence rather than ideology, identity, charisma, and whatever else led us to Trump and Biden as world leaders?

On the historical point, WWII required an enormous number to individuals to excel at very complex decision making without ever having to have had faced similar challenges. It is inevitable that both exceptionally good and exceptionally bad decisions were made with huge life and death consequences.

As for today, it feels like we are at a low point culturally in our political and bureaucrat leaders. If we were to stumble into a WWII situation, heaven help us depending upon those occupying the decision-making seats in Congress, the Executive branch, and the media.

[Seth Petok · Rating 4 out of 5]

Miscalculations and miscommunication amongst American diplomats, naval officers and the executive branch failed to recognize Japanese determination to own the Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere, and thus Pearl Harbor! Excellent researched narrative on the 1941 show down between diplomats on both sides. The US recovered at the Battle of Midway, taking out the Japanese carrier fleet — the turning point in the war.

The voluminous cast of characters in the battle scenes and the acronyms and the multiplicity of naval assets makes it hard to follow without re-reading. An index for these items would have been very helpful.

Still, having Google Earth and Wikipedia filled the gaps and reinforced the geography and wide expanse of the Pacific.

[Grymm Gevierre · Rating 4 out of 5]

There's only been a handful of books I've enjoyed that focus on military history, and I will have to add this one to the list.

This interesting book shares a wonderful view of the prominent battles surrounding the Pearl Harbor attack. WW2 thrust us into a scary, new era, and Jenkins does a beautiful job outlining perspectives and how things could have gone a lot worse very easily. His experience in US Navy plays a prominent role in the writing, but much research and care went into this book through the finer details he goes over.

I recommend this for anyone who loves to stroll through history told with honesty and a military perspective!

[Steve C · Rating 4 out of 5]

There is a great deal of research and information in this book concerning the various Pacific battles and particularly with Coral Sea and Midway. What I found somewhat excessive was the continual assessment of "what should have happened". To use an old cliché, hindsight is 20/20. It is true that there were misses opportunities and bungled efforts throughout the war. That happens in regular daily living. But one has to remember that decisions and information available now was not then, and many of the decisions good or bad, were made on what was known at the time. Other than that, this is a good book with a plethora of information and very interesting.

[Rose · Rating 4 out of 5]

Dale Jenkins has written a detailed and meticulous account of what led to the war in the Pacific between the US and Japan. Beginning with FDR and his cabinet, to the missteps they made in not understanding Japan's concerns, to the attack on Pearl Harbor, and ending with Midway, which led to the eventual defeat of Japan in the Pacific. Through much research, notes, diary entries, pictures, maps, and more, this is a book which provides an understanding of what went wrong in the days leading up to the war. I was truly surprised by the missteps!

[Camila A · Rating 5 out of 5]

Exceptional read on the buildup to Pearl Harbor and the critical Naval Battles that followed. I think it’s important to reflect on the diplomatic failures that built up to Pearl Harbor and I think there’s a lot of good lessons learned in this book concerning international relationships and the criticality of interagency conversations within our government. I also realized I have a knowledge gap when it comes to the Navy and Naval capabilities - this book was a really easy entry into that domain.

I’ll be recommending this book to many!

[Dee · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is my first read by Dale A. Jenkins. Diplomats & Admirals is an in-depth well written military and WWII story. This book will guide you strategically through the events and decisions that were made between the governments of the US and Japan. This period of history will shine a light for many regardless of the knowledge you have going into it. If you enjoy nonfiction, war story, or history this is a must read book.

[Cynthia · Rating 4 out of 5]

A bit dry at times, with all the details, i.e., times, longitude, latitude, but once the author got into the actual battles, it was excellent. I have read many books and seen my fair share of movies/TV documentaries regarding the attack on Pearl Harbor and the battle of Midway, and it's always good to add another perspective to that list, especially the failed attempts by some in the Japanese government to avoid war.

[BookTrib.com]

DIPLOMACY & ADMIRALS by Dale Jenkins is a rigorous retelling of Japanese and American diplomacy in the days, months, and years leading up to WWII. A must read for history enthusiasts!

Read the full review on BookTrib.com